Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Paris Protests - Should UK follow suit?

196 replies

blinkblinkblinkblink · 08/10/2026 15:39

I am following the coverage of the Paris education protests with interest. A lot of the triggers are failures the UK education system are making too (or at least GB, Im not so sure on N.Ire).

AIBU to think if the Paris Protests are successful, the UK should follow suit?

Our children deserve so much better!

OP posts:
Boppydoodah · 18/10/2026 22:42

PacificDinner · 18/10/2026 22:27

Well, maybe the world is ending, and maybe everyone is helpless including your children. Or maybe the world is uncertain, as it has always been, and the people who succeed believe in their own agency and make investments in their future- studying, saving, taking risks, gaining experience, etc.

I have taken the latter approach when raising my children.

As have I, but if you think they should just accept the status quo and not contribute to forming a better future I think that's treating the world with more helplessness than those who get angry about it and actually stand for something. Meritocracy is a bit of a joke; many people do all the above you describe and still don't "succeed". All it takes is one accident, one illness, or a series of unfortunate circumstances to experience the other side. The trouble starts when the numbers "succeeding" under that system become less in number than those "failing".

hattie43 · 19/10/2026 07:19

They are not demonstrating they are rioting and most look far older than schoolchildren

PacificDinner · 19/10/2026 07:50

Boppydoodah · 18/10/2026 22:42

As have I, but if you think they should just accept the status quo and not contribute to forming a better future I think that's treating the world with more helplessness than those who get angry about it and actually stand for something. Meritocracy is a bit of a joke; many people do all the above you describe and still don't "succeed". All it takes is one accident, one illness, or a series of unfortunate circumstances to experience the other side. The trouble starts when the numbers "succeeding" under that system become less in number than those "failing".

You look in disdain at the best times and places to be alive in human history. Things can always be improved, but l would not pull it all down blindly, and I would not take it for granted. Things do fall apart. What we have now takes effort and cooperation.

Boomer55 · 19/10/2026 07:51

blinkblinkblinkblink · 08/10/2026 15:39

I am following the coverage of the Paris education protests with interest. A lot of the triggers are failures the UK education system are making too (or at least GB, Im not so sure on N.Ire).

AIBU to think if the Paris Protests are successful, the UK should follow suit?

Our children deserve so much better!

As seen in France, these ‘protests’ are just an excuse to use violence, vandalise and thieve. 🙄.

HoppityBun · 19/10/2026 08:40

I do not understand why you think that taking to the streets and smashing things up would improve the education system. You’ll have to talk me through that.

What is it that you want changed in the education system and how do you think that could be done?

Naff12 · 19/10/2026 08:43

Of course not. Why should people's stores and businesses be looted and burnt down? Someone's livelihood.

What nonsense!

Yellowbelliedsapsuckeristaken · 20/10/2026 06:38

Electra10E · 15/10/2026 08:18

If you think the Paris protests fit any of those criteria, you might be disappointed…

If you look at the footage of the actual protests... Sadly the media is not showing any of this, only the looting.

Tarttat1n · 20/10/2026 07:23

The time for doing that was during the years of Tory austerity and lies. Now we finally have a prime minister who puts country first instead of self, pockets of mates and party we should work with him and try to right the wrongs for future generations.

EasternStandard · 20/10/2026 09:19

Not sure if the post on Burnham is a serious one but demanding higher spending against borrowing figures is part of the issue for France now.

They’re hitting a wall on what can be done. And destruction costs more, to fix and in debt servicing.

blinkblinkblinkblink · 20/10/2026 11:13

Tarttat1n · 20/10/2026 07:23

The time for doing that was during the years of Tory austerity and lies. Now we finally have a prime minister who puts country first instead of self, pockets of mates and party we should work with him and try to right the wrongs for future generations.

You're probably right. It's not just the cost of an appropriately funded education system, its the cost of fixing everything and undoing the mess post-2010.

But working in the system, I feel it was a bit like the frog in boiling water. You didn't fully realise until it was too late. Or were just hopeful each change/cut would be the last.

OP posts:
blinkblinkblinkblink · 20/10/2026 11:16

EasternStandard · 20/10/2026 09:19

Not sure if the post on Burnham is a serious one but demanding higher spending against borrowing figures is part of the issue for France now.

They’re hitting a wall on what can be done. And destruction costs more, to fix and in debt servicing.

Funding education will only ever have positive economic implications.

OP posts:
ExtraHotDoubleShot · 20/10/2026 11:19

blinkblinkblinkblink · 20/10/2026 11:13

You're probably right. It's not just the cost of an appropriately funded education system, its the cost of fixing everything and undoing the mess post-2010.

But working in the system, I feel it was a bit like the frog in boiling water. You didn't fully realise until it was too late. Or were just hopeful each change/cut would be the last.

Is it a mess though?

I visited a local state college the other week. It was the most amazing place. Friendly teachers who use their first names. Starbucks. Lovely study spaces with up to date tech and ‘quiet zones’. A beautiful garden in the middle for enjoyment during breaks. The courses offered were so varied, both classroom and skill based.

I just don’t see the actual provision being the issue, at least not from my personal experience. What I saw was FAR better more and flexible than my old sixth form college, which was very rigid and rules based with minimal individuality.

What I see are young people with no joie de vivre, no attention span, and resulting MH issues from a life depleted of nature, fun and appropriate responsibility.

EasternStandard · 20/10/2026 11:20

blinkblinkblinkblink · 20/10/2026 11:16

Funding education will only ever have positive economic implications.

I don’t mind if you feel there’s a way to fund it. But you need to deal with the economic situation. Where should the extra money come from?

