Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Sara Sharif father and stepmother statement makes no sense

599 replies

Bramblecrumble22 · 06/09/2023 11:23

So they released a video. I don't know the point of it. Sm is not upset or even pretending to be sad about her death. There is no explanation about why they fled. She claims it's an incident, while media have been lying about the father giving a statement on it being an accident where she fell down the stairs. An incident to me is non-accidenal.

They are in hiding but have no food, they want to cooperate, how? not asking for anything or showing remose.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Viewer23 · 06/09/2023 21:21

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 06/09/2023 17:48

Before anyone gets into a fight here. Yes English men can be abusive as can men the world over. However in UK we don’t have forced marriage, marriage between relatives and honour killings.

I think the reality in our globalised society is that these crimes do happen in the UK. Of course it is important to understand the cultural context within which they take place, but focusing on the ethnicity of perpetrators beyond this is unhelpful and can in fact serve to ‘other’ the victims and marginalise them further. All children should be protected regardless of their ethnic/cultural background so it’s counterproductive to think that these are alien occurrences when they are happening to children in this country.

sorry for double post - only just learnt how to quote posts!

Zarah123 · 06/09/2023 21:22

Viewer23 · 06/09/2023 21:05

I think the reality in our globalised society is that these crimes do happen in the UK. Of course it is important to understand the cultural context within which they take place, but focusing on the ethnicity of perpetrators beyond this is unhelpful and can in fact serve to ‘other’ the victims and marginalise them further. All children should be protected regardless of their ethnic/cultural background so it’s counterproductive to think that these are alien occurrences when they are happening to children in this country.

What do you think is ‘cultural’ about this crime?

I see yet another child who has been failed by her parents and the authorities, and who has been killed when a step-parent has moved in.

Trying to ‘other’ Sara is unhelpful. She is no different to Star Hobson and others killed in the UK.

Skinthin · 06/09/2023 21:27

frazzledasarock · 06/09/2023 20:01

Also whichever poster was saying shariah custody.

the parents are in England therefore an English judge sitting in the English courts gave the father residency probably with recommendations made by English CAFCASS officers, and other English specialists used in the children’s hearings.

shariah has no legal influence in England. It was a non Muslim non Pakistani system which placed a vulnerable child in the care of a known abusive father.

This 👌🏻

Viewer23 · 06/09/2023 21:32

Zarah123 · 06/09/2023 21:22

What do you think is ‘cultural’ about this crime?

I see yet another child who has been failed by her parents and the authorities, and who has been killed when a step-parent has moved in.

Trying to ‘other’ Sara is unhelpful. She is no different to Star Hobson and others killed in the UK.

I was replying to a previous post that said in the UK there isn’t forced marriage, marriage between relatives and honour killings - I didn’t know how to quote the post I was replying to but have since done so.

Obviously that is tangential to this case which as far as we are aware from the reporting is a case of child abuse, which sadly happens in all communities. But my point was that it isn’t particularly helpful to focus too much on ethnicity because it does serve to other victims. If you start to look at certain crimes as things that happen in x or y community, it almost normalises them and serves as a tacit approval for abusers to get away with abuse. Because even within communities where certain traditional practices that can easily become forms of abuse may be more prevalent, it doesn’t stop abuse from being abuse and it does the communities and victims a disservice to assume that certain forms of abuse are normal, when in reality there are likely to be people in those communities trying fight against abuse and hold abusers to account. All it does is allow perpetrators to hide, in my opinion, and it shields the victims from being protected.

jannier · 06/09/2023 21:32

frazzledasarock · 06/09/2023 19:40

Oh @jannier anecdotal evidence? I’ve got plenty of that. And what schools allow NT children who can’t do basic self care?

My DC’s school which has a majority of Asian students are all super clever, have been bought up from a young age to be self sufficient, can do perfectly well at self care, basic cooking, are very highly skilled in sciences, and regularly come out top of the league tables. Majority of my friends and acquaintances who are Indian and Pakistani have children studying at uni, with medicine, dentistry, pharmacy, I know one who’s graduated in theoretical physics his white friend (private school educated) didn’t quite manage it, several are doing law etc.

We all have anecdotal evidence. Mines based on my life, I don’t believe you work at a school with a large Asian population. I hope you don’t.

I am talking 4 and 5 year olds on entry parenting styles not intelligence or academia we rarely had 5 year olds in nappies unless a medical or SEND this year we took 7 in a class of 28 last year it was 5. Physical self care and ability to share and take turns on entry age 4 and 5 has no bearing on even year 7 stats or parental support in academia

jannier · 06/09/2023 21:37

TakeMe2Insanity · 06/09/2023 19:51

By saying asian kids can’t do things on entry to school your hardly saying they are the standard or average, no it means they are behind. Again how is that relevant to this poor child’s death?

