Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What age trick or treating without adults.

72 replies

Laiste · 31/10/2026 15:09

DD is 12, has 2 friends over to go out trick or treating. I'm sending them out at 6 around the village without me this year!

The parents of the friends are ok with it. I'm just wondering what age everyone else is happy with this? Our village is very halloweeny for the kids - lots of houses go all out ! 🎃👻💀

It seems only yesterday they were so little !

OP posts:
waterrat · 31/10/2026 21:27

BOOO HISS to the person saying they are too old and 'desperate for sweets'

what a truly sad attitude. Think how little older kids and teens have in the way of play and fun in our culture - my 12 year old has been looking forward to dressing up and walking about with friends/ being part of the community event = for weeks!! Her face was actually lit up with joy earlier at seeing all the other children and being out in the dark.

as long as they dress up Im delighted when teens knock on our door.

you know its not really about the sweets - its about community and fun.

purpleme12 · 31/10/2026 21:37

My child is just turned 13
I still wouldn't feel comfortable with her going out trick or treating in the dark without an adult to be honest

Moreholidaysthanjudithchalmers · 01/11/2026 08:18

We had lots of teens all dressed up visiting in little groups. Some in bought costumes, some in diy (group of girls dressed as 101 Dalmatians with spots drawn
on school shirts were 13 ish) all very polite.
Glad I live where I do. It’s a nice evening. I like seeing them all dressed up enjoying themselves.

CoconutSwirl · 01/11/2026 08:32

Wow the negativity towards teens on here! And people saying 12 is too old?!?
Miseries!!!!
I live in a semi rural village.
I decorated my house splendidly, put pumpkins out, and spent the evening opening my door to 3/4 year olds with their mums and every age upwards through to 6th formers!
So many teens came round and all of them were in costume. There were small groups of teen girls, duos of 2 or small groups of 3 teen boys, and some boys & girls together. No large groups of teens came. Every single one of them gave me a big smile at my door, had charming manners, thanked me, they complimented me on my outside decorations, engaged me in conversation about how good my house looked "I love the way you've decorated your house! It's amazing!", and talked to me about their costumes and how they came up with their ideas when I remarked on how brilliant many of them were - I saw so much artistic and creative imagination being worn by teens last night! For example a group of 5 dressed up as Alice at the mad hatters tea party, and lots of other truly brilliant costumes. Two 15 year old boys knocked, I saw them approach my driveway with ghoulish masks on, one had a ripped shirt covered in fake blood, they were about 5ft10. I opened the door, they immediately lifted off their masks to show their faces, gave me a huge smile and said "Happy Halloween!" in the friendliest way possible. I asked them if they were having a good evening and they smiled, said yes it's brilliant, and started chatting to me about how all the decorated houses looked amazing, giving me tips on which ones I should go and see. Whilst I was talking to them, some little kids ran up to my door, pushed in front of them and grabbed at my bowl of sweets I was holding. I noticed the 2 teens quickly stepped right back to allow the little kids room to get to my door and they stepped back further than they needed to to give them plenty of space and then gave them a friendly happy Halloween greeting. Not one teenager took more than 1 sweet. If I said "Have a few more!" They said "Oh are you sure? Wow thank you so much!". Every one of them walked off saying "Have a lovely evening!" "Thank you!" "Happy Halloween!".
Honestly it was a delightful evening spent chatting to so many lovely teenagers. So incredibly polite, all of them. And I witnessed so many of them being lovely to the little kids.
In my opinion, it's good for teens to still be able to do things they loved doing as a little kid, it's wrong of adults to tell them they're too old to do something they still enjoy doing, and it's good for the little kids to see teens out on Halloween being friendly, integrating with the community and having fun!

SexyFrenchDepression · 01/11/2026 09:12

1985goingbackagain · 31/10/2026 16:50

Personally I think if they are old enough to go without adults, they are too old for trick or treating. I don’t want my kids knocking on doors without supervision.

I feel this way after last night, the 2 small groups of kids without adults basically ruined it for everyone. First lot too about 40 packets of sweets between the 2 of them and at 6pm 2nd group took the whole lot, heard on camera saying we just as well clear this.

I had to leave the sweets as too stressful for my blind dog to have the door going but everyone else was so lovely, such a shame that it ruined it for the other kids coming round.

SexyFrenchDepression · 01/11/2026 09:14

I should add I'm fine with older kids trick or treating but when mine were younger any older siblings would come along with the younger kids so it was a mixed group together but I guess if the kids are respectful then it doesnt matter so 11/12 is fine alone.

WilliamTopazMcGonagallPoorPoetFromDundeeBeItTold · 01/11/2026 12:09

Jeska7 · 31/10/2026 17:39

I agree. Some people are doing teens an injustice. I’m sure there are some who are a menace particularly in big groups, but the ones I’ve come across are very polite. I guess it depends where you are. It’s a bit of an excuse to go around with friends for those teens that don’t go out a lot or meet up with their friends. Most people know only to go to decorated houses with pumpkins out. So it’s not bothering elderly people.

The problem is that a lot of the bad ones have poisoned the well for the good ones. It's a bit like the nervousness and fear that many women feel when a man is walking close behind along a dark street, even though the vast majority don't pose any danger at all.

Even if they do only go to houses with pumpkins and decorations, it seems like the system is all or nothing, if there's no way of indicating that young kids, local kids you know, family and friends' kids etc. are welcome, but not necessarily everybody. A bit like when you see balloons and Happy Birthday banners on somebody's front door - it's there to welcome and make it special for the people they've invited along to celebrate with them; it doesn't mean that anybody walking past can come and join in the party!

WilliamTopazMcGonagallPoorPoetFromDundeeBeItTold · 01/11/2026 12:12

waterrat · 31/10/2026 21:27

BOOO HISS to the person saying they are too old and 'desperate for sweets'

what a truly sad attitude. Think how little older kids and teens have in the way of play and fun in our culture - my 12 year old has been looking forward to dressing up and walking about with friends/ being part of the community event = for weeks!! Her face was actually lit up with joy earlier at seeing all the other children and being out in the dark.

as long as they dress up Im delighted when teens knock on our door.

you know its not really about the sweets - its about community and fun.

you know its not really about the sweets - its about community and fun.

But this is exactly the problem for some older kids: for them, it IS just about getting their hands on free sweets; that's the only part of it that remotely interests them.

NiaAndFar · 01/11/2026 12:29

I live on an affluent rural village. No secondary age kids out. Theyve all grown out of it by then.They either arent interested or prefer the 'adult' side opening the door to the callers.

AppropriateAdult · 01/11/2026 12:49

As an Irish person I find all the negativity and angst around Halloween a bit baffling. My kids have been looking forward to it for weeks - it’s second only to Christmas in terms of anticipation and planning. 12yo DD went around with her friends for the third year in a row - we live in a fairly nice but not-at-all-posh suburb, and there can be antisocial behaviour from young teens at times, but I’d consider Halloween one of the safest nights for my kids to be out as there are just so many other people out and about. It’s very normal here for kids to dress up and trick or treat until 14 or 15, and everyone who knocked at our door last night was unfailingly polite and friendly.
Honestly, it just brings them so much joy, I really don’t understand the antipathy from so many here.

Stompythedinosaur · 01/11/2026 13:55

WilliamTopazMcGonagallPoorPoetFromDundeeBeItTold · 01/11/2026 12:09

The problem is that a lot of the bad ones have poisoned the well for the good ones. It's a bit like the nervousness and fear that many women feel when a man is walking close behind along a dark street, even though the vast majority don't pose any danger at all.

Even if they do only go to houses with pumpkins and decorations, it seems like the system is all or nothing, if there's no way of indicating that young kids, local kids you know, family and friends' kids etc. are welcome, but not necessarily everybody. A bit like when you see balloons and Happy Birthday banners on somebody's front door - it's there to welcome and make it special for the people they've invited along to celebrate with them; it doesn't mean that anybody walking past can come and join in the party!

I mean, I'd say houses that only want to give sweets to the sub-sections if society they have deemed worthy are probably missing the spirit of a community event.

But they could always not put up decorations and just tell their favoured kids to knock I guess?

It's weird though.

OhBettyCalmDown · 01/11/2026 14:02

12 is fine if your area is safe and you trust your DC & friends.

SplendidUtterly · 01/11/2026 14:07

I thought knocking on doors and asking for treats was more for younger children who were accompanied by a adult.

VioletsTale · 01/11/2026 14:14

I find all the “too old” comments very ironic when there are threads upon threads about kids growing up too fast, having “grown up” interests etc. Yet on this thread , kids acting like kids are either antisocial menaces or pathetic Peter Pans.

SuddenDaredJelly · 01/11/2026 14:25

Ive always told my kids, trick or treating is for young kids, it ends after primary school. If they are old enough to be out with no supervision at all, imho they are too old to trick or treat.

I know people allow teens to, I don't care, mine will be staying home to offer out the sweets for little ones.

CoconutSwirl · 01/11/2026 15:42

VioletsTale · 01/11/2026 14:14

I find all the “too old” comments very ironic when there are threads upon threads about kids growing up too fast, having “grown up” interests etc. Yet on this thread , kids acting like kids are either antisocial menaces or pathetic Peter Pans.

But that's mumsnet all over isn't.
You literally cannot win. Ever. No matter what side of any debate or conversation is ever put across, along will come mumsnetters to shout them down.
It's a sport for some, I think.

CoconutSwirl · 01/11/2026 15:48

SuddenDaredJelly · 01/11/2026 14:25

Ive always told my kids, trick or treating is for young kids, it ends after primary school. If they are old enough to be out with no supervision at all, imho they are too old to trick or treat.

I know people allow teens to, I don't care, mine will be staying home to offer out the sweets for little ones.

Feel sad for your kids.
What an uninclusive, anti-fun, ageist and negative message to give them when they reach year 7 onwards.

Honestly, poor kids.

Laiste · 02/11/2026 11:54

Sorry i havent been back !!! Until today my phone was saying i had zero answers 🧐🎃

Thank you to all. Bit late now i know but very interesting mix of opinions.

Yes DD was dressed up. The other two girls actually made their own costumes - very impressed!

Our village is very much all or nothing. The houses which decorate really decorate and there's no confusion re: 'to knock or not to knock'. A few end up with actual queues of kids up the path! 90% of the kids come out between 6 and 7 so it's a mad hour answering the door (we decorate too obvs).

There is only one school in our village (primary) and nearly all the kids go to the same secondary, a bus ride away in town, when they move up so all the kids know each other or know one of the family so it's nice for them all out on the streets together. Def NO knocking at undecorated houses. She was back home at 7.

All our 'knockers' were so polite ! Taking one sweet out of the bowl and having to be encouraged to take a second. Everyone dressed up. Everyone having fun. Our last knocker was at about 7.30.

Im glad DD went out with her mates. We tracked her round the village with phone tracker. So many houses are decorated round here that it's not actually possible to visit every single one unless you set out at 5 and went hard at it till 7 🤣

Thanks again all.
And now .... well, it's xmas next isn't it ! 🤪

OP posts:
caffelattetogo · 02/11/2026 12:01

I’d say if they’re old enough to go alone they’re too old for trick or treating.

caffelattetogo · 02/11/2026 12:03

CoconutSwirl · 01/11/2026 15:48

Feel sad for your kids.
What an uninclusive, anti-fun, ageist and negative message to give them when they reach year 7 onwards.

Honestly, poor kids.

It’s a balance though isn’t it? Groups of older kids can be pretty intimidating on dark nights. While my older neighbours are happy to see the kids, they find big groups of teens their height a bit intimidating to open the door to.

WilliamTopazMcGonagallPoorPoetFromDundeeBeItTold · 02/11/2026 12:11

caffelattetogo · 02/11/2026 12:03

It’s a balance though isn’t it? Groups of older kids can be pretty intimidating on dark nights. While my older neighbours are happy to see the kids, they find big groups of teens their height a bit intimidating to open the door to.

Yes, I agree - you can't claim that it's a fun community event without acknowledging that the elderly folk are also part of the community, and they very likely may be frightened by a group of masked teenagers at their door after dark.

I think 'ageism' is a bit of a stretch too, when applied to children, as it's an entirely normal fact of growing up that some things are more or less suitable at different stages of childhood. Who seriously believes that a 2yo child and a 16yo child will be doing and enjoying the same activities? Just wait and see your teenager's face light up on Christmas Day when they unwrap their 4-piece Paw Patrol jigsaw, next to their equally excited pre-school sibling with their can of Lynx Africa!!

SuddenDaredJelly · 02/11/2026 12:19

CoconutSwirl · 01/11/2026 15:48

Feel sad for your kids.
What an uninclusive, anti-fun, ageist and negative message to give them when they reach year 7 onwards.

Honestly, poor kids.

They can have different fun. Happy to host their friends for halloween parties, but they dont need to be out door knocking and asking for sweets.

My kids 100% do not need your pity!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page