Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are the far left more dangerous than we realise

1000 replies

MabelsCatMabel · 24/10/2026 10:23

"The French president took to the airwaves on Sunday to condemn the rioters and blame far-Left agitators for hijacking what began weeks ago as a demonstration against poor conditions in schools."

He called for “calm and order” after a day of protests saw shops looted, cars set alight and public buildings burned to the ground. The collapse of the clock tower attached to Limoges city hall after it was gutted by a fire started by rioters on Saturday will become an abiding image of France’s nadir."

Are the far left more dangerous than we realise?

Far right is a known problem, but are we more ignorant to the far left and therefore tolerate that more?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
GeneralPeter · 26/10/2026 23:23

HandPulledNoodles · 26/10/2026 22:59

The right absolutely has its own “omnicause”. Look at the culture wars and the defence of the “traditional family unit”. Abortion, same-sex marriage, sex education, divorce and anything that doesn't fit the husband, wife and 2.4 children model are all presented as part of the same threat to traditional society see also immigration.

That's precisely the linking of disparate issues into one overarching ideological struggle you're claiming doesn't happen on the right. You're just more accustomed to recognising it on the left.

Ok — defence of the traditional family unit, with the other issues you mentioned.

Adam Smith Institute: leans against the state promotion of marriage. Pro-choice. Pro immigration. No position on divorce, though has argued for making marriage matters entirely contractual.

Institute of Economic Affairs: favours tax system support for traditional marriage. No position on abortion. Shifting against immigration. Can’t see much on divorce but in the 1990s took a traditional line.

Conservative Party: introduced gay marriage. Free vote on abortion. Has swung around on immigration, now quite anti. Introduced no-fault divorce.

Reform: pro tax support for marriage. No policy on abortion. Anti immigration. No formal policy on divorce but key figures have spoken against no-fault divorce.

I’m not seeing an omnicause here. Do you have any better examples?

Tiredtaxpayer · 26/10/2026 23:28

babyproblems · 24/10/2026 10:27

In 2026 where we have the biggest wealth inequality gap which is growing; billionaires who live in a different world to the rest of us and who use their money to influence global politics and live above the reach of the legal system; this is a stupid post.

The telegraph is absolute nonsense and part of the above system which is contributing in the great transfer of our wealth into the hands of the ultra wealthy.

"The telegraph is absolute nonsense and part of the above system which is contributing in the great transfer of our wealth into the hands of the ultra wealthy."

It might interest you to know that taxpayers with incomes of £214,000 + pay 29% of the total income tax bill.
A very small fraction—such as around 60 individuals with annual incomes over £50 million—contributed approximately 1.4% of total income tax receipts.

If you want to have a fairer way to use tax revenues then lobby for this government to stop all this Net Zero bo££ock$ they are obsessed with.

GeneralPeter · 26/10/2026 23:32

HandPulledNoodles · 26/10/2026 23:08

I think you're confusing a difference in language with a difference in behaviour. The right routinely links immigration, trans rights, education, net zero and free speech into one overarching battle against “woke ideology”. In the US, Project 2025 united over 100 conservative organisations covering everything from abortion to economics under one political agenda.

The left may be more explicit about intersectionality, but the right absolutely has its own version of the omnicause.

So I am largely talking about the UK, but even in the US the right is riven on major issues between the free-market right, the populist right, and the traditional conservative right.

If I know you support stronger law and order, I’ve no idea whether you are pro-tariffs (strongly) or anti-tariffs (strongly), pro-NATO (strongly) or anti-NATO (strongly). Etc.

I think there was a time in the 1970s where the left were splintered on lots of issues. I don’t really see it now.

HandPulledNoodles · 26/10/2026 23:33

GeneralPeter · 26/10/2026 23:23

Ok — defence of the traditional family unit, with the other issues you mentioned.

Adam Smith Institute: leans against the state promotion of marriage. Pro-choice. Pro immigration. No position on divorce, though has argued for making marriage matters entirely contractual.

Institute of Economic Affairs: favours tax system support for traditional marriage. No position on abortion. Shifting against immigration. Can’t see much on divorce but in the 1990s took a traditional line.

Conservative Party: introduced gay marriage. Free vote on abortion. Has swung around on immigration, now quite anti. Introduced no-fault divorce.

Reform: pro tax support for marriage. No policy on abortion. Anti immigration. No formal policy on divorce but key figures have spoken against no-fault divorce.

I’m not seeing an omnicause here. Do you have any better examples?

Edited

But you're applying different standards. Greenpeace, Stonewall and trade unions are all broadly associated with the left, yet they don't share identical positions or campaign on every issue. Why would you expect the Adam Smith Institute, IEA and Reform to do so?

BLM, Pride and trans rights are linked through a broader equality narrative on the left. On the right, free speech, gender identity, immigration, national heritage and education are similarly linked through the fight against “woke ideology”.

TopPocketFind · 26/10/2026 23:35

GeneralPeter · 26/10/2026 23:23

Ok — defence of the traditional family unit, with the other issues you mentioned.