Btw do you still think we should follow the protests / riots?

blinkblinkblinkblink · 20/10/2026 11:26

ExtraHotDoubleShot · 20/10/2026 11:19

Is it a mess though?

I visited a local state college the other week. It was the most amazing place. Friendly teachers who use their first names. Starbucks. Lovely study spaces with up to date tech and ‘quiet zones’. A beautiful garden in the middle for enjoyment during breaks. The courses offered were so varied, both classroom and skill based.

I just don’t see the actual provision being the issue, at least not from my personal experience. What I saw was FAR better more and flexible than my old sixth form college, which was very rigid and rules based with minimal individuality.

What I see are young people with no joie de vivre, no attention span, and resulting MH issues from a life depleted of nature, fun and appropriate responsibility.

So you've seen 1 establishment putting on a show for an open day. Who only have kids that want to study those subjects and have achieved the grades to get there in the first place.

Now go and teach for a week in pretty much any comp or primary.

OP posts:
blinkblinkblinkblink · 20/10/2026 11:33

EasternStandard · 20/10/2026 11:20

I don’t mind if you feel there’s a way to fund it. But you need to deal with the economic situation. Where should the extra money come from?

Btw do you still think we should follow the protests / riots?

Edited

Im not going to pretend I fully understand government borrowing/spending, but there is always money available. Its up to the government to decide what to borrow/how to use it. Hardly any will bother with something that will take years to see the impact because they're more concerned with getting votes. Which is completely idiotic imo. A government's sole focus should be the future of a country, not bother about popularity.

I would fully support protests.
Yet again...riot is not a synonym for protest.

OP posts:
EasternStandard · 20/10/2026 11:35

blinkblinkblinkblink · 20/10/2026 11:33

Im not going to pretend I fully understand government borrowing/spending, but there is always money available. Its up to the government to decide what to borrow/how to use it. Hardly any will bother with something that will take years to see the impact because they're more concerned with getting votes. Which is completely idiotic imo. A government's sole focus should be the future of a country, not bother about popularity.

I would fully support protests.
Yet again...riot is not a synonym for protest.

I think the French students do have a legitimate ask, more so than here just looking at their situation. I’m not sure how it will be resolved, the French gov seem in a bit of a bind.

The riots on top of the protests will be making it harder to solve too as they’re very costly and drive up debt servicing.

caringcarer · 20/10/2026 11:39

Hankunamatata · 08/10/2026 16:05

No

It wont change anything. Cost a fortune in policing, lost work revenue, damage kids education.

Abosultely terrible idea

This. Only stupid people would waste what little resources there is on policing riots instead of improving the education system. In France they had rats in classrooms in some areas.

KathleenDarleenDayKnight · 20/10/2026 11:44

blinkblinkblinkblink · 20/10/2026 11:33

Im not going to pretend I fully understand government borrowing/spending, but there is always money available. Its up to the government to decide what to borrow/how to use it. Hardly any will bother with something that will take years to see the impact because they're more concerned with getting votes. Which is completely idiotic imo. A government's sole focus should be the future of a country, not bother about popularity.

I would fully support protests.
Yet again...riot is not a synonym for protest.

There isn't endless money though. Look what happened to Greece.

blinkblinkblinkblink · 20/10/2026 11:45

caringcarer · 20/10/2026 11:39

This. Only stupid people would waste what little resources there is on policing riots instead of improving the education system. In France they had rats in classrooms in some areas.

Ask your children if there are little green boxes tucked in corners/behind cupboards in their classroom in the UK. Ive not taught anywhere that doesn't. Rodents are everywhere. Tbf I've only encountered mice in classrooms, not rats, and then it becomes the big gossip for a day or two while the staff track it down and release it as far away from the buildings as possible.

OP posts:
blinkblinkblinkblink · 20/10/2026 11:46

EasternStandard · 20/10/2026 11:35

I think the French students do have a legitimate ask, more so than here just looking at their situation. I’m not sure how it will be resolved, the French gov seem in a bit of a bind.

The riots on top of the protests will be making it harder to solve too as they’re very costly and drive up debt servicing.

There are definitely more problems in France, but that doesn't mean we should accept sub-standard just because they have it worse.

OP posts:
blinkblinkblinkblink · 20/10/2026 11:47

KathleenDarleenDayKnight · 20/10/2026 11:44

There isn't endless money though. Look what happened to Greece.

No, but education is the one area where spending is only ever going to put money back in and reduce costs in other areas.

OP posts:
EasternStandard · 20/10/2026 11:48

blinkblinkblinkblink · 20/10/2026 11:46

There are definitely more problems in France, but that doesn't mean we should accept sub-standard just because they have it worse.

I wouldn’t have chosen the policy from the last GE, I think it could be better addressed. But part of that is people believing hitting the private sector will help state. It hasn’t and there are better ways to improve state.

SiegfriedSassoon · 20/10/2026 11:48

The west is screwed. We'll be on a level with some parts of the third world in 70 years. Civilizations rise and fall. We are replaying the collapse of Rome and the parallels are stark. It's sad.

Cupofteapleasemilkynottoomilkyonesugar · 20/10/2026 11:49

So you really believe this is about poor old French students protesting about getting a bad education. As opposed to violent thugs being violent for violence sake? Interesting.

blinkblinkblinkblink · 20/10/2026 11:51

EasternStandard · 20/10/2026 11:48

I wouldn’t have chosen the policy from the last GE, I think it could be better addressed. But part of that is people believing hitting the private sector will help state. It hasn’t and there are better ways to improve state.

The private school VAT issue is so far down on the list of what needs addressing, its not even on the radar!

OP posts: