Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are the far left more dangerous than we realise

1000 replies

MabelsCatMabel · 24/10/2026 10:23

"The French president took to the airwaves on Sunday to condemn the rioters and blame far-Left agitators for hijacking what began weeks ago as a demonstration against poor conditions in schools."

He called for “calm and order” after a day of protests saw shops looted, cars set alight and public buildings burned to the ground. The collapse of the clock tower attached to Limoges city hall after it was gutted by a fire started by rioters on Saturday will become an abiding image of France’s nadir."

Are the far left more dangerous than we realise?

Far right is a known problem, but are we more ignorant to the far left and therefore tolerate that more?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
ProudCat · 24/10/2026 21:07

PreparationPreventsPPP · 24/10/2026 20:59

It's not a dog whisrle is it ?
Unless people with opp views have decided to dress up in special gear and parade flags around ?

Yes it's a dog whistle. Same one Trump uses when he goes on about Antifa.

As I say, historically it's been in use for well over 200 years.

Funny really (or not, depending on your perspective) but George Orwell was one of those people who refused to simply accept the right wing rhetoric. Presumably, his fighting in the Spanish Civil War as a member of the far left International Brigade would also have folks frothing at the mouth. After that he wrote 1984. Some would argue that he wasn't wrong in his analysis of how the right rises to power.

Papyrophile · 24/10/2026 21:08

We really do not need the economic migrants from Northern France to arrive in the UK. They do not want to be care workers for old men, and old women don't want men providing personal/intimate care services. So there's no reason to admit them into the UK.

quantumbutterfly · 24/10/2026 21:08

MabelsCatMabel · 24/10/2026 20:15

I'm pleased that the UK has several different parties in elections so the masses can out vote the extremist minority.

Remind me what the turnout for recent elections & byelections was.
I figure if you don't vote when you're eligible you shouldn't moan about the outcome of elections.

PreparationPreventsPPP · 24/10/2026 21:10

ProudCat · 24/10/2026 21:07

Yes it's a dog whistle. Same one Trump uses when he goes on about Antifa.

As I say, historically it's been in use for well over 200 years.

Funny really (or not, depending on your perspective) but George Orwell was one of those people who refused to simply accept the right wing rhetoric. Presumably, his fighting in the Spanish Civil War as a member of the far left International Brigade would also have folks frothing at the mouth. After that he wrote 1984. Some would argue that he wasn't wrong in his analysis of how the right rises to power.

Omg it's about any extremism but far easier to aplly to the far left with the how many finger am I holding logic ! And the on going long term mind fuck torture of people

Keyboardkaties · 24/10/2026 21:11

TemperanceWest · 24/10/2026 11:31

Can you give an example of when violence from the far left has been given a "free pass"?

The pro-pal marches. Just utterly hideous intimidation of UK Jews. That is their soul purpose. It’s disgusting.

ProudCat · 24/10/2026 21:12

PreparationPreventsPPP · 24/10/2026 21:10

Omg it's about any extremism but far easier to aplly to the far left with the how many finger am I holding logic ! And the on going long term mind fuck torture of people

Your logic and articulation are impeccable.

CandidLurker · 24/10/2026 21:13

ProudCat · 24/10/2026 21:07

Yes it's a dog whistle. Same one Trump uses when he goes on about Antifa.

As I say, historically it's been in use for well over 200 years.

Funny really (or not, depending on your perspective) but George Orwell was one of those people who refused to simply accept the right wing rhetoric. Presumably, his fighting in the Spanish Civil War as a member of the far left International Brigade would also have folks frothing at the mouth. After that he wrote 1984. Some would argue that he wasn't wrong in his analysis of how the right rises to power.

Just to be clear, you think 1984 was an analysis of how the right rises to power?

WhitegreeNcandle · 24/10/2026 21:18

Papyrophile · 24/10/2026 20:53

Small businesses cannot afford the luxury of funding anything more than the tax they owe. We have a small business, we employ seven people, we're chilled with school runs and sickness emergencies, but we are not big enough to run a nursery too.