You obviously haven't read all my posts or that I was answering someone else as I keep saying racist debate has nothing to do with what happened to this poor child no race or religion has a Monopoly on the number of either good or pure evil

Zarah123 · 06/09/2023 21:37

Viewer23 · 06/09/2023 21:32

I was replying to a previous post that said in the UK there isn’t forced marriage, marriage between relatives and honour killings - I didn’t know how to quote the post I was replying to but have since done so.

Obviously that is tangential to this case which as far as we are aware from the reporting is a case of child abuse, which sadly happens in all communities. But my point was that it isn’t particularly helpful to focus too much on ethnicity because it does serve to other victims. If you start to look at certain crimes as things that happen in x or y community, it almost normalises them and serves as a tacit approval for abusers to get away with abuse. Because even within communities where certain traditional practices that can easily become forms of abuse may be more prevalent, it doesn’t stop abuse from being abuse and it does the communities and victims a disservice to assume that certain forms of abuse are normal, when in reality there are likely to be people in those communities trying fight against abuse and hold abusers to account. All it does is allow perpetrators to hide, in my opinion, and it shields the victims from being protected.

Sorry, I cross posted with your post, now you’ve quoted, I see what you mean, thanks.

Zooeyzo · 06/09/2023 21:41

This thread is crazy. Why are people talking about forced marriages and crime in Pakistan? This happened here. Poor child let down by British courts nothing to do with Pakistan. Ffs everyone here is suddenly an expert on Pakistani culture...

Viewer23 · 06/09/2023 21:42

Zarah123 · 06/09/2023 21:22

What do you think is ‘cultural’ about this crime?

I see yet another child who has been failed by her parents and the authorities, and who has been killed when a step-parent has moved in.

Trying to ‘other’ Sara is unhelpful. She is no different to Star Hobson and others killed in the UK.

Also, your last paragraph is precisely the point I was trying to make - if we focus excessively on ethnicity then we do end up ‘othering’ the child as the turn that this thread has taken over the last few pages shows. There’s been a lot of ‘othering’ of the little girl on this thread. Instead we should be looking at the fact that a child has died and what went wrong and where the failure in protecting that child lay, and how to prevent this from happening again. I do think it’s important to understand the cultural context a child lives in but this should not come at the expense of excusing signs the child is being neglected or abused. If anything, there needs to be more cultural competence in the system (which comes from better representation of the diversity of our society within it) so that important decisions aren’t based on unfortunate assumptions. I’m being very careful to speak in generalities and not go into any details from the reporting of the case.

jannier · 06/09/2023 21:44

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 06/09/2023 19:46

Making statements like that without being clear you are talking about your limited personal experience, rather than actual statistics is disingenuous, and pretty rude.

My experience in 20 years working in education is the exact opposite, but I'd never be arrogant enough to state it as fact as you did because I'm not arrogant enough to think that my experience in my area is representative of the whole country.

Edited

Ok so in my area we are noticing a growing number of pupils then.....and it's being discussed by our LA in how to offer support to staff in nappy changing 5 year olds and if school should toilet train. Along with other PHSE concerns and the issue was noticed before Covid.....again not relevant to the thread but I guess you didn't read or didn't understand what I was saying in the first place.

Viewer23 · 06/09/2023 21:45

Zarah123 · 06/09/2023 21:37

Sorry, I cross posted with your post, now you’ve quoted, I see what you mean, thanks.

That’s ok, it’s my fault for not properly quoting what I was responding to!

jannier · 06/09/2023 21:47

Zooeyzo · 06/09/2023 21:41

This thread is crazy. Why are people talking about forced marriages and crime in Pakistan? This happened here. Poor child let down by British courts nothing to do with Pakistan. Ffs everyone here is suddenly an expert on Pakistani culture...

Because some want to bring race or religion into everything. So a post was answered and people have leapt on racist stuff even more.

jannier · 06/09/2023 21:56

Zarah123 · 06/09/2023 19:35

You. People like you who think you can make statements about percentage of Pakistani people doing this or that but present no stats or proof. Why do you think you can do that? Because you’re white? It’s so arrogant.

No because in my borough all staff are reporting issues with spending a large amount of time that should be educating changing nappies of 4 and 5 year olds and the issue is more prevalent in schools with a higher proportion of children from certain cultures. Can you think of a reason for this? I at no point have said Pakistani by the way. I have said that the race and religion of this family (including the mother's race) has no bearing on what happened to her I don't understand why that ever was raised.

Severalreasons · 06/09/2023 21:58

Jesus the racism on this thread is at another level.

I've never met a Pakistani who practiced female circumcision, most only knew of male circumcision.

The photo was given to the police by Sara's biological mum, she's also mentioned that Sara had loved getting dolled up.

I sincerely doubt this had anything to do with forced marriage, I have lived with and worked with Pakistani families my whole life, my sis in law is Pakistani. And yes there are instances of forced marriage but I've never heard of anyone in Britain trying to marry off a ten year old

howrudeforme · 06/09/2023 21:59

Why that video? To what end? They are making themselves look worse. Just bloody come back and explain yourselves (as Sara’s mum has asked).