Adam Smith Institute: leans against the state promotion of marriage. Pro-choice. Pro immigration. No position on divorce, though has argued for making marriage matters entirely contractual.

Institute of Economic Affairs: favours tax system support for traditional marriage. No position on abortion. Shifting against immigration. Can’t see much on divorce but in the 1990s took a traditional line.

Conservative Party: introduced gay marriage. Free vote on abortion. Has swung around on immigration, now quite anti. Introduced no-fault divorce.

Reform: pro tax support for marriage. No policy on abortion. Anti immigration. No formal policy on divorce but key figures have spoken against no-fault divorce.

I’m not seeing an omnicause here. Do you have any better examples?

Edited

But you see an omnicause in left wing parties and organisations?

You could make a similar left leaning list using the same arguments and outlining the differences to dispel the omnicause.

GeneralPeter · 26/10/2026 23:40

TopPocketFind · 26/10/2026 23:35

But you see an omnicause in left wing parties and organisations?

You could make a similar left leaning list using the same arguments and outlining the differences to dispel the omnicause.

Ok — but I took the issues that a PP suggested the right is an omicause on, and then took four fairly prominent ‘right’ organisations, and looked it up.

I’m not trying to cherry pick.

We can take the three issues PP mentioned as left ones, and some left organisations (maybe the ones PP suggested, or maybe take two parties and two mainstream think-tanks) and do the same.

I haven’t done the exercise yet so maybe it won’t turn out as I expect.

InOverMyHead84 · 26/10/2026 23:51

TemperanceWest · 26/10/2026 16:02

And the far right don't? Look at the likes of Lowe and his supporters for example. Robinson. Danny Thomas. Pretending to be good "Christians".

Edited

As I said, any 'far' is awful. Just more horror.

LouisTheYardTeacher · 26/10/2026 23:52

My feeling is the mentality that nurtures the 'omnicause' is stronger on the left, due to its collectivist approach, as opposed to the right's individualism. That's not to say the right can't also be dicks, just that it's less likely to take that particular form.

GeneralPeter · 26/10/2026 23:57

It’s past my bedtime so I’m just going to trust ChatGPT for now:

“Greenpeace, Stonewall and the unions all back BLM, Pride and trans rights at leadership level; the dissent on trans rights comes from inside Stonewall and the unions.”

This is what I would have expected.

I’m not sure why Greenpeace or Stonewall should have any position on BLM, or why Greenpeace should have a view on Pride or trans issues, other than as a general linking of causes (quod erat demonstrandum).

Countryside Alliance, for example has a view on immigration (it’s for it, because of migrant farm labour). Taxpayers Alliance has a view (it worries about the cost of asylum). Neither derived their view from a general “anti-woke” line.

IsEveryUserNameBloodyTaken · 27/10/2026 00:38

LuckyHazelFox · 26/10/2026 22:56

The right dont need a specific term because everything that is wrong in society is attributed to the them. That's one reason why the left are incapable of criticism because it's much simpler to be virtuous about their beliefs. Instead, the rest of us see how insidious the behaviour of the hard left is, with a common cause to spread their destructive and divisive behaviour around. The hang up on the omnicause term is nothing other than an attempt to divert negative attention from the left. As you have seen on this thread. Palestine/just stop oil/queers for Palestine/stop the fascists while we behave like fascists/attack women for daring to be gender critical etc. It must be exhausting being so easily offended while behaving like dicks.

Yes beautifully put.

YouLittleWally · 27/10/2026 01:59

overnightangel · 24/10/2026 10:27

Of course they are.
-Trans ideology being dangerous to women and to children
-Advocating for unvetted immigration on a crazy scale
-The rise of anti-semitism as sponsored by the Greens
-Labelling anyone who doesn’t embrace extremist Islam doctrine as “far right”

Couldn’t agree more

EasternStandard · 27/10/2026 07:03

LouisTheYardTeacher · 26/10/2026 22:30

I think there is a reflex here to deal with any criticism of the left, by instantly claiming an exact parallel on the right. But for various reasons I don't think the group dynamics on the left and right always play out in the same way.

Yes agree.

@KathleenDarleenDayKnightjust had a look re Bilboa. I don’t think the same will spread here, hopefully not, but it is across various EU countries.,

CornishDaughteroftheDawn · 27/10/2026 07:46

GeneralPeter · 26/10/2026 23:57

It’s past my bedtime so I’m just going to trust ChatGPT for now:

“Greenpeace, Stonewall and the unions all back BLM, Pride and trans rights at leadership level; the dissent on trans rights comes from inside Stonewall and the unions.”

This is what I would have expected.

I’m not sure why Greenpeace or Stonewall should have any position on BLM, or why Greenpeace should have a view on Pride or trans issues, other than as a general linking of causes (quod erat demonstrandum).

Countryside Alliance, for example has a view on immigration (it’s for it, because of migrant farm labour). Taxpayers Alliance has a view (it worries about the cost of asylum). Neither derived their view from a general “anti-woke” line.

Edited

Greenpeace, Stonewall and the unions all back BLM, Pride and trans rights at leadership level; the dissent on trans rights comes from inside Stonewall and the unions.

This rings true. Many of these policy approaches are being driven top down. The Stonewall leadership is on record about when she decided to adopt so called ‘trans rights’ and placed them above all else.

They have thrown gay men and lesbians under the bus and were advocating for changes in the law that will be detrimental to them in its quest to carve out new ‘rights’ for people who feel that they might be the opposite sex.

The Green Party is probably the best example of zealously adopting what they deem to be the righteous view and appears to have all but abandoned sanity the environment - its original purpose and has gone so far left it’s making racist policy and supporting extreme Islamists. Although interestingly some of that has been driven by entryism and although the leadership might have initially enabled the entryism with a view to gain power, they appear now to be regretting it.

OonaStubbs · 27/10/2026 12:00

What do the extreme Islamists in the green party think about their policy on trans rights? It doesn't seem like the two things really go together.

MabelsCatMabel · 27/10/2026 14:08

OonaStubbs · 27/10/2026 12:00

What do the extreme Islamists in the green party think about their policy on trans rights? It doesn't seem like the two things really go together.

Good question.

Any Greens here like to answer that?

OP posts:
YourAmplePlumPoster · 27/10/2026 16:36

The answer to the thread header is read "The Black Book of Communism" by French ex Communist Stephan Courtois. The numerous accounts of life under Stalinism and Soviet Russia by Solzhenitsyn and others and famous accounts of life under Mao by writers such as Jung Chang. The Lives of Others and Stasiland by Anna Funder lets you know the toxic spying and snitching encoraged by Communism. Why anyone wants this back, especially young, is a mystery

LuckyHazelFox · 27/10/2026 16:39

OonaStubbs · 27/10/2026 12:00

What do the extreme Islamists in the green party think about their policy on trans rights? It doesn't seem like the two things really go together.

They dont need go square that because if you notice, they are never put on the spot.

TopPocketFind · 27/10/2026 16:48

OonaStubbs · 27/10/2026 12:00

What do the extreme Islamists in the green party think about their policy on trans rights? It doesn't seem like the two things really go together.

Who are the extreme islamists in the Green party?

Any examples?

Verv · 27/10/2026 16:56

TopPocketFind · 27/10/2026 16:48

Who are the extreme islamists in the Green party?

Any examples?

Mothin Ali.

Crawling in Palestine flags despite being elected to serve Leeds and not Gaza, despite declaring that his win was FOR Gaza, which is weirdly unrelated to the bins in Gipton.

Topped it by yelling "Allahu Akbar".

You could be forgiven for hearing/seeing that shite and thinking "hm, bit extreme".

TopPocketFind · 27/10/2026 16:59

Verv · 27/10/2026 16:56

Mothin Ali.

Crawling in Palestine flags despite being elected to serve Leeds and not Gaza, despite declaring that his win was FOR Gaza, which is weirdly unrelated to the bins in Gipton.

Topped it by yelling "Allahu Akbar".

You could be forgiven for hearing/seeing that shite and thinking "hm, bit extreme".

Is that your example of extreme Islamism?

Or an example of a guy whose views you do not agree with?

LuckyHazelFox · 27/10/2026 17:01

Verv · 27/10/2026 16:56

Mothin Ali.

Crawling in Palestine flags despite being elected to serve Leeds and not Gaza, despite declaring that his win was FOR Gaza, which is weirdly unrelated to the bins in Gipton.

Topped it by yelling "Allahu Akbar".

You could be forgiven for hearing/seeing that shite and thinking "hm, bit extreme".

A vile racist man.

TopPocketFind · 27/10/2026 17:02

LuckyHazelFox · 27/10/2026 17:01

A vile racist man.

But not an extreme Islamist.

Maybe he is part of the omnicause cult?

LuckyHazelFox · 27/10/2026 17:05

TopPocketFind · 27/10/2026 17:02

But not an extreme Islamist.

Maybe he is part of the omnicause cult?

How do you know he's not an extremist. I bet you have no trouble believing Farage is one so what's the difference in your rationale?

TopPocketFind · 27/10/2026 17:07

LuckyHazelFox · 27/10/2026 17:05

How do you know he's not an extremist. I bet you have no trouble believing Farage is one so what's the difference in your rationale?

Have a look at the dfinition of extreme Islamist and think about it.

I don't think Farage is an extremist, if that helps your rationale.

Verv · 27/10/2026 17:07

TopPocketFind · 27/10/2026 16:59

Is that your example of extreme Islamism?

Or an example of a guy whose views you do not agree with?

He is an example as far as Im concerned, yes.

However my inkling that he maybe an extremist POS comes from his unfortunate video where he declared that Hamas has the "right" to "fight back" against the "occupiers" and supported the rape and massacre of young Israelis at a music festival.

Perhaps you'd like to explain why you believe that he isn't an example of extreme islamism.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread