Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Calling child the wrong name

32 replies

purplepuffa · Today 05:37

Would you be offended if someone called your child the wrong name several times in a row?

At my child's birthday party, I called a 6 year old the name of another 6 year old who was there. They look sort of similar, build and hair etc. I did it quite a few times including directly to the child before the mum reminded me of their actual name 😥

They are both kids of friends I know well, so felt terrible and apologised a lot! Obviously I did actually know the child's name - I think I was just in a bit of a weird headspace with all the party planning and hosting!

I've been awake worrying that I've really offended my friend even though she was polite about it.

YABU - I would be very upset if that was my child
YANBU - Not a big deal!

OP posts:
helpfulperson · Today 08:54

I often work with groups of children I don't know well. Eg scouts. I always say 'if I call you the wrong name tell me the first time or I'll be calling you that forever'

Noshadelamp · Today 08:54

Willowbalm · Today 07:44

I’ve called my youngest son by my sister’s dog’s name loads of times now 🫣
They’re different sexes and he’s 16 so I should know his name by now 😅

So funny especially that it's not even your own dog!
I used to call my youngest daughter by our dog's name and vice versa! My excuse was they had similar energy 😅

purplepuffa · Today 08:57

Thanks all. The kids do look similar in terms of build and hair colour/ style, but no there wasn't a racial element.

OP posts:
Sherararara · Today 08:58

Id be more worried about the fact you worried about it so much it kept you awake and then you felt the need to post on MN about it.

dizzydizzydizzy · Today 09:00

wizzywig · Today 07:50

Im asian and yeah i do pick up when white people will get the asian/ black kids mixed up as apparently we all look the same. But im assuming this isnt that situation

That’s a well known and studied issue. We are all better at recognizing faces of the types of people we are familiar with when growing up. So anyone who grows up in a multi-ethnic community will be fine with a range of different people. For someone who grows up in a place where almsot everyone is white, they will struggle with recognizing Asian and black people.

purplepuffa · Today 09:36

dizzydizzydizzy · Today 09:00

That’s a well known and studied issue. We are all better at recognizing faces of the types of people we are familiar with when growing up. So anyone who grows up in a multi-ethnic community will be fine with a range of different people. For someone who grows up in a place where almsot everyone is white, they will struggle with recognizing Asian and black people.

I grew up in a place where almost everyone was white and I don't struggle because I make an extra conscious effort in that scenario. I don't think it's an excuse.

I was pretty mortified that this happened - but I would have made damn sure it didn't happen if they were only two Black or Asian kids at the party.

If I got them mixed up in that scenario I think I'd want the ground to swallow me whole.

OP posts:
DeftGoldHedgehog · Today 09:39

I'm not great with names, and then when people have kids there is another tier of names to remember also!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page