Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Partner shouts at our 2 year old

76 replies

AutumnFlows · 12/10/2026 20:19

I don't know if I'm overreacting or not because I can go 0-100 and start catastrophising.

My partner and I have two daughters aged 2 and 9 months. He's not good with emotional regulation and sometimes shouts at our 2 year old when she's moaning, whining, crying or repeatedly calling for him. Typical 2 year old behaviour.

I'm not saying I don't raise my voice at times but it's usually when she's hurting her younger sister, doing something dangerously or not listening after I've calmly spoken to her severallll times.

When he shouts at her, usually she just continues as normal but today she started crying and it broke my heart. I'm tired of talking to him about this. I know he's struggling with this stage of them being so young and not having the words to express themselves and I try to give him grace about his emotional regulation issues (I come from a family of psychologists and also trained as one so I can clearly see he would meet a diagnosis of ADHD and ASD), but I also don't think that should excuse his behaviour.

I start thinking I should leave the relationship and limit contact (not keep them completely from him but take majority custody) to protect my girls. Am I overacting?

Anyone the child of a father who yelled at them a lot? How did it affect you?

OP posts:
Jimmyneutronsforehead · 13/10/2026 21:53

I'm as big of an advocate for autism as you can get but I wish people who are experiencing abuse or know their children are experiencing abuse would stop trying to look at why someone might be being abusive and just understand that they are being abusive, and link up that this is the action that is happening and this is the consequence that will happen because of that.

In this case, he is being abusive towards a child, the consequence is he needs to be physically distanced from this child because he is causing harm to the child and the wider family unit.

You can be neurodivergent and also be a massive dickhead. You can also be neurodivergent and be the best parent to your child.

There are many of us neurodivergent mums on mumsnet and we don't go round screaming at our kids for no good reason, or because we are emotionally dysregulated, and no, coregulation doesn't come naturally to all of us either. It can be absolutely psychologically destroying when you are dysregulated and your children have contributed to it, but any decent, non-abusive parent would acknowledge this, and find ways to manage their emotions and not place the burden of managing their reactions on a 2 year old.

LTB.

monymonymony · 13/10/2026 23:26

Hopefully you're going to do something about it besides having your heart "broken"

MeetMeOnTheCorner · 14/10/2026 09:32

@AutumnFlows No. It’s not typical toddler behaviour. My DDs didn’t keep whining and tipping food everywhere. I have to say if they had, I’d have been at the end of my tether too.

If you do feel he should leave, I’d take over parenting and be firmer with DD now by having higher expectations. It’s not acceptable to tip drink everywhere at 2 or throw food. I think he’s utterly wrong to shout but you seem to accept a lot as normal behaviour. I don’t think it is and it does need correction. Dc definitely get like this when they are tired but whining a lot is learned behaviour to get attention. The attention she gets is then shouting which is obviously wrong. So why is she whining? Does she get any attention from him? Games, play, reading a book?

You have to limit his contact with dc if he’s not going to engage in play or activities. He’s presumably not there every week day: just evenings and at weekends. Is he ok with the baby? You need to limit his time with them and he needs to access help again.

Perfect28 · 14/10/2026 18:27

@MeetMeOnTheCornerthose behaviours are literally so normal for two. Never heard the phrase 'terrible twos'?

MeetMeOnTheCorner · 14/10/2026 20:55

@Perfect28 Yes, but it’s not a given that dc are like that. Mine weren’t. I fully understand some dc are non verbal and cannot express what they want, but not all dc throw things and make a constant mess without any parent saying no. Mine didn’t tip food and drink everywhere or keep whining. I do see more and more dc who are like this but it’s not a given the that they are. Expectations started early in my house perhaps? I hated whinging and crying. Not that I shouted but my dc seemed to bypass this phase that others talk about. Didn’t see it within friends dc either. I do find many parents just ignore constant whinging from dc and put up with far more than I would have done. I find many dc insufferable now because no one ever corrects dc and says no.

duod · 14/10/2026 20:58

Yo808 · 12/10/2026 20:21

He should leave

Can tell you grew up in a broken home with that comment

Yo808 · 14/10/2026 21:00

duod · 14/10/2026 20:58

Can tell you grew up in a broken home with that comment

Sure did, if parents can’t not shout they shouldn’t have kids

PrincessOfPreschool · 14/10/2026 21:52

Perfect28 · 14/10/2026 18:27

@MeetMeOnTheCornerthose behaviours are literally so normal for two. Never heard the phrase 'terrible twos'?

We take children from 2 years old where I work in 2 different settings, and throwing food is not tolerated, shouting 'no' at an adult is not tolerated, whingeing is firmly put in place (I've said no already and I won't change my mind (further requests ignored)/ If you can ask me in a nice voice, I will get it for you).

Yes, these behaviours are normal. But it is not normal for them to keep being repeated. The only way they will learn is if the behavior is challenged and they are taught a different way to be.

Minasama · 14/10/2026 21:55

I think many men shout (certainly my dad did and my husband did) - but not AT a 2 year old. That seems really quite brutal.

In what context is he shouting at her?
When he is shouting at her, what happens if you tell him to stop?

Pinkissmart · 14/10/2026 22:08

Can he take parenting classes and learn calming techniques?

Wishingplenty · 14/10/2026 22:28

MeetMeOnTheCorner · 14/10/2026 09:32

@AutumnFlows No. It’s not typical toddler behaviour. My DDs didn’t keep whining and tipping food everywhere. I have to say if they had, I’d have been at the end of my tether too.

If you do feel he should leave, I’d take over parenting and be firmer with DD now by having higher expectations. It’s not acceptable to tip drink everywhere at 2 or throw food. I think he’s utterly wrong to shout but you seem to accept a lot as normal behaviour. I don’t think it is and it does need correction. Dc definitely get like this when they are tired but whining a lot is learned behaviour to get attention. The attention she gets is then shouting which is obviously wrong. So why is she whining? Does she get any attention from him? Games, play, reading a book?

You have to limit his contact with dc if he’s not going to engage in play or activities. He’s presumably not there every week day: just evenings and at weekends. Is he ok with the baby? You need to limit his time with them and he needs to access help again.

This is got to be a joke? Your comment is the exact reason the op is in this situation because her dp expects far more of a 2 year old than they are capable of.

Your comment goes to show it is a society problem that expects toddlers to be like adults. You are reinforcing her dp's abuse by stating toddlers are capable of acting like 7 year olds, which is why her dp is getting frustrated in the first place, because he truly believes this to be true as do you obviously, going by your comments. I find people like you abhorrent I really do. If it is not acceptable for a two year old to make a mess, tell me when is it"acceptable" for you, perhaps while they are still in the womb! Is that young enough for you? Or perhaps they should have learnt some self control by then too? Fffs.

Wishingplenty · 14/10/2026 22:33

PrincessOfPreschool · 14/10/2026 21:52

We take children from 2 years old where I work in 2 different settings, and throwing food is not tolerated, shouting 'no' at an adult is not tolerated, whingeing is firmly put in place (I've said no already and I won't change my mind (further requests ignored)/ If you can ask me in a nice voice, I will get it for you).

Yes, these behaviours are normal. But it is not normal for them to keep being repeated. The only way they will learn is if the behavior is challenged and they are taught a different way to be.

Another reason why two year olds don't belong in a childcare setting. Their natural being and development treated with such disdain all in the name of "expertise".

Anon501178 · 14/10/2026 22:50

This reply has been hidden

This reply has been hidden until the MNHQ team can have a look at it.

Wishingplenty · 14/10/2026 22:51

MeetMeOnTheCorner · 14/10/2026 20:55

@Perfect28 Yes, but it’s not a given that dc are like that. Mine weren’t. I fully understand some dc are non verbal and cannot express what they want, but not all dc throw things and make a constant mess without any parent saying no. Mine didn’t tip food and drink everywhere or keep whining. I do see more and more dc who are like this but it’s not a given the that they are. Expectations started early in my house perhaps? I hated whinging and crying. Not that I shouted but my dc seemed to bypass this phase that others talk about. Didn’t see it within friends dc either. I do find many parents just ignore constant whinging from dc and put up with far more than I would have done. I find many dc insufferable now because no one ever corrects dc and says no.

Do you enjoy being sanctimonious and reinforcing the op's, dp's terrible behaviour?
Because that is what your comment is really saying, that you can see the dp's point of view, and that makes you..... well you know? You don't need me to tell you, that's why you said it in the first place so you could feel superior and sympathise with an abuser.

Perfect28 · 14/10/2026 23:44

@PrincessOfPreschoolmy kid, like many other kids (as you should well know), acted like an angel at nursery. He then came home and had a meltdown. Took until at least 4 to significantly improve. We set firm boundaries, say no, react consistently etc. children take time to learn. That's ok. We should expect perfect behaviour at 2 and frankly it's all irrelevant as an adult should never be shouting a child no matter what.

People like you literally expect more from a 2 year old than a grown man.

MeetMeOnTheCorner · 15/10/2026 00:34

@Wishingplenty It does nothing of the kind. It’s pushing back on the notion that all 2 year olds are awful. It’s nothing to do with my “superiority” but I think it’s perfectly clear some people are not great with 2 year olds and they don’t control themselves or parent effectively. I think I said earlier I didn’t agree with shouting at a 2 year old. But - I don’t agree that throwing food and tipping out drink is ok either and should just be accepted. There needs to be better strategies for managing DDs behaviour. That does NOT mean shouting!

sweetpotatopie2 · 15/10/2026 00:53

I know you've heard some rough comments on here. I just want to say that you're taking the right first step by seeking a reality check and other information. You sound like a very conscientious parent so I really think you'll handle it well. Best wishes.

AutumnFlows · 15/10/2026 01:01

sweetpotatopie2 · 15/10/2026 00:53

I know you've heard some rough comments on here. I just want to say that you're taking the right first step by seeking a reality check and other information. You sound like a very conscientious parent so I really think you'll handle it well. Best wishes.

Thank you

OP posts:
GustyGertie · 15/10/2026 14:22

Sorry OP but if he thinks it’s ok to shout at a toddler, what will he think is ok as the children get older.

What on earth can a 2 year old be doing, aside from being in danger, that warrants being shouted at by an adult??

I would be taking my children out of this environment immediately. You’re right to be concerned.

Asuitablecat · 17/10/2026 13:53

Wishingplenty · 14/10/2026 22:33

Another reason why two year olds don't belong in a childcare setting. Their natural being and development treated with such disdain all in the name of "expertise".

I didn't tolerate this in my own home! I wouldn't expect anyone else to either.

ChocolateApples · 17/10/2026 14:07

sweetpotatopie2 · 15/10/2026 00:53

I know you've heard some rough comments on here. I just want to say that you're taking the right first step by seeking a reality check and other information. You sound like a very conscientious parent so I really think you'll handle it well. Best wishes.

I agree. There are a lot of people throwing around terms like abusive and LTB. Obviously it's not good parenting, it's ineffective for a start if you always shout because children just learn to tune it out. You occasionally see people in public who just seem to go straight to shouting at their kids instead of actually talking and it's so depressing. The dad is the adult here and it's his job act like one in the face of a whiney child.

But breaking up a family is a big deal and he wants to be better. Apart from anything these are just two knackered parents with a baby and a toddler. It's perfectly okay to say this isn't acceptable but it doesn't make you a monster of a parent.

AutumnFlows · 17/10/2026 19:51

ChocolateApples · 17/10/2026 14:07

I agree. There are a lot of people throwing around terms like abusive and LTB. Obviously it's not good parenting, it's ineffective for a start if you always shout because children just learn to tune it out. You occasionally see people in public who just seem to go straight to shouting at their kids instead of actually talking and it's so depressing. The dad is the adult here and it's his job act like one in the face of a whiney child.

But breaking up a family is a big deal and he wants to be better. Apart from anything these are just two knackered parents with a baby and a toddler. It's perfectly okay to say this isn't acceptable but it doesn't make you a monster of a parent.

Thank you for your kind words. When contraception failed we ended up with two under two and are completely out of our depth, it's not excuse, but we're trying every day to be better.

OP posts:
Wishingplenty · 17/10/2026 20:40

Asuitablecat · 17/10/2026 13:53

I didn't tolerate this in my own home! I wouldn't expect anyone else to either.

And this folks is why mental health is at an all time low with mothers. Because of sanctimonious poisonous people like this. You cannot control another human being let alone a toddler. And what does not "tolerate" mean for the child? What punishments are dished out to force the child to "comply" to the behaviour desired. It is easy to see why parents lose it because at the end of the day it is all about control and compliance, and if a person really believes that is possible then they will shout or do worse like your husband. If like me they are educated about the natural developments of children, then straight away it makes you adopt a calmer and more patient approach knowing the season will pass in time. If like this person's comment you truly believe you can control things, then that is when tempers are lost and your own mental health will suffer along with the child's!

Asuitablecat · 19/10/2026 21:50

Wishingplenty · 17/10/2026 20:40

And this folks is why mental health is at an all time low with mothers. Because of sanctimonious poisonous people like this. You cannot control another human being let alone a toddler. And what does not "tolerate" mean for the child? What punishments are dished out to force the child to "comply" to the behaviour desired. It is easy to see why parents lose it because at the end of the day it is all about control and compliance, and if a person really believes that is possible then they will shout or do worse like your husband. If like me they are educated about the natural developments of children, then straight away it makes you adopt a calmer and more patient approach knowing the season will pass in time. If like this person's comment you truly believe you can control things, then that is when tempers are lost and your own mental health will suffer along with the child's!

Where did i say I shouted at my children? Or that I punished them? You can certainly teach toddlers how to do things the accepted way. Even the mad tantrummy ones. Then they grow up into fabulous, witty teenagers. Everyone 's mental health still in tact; largely from having boundaries from a young age.

The point I was initially responding to though, was your hyperbolic rant about the evils of childcare and not allowing 2 year olds in nursery to behave like chimps.

Copperoliverbear · 19/10/2026 22:59

Ask him to leave