Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if her if she will cook me halal meat for Christmas?

224 replies

Libertyy · 17/12/2023 21:47

So I’m celebrating Christmas with a friend and it’s just gonna be the two of us as my partner is spending time with his nana 200 miles away. We’ve decided on turkey and chicken or lamb and chicken, AIBU to ask that the chicken or lamb is halal for me? I’ll be buying the meat and it’s our shared rented home from before I met my partner.

OP posts:
Crinkle77 · 17/12/2023 22:57

All2Well · 17/12/2023 22:48

Yet 65% of halal meat slaughtered in the UK IS stunned and many of us actively refuse to purchase or eat halal meat that hasn't been stunned.

And before people comment...when I eat at an Indian restaurant, unless I know and trust their supplier, I eat vegetarian or fish/seafood. I don't eat at KFC/Nandos etc.

Yep, the RSPCA website confirms this https://www.rspca.org.uk/adviceandwelfare/farm/slaughter/religiousslaughter#:~:text=Around%2065%25%20of%20animals%20slaughtered,Kosher)%20are%20non%2Dstunned.

Religious Slaughter - Animal Welfare | RSPCA

Find out why we're opposed to the slaughter of animals without pre-stunning (religious slaughter) and learn about the welfare issues involved.

https://www.rspca.org.uk/adviceandwelfare/farm/slaughter/religiousslaughter#:~:text=Around%2065%25%20of%20animals%20slaughtered,Kosher)%20are%20non%2Dstunned.

AlbatrosStrike · 17/12/2023 22:58

BrightLightTonight · 17/12/2023 22:21

Halal meat is cruel to the animals - I would never buy it and would refuse to have it in my house.

Isn't all meat cruel to animals? 🤷‍♀️

Runoutofinkagain · 17/12/2023 22:59

All2Well · 17/12/2023 22:48

Yet 65% of halal meat slaughtered in the UK IS stunned and many of us actively refuse to purchase or eat halal meat that hasn't been stunned.

And before people comment...when I eat at an Indian restaurant, unless I know and trust their supplier, I eat vegetarian or fish/seafood. I don't eat at KFC/Nandos etc.

Hi. Just wondering, do you not eat at KFC and nandos because you can't guarantee that the branches that serve halal meat have been stunned or is there another reason?

MyopicBunny · 17/12/2023 22:59

YANBU a friend should care about the things that are important to you.

vanillaredbushtea · 17/12/2023 23:01

I’ll be buying the meat and it’s our shared rented home from before I met my partner. so you rent it and live there? I'm so confused by this sentence I'm sorry.

Just ask and if she says no then you have to cook yours.

vanillaredbushtea · 17/12/2023 23:02

I don't think it will make a difference it being Christmas day or not. If she doesn't eat/cook it that will either be a year round thing or not.

All2Well · 17/12/2023 23:02

@Runoutofinkagain KFC and Nandos uk both say they are stunned so for me it's not that, it's other welfare concerns and bad experiences.

Youngersis1 · 17/12/2023 23:02

I wouldn’t knowingly eat halal meat both for animal welfare and religious reasons.

ForTonightGodisaDJ · 17/12/2023 23:03

AlbatrosStrike · 17/12/2023 22:58

Isn't all meat cruel to animals? 🤷‍♀️

Halal is crueler and I too would absolutely refuse to have it in my house.

JamSandle · 17/12/2023 23:06

millymollymoomoo · 17/12/2023 22:04

animaks killed by halal methods are not stunned prior to slaughter, something the rspca strongly object to. That’s why many non Muslims object and don’t want to eat it, aside from any religious/prayer aspect

Yes this, of course eating animals involves suffering either way but halal methods don't involve stunning so arguably the animal suffers more.

NoSquirrels · 17/12/2023 23:07

Libertyy · 17/12/2023 22:26

I know she’ll eat either type of meat on any other day because she doesn’t really care and has eaten halal meat made by my family before. But I’m talking about it specifically being for Christmas, like is it better to have non halal stuff for her? If you normally eat halal meat, would you eat it for Christmas?

If you’re not bothered by eating halal meat on ‘regular’ days you won’t be bothered by eating halal on Christmas Day. Don’t worry.

Most people are woefully ill-informed about the issue on both sides of the argument!

Nagado · 17/12/2023 23:09

If she knowingly and happily eats halal meat at other times, then I’m pretty sure that it being Christmas wouldn’t make a difference to her. And if she knows that you only eat halal, it probably hasn’t occurred to her that the meat wouldn’t be halal, especially as you’re the one buying it. I’d imagine she’s thinking that the entire meal will be halal, rather than her cooking something different for just you.

AlbatrosStrike · 17/12/2023 23:10

ForTonightGodisaDJ · 17/12/2023 23:03

Halal is crueler and I too would absolutely refuse to have it in my house.

But how do you know that? The animals are not able to tell us.

Maybe they’re too distracted by the prayer on the loudspeaker to notice the bloke with the stun gun and the knife. Who knows.

sprigatito · 17/12/2023 23:11

I wonder how many of the "halal is cruel to the poor animals" brigade actually interrogate the sources of their non-halal meat products or eggs and dairy. Most people eat enough dubious processed food to ensure that SOME elements of their diet have come from animals that have been held in dark, cramped, dirty, terrifying conditions. If you really think every hotdog/yoghurt/cake/chicken goujon is ethically pure as the driven snow because it isn't halal, I have a bridge to sell you.

I eat meat and am under no illusions about the implications of that. I just don't trust any white British omnivore who froths about halal meat in primary schools, declares that they "won't have it in the house". It's so painfully transparent.

Libertyy · 17/12/2023 23:11

vanillaredbushtea · 17/12/2023 23:02

I don't think it will make a difference it being Christmas day or not. If she doesn't eat/cook it that will either be a year round thing or not.

That’s true, this is our first actual Christmas together where we are both celebrating it and her cooking it. Usually my partner brings me in an Asian style roast and she goes to her family but this year my partner is away and my friend is only celebrating new year’s eve with her family so we’ve got christmas Day together and she wants to make something traditional so obviously I just wanted to check. Since me and her share a house, I buy her non halal meat anyways and she does cook me halal stuff that she does eat as well so hopefully shouldn’t be an issue

OP posts:
ThreeTreeHill · 17/12/2023 23:12

If there's only 2 of you it would be madness to buy 2 meats that only one of you can eat?

If she has no moral objection to halal usually then it would be pretty hypocritical to suddenly care on Christmas day.

I think most supermarket halal meat is pre-stunned isn't it?

NoSquirrels · 17/12/2023 23:13

Libertyy · 17/12/2023 22:47

Because she hasn’t given me a proper answer. So I was asking if I’m unreasonable for asking her if she’d make one of the meals halal for me?

It’s because you’ve made her think about something she never really thought about - how the meat is slaughtered - and because she’s not sure if it’s going to be a pain in the bum now if the turkey isn’t halal and she’s stuck eating only turkey for the end of time after Christmas is over.

Instead of asking her to cook something separate, say ‘I’ll buy the turkey and lamb, is that OK?’

Dutch1e · 17/12/2023 23:14

I'm not Muslim but I have hunted and slaughtered my dinner. Everyone who eats meat should.

Personally I prefer halal, if I'm understanding it correctly: death must be delivered by hand, not by machine. And it must be a clean cut across the jugular or similar, to ensure that as little blood as possible remains in the meat (meaning that death is fast and painless).

Am I on the right track? If so, YANBU.

ThreeTreeHill · 17/12/2023 23:14

sprigatito · 17/12/2023 23:11

I wonder how many of the "halal is cruel to the poor animals" brigade actually interrogate the sources of their non-halal meat products or eggs and dairy. Most people eat enough dubious processed food to ensure that SOME elements of their diet have come from animals that have been held in dark, cramped, dirty, terrifying conditions. If you really think every hotdog/yoghurt/cake/chicken goujon is ethically pure as the driven snow because it isn't halal, I have a bridge to sell you.

I eat meat and am under no illusions about the implications of that. I just don't trust any white British omnivore who froths about halal meat in primary schools, declares that they "won't have it in the house". It's so painfully transparent.

The meat industry in general isn't exactly ethical, even 'free range'. I agree Im always dubious of people who are very anti halal but generally meat eaters

Libertyy · 17/12/2023 23:15

Dutch1e · 17/12/2023 23:14

I'm not Muslim but I have hunted and slaughtered my dinner. Everyone who eats meat should.

Personally I prefer halal, if I'm understanding it correctly: death must be delivered by hand, not by machine. And it must be a clean cut across the jugular or similar, to ensure that as little blood as possible remains in the meat (meaning that death is fast and painless).

Am I on the right track? If so, YANBU.

Yes that’s right

OP posts:
ditalini · 17/12/2023 23:18

There are no religious or cultural objections to eating halal meat that are specific to Christmas.

If she eats it at other times then it won't be a problem.

AlbatrosStrike · 17/12/2023 23:18

sprigatito · 17/12/2023 23:11

I wonder how many of the "halal is cruel to the poor animals" brigade actually interrogate the sources of their non-halal meat products or eggs and dairy. Most people eat enough dubious processed food to ensure that SOME elements of their diet have come from animals that have been held in dark, cramped, dirty, terrifying conditions. If you really think every hotdog/yoghurt/cake/chicken goujon is ethically pure as the driven snow because it isn't halal, I have a bridge to sell you.

I eat meat and am under no illusions about the implications of that. I just don't trust any white British omnivore who froths about halal meat in primary schools, declares that they "won't have it in the house". It's so painfully transparent.

This 100%

Naddd · 17/12/2023 23:20

Anyone who had an issue with halal should not be eating meat at all.

BMW6 · 17/12/2023 23:22

Dutch1e · 17/12/2023 23:14

I'm not Muslim but I have hunted and slaughtered my dinner. Everyone who eats meat should.

Personally I prefer halal, if I'm understanding it correctly: death must be delivered by hand, not by machine. And it must be a clean cut across the jugular or similar, to ensure that as little blood as possible remains in the meat (meaning that death is fast and painless).

Am I on the right track? If so, YANBU.

That's my understanding too, and I think death would be quicker and more painless done so.

WillowCraft · 17/12/2023 23:22

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 17/12/2023 22:41

Halal method of killing animals is seen by people who care about animal rights as a more painful death as they die by having their throat slit they are not stunned first, so for a second or two they will experience awful pain if killed in halal way, in comparison to the non halal way.

They die from bleeding to death and it takes quite a long time. Ten minutes for cattle. Less for sheep but more than 2 seconds. Not sure about poultry, not seen them killed

Some halal is prestunned so that wouldn't apply.

Mind you stunning can go wrong too. There's no such thing as a pain free stress free death in a commercial slaughterhouse, by any method

(Not a vegetarian so no axe to grind here, just spent a fair bit of time in slaughterhouses for work)