But Sara’s photo heavily made up was submitted by her mother ……. (Lots of grooming assumptions re the father here).

Noone knows until her family come back and answer questions.

Severalreasons · 06/09/2023 22:00

Oh and @jannier, with the Pakistani families I've worked with and lived with, nearly all the children were doing chores from a very young age, I would say they and those from a chinese culture had much more knowledge of cooking and household tasks than other ethnicities

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 06/09/2023 22:03

jannier · 06/09/2023 21:44

Ok so in my area we are noticing a growing number of pupils then.....and it's being discussed by our LA in how to offer support to staff in nappy changing 5 year olds and if school should toilet train. Along with other PHSE concerns and the issue was noticed before Covid.....again not relevant to the thread but I guess you didn't read or didn't understand what I was saying in the first place.

There is a higher number of children generally entering education unable to do things. If you have any actual statistics to back up your assertion that this is a particular issue with children of Asian origin, as you said, I’d be very interested to see it…

I won’t hold my breath waiting though

Zarah123 · 06/09/2023 22:05

jannier · 06/09/2023 21:56

No because in my borough all staff are reporting issues with spending a large amount of time that should be educating changing nappies of 4 and 5 year olds and the issue is more prevalent in schools with a higher proportion of children from certain cultures. Can you think of a reason for this? I at no point have said Pakistani by the way. I have said that the race and religion of this family (including the mother's race) has no bearing on what happened to her I don't understand why that ever was raised.

This makes no sense Jannier. Ime Asian families tend to potty train toddlers as soon as possible and aim for them to be trained by the age of 2.

Do you have any evidence that Asian children are going into school in nappies aged 4 and 5?

socialdilemmawhattodo · 06/09/2023 22:15

frazzledasarock · 06/09/2023 19:45

We don’t know how the other children of the family are being treated or what condition they’re in.

the system fails a lot doesn’t it? Maybe the individuals who recommended an abusive man have residency of young children should be held to account, the judge the CAFCASS officers, everyone who worked to remove the children from a safe and loving environment.

it’s not the system it’s the individuals who actively worked to put vulnerable children in the care of an abusive man who should be held responsible and removed from their positions and never ever allowed to work in any area where they could put children in harms way.

This is what I would like to see. Accountability.

BodegaSushi · 06/09/2023 22:28

Severalreasons · 06/09/2023 18:31

The photo of Sara was given to police by her mum, just saying

Yes I assumed so seeing as her father fled? Doubt he's handing out photos to media

That's not the issue. The issue is why the papers have chosen that particular photo to lead with. As someone linked above there are others, just the one with her in makeup so the most common one being used.

As I've said higher up, I think it's done due to adultification bias to portray her as 'older than her years'

Lookright · 06/09/2023 22:45

This thread is a perfect example of how you can be born here in the UK, live all your life here, complete your education, work and feel a complete part of the culture and society but actually, to so many, you will always be nothing more than the colour of your skin or ethnicity or religion.

Very sad, eye opening, concerning and yes, racist.

Lookright · 06/09/2023 22:48

As far back as 10 years ago, white working class children in my daughters nursery were coming in wearing nappies and teachers were repeatedly asking their parents to just send in spare clothes in case of accidents. but please no nappy.

It's not a new thing, it's not am Asian thing and has no purpose being mentioned on this thread.

Fizbosshoes · 06/09/2023 22:52

I haven't rtft but feel very worried for the siblings (presumably they are in Pakistan as well?)
Even if the death was an incident/accident it very likely involved one or both of the adults caring for them. Instead of having a period of grief/mourning for a sibling and potentially being supported by school/community/wider family....they have been abruptly taken to another country.
And why if it was an accident why the hell would you not call for help straight away? Weren't they already abroad when they made the call?

tescocreditcard · 06/09/2023 23:52

Candlelight34 · 06/09/2023 18:16

I guess they will be caught and bought back to the UK within 2 weeks.
They will all be charged and in my opinión be charged with murder.

Running away to another country will.add to the sentence length.

In my opinión they will all be serving a sentence on 25 to 30 years minimum if found guilty.

Rightly so.

Thats my prediction too.

Cazzie1979 · 07/09/2023 06:38

My children actually go to the school which Sara and her siblings attended. We could not believe this happened to a child at our village school, I took mine in on Tuesday and it felt so strange. They did special assemblies for Sara, so we had to talk to my older child about it before she went back. A parent who has a child in Sara’s class said she was off for a lot of the year and they just thought she was ill. Another said she’d come in with cuts and bruises once and told classmates it was from falling off her bike. One of the photos of her was from the Egyptian Day they have at school, I felt so sad seeing that one.

I hope with all my heart the father and stepmother are found and brought back to face the consequences of what they’ve done - and I don’t believe it was an accident at all.