Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think no contact may be better for my son?

5 replies

User3627282646322244 · 04/10/2026 17:51

I have ds 15 with an ex partner, however I have been with my DP since ds was 1 years old and he’s been much more of a father, a role model and a consistent in his life.

I do believe that a totally absent father is somewhat better than a dad who’s in and out when the please. This is coming from myself who never knew my father and struggled with this and neither are good obviously but when it is on and off lacking stability, it can really affect children imo.

for context, ds is autistic, struggles understanding his own thoughts and feelings, he’s not a typical teenager who wants to be out with his friends all the time, in fact the opposite, he enjoys time with adults more than people his own age. Ds thrives on routine, consistency and uncertainty, he doesn’t get any of this with his father. Uncertainty makes him anxious, in the past his dad has been late, has changed plans last minute and not even turned up at all last minute which has often led to meltdowns and sometimes when younger and his dad was meant to be collecting him, ds will ask where they are going, who with etc and his dad will never give him an answer which again causes uncertainty. I believe with age ds has realised all this and decided to avoid his dad on the few times a year his dad shows an interest.

anyway, his ‘dad’ wasn’t too bad when he was younger. He’d pick him up, visit paternal grandparents, go swimming etc but it has got worse over the year and pretty much hanging by a thread.

I have no doubt that my ex loves our son, as does my son with his dad however, it can be weeks and months with no contact at all, then his dad will message him and ask if he wants to go out next weekend, he gets offended when ds says no. There’s no messages in between asking how ds is, how’s school etc, in fact in the past ds has messaged his dad with no response or he says he’s too busy dealing with his other kids!

it’s always an excuse - work, illness, break ups with his younger sons mum, helping a friend, car issues. But I am calling BS on all of it. He only lives 10 minutes away.

I don’t want to be the person who says no contact, as it’s really up to ds, but I feel like this is going round in circles, hanging by a thread. He’s perhaps seen him 2-3 times since last Christmas, including half an hour on his birthday.

I feel like no contact would be easier. But I always end up the bad guy. When his dad lets him down, I’m the bad guy and he takes all the frustration out on me, when I try and talk to his dad, his dad thinks I’m the bad guy. I don’t like confrontation but it’s not fair on anyone anymore.

when he has had ds on occasion, it’s been 1-2 hours max, not worth it at all. Ds isn’t particularly hard work, he’s quite chilled and would be happy just spending time with his dad and brothers.

ds barely knows his brothers!

OP posts:
Batties · 04/10/2026 17:54

Easier on your DS or on you?

User3627282646322244 · 04/10/2026 17:59

Batties · 04/10/2026 17:54

Easier on your DS or on you?

Easier for my son,as his dad causes him so much uncertainty, but in turn easier for me when on the occasions his dads asks and ds decides to see his dad, he gets let down and then in the bad guy, dealing with the meltdown.

OP posts:
whippersnapper55 · 04/10/2026 20:57

At 15, this is something for your son to decide.

Autumnalhibernationisthedream · 04/10/2026 21:00

I agree that easier might seem easier but may not be better no matter what your son’s situation. As mums we try to micromanage what we can but he’s a teenager and life will throw him things that aren’t easy. It’s his dad, your dp isn’t his dad (although it’s great he’s good with him)

Russetboots · 04/10/2026 21:10

I'm so sorry for your DS and totally agree with you that inconsistent contact is really not good for children.

However, at least your son has got to see for himself the kind of person his father is, rather than always wondering what could have been if his father had been wholly absent. Your son will be able to make his own decision about contact as he gets older as he understands his father's behaviour towards him.

Soon you won't be the person in the middle as your son and his dad can contact each other directly. You would just need to continue doing what I'm sure you are doing really well now - keep showing your son that he is loved and valued, and show him that he doesn't need to chase the love of someone who is a self centred and an inadequate dad.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread