Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are the far left more dangerous than we realise

1000 replies

MabelsCatMabel · 24/10/2026 10:23

"The French president took to the airwaves on Sunday to condemn the rioters and blame far-Left agitators for hijacking what began weeks ago as a demonstration against poor conditions in schools."

He called for “calm and order” after a day of protests saw shops looted, cars set alight and public buildings burned to the ground. The collapse of the clock tower attached to Limoges city hall after it was gutted by a fire started by rioters on Saturday will become an abiding image of France’s nadir."

Are the far left more dangerous than we realise?

Far right is a known problem, but are we more ignorant to the far left and therefore tolerate that more?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
CornishDaughteroftheDawn · 27/10/2026 23:02

TopPocketFind · 27/10/2026 22:59

A false impression of what?

Parents can fill in the gaps if necessary.

A false impression that the left are not equally perpetrators of human atrocities.

Why should it be up to parents to ‘fill in the gaps’?

LizzieW1969 · 27/10/2026 23:03

CornishDaughteroftheDawn · 27/10/2026 22:52

There is a lack of info about Stalin and Mao in schools compared to info about Hitler. It gives children a false impression.

I suspect that’s only because of the focus on World War II, though. Where Hitler was the enemy and Stalin was one of the allies. And I don’t really see how that’s anything to do with the left, when the Tories have had more involvement with the National Curriculum than Labour.

LuckyHazelFox · 27/10/2026 23:12

CornishDaughteroftheDawn · 27/10/2026 23:00

Exactly. An Islamist website is pleased that there are so many Muslim Green Party members “despite” the party’s stance on LGBTQ.

It is bizarre that so many people would join a party that has a significant and fairly central set of views that so drastically oppose their own.

They really are officially now the paradox party.

CornishDaughteroftheDawn · 27/10/2026 23:13

TopPocketFind · 27/10/2026 22:57

Extreme Islamic views. I have posted the definition earlier today.

Yet an Islamic website is pleased that more Muslims have joined the Green Party “despite” their stance on LGBTQ.

I’d say objecting to the existence of gay people is an extreme view, no?

What about their proposed motion to allow greater ‘free speech’ rights over Gaza/Islam following cases like the NHS doctor who was suspended for calling for the death of a Hindu man for disrespecting Islam? That sounds like a pretty extreme view.

TopPocketFind · 27/10/2026 23:21

CornishDaughteroftheDawn · 27/10/2026 23:13

Yet an Islamic website is pleased that more Muslims have joined the Green Party “despite” their stance on LGBTQ.

I’d say objecting to the existence of gay people is an extreme view, no?

What about their proposed motion to allow greater ‘free speech’ rights over Gaza/Islam following cases like the NHS doctor who was suspended for calling for the death of a Hindu man for disrespecting Islam? That sounds like a pretty extreme view.

It is an extreme view and not one shared by all Muslims.

I am sure you are not saying that all Muslims are extreme Islamists. Or that anyone who cares about what is happening in Gaza is an extreme Islamist.

TopPocketFind · 27/10/2026 23:22

You know a lot more about the Green party than me.

Tiredtaxpayer · 28/10/2026 00:56

TemperanceWest · 26/10/2026 16:02

And the far right don't? Look at the likes of Lowe and his supporters for example. Robinson. Danny Thomas. Pretending to be good "Christians".

Edited

I'd like to disabuse you of the notion that there are such things as "good Christians" - the church is a hospital for sinners, not a club for saints.

You have to recognize that Jesus never promised that the church would always have all their Ministers and Members be holy and saints at all times. In fact, to the contrary, he said, “Well, I’m picking a bunch of people who have defects and are sinners.” And as St. Paul says, “Through your weakness, my power is shown.” In other words, the fact that Christ can work through defective human instruments and still keep his church going is itself kind of an evidence for the truth of the Christian faith.

Koalacanth · 28/10/2026 01:09

The far left are more dangerous than the extremely naive realise. Anyone with a grasp of history should be aware of the danger.

CornishDaughteroftheDawn · 28/10/2026 07:38

TopPocketFind · 27/10/2026 23:21

It is an extreme view and not one shared by all Muslims.

I am sure you are not saying that all Muslims are extreme Islamists. Or that anyone who cares about what is happening in Gaza is an extreme Islamist.

You said ‘an Islamic extremist’ would not be in the Green Party - but you have suddenly jumped to the tired old manoeuvre of accusing me of meaning ‘all’ Muslims.

I demonstrated that it is quite an accepted view that Muslims who are anti LGBTQ would be in the GP, as observed on a high profile Islamic website. They said the members were there “despite” the LGBTQ policies. Such anti views are quite common among U.K. Muslims - polls show that more than 50% of Muslims think that homosexuality should be outlawed. Their Muslim Deputy leader is unusually coy about his opinions on the topic and has been criticised internally for his lack of support for the policies.

Can you just clarify whether you class being anti LGBTQ as an extreme view?

TemperanceWest · 28/10/2026 08:46

Tiredtaxpayer · 28/10/2026 00:56

I'd like to disabuse you of the notion that there are such things as "good Christians" - the church is a hospital for sinners, not a club for saints.

You have to recognize that Jesus never promised that the church would always have all their Ministers and Members be holy and saints at all times. In fact, to the contrary, he said, “Well, I’m picking a bunch of people who have defects and are sinners.” And as St. Paul says, “Through your weakness, my power is shown.” In other words, the fact that Christ can work through defective human instruments and still keep his church going is itself kind of an evidence for the truth of the Christian faith.

If Christ is working through violent, racist, coke addled scumbags, I can only assume he wants to turn people away from Christianity not towards it.

TopPocketFind · 28/10/2026 09:06

Can you just clarify whether you class being anti LGBTQ as an extreme view?

I think it is a hateful view that can lead to extremism

Sadly a lot of relgions and groups share this hatred.

Tiredtaxpayer · 28/10/2026 09:14

TemperanceWest · 28/10/2026 08:46

If Christ is working through violent, racist, coke addled scumbags, I can only assume he wants to turn people away from Christianity not towards it.

You can assume what you like because it appears you are very ignorant about the Christian faith.
Why bash Christianity ?
Peoples' faith/belief systems aren't relevant to this discussion.

Tiredtaxpayer · 28/10/2026 09:16

@TopPocketFind "Sadly a lot of relgions and groups share this hatred."

Maybe you'd like to name some?

Sartre · 28/10/2026 09:18

Far anything is dangerous. Stalin and Lenin were hardly the political heroes many on the left seem to think. The Green’s have gone way too far recently and ironically (given the leader) are fuelling antisemitism.

TemperanceWest · 28/10/2026 09:19

Tiredtaxpayer · 28/10/2026 09:14

You can assume what you like because it appears you are very ignorant about the Christian faith.
Why bash Christianity ?
Peoples' faith/belief systems aren't relevant to this discussion.

I am not bashing Christianity. I respect other people's faiths.

I am bashing your ludicrous theory that Christ has chosen to work through the likes of Yaxley-Lennon. His Christianity is fake.

Tiredtaxpayer · 28/10/2026 09:30

TemperanceWest · 28/10/2026 09:19

I am not bashing Christianity. I respect other people's faiths.

I am bashing your ludicrous theory that Christ has chosen to work through the likes of Yaxley-Lennon. His Christianity is fake.

"I am not bashing Christianity. I respect other people's faiths."

I don't see much respect in your post.

It isn't up to any of us to assume we know how God works. Neither is it to judge who God uses as his instrument.

FYI
Notable Saints with Sinful Pasts;

Saint Augustine of Hippo: Lived a restless youth of hedonism, intellectual pride, sexual immorality, theft (such as stealing pears), and a long-term concubinage before his conversion and baptism by Saint Ambrose. He later detailed his journey in his famous Confessions.

Saint Mary of Egypt: Spent roughly 17 years in Alexandria leading a life driven by insatiable lust and prostitution, often actively trying to drag others into sin, before undergoing a sudden conversion at the Church of the Holy Sepulchre and spending 47 years as a desert hermit in deep repentance.

Saint Paul the Apostle (Saul of Tarsus): Actively persecuted, imprisoned, and consented to the murder of early Christians until his dramatic conversion experience on the road to Damascus.

Saint Olga of Kiev: Ruled with brutal vengeance after her husband's assassination, executing her enemies by burying them alive and burning rival factions before traveling to Constantinople and converting to Christianity.

Saint Moses the Black: Originally a violent brigand, robber, and gang leader in Egypt who turned to a monastic life of radical humility and ascetism after repenting of his criminal ways.

TopPocketFind · 28/10/2026 09:32

Tiredtaxpayer · 28/10/2026 09:16

@TopPocketFind "Sadly a lot of relgions and groups share this hatred."

Maybe you'd like to name some?

Yaxley Lennon opposes trans rights.

TemperanceWest · 28/10/2026 09:36

The notion that Yaxley-Lennon is God's instrument has to be one of the most, er, unusual takes I have read in a while. I am not convinced pp is serious so am not going to indulge them further.

Shakeoffyourchains · 28/10/2026 10:05

Always amazes me how clearly right wingers cab see the issues on the left while not just turning a blind eye to their own (much more serious) issues, but actively defending them.

Last I checked it's not left leaning tech bros interfering in democracies around the world or pushing specific viewpoints while surpressing the one's they don't like.

Nor is it left leaning religious extremists tirelessly working to remove fundamental human and women's rights and take us back to the middle ages.

Nor is it left leaning governments presiding over ever worsening wealth inequality, while simultaneously starting wars, destroying the environment and attempting to further erode workers' and human rights.

But sure, loose collections of left leaning people protesting specific issues is far more dangerous than organised and well funded right wing groups working directly with powerful political figures to shape government policy and approach.

OhBotherSaidPoo · 28/10/2026 10:09

Shakeoffyourchains · 28/10/2026 10:05

Always amazes me how clearly right wingers cab see the issues on the left while not just turning a blind eye to their own (much more serious) issues, but actively defending them.

Last I checked it's not left leaning tech bros interfering in democracies around the world or pushing specific viewpoints while surpressing the one's they don't like.

Nor is it left leaning religious extremists tirelessly working to remove fundamental human and women's rights and take us back to the middle ages.

Nor is it left leaning governments presiding over ever worsening wealth inequality, while simultaneously starting wars, destroying the environment and attempting to further erode workers' and human rights.

But sure, loose collections of left leaning people protesting specific issues is far more dangerous than organised and well funded right wing groups working directly with powerful political figures to shape government policy and approach.

It always amazes me when people says shit like this and are completely oblivious to their own hypocrisy.

quantumbutterfly · 28/10/2026 10:18

Shakeoffyourchains · 28/10/2026 10:05

Always amazes me how clearly right wingers cab see the issues on the left while not just turning a blind eye to their own (much more serious) issues, but actively defending them.

Last I checked it's not left leaning tech bros interfering in democracies around the world or pushing specific viewpoints while surpressing the one's they don't like.

Nor is it left leaning religious extremists tirelessly working to remove fundamental human and women's rights and take us back to the middle ages.

Nor is it left leaning governments presiding over ever worsening wealth inequality, while simultaneously starting wars, destroying the environment and attempting to further erode workers' and human rights.

But sure, loose collections of left leaning people protesting specific issues is far more dangerous than organised and well funded right wing groups working directly with powerful political figures to shape government policy and approach.

Nor is it left leaning religious extremists tirelessly working to remove fundamental human and women's rights and take us back to the middle ages.
So much to unpack there. It is indeed a strange (and dangerous) alliance of faith & politics. Just as it was in Iran. In USSR the church was a useful tool for the security services apparently.
PRC seems to realise the threat to its authority of externally led faith groups ( as did Henry VIII). If they can persuade buddhists to accept their choice of dalai lama reincarnation that will consolidate power over a traditional faith perhaps.

EasternStandard · 28/10/2026 10:22

quantumbutterfly · 28/10/2026 10:18

Nor is it left leaning religious extremists tirelessly working to remove fundamental human and women's rights and take us back to the middle ages.
So much to unpack there. It is indeed a strange (and dangerous) alliance of faith & politics. Just as it was in Iran. In USSR the church was a useful tool for the security services apparently.
PRC seems to realise the threat to its authority of externally led faith groups ( as did Henry VIII). If they can persuade buddhists to accept their choice of dalai lama reincarnation that will consolidate power over a traditional faith perhaps.

Yes that’s one of the reasons listed below which has been picked up a fair few times with women agreeing.

Looking at Iran once the left help religious extremists get in they can’t get out from under them. It’s brutal and violent, and very hard to reverse.

Tiredtaxpayer · 28/10/2026 10:23

TemperanceWest · 28/10/2026 09:36

The notion that Yaxley-Lennon is God's instrument has to be one of the most, er, unusual takes I have read in a while. I am not convinced pp is serious so am not going to indulge them further.

If you had read my post properly and understood what I actually said (not what you think I said) you'll see I never claimed that Mr Y-L was 'God's instrument'.
What I said was that God uses the most unusual people (unusual to us that is) to fulfill his purpose.

Tiredtaxpayer · 28/10/2026 10:26

@Shakeoffyourchains "Always amazes me how clearly right wingers cab see the issues on the left while not just turning a blind eye to their own (much more serious) issues, but actively defending them."

That isn't a left/right issue just a human failing. We are all experts at justifying our own behaviour.

Tiredtaxpayer · 28/10/2026 10:33

TopPocketFind · 28/10/2026 09:32

Yaxley Lennon opposes trans rights.

Apparently he said that 'biological men cannot have babies'.
That's a biological fact, not an erosion of an individual's rights.
So what else did he actually say?
I don't see what the issue is.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.