Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU if I expect my husband to work more days than me so I can stay at home with our child?

425 replies

Newmumma123 · 21/10/2023 20:32

I am currently 38 weeks pregnant and I am due our first baby in ten days. Me and my husband have been together nearly seven years after meeting online when we were in our late teens.

My husband is an engineer and works 5/6 days a week with a 45 minute commute each way. I am a primary school teacher and I currently work four days a week after cutting down my hours two years ago to support my mum who was diagnosed with BPD but I am now off on MAT leave until June next year. We used to car share to work as we both worked in an area 45 minutes from where we currently live, however when I fell pregnant I decided that I will move to another school closer at the end of my MAT leave so that one of us is close by for our baby who will be in nursery three days and looked after by grandparents two days at that point.

Originally, we discussed the option of me going back five days a week after MAT leave but after talking with other friends and family who are teachers, lots of them have said how stressful it is balancing motherhood and full time work. Over the last few weeks, I have been considering when taking a new job getting a three or four day contract so that I can actually spend sometime looking after the child that I have grown for nine months.

Tonight, I said to my husband that I'd like to go back to work four days after MAT leave instead of five and he said that he would like to only work five days instead of six and that I should go back to work five days so that he can do five days too and doesn't have to work 7 to 12 on a Saturday morning to help bring in a bit more money (cost of living!). If I did four days we would pay one day less a week for childcare and my wages alone pays for childcare/ plus covers my percentage of bills too(this is without the funding that should be coming into place in September 2024) so we should financially be fine if we are careful with money. My husband said to me that our child will miss out on the development but honestly, I feel that I am well equiped to fill that gap as I am early years trained and an educational professional myself plus being the mum (I also don't feel like I should be justifying myself as the mum). My husband is coming across very jealous as he feels we should both work five days so we can both be with our baby on the weekends however I feel that its best for our baby to be with one of us three days out of seven rather than two of us two days out of seven.

My husband has always had this attitude that I get a 'week off' every 6/7 weeks and quite honestly, it annoys me as being a teacher is HARD work physically and mentally. I can't just switch off when I get home. I also don't want to work five days and have someone else look after the child that I have grown and will birth. I want to be with him whilst he is young. My husband has attacked my work ethic and has described me as being 'soft' because I want to be at home.

Alot of this rides on me being able to get a contract for specific days but my husbands attitude is really annoying me. He said why should he have to scarifice time with our baby so I can have more time with him. My answer back was I have scarificed a year out of my career, my pension contributions and my body plus the mental toll of looking after a baby in order for us to have a child. I feel that he should work a bit extra so that I can spend more time with our baby as I am his mummy. We have ended up having an argument as I am very upset as I don't feel like he understands just how important I will be in our childs life and I feel that he is a bit jealous of how much I will be needed more than him by the baby.

AIBU with my feelings of wanting to stay at home with our baby one day a week ? Should I go back to work five days after MAT leave so that we both have an equal amount of time with our ten month old ?

Please help!

OP posts:
HunterHearstHelmsley · 21/10/2023 21:48

Rtc12 · 21/10/2023 21:42

I think you should have put this info in your first post. If he only works half a day on Friday and Saturday then I think he's being unreasonable asking you to do 5 days. Especially as teachers end up doing lots of work in the evenings /weekends /school hols.

I expect he's starting early in order to finish early.

HattieIou · 21/10/2023 21:48

How many hours a week does your DH work?

ACGTHelix · 21/10/2023 21:50

was this always the plan or was it a rolling plan ?

Zanatdy · 21/10/2023 21:50

So I dropped to 4 days after DD as I had a 3.5yr old, a teenager and was commuting to london every day. I still paid 50% of the bills. For a time DP (now ex) did half the childcare but not for long. After we split he ended up working overseas for the majority of the time. Kids are late / mid teens now. I’ve done the vast majority of the parenting, and you know I feel like mothers should be supported to spend a little bit more time with their babies when they are tiny. Let’s face it; they are the ones who end up doing the majority of pick ups - drop offs, night feed etc. My ex benefited from a day less at nursery but never considered I paid a bit less towards bills given I earned less. So yeah, I don’t think you’re being unreasonable at all. My career and therefore future pension took a hit being the sole parent for most of their childhood and so so many women’s. I’d wait anyway as chances are when he realises how hard work 1yr olds are, he will be thinking again!

