Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Using AI to remove school photo watermarks

166 replies

marblyarch · 17/10/2026 21:01

I’m surprised at how many people are doing this. Some school mums were discussing it after I mentioned forking out for DSs photographs (20 pounds for one digital image), sort of in a ‘why would you pay for them when ChatGPT removes the watermarks for free!’ I mentioned it later to my sister who proceeded to show me how she’d done it with my nieces school images! To be fair they looked great! No difference at all and she saved £££. But it just feels a bit off to me? If everyone starts doing it then professional school photos just won’t happen anymore…

OP posts:
Wrestling67 · 18/10/2026 21:13

Well it’s theft but I think the bigger issue is being stupid enough to upload your child into AI

Discodance1988 · 18/10/2026 21:50

I don't agree with people using AI to essentially steal the photograph, however I have to disagree with everyone saying the photographer spends ages editing the photos etc, our schools doesn't..you get the raw unedited photo unless you pay additional money to have it run through Photoshop.. the photos are expensive, nobody can deny that and honestly, photographers do NOT need to charge £20+ on each photo, digital downloads are £10-£15+, I buy them for my household, my mum and my partner's parents and his grandparents. Yes it's nice to have a professional photo of our children, but the photographer does not need to charge that much money for a single photograph, let's be completely honest with that.

If someone is short on money but they want the photo of their son/daughter and they can remove that watermark and have it for free they will do it.. they probably know the risks of using AI to do it but they don't want to not have that photo either.

School photographers need to understand that they charge far too much. They get paid a fee to take the photos, they then get paid again and insane amount by the parents purchasing the photos.

My opinion is that they should work towards making school photos more affordable, which will lessen the chance of someone using AI to fraudulently remove the water mark (or getting a photographer friend to remove it with Photoshop)

GeneralPeter · 19/10/2026 07:17

NewNameW · 18/10/2026 19:53

Yeah they are removing the watermarks and giving me a better picture for 1/3rd of the price, I'm not fighting you on that.

It doesn't make me a thief or my kids tainted for the fact that I can get better, and cheaper, and going down that route.

I have so many photos of my kids in uniform it's half their life really isn't it? But the idea is that 'oooh its school photos tomorrow' 'make sure your kids come in full uniform' 'mum i want my hair like this' 'ok show us your best smile'

For the photos to come out quite, meh.

I'm not gonna say it's wrong to save a ton of money on someone whos already been paid to come in and take the photos

You know if you go to a theme park and they say hey £30 for the terrible photo I took of you in the moment, but someone behind you is snapping a photo of the photo of them on the back screen?

Is that theft too?

Actually the theme park gives us an OK analogy:

They send you a promo voucher to visit for an afternoon.

You pay a friend to change the barcode so that it gives you access for a year.

Is this wrong? Is it unlawful?

(You didn’t ask for the voucher, the park is there anyway, and you’ve paid your friend to improve something you’ve been given for free).

TheGentleHelper · 19/10/2026 13:21

At least when its handed to you in person you only get your child.

I hate the online versions that allow anyone to buy any picture they want. You really have to trust the company only to sell to the family.

whyohwhyohwhyohwhyohwhyohwhy · 19/10/2026 16:30

TheGentleHelper · 19/10/2026 13:21

At least when its handed to you in person you only get your child.

I hate the online versions that allow anyone to buy any picture they want. You really have to trust the company only to sell to the family.

That’s awful. You can only see you own child’s on whatever system our kids school uses

GeneralPeter · 19/10/2026 18:08

GeneralPeter · 19/10/2026 07:17

Actually the theme park gives us an OK analogy:

They send you a promo voucher to visit for an afternoon.

You pay a friend to change the barcode so that it gives you access for a year.

Is this wrong? Is it unlawful?

(You didn’t ask for the voucher, the park is there anyway, and you’ve paid your friend to improve something you’ve been given for free).

Edited

@NewNameW

You sent me a flower, which I assume means you think my analogy is silly in some way. But I'm just trying to apply principles you've stated or implied previously, so I'd like to see where you think I'm going wrong.

Reasons it's not wrong to change the theme park ticket:

  • The theme park loses no money, compared to you not going at all.
  • You are simply altering something they gave you unasked to make it more useful to you.
  • You have paid your friend to make the alteration.

If you do think changing the ticket would be wrong, I'm interested in why you think that. Where's the harm?

KindlySurfiingPlatypus · 19/10/2026 18:14

It's a really shitty thing to do, to take advantage of a photographer's skills, experience and expensive equipment and steal the results, which is what you are doing if you use AI like this. If you want a cheaper photograph then take one yourself with your phone and get AI to put a professional-style backdrop behind the child. If you recognise that the photo taken by the professional photographer with professional equipment looks better than what you can do on your phone then pay for it. If it's not better then don't pay. Just don't steal.

