Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

just got thrown out of a bar for having a (private) conversation with my friend about immigration

359 replies

Ozandtom · 01/09/2023 01:23

Just to give some background I am a child of an immigrant (my father) and my mothers parents both came from Ireland. Me and a friend met up this afternoon for lunch and a few drinks. We went to a local bar and ended up staying until last orders when it got quiet and we got on the subject of the state of the country and cost of living. I brought up how with the pressures on all our services were not helped by the amount of people coming into the country. Pointing out that we are a small island compared to the rest of the world and the people arriving on boats were reaching safe countries before making their journey here. My friend disagreed and said that this country was built on immigration to which I agreed but replied that we had seen such a massive increase in the last 20 years (something like 10 million). This is where we were interrupted by one of the bar staff who said he’d like us to finish our drinks and anyway he “didn’t like the tone of our conversation”. Me and my friend were shocked. We’ve never been asked to leave a bar due to a conversation we were having. She called it communism, I said it’s cancel culture. AIBU to think his reaction is completely out of order ?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
BackOfTheMum5net · 01/09/2023 08:42

If you’re creating an unpleasant environment in a social space that other customers won’t enjoy, it makes business sense to ask you to leave @Ozandtom . They’re not running a debating club!

lollipoprainbow · 01/09/2023 08:43

RadishAndTwiglet · 01/09/2023 08:26

OP said:

I brought up how with the pressures on all our services were not helped by the amount of people coming into the country.

As not every immigrant is an NHS doctor or nurse, or a teacher, and we know we have an massive shortage of decent, affordable housing in the UK, this statement is pretty much true. You can argue all you like about the wider reasons or solutions, but it's pretty accurate to say that more people creates more pressure on public services, when expansion of intrastructure, the NHS etc., hasn't kept pace with the expansion of the population. And not everyone who comes into the country (or their future offspring) is going to be a net contributor to our system. That's fine, not everyone is going to be a high earner and we need people to do the essential, lower earning jobs too. But to use the argument that most immigrants are young and will therefore 'contribute' to the tax pot is a bit of a fallacy really. In real terms, if you take more out by way of public services and in-work benefits, child benefit, HB, etc, then regardless of the fact that you pay your taxes, you are actually a net beneficiary of the system, not a net contributor. The problem comes when we have too many of the latter and not enough of the former.

Pointing out that....the people arriving on boats were reaching safe countries before making their journey here

Also true. It's just true. Not an opinion. Simply a plain old fashioned fact. We know all the arguments about why it shouldn't matter in some people's eyes, but it doesn't make the statement any less true.

My friend disagreed and said that this country was built on immigration to which I agreed but replied that we had seen such a massive increase in the last 20 years (something like 10 million).

Forget the arguments about net migration cancelling out some of the figures for net immigration. It's irrelevant. Let's just look at numbers in the country now, compared to 30 years ago.

From the Office For National Statistics: The UK population at mid-year 2021 was estimated to be 67.0 million, an increase of 3.7 million (5.9%) on the population in mid-2011.

In 1993, 30 years ago, the population of the UK was 57, 647, 463.

Today it's estimated to be 67, 736,802. That's an increase of over 10 million.

By 2053 it's estimated to be around 71, 800,000. So in the next thirty years that's an increase of another 4m +

If you are going to hold bigoted views, you may have to accept that other people don't want to be subjected to them

How do we know that the OP said anything bigoted? From what she's said here I only see facts. Not views or opinions.

I don't talk to people with your views.

That pretty much sums up every single thing that has gone wrong in western culture over the last few years. A generation of young people who think refusing to engage at all with anyone who holds different views to them with is a healthy way to understand one another.

I would have been offended if I overheard your conversation. You were/are offensive

How? By stating some facts? If facts offend you then you have the problem, not the OP.

You're unreasonable and ignorant and the stats you quite are wild fantasties peddled by others. There were not stats quoted as such, the OP estimated that the population had grown 'by something like 10 million' in the last 20 years. However, a quick google at official government websites and the ONS will show you that her estimate is not so far off. pretty It's something like 8m in the last 20 years, but over 10m in the last 30 years.

And as I said above, the people arriving on boats having travelled through safe, non-war torn countries where they could have claimed asylum is also true. So there hasn't really been any 'wild fantasy peddled by others' has there?

If you have loud racist or xenophobic conversations in public, you have to accept the consequences OP.

I agree about having loud drunken debates, it's annoying to have to listen to them when you are trying to mind your own business. But there is absolutely no evidence here that the OP said a single thing that was racist or xenophobic. She may well have done, but we don't know because we weren't there. Certainly from what she has told us here, she hasn't said a single racist or xenophobic thing. It is not racist or xenophobic per se to have opinions or concerns on levels of immigration, pressures on public services and housing, and future population projections. If you think that it is, then you are a huge part of the problem.

It’s sad that people so intelligent, like you, are duped into thinking there’s ‘millions’ of people coming to our country. There isn’t, there’s so very few asylum seekers compared to our population…

Millions of people 'coming'? In the present tense? Where did the OP ever say that? She talked about the millions of people who have already come. You are putting words in the OP's mouth.

When people talk about 'millions' in immigration terms, they don't just mean current immigration figures in the here and now,. They mean the amount accumulated over previous years, their offspring born in the UK and future projections that affect our population size as a whole. If do wish, when people want to have a proper debate about the pros and cons of mass immigration, that the people in the 'for' camp would at least listen to what people in the 'against' camp actually say, and not just respond to what you think they mean. Coming at it from the angle of 'you must be a pretty stupid racist and a xenophobe' is not very helpful or very clever.

^this

Eleganz · 01/09/2023 08:45

And as I said above, the people arriving on boats having travelled through safe, non-war torn countries where they couldhave claimed asylum is also true. So there hasn't really been any 'wild fantasy peddled by others' has there?

As a wealthy nation deeply involved in many of the geopolitical situations that lead to mass migration why should we not take our fair share of refugees? Why are we a special case? We already take fewer refugees than many of those "safe countries" anyway.

If you want people to listen to your arguments then actually have decent ones to listen to.

FirstOfManyNameChanges · 01/09/2023 09:00

Hi folks, it's GB News editorial team here. Just wanting to say thanks for todays leader ...

NerrSnerr · 01/09/2023 09:08

Hope the head's ok this morning OP.

Its not the best time to try and have a 'serious' conversation after a long drinking session- I'm assuming you usually keep your bigoted views hidden unless you're wasted.

You would have been loud and annoying, probably hoping that others heard your conversation too.

ilovesooty · 01/09/2023 09:12

I was the person who said they didn't talk to people with views like the OP's.

I'm not young. You don't have to be young to be disinclined to spend time with people who express xenophobic viewpoints.

RadishAndTwiglet · 01/09/2023 09:28

As a wealthy nation deeply involved in many of the geopolitical situations that lead to mass migration why should we not take our fair share of refugees? Why are we a special case? We already take fewer refugees than many of those "safe countries" anyway.

And where in my post did I say that we shouldn't? I am merely making the point that the OP stated a simple fact and as a result she has been called racist, xenophobic and offensive, without anyone having had the benefit of hearing the full conversation or the context in which she made that remark.

And you have now made the assumption that I am against offering asylum to genuine refugees. Once again I am forced to say:

I do wish, when people want to have a proper debate about the pros and cons of mass immigration and the long term effects of it, that the people in the 'for' camp would at least listen to what people in the 'against' camp actually say, and not just respond to what you think or assume they mean. Coming at everything from an angle of 'you must be a pretty stupid racist and a xenophobe' is not very helpful or very clever. And it's actually bigoted and narrow minded in itself.

If you want people to listen to your arguments then actually have decent ones to listen to.

No. That's exactly where you are going wrong. You listen to all arguments. You don't exist in an echo chamber. If you make the effort to listen properly and don't make sweeping judgements based on your preconceptions of the people talking, you will learn things. You won't always come away with an entirely changed point of view, but you'll learn things that will help your wider understanding of their viewpoint, nonetheless.

You don't get to decide ahead of time that one side of a debate isn't 'decent' enough to warrant consideration before you've even heard it. How arrogant.

Whyohwhywyoming · 01/09/2023 09:28

Blanketsburg · 01/09/2023 07:52

Empty words, but I'm sure they make you feel good 👍

Picking on someone for their English means you took the low road. Own it.

Picking on refugees is about as low as you can get.

Toenailz · 01/09/2023 09:30

I wouldn't have enjoyed overhearing that conversation in a light setting tbh. You go to a pub to meet up and have a nice time, generally.

Overhearing a bigot at the next table going on about immigration would make me want to leave. If the barman could hear it, he's obviously aware it could be in earshot of erm possibly, immigrants too? I have a lot of friends who are immigrants (they didn't arrive on boats funnily enough...) and honestly, I can't stand listening to the bile about it anymore. They're good people, pay their way. and I'm not interested in hearing the shit about how people separate them from other fellow human beings.

If you've had a drink, you're often louder than you realise. It was last orders anyway. Maybe barman has friends or family who are immigrants and was offended, or maybe he doesn't and was just uncomfortable with what you were coming out with, which is fine.

The irony that a) you come from immigrants yourself (but that's fine...) and b) you're offended that someone was offended by your opinions, is entitled.

Have your opinions, but time and a place.

Clymene · 01/09/2023 09:36

It occurs to me that some of the sneering on this thread is exactly what enabled Mosley to get such a toehold. You'd think we'd have moved on since then and 100 years on, some people have learned nothing.

SapphireSeptember · 01/09/2023 09:38

Catsmere · 01/09/2023 02:33

I think it was a reference to one of the threads about the asylum seekers on the barge.

Since when was France a war torn country? I know up to 1945 it was, and I know Paris can be scary, but I've missed those threads, so...

FirstOfManyNameChanges · 01/09/2023 09:40

Clymene · 01/09/2023 09:36

It occurs to me that some of the sneering on this thread is exactly what enabled Mosley to get such a toehold. You'd think we'd have moved on since then and 100 years on, some people have learned nothing.

Au contraire. The sneering on this thread is what told Mosely and his blackshirts to go fuck themselves.

And I for one, am ever ready for duty.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Cable_Street

Battle of Cable Street - Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Cable_Street

FirstOfManyNameChanges · 01/09/2023 09:41

Whyohwhywyoming · 01/09/2023 09:28

Picking on refugees is about as low as you can get.

Disabled refugees ?

CurlewKate · 01/09/2023 09:41

People are aware of where the UK sits in the international tables for taking refugees and asylum seekers, aren't they?

Toenailz · 01/09/2023 09:45

Essentially OP, controversial topics are best left for discussion in more private surroundings IF you are going to be offended that others may take issue and perhaps be offended by your discussion. Most of us have controversial views but understand through social awareness that some things are best kept in our homes or other truly private places so as not to upset other people.

I wouldn't enter into a discussion for example about 'are trans women women' in my local pub. Because I don't want to upset others, or face backlash for my strong views. I'll enter into it in my home with friends for example, if I deem the company to be appropriate to discuss and they're not likely to be upset by it.

Expecting to discuss things in a pub and not be overheard is silly.

It seems like you got what you wanted though. Another discussion about your chosen topic.

thedancingbear · 01/09/2023 09:45

FirstOfManyNameChanges · 01/09/2023 09:40

Au contraire. The sneering on this thread is what told Mosely and his blackshirts to go fuck themselves.

And I for one, am ever ready for duty.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Cable_Street

Likewise.

"You made us act like cunts! You, with your fucking principles!" Racists can go fuck themselves.

Clymene · 01/09/2023 09:47

@FirstOfManyNameChanges - the rise of fascism in Europe is very real. Don't think it couldn't happen here.

Dismissing people as stupid and illiterate bigots is never going to change hearts and minds.

thedancingbear · 01/09/2023 09:52

Clymene · 01/09/2023 09:47

@FirstOfManyNameChanges - the rise of fascism in Europe is very real. Don't think it couldn't happen here.

Dismissing people as stupid and illiterate bigots is never going to change hearts and minds.

I've debated with you guys over a period of decades. At university, in the pub, in work - wherever. I've tried reasoning, I've tried logic, I've tried appealing to your humanity and compassion. You can't or won't listen.

You don't have a heart and you don't have a mind. I've seen the evidence.

ilovesooty · 01/09/2023 09:58

CurlewKate · 01/09/2023 09:41

People are aware of where the UK sits in the international tables for taking refugees and asylum seekers, aren't they?

Seemingly not.

Clymene · 01/09/2023 10:03

When you say 'you guys' @thedancingbear, are you accusing me of supporting the OP's views?

I should be incredibly offended but I'm just laughing at what a ridiculous assumption you've made

thedancingbear · 01/09/2023 10:05

Clymene · 01/09/2023 10:03

When you say 'you guys' @thedancingbear, are you accusing me of supporting the OP's views?

I should be incredibly offended but I'm just laughing at what a ridiculous assumption you've made

Are you saying you don't share the OP's views?

RadishAndTwiglet · 01/09/2023 10:06

I've debated with you guys over a period of decades. At university, in the pub, in work - wherever. I've tried reasoning, I've tried logic, I've tried appealing to your humanity and compassion. You can't or won't listen.

You don't actually mean they can't or won't listen though, do you? You mean they can't or won't change their minds and capitulate to you and your entire argument. But by at least engaging with you, you might have opened their minds a little to an aspect of the debate that they hadn't considered previously.

You don't have a heart and you don't have a mind. I've seen the evidence.

Really? That's quite some big statement to make. Who is the 'you' here, The OP? Anyone who debates this topic on the opposite side to you?

I suppose you think all 17.4 million people who voted for Brexit fall into this category too, since it's generally assumed among remainers that they had no other motive other than racism and xenophobia, and no excuse except a basic lack of intelligence.

thedancingbear · 01/09/2023 10:11

RadishAndTwiglet · 01/09/2023 10:06

I've debated with you guys over a period of decades. At university, in the pub, in work - wherever. I've tried reasoning, I've tried logic, I've tried appealing to your humanity and compassion. You can't or won't listen.

You don't actually mean they can't or won't listen though, do you? You mean they can't or won't change their minds and capitulate to you and your entire argument. But by at least engaging with you, you might have opened their minds a little to an aspect of the debate that they hadn't considered previously.

You don't have a heart and you don't have a mind. I've seen the evidence.

Really? That's quite some big statement to make. Who is the 'you' here, The OP? Anyone who debates this topic on the opposite side to you?

I suppose you think all 17.4 million people who voted for Brexit fall into this category too, since it's generally assumed among remainers that they had no other motive other than racism and xenophobia, and no excuse except a basic lack of intelligence.

(i) I do mean can't or won't listen. Various posters throughout this thread have made sensible arguments and drawn people's attention to facts and information, and they have largely been ignored. Look at any other thread on this site on the subject and the same pattern is there.

(ii) No, I don't mean everyone who voted for Brexit. You suppose wrongly. I think there are all kinds of things wrong with the EU as an institution. I voted remain because I thought we were still better in it than out. But yes, a substantial proportion of people who voted for Brexit because Farage etc. They are heartless and mindness.

ToWhitToWhoo · 01/09/2023 10:15

Since the bar is a private business, and not part of the state, concepts of democracy and communism, etc. are not relevant. No, the bartender doesn't own the bar, but he is employed by those who do. It may be that he was heavy-handed, and was taking the other group's anti-social behaviour out on you. It may be that you were drunk and much louder and more offensive than you realized. Either way, it's nothing to do with living in a democracy.

Jetstream · 01/09/2023 10:20

Waffle78 · 01/09/2023 02:09

Your not really an immigrant from Ireland though are you. Most British wouldn't consider Irish as immigrants I know I've been twice first time BIL drove us and ferry. No ID was needed only the driver needed ID. But we had to have passports for the ferry to France.

Second time we flew we could have flown just with driver's license as ID. But because we don't drive and ID cards were hard to obtain we had to get passport's. DC just needed birth certificate.

It is due to the Common Travel Area between both countries in existence since the 1940s -I think.
People moving between both countries are immigrants , as I was told repeatedly when I lived in the UK.,