Tempo by Hilton or Times Square EDITION?

[Marionwhereareyou]

Posting on aibu for traffic

I've got a choice for me and dh! Which would you choose?

Tempo is £300 cheaper but is 4 star compared to EDITION which is 5 star. They are both on the same street in Times Square New York. We will go around christmas time.

Tia

Yabu - Tempo
Yanbu - Edition

Tempo is newer I think, and the higher floors have a great view.

But it is lacking in many respects. Tiny rooms, a bar that closes early, no lobby to speak of, and generally not very comfortable.

Thank you

What a shame about the bar. The Edition seems to be good for nightlife but we wouldn't be out every night really

Having lived in New York, I'd try not to stay in Times Sq.

Somewhere upper West ish. The Beacon is a gem. It's above a theatre and music venue so it's sound proofed. I quite like the Lucerne as well. Also there are great apart hotels. Plus don't book a package

Hes already decided on times square, weve just to choose between the two hotels!

Anyone?