NewNameW · 19/10/2026 20:35

GeneralPeter · 19/10/2026 18:08

@NewNameW

You sent me a flower, which I assume means you think my analogy is silly in some way. But I'm just trying to apply principles you've stated or implied previously, so I'd like to see where you think I'm going wrong.

Reasons it's not wrong to change the theme park ticket:

  • The theme park loses no money, compared to you not going at all.
  • You are simply altering something they gave you unasked to make it more useful to you.
  • You have paid your friend to make the alteration.

If you do think changing the ticket would be wrong, I'm interested in why you think that. Where's the harm?

Edited

Maybe the flower is misunderstood but I take it as a way to agree to disagree, I didn't want to continue the 'i'm right your wrong' so I sent it as a, okay we're good.

It's not personal for me, I spend alot of money on alot of things and I did this for years, but I also live in a tiny box of a house and these photos end up in a box somewhere in the loft that one day my kids may or may not appreciate, unfortunately this is not a thing you can change my mind on, if I can get it for half price, I will continue to do this.

The fact you think it's similar to stealing an annual pass at Thorpe park isn't a road I was willing to go down.

I was simply saying people take pictures of their pictures at a theme park but you made it into a whole different thing. No person is getting charged at Alton towers gate for taking a photo of a photo - it's not quite the same as taking a £300 (?) season ticket per person

BoredZelda · 19/10/2026 20:37

School photos are massively over priced for what they are. I rarely bought them for many reasons, but was shocked one year when they wanted £18 just for the digital image.

GeneralPeter · 19/10/2026 20:42

NewNameW · 19/10/2026 20:35

Maybe the flower is misunderstood but I take it as a way to agree to disagree, I didn't want to continue the 'i'm right your wrong' so I sent it as a, okay we're good.

It's not personal for me, I spend alot of money on alot of things and I did this for years, but I also live in a tiny box of a house and these photos end up in a box somewhere in the loft that one day my kids may or may not appreciate, unfortunately this is not a thing you can change my mind on, if I can get it for half price, I will continue to do this.

The fact you think it's similar to stealing an annual pass at Thorpe park isn't a road I was willing to go down.

I was simply saying people take pictures of their pictures at a theme park but you made it into a whole different thing. No person is getting charged at Alton towers gate for taking a photo of a photo - it's not quite the same as taking a £300 (?) season ticket per person

Ah, my apologies.

Anyway, we don’t need to continue the convo.

(I don’t think they are exactly the same, but I was genuinely interested to see where you thought the difference lay).

psychodacat · 19/10/2026 20:53

Bamboozledbylife · 18/10/2026 18:50

If they weren't so ridiculously overpriced I'd have more sympathy for the photographers.

This. My jaw actually dropped when I priced up two single 6x4 prints for the grandparents. £20 each, or £40 for the digital image. Not even in a crappy strut mount.

Bikenutz · 19/10/2026 20:58

I feel as though school photos will just die out.

accidentalmillionaire · 20/10/2026 18:10

I’ve just been into my bedroom and realised the photo I have in there is one taken by a school photographer 20+ years ago of both my children. It shows them looking so… well, them. Complete with wonky collars and cheeky smiles. Really lovely. I’ve taken thousands of photos of them, but this is the one I have up as a favourite. Bravo that school photographer

ColinOfficeTrolley · 20/10/2026 18:15

That picture can now be used for any purpose by the AI generator. Including child prn. It's diabolical*

There is no such thing as child porn. What you mean is images of children being sexually abused/exploited.

Edenmum2 · 20/10/2026 18:28

You can’t do that with ours because they are slightly blurry as well as the watermark so the quality would be awful.

Also, pay the bloody photographer

calishire · 20/10/2026 19:16

BluebadgeCF · 17/10/2026 21:50

I haven’t bought a school photo in ten years, I pass the link to grandparents and they can buy one should they wish. It just seems an INSANE amount of money when we nearly all have very high quality cameras in our pockets.

Its outdated and has fallen out of fashion for there to be a school picture, I can take much more candid and natural pictures that I adore for a fraction of the cost.

I do feel sorry for businesses who are suffering but it’s time to diversify, steeling is never a good look though, I find school pictures awful and cold looking. My child always looks so awkward. So can’t imagine why anyone would want to steal one anyway!

I would buy some candid shots of my child playing with his mates in school, or concentrating in a lesson etc, an awkward headshot under harsh lighting no thank you. He would also hate that too!

Edited

I don’t buy school photos either. It’s a complete waste of money!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page