Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

5 year old asked to wear cycling shorts by after school club

245 replies

LynseyR80 · 14/01/2024 23:04

My DD is 5 years old and tall for her age, wearing 7-8 clothes. When I picked her up from after school club last week the carer came out to have a word (in front of DD) and said that she’d had to point out to DD that she could see her pants whilst she was sitting down. DD doesn’t like tights and doesn’t want to wear trousers to school.
The carer said that she was under a moral obligation to point out to DD that she could see her pants and “why didn’t DD wear cycling shorts or tights like some of the other (older) girls?”

i don’t disagree that the carer could point out to my DD that she was “displaying” her pants (although she is 5) but AIBU to think that it’s not her place to say to my DD that she should be wearing gym shorts or tights under her skirt/pinafore?

OP posts:
Tandora · 15/01/2024 01:44

Superduper02 · 15/01/2024 01:08

Agree. It's not about sexualising kids. It's about accepting that sexual predators exist in every environment. If it were my DD, I'd be grateful to the lady for addressing this with me and either insist my DD wears tights, leggings or shorts.

You clearly have zero understanding of CSA if you think it is prevented by cycling shorts.
(Or do you think we should all wear burkas and cover our faces to prevent rape?)
it’s sexualising and body shaming kids that creates the conditions for child sexual abuse. Disgusting.

thirdfiddle · 15/01/2024 01:56

I don't think having uniform rules equates to sexualising a child.
It's easier to /not/ sexualise them if the rules from the start are that uniform means pants covered up. Otherwise at some point down the line they either get self conscious or someone has to say something to them - or most likely their classmates do. Whichever way, it's embarrassing, and potentially more sexualising than simply getting in the habit of having pants covered from the age of 5 because them's the rules.

It's also more practical and comfortable these days when schooling in reception involves lots of crawling around the classroom floor, climbing things and general rough and tumble.

The pants we did PE in back in the day were thick school uniform pants, very robust, dark colours. More like the cycling shorts than the pants most kids wear these days.

Justia · 15/01/2024 01:57

OP we wore gym pants (like hot pants in school colours) over our pants under our skirts in school from reception.

That was in the 80s….

It has always been an issue; kids shouldn’t be put at risk by not having their pants covered. The carer was right to mention this to you.

A swimsuit is a different issue than underwear. Underwear are private clothing items that are sexualised in teens and adults. They need to be covered. Swimsuits are functional pieces of sports clothing that are generally of thicker material.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 15/01/2024 01:58

AutumnNanny · 15/01/2024 00:18

@LynseyR80 they don't think that deeply, they just follow what you tell them

I thought that deeply.

Coyoacan · 15/01/2024 02:01

GrazingSheep · 14/01/2024 23:34

How many layers are girls expected to wear over their genitalia?

This

thirdfiddle · 15/01/2024 02:02

How many layers are girls expected to wear over their genitalia?

Two. Same as the boys.

Tryingmybestadhd · 15/01/2024 02:02

It’s ridiculous imo , she is 5 . I would have replied “ I’m assuming you can vouch none of your staff are pedophiles , so why is this a issue at 5 “
Honestly my only concern would be I would worry an adult found it so morally wrong to see a kids knickers !

why should girls have to wear shorts ffs so boys or worse men don’t look ? the misogyny in this thread 🤦🏻‍♀️

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 15/01/2024 02:03

Itssodarkinhere · 15/01/2024 01:11

I was touched inappropriately by some year 6 boys whilst I was at primary school. They lifted my skirt and pushed my knickers aside quite easily. If I'd had shorts on it may have made it harder for them. This was a leafty, small middle class village school in the late 80s and I burn with shame at being abused and not believed. It also lives rent free in my head.
My dd wears trousers, shorts, or skirt and cycling shorts.
The sitting on carpet with knickers showing is a non issue. Its in case the child is cornered and the amount of time.
Just buy the shorts.

Adding to your testimony:

I was wearing PE shorts when I was sexually assaulted at primary school. The shorts did not protect me. The teacher staying in the changing room would have protected me. Single-sex changing rooms with doors would also have protected me.

This girl's knickers are not the risk factor here.

Coyoacan · 15/01/2024 02:06

Many years ago I worked in a care home in Canada and it was beset by euphemisms. A shit was called a BM as a euphemism for bowel movement. I'm afraid this need to hide knickers reminds me of that

SammyScrounge · 15/01/2024 02:06

LynseyR80 · 14/01/2024 23:11

It’s a knee length skirt / pinafore but if she’s sitting on the ground cross legged then you probably can see her pants. She genuinely does not feel the cold and due to her dislike of tights wears over the knee socks.
I don’t disagree that the after school carer shod point out that to my DD on the visibility of her pants but I don’t feel comfortable with my DD being told what to wear.

If the carer was right to point out the visibility of DD's pants then she was only being helpful in suggesting a suitable alternative.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 15/01/2024 02:07

thirdfiddle · 15/01/2024 02:02

How many layers are girls expected to wear over their genitalia?

Two. Same as the boys.

  1. The knickers have a double gusset, so two layers.
  2. Scots boys wear kilts with just underwear.
  3. Some girls are prone to vulval and vaginal thrush, which extra layers over the crotch will aggravate.
Alloftheskies · 15/01/2024 02:14

Wearing an extra layer of cotton is not going to protect anyone from predatory behaviour.

Just to add to the other story on here, I was sexually assaulted at the age of ten and I was wearing baggy jeans and one of my dad's massive old tshirts. Paedophiles do not give a shit what you are wearing. We really need to stop pretending we can protect girls by convincing them they need to cover up more. It makes no difference all it does it make them carry the weight of responsibility and feel like they are constantly being watched. No 5yo child should have to worry about what seeing a glimpse of her knickers accidentally might make anyone else feel
And no, pants on anyone are not an inherently sexual item. That is ridiculous. Of course they can be in certain contexts and designs. But ordinarily they are literally just an item of clothing. You might occasionally see. Leave people alone.

.

LivingroomWarzone · 15/01/2024 02:28

Honestly as someone who works with children, we are teaching them ‘pants are private’. So I’m inclined to say that they shouldn’t be able to be seen. It’s not that I think it’s wrong or immodest, more just to reiterate that pants ARE private and nobody should be able to see them because it confuses the message otherwise. Can children really understand fully why say hanging upside down on monkey bars would be okay because they’re playing and then someone making a ‘game’ of seeing their underwear.

wellhello24 · 15/01/2024 02:41

Sadly we live in a world where perverts make it so that we have to adapt our dress and behaviour accordingly to protect ourselves. Even as a 5 year old child. It’s so messed up.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 15/01/2024 02:48

LivingroomWarzone · 15/01/2024 02:28

Honestly as someone who works with children, we are teaching them ‘pants are private’. So I’m inclined to say that they shouldn’t be able to be seen. It’s not that I think it’s wrong or immodest, more just to reiterate that pants ARE private and nobody should be able to see them because it confuses the message otherwise. Can children really understand fully why say hanging upside down on monkey bars would be okay because they’re playing and then someone making a ‘game’ of seeing their underwear.

How does that work with communal school changing rooms? Oh wait, it doesn't...

"Pants are private" makes no sense. "What your pants cover is private" doesn't come with glaring contradictions (swimming costumes, PE changing rooms) whilst still stating that the penis or vulva is private.

cerisepanther73 · 15/01/2024 02:53

@LynseyR80

I 🤔 think it's a case of you have to move with the times and moral mores,

Just because it was different when you were growing up in regards of school wear and school extra curricular activities such as your daughter's school club ect..

Don't you think 🤔 it's good and beneficial that nowadays that our society is more aware of child safeguarding a lot more,

than back in the days when society wasn't as switched on about issues such as this,

BayCityCoaster · 15/01/2024 03:11

My DD wears bike shorts any time she puts on a skirt, regardless of length. She’s 13 and I can’t remember a time she didn’t.

To be fair, she has only really worn skirts in the last couple of years, since starting secondary school. She has a long (just below knee length) skirt for her uniform - and religiously wears bike shorts even under that.

She wears them under regular skirts, as well as netball and tennis skirts, and would be mortified to flash her underwear while playing.

The teacher (or whoever it was) was really indiscreet to raise it in front of your DD (honestly, how dense is she?), but I don’t know a single girl who doesn’t wear bike pants under skirts.

The comparison with bathing suits is silly. They’re designed to be worn in public.

Underpants (the clue is in the name) are not. No-one (of either sex) goes out in public in just underpants / a bra.

Any girl wanting to run and play in a skirt, doesn’t want to be inhibited. That’s where bike pants come in.

Bournetilly · 15/01/2024 03:24

They didn’t say your daughter had to wear cycling shorts it was just a suggestion. They probably thought it would be more comfortable for her when playing (running, climbing etc). It’s just about her privacy.

I remember wearing shorts under my uniform through primary school, probably from around year 2 so age 6/7 and all through high school. My daughter wears trousers now (also hates tights), if she wore a skirt or wears a dress in the summer I will be getting her cycling shorts to go underneath.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 15/01/2024 03:25

BayCityCoaster · 15/01/2024 03:11

My DD wears bike shorts any time she puts on a skirt, regardless of length. She’s 13 and I can’t remember a time she didn’t.

To be fair, she has only really worn skirts in the last couple of years, since starting secondary school. She has a long (just below knee length) skirt for her uniform - and religiously wears bike shorts even under that.

She wears them under regular skirts, as well as netball and tennis skirts, and would be mortified to flash her underwear while playing.

The teacher (or whoever it was) was really indiscreet to raise it in front of your DD (honestly, how dense is she?), but I don’t know a single girl who doesn’t wear bike pants under skirts.

The comparison with bathing suits is silly. They’re designed to be worn in public.

Underpants (the clue is in the name) are not. No-one (of either sex) goes out in public in just underpants / a bra.

Any girl wanting to run and play in a skirt, doesn’t want to be inhibited. That’s where bike pants come in.

I don't and I'm in my forties. That's just absurd.

BayCityCoaster · 15/01/2024 03:27

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 15/01/2024 03:25

I don't and I'm in my forties. That's just absurd.

You’re probably not going to be playing as much tag, or hanging upside down from bars, as my 13YO.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 15/01/2024 03:32

BayCityCoaster · 15/01/2024 03:27

You’re probably not going to be playing as much tag, or hanging upside down from bars, as my 13YO.

I didn't wear shorts at secondary school either. I'm surprised that she goes outside at break, none of the girls in my entire school did. The teachers used the "playground" as a car park because it was ignored by all the girls.

NaughtybutNice77 · 15/01/2024 03:35

I don't think she was giving instructions, just making reasonable suggestions. Maybe you're on the defensive and feel attacked and awkward because you hadn't noticed?
If neither of these solutions are agreeable how about lo ger dresses or even the gingham dress style uniform playsuit you can buy 🤔

BayCityCoaster · 15/01/2024 03:37

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 15/01/2024 03:32

I didn't wear shorts at secondary school either. I'm surprised that she goes outside at break, none of the girls in my entire school did. The teachers used the "playground" as a car park because it was ignored by all the girls.

Well, whatever.

It’s entirely the norm for girls to wear bike pants under skirts these days.

I don’t, but I’m not a girl, so…..

OP - it was merely a suggestion. Take it or leave it.

FuckinghellthatsUnbelievable · 15/01/2024 03:41

I don’t disagree with you. I find it ridiculous tbh. Dd is a bit older now and wears skorts which seems like the go to compromise in these situations