Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think men don’t find ‘good mums’ as attractive as women find ‘good dads’

33 replies

UsernameNotAvailableApparently · 30/10/2026 20:49

Backstory: DSis is a single mum and falls head over heels with any man who is a good dad to their kids (divorced dads only, she’s not a monster)

She is literally an amazing mum, she’s so good with her kid and anyone else’s kids, it’s genuinely lovely to see.

BUT I just feel like men don’t see that as a character quality in her and it made me think that men don’t have that as high on their priority list.

So YANBU men just don’t find that attractive or YABU your sister is just dating shitty men

OP posts:
ExOptimist · 30/10/2026 22:18

There are also plenty of women who find shit dads very attractive. Lots of women on here who are the second or third wife to a man who rarely, if ever, sees his children from the previous marriage, and don't think that says anything negative about him.

Women are generally assumed to be good mothers, but that's not attractive to a man. The men who talk about and praise good mothers are talking about their wives, they aren't single men looking for a woman with whom to have a new relationship.

maybemaybenot17363 · 30/10/2026 22:23

This is interesting actually. I think a man only wants a good mother for HIS children and not other males.

TheFormerMrsTruelove · 30/10/2026 22:23

I think the only time a man is going to take a woman’s parenting skills into consideration is when he’s a shit dad and is looking for a nanny, cook and cleaner who’ll also have sex with him.

If she’s listening to you, tell her to stop putting being a good dad so high on her list. That’s an absolute basic requirement, they don’t get points for that. The same as they don’t get points for being nice, not lying, being faithful and pulling their weight. It’s only if they go above and beyond these things that they become impressive.

Unwantedmaleopinion · 30/10/2026 22:41

@UsernameNotAvailableApparently

Are you not conflating two issues here. In regards to your DSis if she’s dating youngish men with youngish children is she not pulling from a pool of men that are proven to be shit as it takes a lot for a woman to walk away from a relationship when she has children so the high chances he’s shit to me seems a no brainer?

My friend was kicked to the curb for being a bit shit. He has a daughter one night a week plays dad of the year in that time but has the rest of the week to sleep go the gym spend more of his money on clothes. Where the likes of myself have got the same time as anyone else in a relationship with two little kids and most my money goes on family life and family holidays.

AllPlayedOut · 31/10/2026 09:33

Crushed23 · 30/10/2026 20:58

I have never been attracted to a man who is a dad, good or otherwise. Instant turn-off.

Likewise. If I see an attractive man then I see that he has a child, I can practically feel my ovaries shrivel and put up a closed sign.

potterypieces · 31/10/2026 10:40

BabyBa · 30/10/2026 21:43

Well I remember doing a google search once and it was “why are single mums” and the suggests were “easy” “stigmatised” “looked down on” “so bitter” so out of interest I looked up why are single dads and the suggestions were “so hot” “attractive” “better parents” as pp said being a mum isnt hot or sexy to men

Google search prompts do open your eyes don’t they?

Brightbluesomething · 31/10/2026 10:47

Man usually aren’t interested in whether you’re a good mum to someone else’s children. Having your own kids is competition for your time and energy so it’s not attractive to them.
I wouldn’t date a man who doesn’t see or pay for his kids, that tells you a lot about their morals and values. Even the ones that do are not always great fathers, and none of that tells you whether they’d be a good partner.

VimesandhisCardboardBoots · 31/10/2026 10:52

Generalising, but men and women tend to date differently.

Women date looking for a partner, right from the first date. That means they're looking for traits that will be beneficial in a long term relationship. "Good Dad" is one of those traits.

Most men aren't looking for a long term relationship when they're dating. They're looking for a second date. The only things they're looking for on the first date someone they enjoy themselves with, that they're attracted to, and who likes them back enough for a second date.

From watching my single friends, the two sexes see dating so differently. For men, dating is fun. It's an enjoyable activity in its own right, like a hobby. For women, it's a chore. It's risky, it's fruitless a lot of the time. It's just something you have to do to get to the good stuff later.

For men, A long term relationship isn't the aim, it's something that happens when they're not looking. At which point they realise, "shit, I'm in a relationship, um, actually this woman has qualities I don't actually want in a long term partner. For a start, she doesn't seem like that good a mum" and they promptly dump the woman.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page