Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Stayed or walked away over another woman?

38 replies

Hannahmum1976 · 18/10/2026 09:37

I've recently ended a long-term relationship over my partner's friendship with another woman, and I'd genuinely appreciate some honest opinions.

I'm a confident, independent and generally secure person. I've never had an issue with female friends, but this situation was different.

Several years ago, my partner became very close to a married woman who worked in emotional wellbeing. They exchanged affectionate messages, including expressions of love and heart emojis, which I tried to put down to her naturally affectionate personality.

However, my biggest issue was how my partner treated me. He constantly praised her, told me how amazing she was, how well she understood him and even questioned why I couldn't communicate like her. At times, it almost felt like he was deliberately trying to make me jealous.
He also visited her at home when her husband was working, sometimes without my knowledge.

I'd never experienced insecurity like this before, but his constant comparisons destroyed my confidence. I spent years questioning why I wasn't good enough.
I even suggested that the four of us, including her husband, should meet socially. If she was such an important friend, why couldn't I get to know her?

Unfortunately, that never happened.
Eventually, my partner acknowledged how much he'd hurt me and apologised. For several years afterwards, she was barely mentioned, and I finally managed to put that painful period behind me.

Recently, he mentioned someone had invited him to meet up. I initially suggested he go, not knowing it was her.
When I discovered who it was, my stomach dropped.

I explained how much his previous behaviour had damaged me and that I'd promised myself never to experience that situation again.

I couldn't bring myself to tell him not to see her. He's an adult, and I don't believe in controlling someone's friendships.
But I desperately hoped that, knowing the history and how much he'd hurt me, he'd voluntarily decide not to go.

Instead, he became incredibly defensive, repeatedly insisting he'd done nothing wrong and that I needed to separate the past from the present. I felt I couldn't even discuss my feelings without him becoming defensive.

I'd made it very clear that I couldn't go through that situation again and that our relationship was at risk.

On the day they were due to meet, I asked whether he'd gone ahead with it.

He refused to answer.

Even when I told him I was taking his refusal as a yes, he still wouldn't deny it.
I strongly believe he went anyway, knowing I might walk away. I can't help wondering whether he refused to admit it because he knew what it would mean for our relationship.

I ended the relationship, despite still loving him and never wanting us to separate.

I've since reached out asking for one honest answer, explaining that if he didn't go, it would change how I felt about the breakup. I've received no response.
What I'm struggling with is that it wasn't just about one meeting. What about every time he wanted to see her afterwards?

Was I expected to smile and pretend everything was fine, knowing what I'd already endured for years?

I felt completely trapped. I couldn't tell him who he could see, but I couldn't face going through that pain again either.
I wasn't asking him to choose between two women. I was hoping he'd care enough about what he'd previously put me through to make that decision himself.

Am I unreasonable for hoping he'd voluntarily distance himself from this particular friendship? Would you have stayed or walked away?

OP posts:
LifeTakeTwo · 19/10/2026 19:14

The fact he's not replied and also knew what going would do meant he 'wanted an out' of the relationship. This way he didn't have to be the one to do it. Hence why there's no declarations of love and trying to win you back.

It's awful but I know of many experiences like this. Someone tells their partner that doing something would be a deal-breaker and end the relationship. So the partner does just that thing. Then when they are dumped they are just like 'oh okay'. No pleading, no begging, no promises of change. Just a quick acceptance.

Maybe this woman reached out and told him she's going through a potential separation so will be on the market. Maybe he wanted to for a while and this was the opportunity.

Regardless, you've done the right thing. No partner is worth your dignity or self esteem. You'll look back and be grateful you made this choice.

Lifeislikeaboxofchocolate · 19/10/2026 20:12

Unfortunately he values her more than your relationship. That says it all….. You did the right thing. I wouldn’t be surprised if they ended up together in the future

Tuesdayschild50 · 19/10/2026 20:42

You absolutely did the right thing leaving .. and to be honest his silence gives you all the answers you need.. you cant live happily like that .
What he put you through was wrong unfair and cruel .
I know you love him but out of self respect keep walking forwards you deserve more than him .

Hannahmum1976 · 19/10/2026 21:05

Thank you I really appreciate your replies, even tho hard to hear but he did twist it. Like I’m blocking him having female friends! I asked if he met her wouldn’t answer so ended it. Maybe because I’m so angry I feel like contacting her husband 🤦🏻‍♀️

this is his actual reply WTF -

I'm not dismissing your feelings or denying that the past hurt you. I understand why this situation has brought those feelings back, and I acknowledge how deeply what happened before affected you.

However, I need you to distinguish between what happened in the past and what I've actually done in the present.

I'm prepared to listen and understand why this has upset you, but I also need you to recognise the circumstances as they are now, rather than treating me as though I'm repeating what happened years ago

OP posts:
Lampsandlightsandotherthings · 19/10/2026 21:56

He’s a gaslighting prick. Leave him, he’s holding a candle for her.

DontBotherJustChooseYourself · 19/10/2026 22:08

"I'm prepared to listen and understand why this has upset you" - what a sanctimonious knob he is.

You've done the right thing, OP.

Greenmouldycheese · 19/10/2026 22:48

You arent right for eachother. I wouldnt tolerate my partner telling me who I could be friends with, but then I wouldnt send male friends love messages either. Hes not responded because he met uo with her. Time for you to move on and find your person. No need to waste anymore time.

LeftieRightsHoarder · 19/10/2026 22:54

rather than treating me as though I'm repeating what happened years ago

He is repeating what happened years ago! Maybe not in terms of his behaviour with the OW. But he's treating you in the same high-handed way he did before. Expecting you to accept whatever he chooses to do.

And his three-paragraph reply makes me want to shove it down his throat.

noodlebugz · 20/10/2026 07:04

What a prick - you will come to realise you’re better off without him.

Autumnalhibernationisthedream · 20/10/2026 07:08

I think you were so strong and right to leave x

Frillysweetpea · 20/10/2026 10:09

Hannahmum1976 · 19/10/2026 21:05

Thank you I really appreciate your replies, even tho hard to hear but he did twist it. Like I’m blocking him having female friends! I asked if he met her wouldn’t answer so ended it. Maybe because I’m so angry I feel like contacting her husband 🤦🏻‍♀️

this is his actual reply WTF -

I'm not dismissing your feelings or denying that the past hurt you. I understand why this situation has brought those feelings back, and I acknowledge how deeply what happened before affected you.

However, I need you to distinguish between what happened in the past and what I've actually done in the present.

I'm prepared to listen and understand why this has upset you, but I also need you to recognise the circumstances as they are now, rather than treating me as though I'm repeating what happened years ago

Edited

It's absolutely impossible to have a friendship with someone who has been an emotional affair partner in the past. No reasonable person would think otherwise and he was gaslighting you. You did exactly the right thing - well done. Don't keep torturing yourself with self-doubt. There's not a chance in the world you have thrown away anything worth keeping.

LellyLov2 · 21/10/2026 04:06

He doesn’t deserve you

XMissPlacedX · 21/10/2026 08:54

He is gaslighting you

New posts on this thread. Refresh page