This with bells on. Small business ownders are hanging in by a thread. We have a small number of staff through. We manage most of our staff childcare emergencies by getting our own kids to work. Or we do it. That’s the reality for people who don’t have massive corporations behind them. Or even big business.

Keyboardkaties · 24/10/2026 21:21

Papyrophile · 24/10/2026 20:03

Really, what I want is for a brave Chancellor to rewrite the tax book. Shred the 20,000 pages, eliminate all the exceptions and get out clauses that make accountancy the path to wealth. Earn £xxxx, then £xxx is your tax liability.

What affect do you expect that to have? What are you seeking?

France has hugely overspent. Things like pensions are totally unaffordable. Nobody wants to face the truth. So the riot because they can’t get what they want.

People here they are unhappy with the current state are totally unrealistic. Every worker and company pays too much tax. Welfare spending is out of control. Nobody wants one seems to want to take control of welfare so the bond markets take one look at the UK, say ‘oh god they’re fucked they’re spending so much it’s unsustainable’, and understandably whack our debt interest up a knot. There’s no way out until people accept that things are going to be tough.

There’s are no tax options that raise money on ‘the billionaires’ for the simple fact that to BECOME a billionaire you have to be a globally successful businessman, and they live across many countries because that’s what their business interests require. If we tax them more than they want, they spend a few less weeks in the UK, a few more in Italy. Wealth taxes haven’t worked anywhere they’ve been tried for this very reason.

If people want life to get less tough in the UK, we need to cut benefits - pensions, eligibility for disability, housing benefit, SEND. We need to introduce mandatory insurance for social care. Then the bond markets might take us more seriously, then they’ll drop bond rates, then we’ll have more money.

ProudCat · 24/10/2026 21:22

CandidLurker · 24/10/2026 21:13

Just to be clear, you think 1984 was an analysis of how the right rises to power?

Good catch.

About any dictator. Could be Stalin. Certainly wasn't Ho Chi Minh.

I mean he was an avowed anti Stalinist and saw Stalin as the absolute opposite of left ideology. Orwell fought on the side of the Communists and Anarchists in the Spanish Civil War.

Keyboardkaties · 24/10/2026 21:23

Keyboardkaties · 24/10/2026 21:21

What affect do you expect that to have? What are you seeking?

France has hugely overspent. Things like pensions are totally unaffordable. Nobody wants to face the truth. So the riot because they can’t get what they want.

People here they are unhappy with the current state are totally unrealistic. Every worker and company pays too much tax. Welfare spending is out of control. Nobody wants one seems to want to take control of welfare so the bond markets take one look at the UK, say ‘oh god they’re fucked they’re spending so much it’s unsustainable’, and understandably whack our debt interest up a knot. There’s no way out until people accept that things are going to be tough.

There’s are no tax options that raise money on ‘the billionaires’ for the simple fact that to BECOME a billionaire you have to be a globally successful businessman, and they live across many countries because that’s what their business interests require. If we tax them more than they want, they spend a few less weeks in the UK, a few more in Italy. Wealth taxes haven’t worked anywhere they’ve been tried for this very reason.

If people want life to get less tough in the UK, we need to cut benefits - pensions, eligibility for disability, housing benefit, SEND. We need to introduce mandatory insurance for social care. Then the bond markets might take us more seriously, then they’ll drop bond rates, then we’ll have more money.

Oh and the situation in France - just immature wankers - mainly middle class young lefties - agitating for a fight.

EasternStandard · 24/10/2026 21:26

Keyboardkaties · 24/10/2026 21:21

What affect do you expect that to have? What are you seeking?

France has hugely overspent. Things like pensions are totally unaffordable. Nobody wants to face the truth. So the riot because they can’t get what they want.

People here they are unhappy with the current state are totally unrealistic. Every worker and company pays too much tax. Welfare spending is out of control. Nobody wants one seems to want to take control of welfare so the bond markets take one look at the UK, say ‘oh god they’re fucked they’re spending so much it’s unsustainable’, and understandably whack our debt interest up a knot. There’s no way out until people accept that things are going to be tough.

There’s are no tax options that raise money on ‘the billionaires’ for the simple fact that to BECOME a billionaire you have to be a globally successful businessman, and they live across many countries because that’s what their business interests require. If we tax them more than they want, they spend a few less weeks in the UK, a few more in Italy. Wealth taxes haven’t worked anywhere they’ve been tried for this very reason.

If people want life to get less tough in the UK, we need to cut benefits - pensions, eligibility for disability, housing benefit, SEND. We need to introduce mandatory insurance for social care. Then the bond markets might take us more seriously, then they’ll drop bond rates, then we’ll have more money.

Yep it’s debt. No one wanted to hear it couldn’t go up anymore and France are seeing what happens when it’s near the end of the road on borrowing even more.

All this costs; the violence, the boarding up if shops, the extra debt servicing.

I do feel sorry for students as it appears they were the last to be spent on meaningfully, their conditions don’t look that great. But every protest, riot and strike makes it harder to resolve. They’re stuck. I hope we don’t get to the same point.

LizzieW1969 · 24/10/2026 21:33

TempestTost · 24/10/2026 19:04

There are posters right from the beginning of the thread saying that these violent groups must really be right wing.

People were desperate to minimise the possibility of a left wing motive with Charlie Kirk, or even Anne W.

I personally have no difficulty believing that the murder of Charlie Kirk was about left wing extremism. And, as i recall, the man arrested had been influenced in that direction despite having come from a Republican leaning family? (I’m not sure, it was some time ago when it was in the news.)

Moderate left and centrist voters do accept that both extremes, whether right or left wing, are dangerous and as bad as each other.

LouisTheYardTeacher · 24/10/2026 21:33

@ProudCat
I could be wrong but you don't sound like you've read much Orwell but are instead going on a hunch and a quick Google.

And talking about the far right while describing the use of 'far left' as a dog whistle seems a bit of a double standard.

FacetiousFace · 24/10/2026 21:37

CandidLurker · 24/10/2026 20:50

Do you think none of the workers/shop,owners have children in the French school system? Of course they do and they understand the issues. Destroying businesses and livelihoods through uncontrolled violence is not peaceful protest is it?

99% of the protest is peaceful protest though isn't it? Hundreds of thousands including many, many workers have protested peacefully.

If they care then what's their plan? For years schools have been left to rot, ceilings falling down on students, more rats than teachers, children going whole school terms without having teachers. Their children are out protesting because they want better and facing police brutality for it but the right who weirdly are all business owners apparently are doing what? They see the issues and what are they doing about it?

LouisTheYardTeacher · 24/10/2026 21:38

And, as i recall, the man arrested had been influenced in that direction despite having come from a Republican leaning family? (I’m not sure, it was some time ago when it was in the news.)
That's how I remember it too, but it did seem odd that people made so much of the Republican leaning family thing - people having different politics from their parents is hardly rare.

EasternStandard · 24/10/2026 21:39

FacetiousFace · 24/10/2026 21:37

99% of the protest is peaceful protest though isn't it? Hundreds of thousands including many, many workers have protested peacefully.

If they care then what's their plan? For years schools have been left to rot, ceilings falling down on students, more rats than teachers, children going whole school terms without having teachers. Their children are out protesting because they want better and facing police brutality for it but the right who weirdly are all business owners apparently are doing what? They see the issues and what are they doing about it?

Surely you can see wrecking businesses isn’t going to help, it’s going to make the situation harder to resolve

Keyboardkaties · 24/10/2026 21:40

FacetiousFace · 24/10/2026 21:37

99% of the protest is peaceful protest though isn't it? Hundreds of thousands including many, many workers have protested peacefully.

If they care then what's their plan? For years schools have been left to rot, ceilings falling down on students, more rats than teachers, children going whole school terms without having teachers. Their children are out protesting because they want better and facing police brutality for it but the right who weirdly are all business owners apparently are doing what? They see the issues and what are they doing about it?

