Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ely or Winchester? Rightmove links.....rightmove psychosis part 2.

53 replies

TonbridgeorWinchester · 31/10/2026 15:09

Vote YABU for Ely
Vote YANBU for Winchester

Been ravenously searching for a house for 2 years. Rightmove app shows 9 hours of usage per day. I've even taken an unpaid week off work to househunt it's taking so damn long.

Sorry to everyone for being a pain and asking again. Apparently Winchester is a no brainer.

I am considering a 2 bed flat in Winchester vs a 2 bed exposed beams house in Ely.

I have lived in Winchester and love it there.

My heart personally is in Winchester and having taught at Ely college I wouldn't really want my future child there and not sure about private at this stage due to rising costs, tax raids and bf's disapproval.

Ely is much closer to both my parents and sister but Winchester is close to my slightly more distant cousins.

The Winchester one I can buy for cash. NO mortgage. Plus has a garden for future baby.

My whole family and bf much prefer Ely house but I think Winchester is where I want to be. In my opinion it's location, location, location.

Which is best?

Ely rejected my initial offer and Winchester have accepted subject to viewing....

Winchester:
https://www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/174066974#/?channel=RES_BUY

Ely:
https://www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/92850702#/?channel=RES_BUY

I don't really fancy a mortgage.... even for a little amount. I'm done saving. I've been frugal for 10 years. I'm 28 and looking to start a family with my serious partner in about 5-7 years. Will be buying alone and get relevant legalities sorted.

My heart says Winchester.....

Check out this 2 bedroom apartment for sale on Rightmove

2 bedroom apartment for sale in Sussex Street, Winchester, Hampshire, SO23 for £270,000. Marketed by Romans, Winchester

https://www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/174066974#/?channel=RES_BUY

OP posts:
HewasH2O · 31/10/2026 17:39

That's not a garden, it's a couple of paving slabs. Dreadful location, just like the one on St Cross Road.

Traitorousurges · 31/10/2026 17:45

I think OP the problem is you are more interested in what you want atm than a family home. Right now you want central, stylish and are not too fussed about space and layout.

Family homes tend to need to be practical more spacious and often not as central.

Maybe consider if you are better of planning to move again later.

likelysuspect · 31/10/2026 17:52

The house is a much better investment, its also bigger, no service charge

In 10 years, you'l have spent the same in service charges as you'll have paid exgtra for the house, so all in, they are the same price over a 10 year span

We have visited both cities several times and loved them both, they both have huge attractions to my mind.

I wouldnt buy a flat, or a leasehold property

Look for a house in Winchester if thats the place for you, but these two properties are not comparable because its flat vs house and house wins hands down every time.

Catza · 31/10/2026 17:55

It's taken you so long to find a house because you haven't actually sat down and thought about your no-negotiables.
If buying with no mortgage is non-negotiable, then it will considerably shrink your pool of available properties. I think a small mortgage would be preferable. 30k-50k extra would give you infinitely more choice and cost very little if spread across long-term mortgage (which you can pay off much faster than the agreed term).
You say you want a garden for the baby but the "patio" in the flat is much smaller than the courtyard in the house you ported so, technically, neither of those has a garden. The patio in the flat is definitely not secure enough in any shape or form. to let children be there unsupervised.
The layout of the flat is also ridiculous. I can't be arsed with trapeze rooms leaving you forever struggling to fit furniture in more than one configuration.
Not to mention that you have a very short lease and £200 a month to fork out in service charges (which will continue rising!) making a small mortgage a much cheaper option overall.
I would also only even consider a top floor flat.
I am not saying go for Ely, since you want to stay in Winchester. But it would be smart to run some numbers and figure out a comfortable mortgage amount, then look for a more suitable property without leasehold obligations.

AlertCat · 31/10/2026 18:03

The Ely place is much nicer and more suitable for a young child. More private too. I don’t know either city, but purely on the properties it’s a no brainer.

The Winchester flat looks superficial, and veneered, whereas the house in Ely looks as if it’s been done out to a nicer quality.

If you are planning a family, be near your family (assuming you like them).

I don’t understand why these are the only two options. If you want to be in Winchester, aren’t there any other places you would consider? If you don’t want to live in Ely why are you looking at houses there anyway?

ThreeLocusts · 31/10/2026 18:05

Hi OP, fwiw: I visited Ely repeatedly from Cambridge when living in CB. The cathedral is amazing and there's a nice stretch along the river. Other than that, it's tiny and there's nothing going on. If you move to Ely, you've got to be happy with a quiet life. But you probably know that....

phlebasconsidered · 31/10/2026 18:07

Ely is hugely on the up. I spent today there, I live in a nearby village. Brilliant places to eat, good pubs, a theatre, music nights, great market, train to Cambridge.

I'm a secondary teacher myself at another school and i'd bite the head's hand off to work there. Their 6th form is excellent too.

It's safe, culturally active and the green spaces are brilliant. You'll get far more for your money there than Winchester, which I lived in in 1994. I would say Winchester back then felt similar to Ely now, although last time I visited )2009) it had changed a lot.

OlderGlaswegianLivingInDevon · 31/10/2026 18:20

Yesterday's thread was Tonbridge or Winchester.

No wonder you have been actively house hunting for 2 years if you can't even decide where you want to live.

Where does the boyfriend prefer to live as I guess he has to commute somewhere too ?

Yellowsubmarine55 · 31/10/2026 18:20

I'd go a house over a flat anyday but Winchester has my heart. So I'd say find a house in Winchester or just outside and you'll be just great.

Takeoutyourhen · 31/10/2026 18:21

Tomorrow’s search:
Winchester or Tring.

stringbean · 31/10/2026 18:32

The Winchester flat is a great location in that it’s central and close to the station but it would be incredibly noisy - traffic goes past on both sides, buses, car park/civil offices across the road; and at ground floor level you’d get the worst of it. I’d definitely give that one a swerve.

Enko · 31/10/2026 18:41

That is a high service charge and it will only go up. You didn't have the option of something else but for you I would keep looking.

HewasH2O · 31/10/2026 18:53

Yesterday you were going to wait 9 years to start a family.

Why didn't you actually visit during your week off? A couple of nights in a Travel Lodge might give you a more realistic view of the flats you're considering.

Spirallingdownwards · 31/10/2026 18:56

Talkinpeace · 31/10/2026 16:32

Winchester state schools are the best
all of the primary and secondary catchments are good
and of course Symonds is fab

Once the A34 roadworks are done, the riverside walking and cycling will be excellent

Easy train connections to all over the country

Ely is catchment though for Hills Road Sixth Form which has a similar profile to Peter Symonds anyway.

@TonbridgeorWinchester The reality is the Ely house is freehold. Less than 10 years of service charge is the difference in price. If you plan to stay long term the lease is relatively short in that you would need to extend in less than 20 years and pay a price to do so.

You say there is a garden at the flat but is the flat ground floor. You won't realise what a pain it is lugging babies, pushchairs, shopping upstairs until you do it.

autumnalannie · 31/10/2026 19:04

First, decide where you want to live. look at the opportunities for life in that place - what are you into? And I mean now, not in 15 years time. Then decide what you want to live in. Then visit and see loads of properties over a few days. If you’re only 28, look at what a small mortgage would get you.

(I wouldn’t live in that Winchester flat. I remember them being built).

NotGalinda · 31/10/2026 19:06

Ely is lovely, but the location of that house is not good. It's on a busy junction, there is no parking, and behind it is a coffee yard. I love the coffee place, it's great, but it is open late some evenings, so I wouldn't want to back on to it. I can't see that the house has parking, you can't park outside because of the junction, and the street parking is always very busy. You'd have to park round the corner and walk a bit. That's the sort of house that would be a great Airbnb as it's so central to everything but you wouldn't want to live there.

Gengha · 31/10/2026 19:07

How can you be making such a drama out of buying a house? I used to wonder about the people who ended up on Phil and Kirstie, now I know.

JWhipple · 31/10/2026 20:02

Ely is freehold, no ground rent or service charge.
Is there no similar house in Winchester?

InOverMyHead84 · 31/10/2026 20:39

JWhipple · 31/10/2026 20:05

Again, in Kings Worthy just around the corner from me. Lovely area, know one of the families in that development, they are very happy with it.

Amazed how many of us are around here.

TaraRhu · 31/10/2026 20:44

I'm not keen on the Winchester property. The windows are too high to see out of. Plus there must be a service charge. A house is much more future proof. I think you'll go stir crazy in a flat like the Winchester one. I'd settle on Winchester but look for another home.

likelysuspect · 31/10/2026 21:47

JWhipple · 31/10/2026 20:05

Its shared ownership, expensive for half a property and OP didnt want to take a mortgage out

TheWildZebra · 31/10/2026 21:53

Hi! Grew up in Ely and lived there until 2 years ago when I had to move for work. I LOVE Ely. I used to hate it but tbh the Cambridge effect has been really positive for it and it’s a lot lot nicer than it used to be. The market is lovely on the weekends and there’s mroe of a community feel than there used to be. Being 15 mins from cambs on the train obviously also a bonus.

downsides:

  • the landscape isn’t the most exciting and apart from a couple of walks by the river you tend to have to travel to go somewhere nice (Norfolk obv nice)
  • Newnham Street is very busy - I’m not sure I’d choose to live on it myself.
  • to balance these and still get a good property: would you consider looking at villages outside like Little Downham - there’s a couple going there at the minute that are similar price bracket.
KnitOneSlipOneKnitOnePassSlippedStitchOver · 31/10/2026 22:00

Are you completely well, OP, or are you having a bit of a manic episode? This swinging from one city and property to another, fixation on being mortgage free at 28 (!), planning to leave a good career in finance to return to teaching, picking homes which are totally unsuitable for a family but insistent it’ll be a family home for a child you’re not even planning for nearly a decade, buying on your own but planning to have a non-working boyfriend live with you and potentially needing to house your parents… it all sounds like very muddled and chaotic thinking, and you’re not likely to make a sensible and sustainable decision in this sort of mood.

Can you just take a breath and talk to someone who knows more about property than you? At the very least you need to work out a good, sensible, lasting set of criteria for your home, especially as you want to be there for a long time.

I’d focus on getting a job first if you want to change career again, then your location will be set. Then look at homes - not just anything cheap enough that it would allow you to be mortgage free, because the homes in this bracket you’ve found so far all have huge disadvantages which would make them bad investments - but something that gives you everything you need for a family home. Even if you take out a mortgage - which 95 to 100% of people in your situation would need to - you’ll still only be in your early 50s by the time it’s paid off if you take out a standard 25 year term and never overpay a penny.

The sense of desperation in your posts makes me genuinely worried that you’re not in a fit state to handle this purchase and that you’re going to make a catastrophic and unrecoverably expensive mistake.

StormKevin · 31/10/2026 22:18

KnitOneSlipOneKnitOnePassSlippedStitchOver · 31/10/2026 22:00

Are you completely well, OP, or are you having a bit of a manic episode? This swinging from one city and property to another, fixation on being mortgage free at 28 (!), planning to leave a good career in finance to return to teaching, picking homes which are totally unsuitable for a family but insistent it’ll be a family home for a child you’re not even planning for nearly a decade, buying on your own but planning to have a non-working boyfriend live with you and potentially needing to house your parents… it all sounds like very muddled and chaotic thinking, and you’re not likely to make a sensible and sustainable decision in this sort of mood.

Can you just take a breath and talk to someone who knows more about property than you? At the very least you need to work out a good, sensible, lasting set of criteria for your home, especially as you want to be there for a long time.

I’d focus on getting a job first if you want to change career again, then your location will be set. Then look at homes - not just anything cheap enough that it would allow you to be mortgage free, because the homes in this bracket you’ve found so far all have huge disadvantages which would make them bad investments - but something that gives you everything you need for a family home. Even if you take out a mortgage - which 95 to 100% of people in your situation would need to - you’ll still only be in your early 50s by the time it’s paid off if you take out a standard 25 year term and never overpay a penny.

The sense of desperation in your posts makes me genuinely worried that you’re not in a fit state to handle this purchase and that you’re going to make a catastrophic and unrecoverably expensive mistake.

Harsh but fair!

Agree that you sound all over the place with your thought processes. Nothing makes sense!

I’d suggest you don’t buy anywhere until you have a better sense of purpose, what you are actually looking for in life.

Good luck to you.