Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have toddler in ft nursery even though I don’t have to?

275 replies

NurseryFT · 06/10/2023 05:05

Initially I went back to work when ds was 9 months and he started nursery FT, up until he was 19 months. Then I got work to agree to three days a week. He still does this.

I don’t want to go back ft - I have another child now. Equally though it doesn’t seem that things are working well having ds home with me/us 4 days a week. I know this is partly our fault but he just doesn’t eat. Nursery he eats everything. Breakfast, snack, hot lunch, pudding, tea. Home he barely touches anything. Today after refusing two breakfasts he finally ate a banana after a lot of persuasion, had a biscuit at a toddler group and an apple, refused lunch and then had maybe three mouthfuls of macaroni cheese. He then demands yoghurt and biscuits. He has been awake half the night and I’m sure it’s hunger related.

I know people will say he won’t starve and I’m not so sure! He might not starve but he doesn’t eat anything near enough and this affects behaviour and sleep. So - AIBU to have him in nursery FT? It’s expensive but worth it for peace of mind.

OP posts:
Babyboomtastic · 06/10/2023 13:59

This all sounds like it got worse during your third trimester and with the new baby. Its pretty normal for things to get tricky with your toddler at that time. They regress in all sorts of ways/have challenging behaviour, because having a new sibling is HARD.

From yours sons perspective its probably how you'd feel if your husband moved in another woman. He's not used to sharing your love or your time, and whilst having a sibling it's natural, it's new to him and it's massive. They often worry that they are being replaced.

Putting him in childcare full time may just cement that worry. Spending time together with his sibling is so important, and he can learn that you can love both of you. Food is one small aspect they is important, but not the be all and end all.

I'd also be very wary of upping it to 5 days temporarily as things will get easier juggling the two. Everyone's experiences vary, but for me it got a lot harder 6-18m (for the youngest) not easier. Sleep also got a lot worse. At least at this age only one is mobile!

3 days a week seems a good compromise - he gets some good time with you but also the structure of nursery.

NurseryFT · 06/10/2023 14:02

I hate these posts, it just makes me hate myself for having the temerity to have another child. Hate them. Not helpful in the slightest. I know. I’ve made him miserable. Thanks. Now let’s leave it. I can’t really put the baby back, can I?

OP posts:
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 06/10/2023 14:07

4 days a week as a compromise? I’ve been reading your updates and I think a part of it is the fact that your DH just gives in.

With 4 days he’s there and in routine most of the time, but he gets that time with you.

What I found was a problem with mine being in nursery full time was the lack of time to do things like quiet reading, starting to look at letters etc with them, and also the lack of outdoor time.

NurseryFT · 06/10/2023 14:09

Nursery do all that much better than me so that’s all good. I can’t get ds to have any sort of quiet time with me anyway.

OP posts:
WillowCraft · 06/10/2023 14:11

It's hugely stressful for your son to have a new baby sibling, this will be where this behaviour is coming from, he's trying to gain control and attention, so if you can stop giving him attention over food and give him one to one time elsewhere then that will probably help. More time at nursery will probably not be helpful other than as a short term coping strategy.

I don't think you're a shit parent, you're just really tired. These are really difficult ages especially with the sleep problems and you do what you need to survive, so if that is nursery, then just do it and don't feel guilty.

On the other hand I am sure that if you can put in some consistent boundaries then things will improve really quickly, within a few days. Your husband will have to get his act together and eat his biscuits out of sight of your son at least for a couple of weeks. Best not to have any junk food in the house to avoid that 4 am temptation to lob a pack of chocolate biscuits into his cot - I speak from experience!

Offer your son 3 meals a day plus 2 snacks, all of which should be unprocessed e.g. no "snack" foods just sandwiches, fruit, cheese, plain yogurt, proper food. Try and do the same timings as nursery if that is what works for him. Sit down at the table and eat at the same time. If he doesn't eat it put it away until next time. Don't make any comment on whether he eats it or not, just ignore completely. The idea is you decide what he is offered, he decides how much/whether to eat. Definitely don't chase him round with the food or give him food during the night - that way madness lies!

If your son is refusing to get in the car etc then you just have to put him in, gently without getting annoyed, but wrestle him in if need be. It's normal to have to do this sometimes with 2 year olds. You can't control them. They do not (usually) care about sticker charts or rewards. It's all normal. All you can do is hold the boundary and ignore the wailing and eventually they come out the other end. If you give in/are inconsistent/use bribery (more than occasionally) that actually causes more tantrums.

Have you read Janet Lansbury No bad kids? That is a really easy straightforward read with no complicated techniques to remember. It hugely helped me both with managing my very difficult 2 year old, and feeling better about when things didn't go to plan.

NurseryFT · 06/10/2023 14:13

Yeah I know, I know. Can’t do much about it now though. Never mind. He won’t remember.

OP posts:
WillowCraft · 06/10/2023 14:17

NurseryFT · 06/10/2023 14:02

I hate these posts, it just makes me hate myself for having the temerity to have another child. Hate them. Not helpful in the slightest. I know. I’ve made him miserable. Thanks. Now let’s leave it. I can’t really put the baby back, can I?

Oh come on, your son will love having a sibling and it will be a great benefit in the longer term. People are just trying to help you understand how to help your son and resolve this, logically, fobbing him off on nursery will not help him feel secure and behave better. But if you need to send him to nursery then do it, if you are at the end of your tether with an unhelpful partner.

Isthisexpected · 06/10/2023 14:48

From yours sons perspective its probably how you'd feel if your husband moved in another woman. He's not used to sharing your love or your time, and whilst having a sibling it's natural, it's new to him and it's massive. They often worry that they are being replaced.

^ this is a good way to think about it OP. How can you emotionally nurture your son through this difficult time and support the bonding?

NurseryFT · 06/10/2023 14:53

Jesus Christ. I’ll drive us all into the fucking river shall I?

OP posts:
spitefulandbadgrammar · 06/10/2023 14:57

I think you ought to talk to your GP about PND, and your health visitor if you’ve got a rare good one. Put your son in nursery FT for a break for you (not from you).

NurseryFT · 06/10/2023 15:01

Thanks. I’m not really interested in me, tbh. I just don’t know how repeatedly telling me that I’ve done something akin to betrayal and something that is still (wrongly) punishable by death in some parts of the world is going to help. The fact is that the baby is here. I cannot do anything about that. I also have to say ds was tricky long long before her conception or her time in utero or her eventual arrival. I can remember the day before I got my BFP being attacked by ds grabbing the skin on my face and twisting it and yanking my hair. That behaviour has mostly stopped in fairness but does show that we had a difficult relationship before anyway.

OP posts:
LolaSmiles · 06/10/2023 15:04

You're not a shit parent. You sound exhausted and with a DP who is refusing to step up and support you making changes.

When toddlers feel out of control and lacking connection there are very few things they have total control over. Toileting and food are the two things they can exert control over, and it sounds like your DC is displaying behaviour around food in that way. The refusal to eat is one way of processing feelings and regaining either attention, connection or feeling back in control.

Passing him to nursery isn't going to resolve the root of the behaviour and I suspect you know that deep down.

Others have already given great suggestions on boundaries, how to handle snack and junk food in the house and some strategies to try so I'm not going to echo those.

Mouthulcer · 06/10/2023 15:06

spitefulandbadgrammar · 06/10/2023 11:45

I think if you can afford it, more hours in nursery is a great solution to maternal mental health: the sleep deprivation and work of parenting two made me shouty, impatient, chaotic, out of control; and if I got a handle on all that, I burned out completely and ended up panicky and insomniac in the evenings/nights. I’m much happier and parent better now my older child is in school. And she was absolutely given tea in preschool!

You really do need DH on board with food issues, though. He needs a come to Jesus talk about the implications, and to come up with solutions to his forgetfulness around it: eg crisps in a lockbox on a high shelf, so when he goes to have some, he has to consciously get them and thus think “why are the crisps locked up? Oh, because I’m not meant to eat these in front of DS” instead of mindlessly grabbing a bag.

Some things that helped us:

Don’t use food as bribery, reward or punishment. No “eat your broccoli if you want pudding”: all that teaches is that pudding is a desirable thing that you have to earn by suffering through something else, then the next time they see broccoli all they think is “oh, there’s the yucky food”. Treat all food equally.

If everyone’s having pudding, everyone has pudding. Regardless of if they’ve eaten their main course.

Ice cream in the park? Totally fine, what a nice idea, it’s sunny. Not because DS has been so good, or whatever. It’s good, not a reward for behaviour.

At nearly 3 he can help prep food: DD got into avocados because they’re fun to mash. Even if they don’t eat something, they’re exposed to the food and the idea of it.

Serving dishes. DP comes from a “plating up” family and I hate it, I don’t want someone else deciding my portion for me and I think kids are the same: big bowls of everything on the table, the rule is help yourself to what you want and you never have to try something you don’t want. It made DD less afraid of new things because they were just there, no pressure. You have to play the long game. (This goes against the War and Peas advice, which I otherwise agree with, but I bloody HATE being plated for unless at a restaurant and my children hate it too.) I think we were also offering DD far too much food: after that incredible growth spurt they go through from birth to two, and all the brain development, later on their calorific needs slow and stabilise and they stop doing that mad thing where they eat five baked potatoes or a whole melon. DD serves herself much smaller amounts, has seconds if she needs, generally sleeps through and only wakes hungry if she’s missed food for other reasons – ie starting school meltdowns, a birthday party where she filled up on crisps.

No praise for “good” eating, like “well done on eating all your spaghetti bolognese!” You’re supposed to eat your dinner! Praising it lets your DS know what you want, and kids are clever: he’ll know he’s got your attention and that he’ll get even more of it by not eating than by eating. Definitely talk about food (“yes, I like how green peas are, it’s a nice colour”), just don’t attach good/bad behaviour around it.

Make food attractive! I don’t mean Pinterest bullshit like smiley face pancakes. But at nearly 3 they’re discerning in a way babies, who are human compost bins, aren’t. I don’t want to eat soggy broccoli dumped willy nilly on top of my roast dinner, why would a kid?

Follow nursery timings for snacks and meals, and don’t overfill on snacks. Be led by appetite basically: being hungry is a good thing at mealtime. A snack like a rice cake or an apple is enough to stave off hunger til lunchtime, generally. By mimicking nursery’s timings we met DD where she was, hunger wise, and got to her before she was too tired to eat.

But none of this will work if your husband wanders in with a bag of crisps! You need to read him the riot act really: you’ve just had a baby, still in the fourth trimester, the exhaustion is unreal, the food/sleep stuff is a real issue, WHY is he not on board with making your life easier and his DS’s food intake healthier?

Brilliant post, this has been our exact approach to food and I can only recommend!

It doesn't involve a lot of work or elaborate dishes or anything. Just easy tweaks.

I was definitely the odd one out when the children were little, parents couldn't understand why I wasn't feeding my kids snacks constantly when out. Because it is not needed and will only just teach them not to eat their meals.

You have my sympathies OP as your DH would drive me batshit.

NurseryFT · 06/10/2023 15:11

Boundaries is such a MN word and I’m sorry I’m going to be rude here and that’s not the intention but it’s not remotely helpful to me - probably because I actually am a shit parent. I’m going to give one example and this is illustrative rather than wanting advice on it. Just to show what I mean.

So yesterday ds is climbing up on the dining room table and throwing things on the floor.

So if I say - OK, my boundary is no climbing up on the table, partly because he destroys it by scratching and also it’s dangerous and he’s wrecking the house. That’s reasonable isn’t it?

The problem is I have no way of enforcing that boundary. Downstairs is all open plan. There is a lounge dining area and conservatory that’s all one. I can’t lock him in the kitchen.

Use the stern no nonsense I mean this voice? Laughs.

Shout? Ignores.

Consequence like removal of a toy, gives no fucks. Isn’t interested in tablets or TV or anything.

I know people will say to keep removing him, but when you do that it feeds into the attention. We had to leave a group the other week because he wouldn’t stop running into a different room. He loves it.

So you can have a boundary but if your child ignores it there’s fuck all you can do. Except hit which I won’t do.

OP posts:
NurseryFT · 06/10/2023 15:12

Anyway people keep doing long long posts that aren’t helpful and I don’t want to waste anyone’s time. Please stop.

OP posts:
spitefulandbadgrammar · 06/10/2023 15:15

Follow drbeckyatgoodinside on Insta, she’s fantastic on boundaries. What you’re saying isn’t a boundary, it’s a request. A boundary is saying “if you don’t stop climbing on the table, I will remove you from it”. Then do it. Over and over again. Requires your kid to do nothing, and you enforce the boundary yourself. Removing him is exactly what you do, because it requires nothing of his toddler lizard brain, which is totally underdeveloped and cannot grasp what you’re asking of him.

NurseryFT · 06/10/2023 15:16

Can you not read?

OP posts:
NurseryFT · 06/10/2023 15:17

Sorry that was rude but I really don’t want to hear any more about Janet Lansbury Sarah ockwell smith instagram, boundaries, books, Hvs or anything. I really don’t. I would love to know what Becky whoever would do but I know already - won’t work.

OP posts:
Hercisback · 06/10/2023 15:20

Keep taking him off the table, boringly and predictably. Carry him to another room each time if need be.

See a doctor, the more you write the more you need some support. Sorry for my earlier posts, you sound lost and at the end of your tether.

Short term more nursery won't harm.

NurseryFT · 06/10/2023 15:23

You’ve not seen where I explain that doesn’t work? I guess not.

he LOVEs being taken down: great gane( lots of attention. So much fun. I don’t need to see my GP. I need to rewind these past three years and do it all again, maybe better this time.

OP posts:
spitefulandbadgrammar · 06/10/2023 15:25

Be as rude as you like, I don’t mind. I’ve been in the same mental state as I think you might be in and I know how frantic it can feel when posters try to help even though you do actually need some help. I’m going to bow out but my two cents’ worth (aside from saying I think Sarah Ockwell Smith is AWFUL and does a massive disservice to mothers with her “oh well, chronic sleep deprivation is awful but what can you do? lol” bullshit) is:

  1. Yes, put your son in FT to get the break you sorely need.
  2. Talk to your GP about PND. Even if it’s to scoff and dismiss me and say you don’t have it, but tell them (you think) you’re a crap parent and you’re raging and fed up, whatever. See what they say. Try the drugs I think they’ll prescribe. They help. So do the PND groups even if you go in thinking “what do these other mothers know, this won’t help”.
BertieBotts · 06/10/2023 15:25

I don't think you're a shit parent but you do sound overwhelmed, which is totally normal with a 3mo and a toddler.

And you haven't ruined his life. It's common for them to act a bit attention seeking after you have a new baby but I don't think the "other woman" analogy is particularly helpful, yes they do seek reassurance that you still love them, I'm sure you're giving him that, so don't worry about it!

At 19 months with the table example I'd take him down then try to engage him in another activity, this is generally the most effective thing as it distracts them for a bit which then reinforces that playing on the floor is expected whereas climbing on the table isn't. However IRL I also just get frustrated and/or give up and stop worrying about the table getting scratched. They also bounce/get upset when they hurt themselves so they do start to learn not to be quite so ridiculous in terms of risk taking at some point.

Maybe for the snacks it would be helpful if you and DH have a blanket rule of no junk food until after bedtime. If DH forgets then you can just say "Hey, DH, I thought we agreed no junk?" Then if he was on board with the plan he'll probably be like "Oh shit yeah sorry!" If this is happening a lot then maybe agree a back up plan like - if you notice you're doing it halfway through, then share one crisp for the sake of fairness and then he can take them back to the kitchen and put the open pack into a tupperware box so it doesn't go stale, or get some of those bag clips from Ikea or something and he can seal it up and finish them in the evening.

It SHOULD get easier over time, it's not as easy as a MN post sounds to just instantly change an ingrained habit, and neither LTB nor treating your husband as an extra toddler is likely to be helpful really!

Hercisback · 06/10/2023 15:26

2yos and 3yos are like that though. You have to stick at it and be relentless. It's a slog, it's boring, you feel like death, you're knackered, it's bollocks, you think everyone else parents better. They don't.

It's grunt work. Real hard slog grunt work..

Hercisback · 06/10/2023 15:28

With the snacks, could you buy some more kid friendly snack things for your son? Like those Ella ones and stuff that aren't as unhealthy? Then if DH does need a bribe, there's one there. You could make a special box of DS only treats?

BertieBotts · 06/10/2023 15:29

Meh, rewinding time wouldn't help either. Your toddler isn't acting like this because you've done anything wrong. He's just being a toddler. And you've posted on AIBU, so people will keep replying until it drops off the board.

Hide the thread, if it's stressing you out. People will waste their time or not.