There is no money. What do these kids suggest? Pensioners work until they’re 70? Well that would be a huge start, but I can’t see that happening. Can you?

FacetiousFace · 24/10/2026 21:41

EasternStandard · 24/10/2026 21:39

Surely you can see wrecking businesses isn’t going to help, it’s going to make the situation harder to resolve

And 99% of protesters aren't responsible for that. They have a right to protest, surely you can see that?

FacetiousFace · 24/10/2026 21:42

Keyboardkaties · 24/10/2026 21:40

There is no money. What do these kids suggest? Pensioners work until they’re 70? Well that would be a huge start, but I can’t see that happening. Can you?

Well that's for the government to figure out, the people that the kids are appealling to with their protests. They are children why should they be expected to fix the problems caused by the adults around them?

Are we really at the point where we expect so little from our governments that sorry kids, there's no money for you have to have an education is acceptable?

EasternStandard · 24/10/2026 21:44

FacetiousFace · 24/10/2026 21:41

And 99% of protesters aren't responsible for that. They have a right to protest, surely you can see that?

Yes as said below I feel sorry for the students, and I’ve also said they have a legitimate ask. They haven’t had the funding they should have.

They can protest of course, as is their right. The problem is the destructive part which gets added on and then debt servicing goes up. But still they can protest. There’s an issue with how to fund a resolution, the pp is right on changing pension age would help, that probably isn’t wanted either.

It’s a difficult situation and I’m not sure how they’ll tightrope out of it.

PreparationPreventsPPP · 24/10/2026 21:45

EasternStandard · 24/10/2026 21:26

Yep it’s debt. No one wanted to hear it couldn’t go up anymore and France are seeing what happens when it’s near the end of the road on borrowing even more.

All this costs; the violence, the boarding up if shops, the extra debt servicing.

I do feel sorry for students as it appears they were the last to be spent on meaningfully, their conditions don’t look that great. But every protest, riot and strike makes it harder to resolve. They’re stuck. I hope we don’t get to the same point.

Edited

I feel sorry for the students protesting but having their cause hijaked and ruined.

People have sympathy but quickly loose it when they suffer personaly.

Netcurtainnelly · 24/10/2026 21:45

overnightangel · 24/10/2026 10:27

Of course they are.
-Trans ideology being dangerous to women and to children
-Advocating for unvetted immigration on a crazy scale
-The rise of anti-semitism as sponsored by the Greens
-Labelling anyone who doesn’t embrace extremist Islam doctrine as “far right”

Yes agree.
Anyone who says anything about migrants is racist and they can want to seek out other extremists to match with it carry out stuff.
I used to read this fb group where I like the admins two women were horrible. Even some people on their own group didn't like their ways
Don't read it now.

PreparationPreventsPPP · 24/10/2026 21:47

This is what comes from failing to put your people first. From failing to protect your own citizens

Keyboardkaties · 24/10/2026 21:50

FacetiousFace · 24/10/2026 21:42

Well that's for the government to figure out, the people that the kids are appealling to with their protests. They are children why should they be expected to fix the problems caused by the adults around them?

Are we really at the point where we expect so little from our governments that sorry kids, there's no money for you have to have an education is acceptable?

Edited

But the French government keeps falling because the French public have totally unrealistic ideas about what can be afforded. There is nothing to ‘figure out’. The government is skint, the public riot cause they want stuff that cannot be afforded, the government does nothing because it can do nothing, the government falls, another government comes in and exactly the same thing happens. And all the time the debt pile grows and all the time the debt interest rate increases and all the time total collapse in the economy gets closer.

And it’s happening here too. Keir Starmer tried doing sensible things but the WFA outrage by greedy pensioners was laughable. The backbenchers thwarting sensible disability reforms. So he gave up and we have Andy Burnham instead. The budget this week is a really crucial moment in seeing whether this country can survive. Massive spending cuts are needed if we’re going to stave off a doom loop, where there’s a revolving door of PMs unable to deliver what the public think they deserve, and debt exploding.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread