Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To need instruction on how to drive an automatic?

132 replies

museumum · 01/11/2026 09:57

Is it unreasonable to feel nervous about just hopping into an automatic after driving a manual all my life?
I really feel uncomfortable. But everyone else just seems to do it with no instruction book or lessons.

Im sure I could manage in an emergency but how are you supposed to handle one? When do you use neutral? Do you keep your foot on the break in stopped traffic? Is there no equivalent to putting the hand break on at lights? It just doesn’t seem safe.

AIBU to think that the bulk of the population shouldn’t be swapping without a bit more information?

OP posts:
ChapmanFarm · 01/11/2026 11:03

museumum · 01/11/2026 09:57

Is it unreasonable to feel nervous about just hopping into an automatic after driving a manual all my life?
I really feel uncomfortable. But everyone else just seems to do it with no instruction book or lessons.

Im sure I could manage in an emergency but how are you supposed to handle one? When do you use neutral? Do you keep your foot on the break in stopped traffic? Is there no equivalent to putting the hand break on at lights? It just doesn’t seem safe.

AIBU to think that the bulk of the population shouldn’t be swapping without a bit more information?

I thought this too. But picked up my new car and drove it 200 miles home and it was much easier than I thought.

Once you know to push the paddle to change to reverse, that's about it.

Keep your left foot on the bit at the side to keep it well out of the way so you don't try and use it. You will fish for an imaginary vear stick a few times ut it really is fine.

Honestly, I thought just the same as you did a few weeks ago and was pleasantly surprised.

Seziah · 01/11/2026 11:03

I have managed to both stall and roll backwards in an automatic but that was my driving not the car. With a bit of quick instruction or practise you get used to it, although you might try and grab a non-existent gear stick few times

LouisFuton · 01/11/2026 11:06

Think of it like a go cart! I like automatics for long drives but prefer my little up (gti no less) for the town 😂

autumnboys · 01/11/2026 11:07

DS2, 21, nearly crashed my new automatic this week while he was getting used to driving it. He’s a careful and confident driver in a manual. I don’t think you’re being unreasonable, they are different to drive.

in DS’s case we had talked about creep when you going forward, but not when reversing. So watch out for that!

Wheniswinenight · 01/11/2026 11:10

You’re overthinking it for sure. It’s so much easier than manual. You put it in drive and you go. My car has a foot rest on the left to keep left foot out of the way!
I stick mine in neutral when if I’m stopped at long lights. Then back into drive and off I go.
There’s no actual handbrake. It’s more like a switch. Good luck! You’ll never look back honest.

bababamama · 01/11/2026 11:11

Me too! Thankfully I know a driving instructor who offered last week to take me out for half an hour in return for a couple of beers. I want to change my car and sell his but nearly all the newer ones are automatic

Saucery · 01/11/2026 11:13

I put off getting a new car for a few months as the model I wanted only came in hybrid automatic and like you, OP I was worried about the switch. I needn’t have been, it comes so naturally to me to leave my left foot on the little footrest thing. When I did take the plunge and get the hybrid it took about half an hour to get used to it. Maybe a week before my left hand stopped twitching towards a nonexistent gear stick!
Mine has Brake Hold that I switch on at the start of every journey. You have to come to a complete stop for it to engage so you do keep moving slowly in slow moving traffic.
Never use Neutral, or the Boost setting. Just Park, Reverse and Drive. Has a brilliant amount of pick-up from standing, feels very safe at junctions and roundabouts because of that, unlike my 12 year old hatchback that it replaced.

Carouselfish · 01/11/2026 11:14

It's literally like a toy car. D for drive and then stop and go pedals Grin My only regret in swapping is that now I cant remember how to drive manual.

MrMurphysComeuppance · 01/11/2026 11:15

When my DH first wanted to switch our manual car to automatic I was nervous and reticent and felt like you. I was worried about not feeling in control. Honestly it was SO easy and after 15 minutes behind the wheel I was completely sold. Our last few cars have all been automatic and I would NEVER EVER switch back to manual. In fact I absolutely hate it if I ever have to drive a manual car now. It's always much more expensive if we need to rent a car on holiday to get automatic but I insist on it.

Fleabagpeabag · 01/11/2026 11:17

You will honestly pick it up in 5 mins. Don't stress

Chocolatebunny61 · 01/11/2026 11:18

I recently had to change to an automatic after 40 years driving a manual as a hip replacement left me with nerve damage and I was unable to lift my left foot on and off the clutch. I was petrified at first, no idea what to do - I wanted to have a single lesson with an automatic driving instructor but everyone laughed at me so I didn’t! In the end I just went out with my husband a few times ( there was a lot of swearing! 😂) but I soon got the hang of it. I’ve been driving it about 4 months now and I love it so you will be fine. Best wishes!

Sadcafe · 01/11/2026 11:22

Drove a manual car for over 40 years, recently changed to automatic ev and it was honestly so easy, you can still apply the parking brake at traffic lights etc and it just goes off automatically when you drive, it’s nothing to be concerned about, in some ways it’s much easier to drive than a manual car

LlynTegid · 01/11/2026 11:24

The OP is reasonable, it is different.

I don't like automatic cars myself, prefer the greater degree of control with a manual car especially in wet or snowy weather, and I think with a manual there is greater concentration when driving.

Smallestshadow · 01/11/2026 11:29

I’m scared of driving an automatic 🤣 I know they’re supposed to be “easier” but it’s the fact that’s it’s so different and I’m terrified I’d make stupid mistakes while driving and wouldn’t be able to adjust. We get hire cars for the occasional work trip and I was once sent an automatic. I had to exchange it as I couldn’t drive a car so different 100 miles to a different location. I always request a manual now.

ginasevern · 01/11/2026 11:29

No you aren't being unreasonable. A few years back I was looking to buy another car. I didn't realise the one I was eyeing up was an automatic until I got in it. I've been driving manuals for 36 years. The guy said I could take it for a spin (with him in the passenger seat). I was flummoxed and had to abandon the test drive. I think anyone that's driven a manual long term would need at least some basic instructions and practice.

BestMugPlease · 01/11/2026 11:30

I had one as a courtesy car. Hated it.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 01/11/2026 11:36

Very very easy. Like driving a golf buggy if you ever have.

Took me a few mins to get into it (and stop reaching for the gear stick!) but no bother at all.

Edit - just to say, had only driven manuals so far in 30 years of driving, and the most recent 20 of those being driving very regularly. Please don’t let anyone tell you it’ll be difficult as it really really isn’t.

Elsvieta · 01/11/2026 11:40

What's neutral? I don't think I have that. (Can you tell I've never driven manuals?). Mine doesn't have a handbrake either, just a sort of little button for when you're actually parking. Foot on gas to move, foot on brake to not. Yes, foot stays on brake at lights. Couldn't be easier. Yes, book a session with an instructor if you're really worried, but you won't need more than an hour. Trundle round a few back streets and you'll have it.

Justploddingonandon · 01/11/2026 11:43

It’s really easy, I never use neutral unless parked, but mine does have auto hold. Only problem is that after over a year of only driving one I seem to have forgotten how to drive a manual car.

NewYearVibes · 01/11/2026 11:47

Are you getting a modern hybrid or electric vehicle? They have no handbrakes. At the lights, keep the foot on the brakes. If it’s a very long wait, either press the brake button or shift into park.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 01/11/2026 11:50

Interesting this thread has shown they’re all a bit different.

In mine it brakes (as in won’t move either way) if you put it in neutral. So I’d do that if I wanted to take my foot off the brake (eg in a traffic jam).

P for parking is separate to this and you can’t turn it off without putting it into P

ILoveKits · 01/11/2026 11:55

As others have said:
D for drive
R for reverse
P for park
Apply handbrake when parked.
Foot on footrest.

it came into its own when I broke my left foot

The car does all the work. I got my first auto in 2012. Would never, ever go back.

Sidge · 01/11/2026 11:57

I miss my automatic 🙁 back in a manual now and whilst I feel more like I am actually driving, I miss the ease of an automatic especially on hills etc.

I do hate being behind someone sitting on their brakes at lights though, modern lights are blindingly, dazzlingly bright and when you’re sat behind them for any length of time it’s really difficult at night. Please put it into park or use the auto brake and come off the brake pedal!

SoVeryVeryBored · 01/11/2026 12:13

museumum · 01/11/2026 09:57

Is it unreasonable to feel nervous about just hopping into an automatic after driving a manual all my life?
I really feel uncomfortable. But everyone else just seems to do it with no instruction book or lessons.

Im sure I could manage in an emergency but how are you supposed to handle one? When do you use neutral? Do you keep your foot on the break in stopped traffic? Is there no equivalent to putting the hand break on at lights? It just doesn’t seem safe.

AIBU to think that the bulk of the population shouldn’t be swapping without a bit more information?

It is so much easier than a manual, the only thing is you will find yourself moving your left foot, and sometimes reaching for the gear stick, but just keep that hand in your lap. You really don’t need neutral. If you’ve been using it for anything other that at lights then you’ve been driving incorrectly (one shouldn’t coast, but if you did you’d probably be a more confident driver and not worrying so much).

One of my vehicles is automatic and the other manual and I switch between them frequently, it really is fine.