Cornishclio · 21/10/2023 21:53

I don't think it is fair for you to expect your husband to work 6 days a week so you can only work 4. I think it is tough for him to just get one day a week off if he wants to spend time with your son. You are the mum but he is Dad and it is just as important for him to be a good parent. Sidelining him so you can work less especially if he supported you while you took time to help your mum is unfair.

Coffeerum · 21/10/2023 21:53

@Zanatdy I’d wait anyway as chances are when he realises how hard work 1yr olds are, he will be thinking again!

What a depressing comment. Just because you picked a shit partner to have children with who left you to do “the majority of pick ups - drop offs, night feed etc” doesn’t mean that’s all men by any means.
There are plenty of men who enjoy and value their role as a father.

Maybe your view on men and fathers influenced the dynamic you ended up having in your relationship.

Weefreetiffany · 21/10/2023 21:54

I actually wonder if the stress of the upcoming birth is affecting both of you? I certainly don’t think you need to read all the judgy and mean comments. You’re really not being unreasonable and there’s a lot of people ready to shit on you while shining your husbands halo, based on one OP. You are important, mums are important, women are important, and you should step away from the thread and not worry about any of this, lest of all the opinions of mean internet strangers when you should be relaxing and getting ready for birth. Please treat yourself kindly tomorrow and park the convo with your husband until you’ve got through the first few months as a team. Congratulations and best of luck!

ThinWomansBrain · 21/10/2023 21:55

aside from your illogical reasoning of DH should work 6 days to facilitate you working part time, you are very dismissive of his role - or do you consider that to be totally enjoyable and stress free?
the half day on a Saturday - but starting at 7am - with an hour and a half commute on top of that.
No wonder he's hacked off

LyndaLaHughes · 21/10/2023 21:57

Coffeerum · 21/10/2023 21:33

@LyndaLaHughes you say no one is making it out they teachers have the monopoly on difficult jobs but you’re the one trying to.

I can guarantee a teacher working full time is doing a damn sight more hours than the husband.

From your own comment. Based on absolutely minimal information. It’s really really by no means a given that a FT teacher is working more than an engineer working 6 days a week.

Banging on about how many teachers left is irrelevant too. Job hopping and industry changing is the norm in many roles, teaching is changing as the world changes. You cannot claim that every single teacher left because it’s the worst job in the world rather than wanting a new challenge as many people have as their reason for changing industry.

The poster literally said "my husband is home by 4.30 each day and finishes at 1pm on a Friday". That's what I was referencing when I made that comment?

As to why teachers are leaving, it's not because they fancy a career change. It's mainly because of workload, Ofsted and government policy. We have a massive crisis which I see first hand affecting my own children.

PutinSmellsPassItOn · 21/10/2023 21:57

Yabu.

Not forgetting you get the majority of the school holidays to spend with your child too......stop being an arsehole to his dad for wanting one extra day with his child.

nutbrownhare15 · 21/10/2023 21:57

My suggestion would be to do the money makeover on moneysavingexpert.com. going through your finances with a fine toothcomb, so that you can both afford to work the hours you want. If you are going to tutor on a saturday morning and the hours make up for you doing 5 days than I'm not sure how he can argue against this as you would both be working 4.5 days if he just does M-F. Make sure he picks up the baby at friday lunchtimes once they go into childcare.

Zanatdy · 21/10/2023 21:58

Coffeerum · 21/10/2023 21:53

@Zanatdy I’d wait anyway as chances are when he realises how hard work 1yr olds are, he will be thinking again!

What a depressing comment. Just because you picked a shit partner to have children with who left you to do “the majority of pick ups - drop offs, night feed etc” doesn’t mean that’s all men by any means.
There are plenty of men who enjoy and value their role as a father.

Maybe your view on men and fathers influenced the dynamic you ended up having in your relationship.

Or maybe my view is based on being a parent for 30yrs and seeing maybe one or two dads step up and do more than the mother.

Lavender14 · 21/10/2023 21:59

So I do think yabu but I have a ds the same age and am getting ready to go back to full time work so I understand exactly what you're feeling.

Personally I think you're in an extremely privileged position in teaching as you'll also have all holidays off and a long period with your wee one over the summer that your dh won't have. I think family time is really important and if there's an opportunity for you both to be home together with baby then I'd see that as beneficial because a) You've a bit more support b) dh has opportunity to enjoy his child and build a closer bond and c) it gives you more opportunity for time to yourself

If your dh was totally on board and happy about it then that's a mutual agreement you're coming to, but he's not. He wants as much time with his child as he can have and op, that's a really good thing. There are too many men who prioritise other things over time with their family. If you plow on with this you risk building resentment between you and dh at a time when your relationship will already be under pressure.

Even though he's working two half days , it means you're only left one day where you can go for a day away and enjoy being a family. And while I understand you're happy to do without holidays etc and cut back, your dh is the other half of your team and he maybe wants to keep enjoying your quality of life with your baby in tow to make lovely memories together.

The idea of going back is really daunting and it's natural you'd feel anxious about leaving your baby but it does become the norm, you will find a routine. And if for some reason it really really isn't working, then you can revisit it with dh and at least he knows you gave it a fair shot.

SequentialAnalyst · 21/10/2023 22:01

You really won't be able to discuss this from an informed point of view until your DC is here, and you find out first hand how you and DH work together as a family unit. And people should not forget that it is the woman's body that grows a child, and sends it into the world. Usually this is straightforward, but you can by no means count on that. Also, you just never know what your new baby is going to be like as a person - and they are a person, which you will know as soon as you set eyes on them, or even before that, when they quicken in your womb (I loved feeling them move)Smile

I would also suggest that you defer any final decision until DC sleeps through, or at least until neither of you is sleep deprived.

NB My DM didn't have mat leave. It was taken for granted that she would be a SAHM, and DF could afford it. When I gave birth in the late 1980s-early1990s, I was entitled to 2 weeks mat leave, though wasn't in a job. H was though, and he took the 2 weeks paternity leave he could claim by law - a law that had only recently been brought in.

NB2 My DIL has recently changed from teaching to an IT apprenticeship, because she couldn't take the stress and it was making her ill. And this was in a well-respected Girls' School.

StripyHorse · 21/10/2023 22:02

If you were in a 9-5 job I would say YABU to insist you cut your hours but DH must work Saturdays.

But I know your job will involve working at the evening and presumably at least 1 day in the weekend. Other teachers I know who do '4 days' usually use much of the 5th day for work.

Chalkdowns · 21/10/2023 22:03

I really understand that you want to be with your baby / small child as much as possible. I felt the same.

I also understand that you are very daunted by the thought of returning to full time teaching with a baby. I would be too. It’s a tough job.

But LONG term it’s very good for you to have a full time job, full time pension. You get good holidays with your child.

It is good for your child to have a very invested Dad.

I would try and look at this in a balanced way.

my experience was that my DH fully supported me in leaving work to be the full time parent with small children BUT it is a massive load to carry and in the end is worse for me and worse for him and worse for them.

Don’t spurn a modern equal partnership if that is what you are being offered by your partner.

Cosyblankets · 21/10/2023 22:04

Zanatdy · 21/10/2023 21:58

Or maybe my view is based on being a parent for 30yrs and seeing maybe one or two dads step up and do more than the mother.

This daddy is trying to do just that

Fukuraptor · 21/10/2023 22:04

It sounds like both you and your husband really value the idea of time with your child.

Now that you know that, you can maybe look again at the budget and see if there are changes you all could make to make the 4 & 5 days work.

It isn't a decision that you can probably finalise right now when both of you have zero parenting experience.

If either of you are just looking at this as an escape from a job that is soul sucking, then maybe it's time to think about moving towards careers/workplaces you find more fulfilling. Because doing them for 4&5 days in job like that instead of 5&6 days probably isn't enough long term.

Coffeerum · 21/10/2023 22:04

LyndaLaHughes · 21/10/2023 21:57

The poster literally said "my husband is home by 4.30 each day and finishes at 1pm on a Friday". That's what I was referencing when I made that comment?

As to why teachers are leaving, it's not because they fancy a career change. It's mainly because of workload, Ofsted and government policy. We have a massive crisis which I see first hand affecting my own children.

Given he works from 7am on a Saturday it’s not unreasonable to think he could start earlier in the week too.
I’m home by 4:30 M-Th and finish around 1
on a Friday because I have early starts and condensed hours. I don’t know how you could claim every teacher would be working more than me? I also know several teachers who are home by this time so they can be with their own kids after school.
People are very quick to say that teachers bring work home while ignoring the fact that many professions involve an element of working late or logging back on in the evening.

LyndaLaHughes · 21/10/2023 22:05

I think you're in an extremely privileged position in teaching as you'll also have all holidays off

Sorry but teachers don't have all the holidays off. The May half term, for instance is total write off with writing reports. There is work to be done in every single holiday. So part of them - yes and that's a fair comment to make in this context but please don't say teachers have all holidays off as I would hope my now that myth is well and truly dead.

delanew · 21/10/2023 22:08

All these teachers saying 'you don't know how hard it is because you've never been a teacher'.

Have you been a doctor as well as a teacher? Or a lawyer too? No? Well how can YOU know 'it's the hardest job' out there then? Works both ways.

People only know what they experience but that doesn't mean you can compare. Teachers seem to be the only people who feel they can compare to everyone else.

Teachers don't have the monopoly on being busy and having a difficult job and it's really boring hearing it as an excuse to justify every argument.

LolaSmiles · 21/10/2023 22:09

LyndaLaHughes
Why are you making this thread into a debate about teacher workload, which varies school to school and teacher to teacher.

Anyone who's vaguely paid attention to the news or has children in school, or has spent any time on Mumsnet will know there are problems in schools.

We still have 13 weeks holiday. Some of that is spent working, but it's a lot more than many parents who cover school holidays by juggling annual leave, family, friends, holiday clubs, flexi time and unpaid leave.

The fact you have spent every day of your May half term writing reports is irrelevant to the OP and her DH finding a work pattern that's right for their family that allows both parents the ability to be engaged parents.

Scoobydoobywho · 21/10/2023 22:09

Do you actually want your husband to bond with your joint baby. Just because your the Mummy doesn't usurp what the Dad's wants.

HMW1906 · 21/10/2023 22:10

I feel that he should work a bit extra so that I can spend more time with our baby as I am his mummy.

well maybe your husband feels you should work a bit extra so he can spend more time with your baby as he is his daddy! Being the baby’s mum doesn’t trump being the dad. Let your husband spend time with his child! Sorry OP if you continue being this unreasonable then I see a divorce in your future and then you won’t be having all this extra time with your child.

Weefreetiffany · 21/10/2023 22:10

Chalkdowns · 21/10/2023 22:03

I really understand that you want to be with your baby / small child as much as possible. I felt the same.

I also understand that you are very daunted by the thought of returning to full time teaching with a baby. I would be too. It’s a tough job.

But LONG term it’s very good for you to have a full time job, full time pension. You get good holidays with your child.

It is good for your child to have a very invested Dad.

I would try and look at this in a balanced way.

my experience was that my DH fully supported me in leaving work to be the full time parent with small children BUT it is a massive load to carry and in the end is worse for me and worse for him and worse for them.

Don’t spurn a modern equal partnership if that is what you are being offered by your partner.

Broadly I agree with this but how do we know it is a “modern equal partnership” when she’s already said she does 80% of the house stuff. Equal always seems to end up being the woman contributing 50% financially and working full time, but still doing the majority/ 80% of the housework and childcare on top, which ultimately benefits men more as they benefit from less financial pressure but an easier home life being taken care of. Her husband calling her “soft” for being concerned about this and wanting to work less so she can give her child more while he continues in a set up which already works for them rings an alarm bell for me that it’s obviously ringing for her.

Swipe left for the next trending thread