What does this mean?

[Salamandras]

Met someone new and went on first date... Made a joke after about how they couldn’t keep me out too late or would turn into a pumpkin. Their response: “I knew there was a catch!” Good/bad/—overthinking—? 😂

Cinderella reference - home before midnight?

Overthinking! But it’s good. He thinks everything about you on the date was great!

Sounds good! Enjoy

I reckon they think you're gorgeous, so the 'catch' is that you'll turn into a pumpkin!

And sorry I massively generalized by saying “he”!

What do you think it means, OP? I can't see it as anything except complimentary.

Thanks yes I know I am overthinking! Just want to get inside his head hahah

I don't get what you're worried about? Sounds like a normal, purely complimentary response to your joke?

Overthinking, especially wanting to get inside his head after one date chill.

I know

Means your date thought you were perfect

Overthinking but good.

Thanks all - now the age old do I wait for him to text?!? Think I will

Yes, wait. And polish your glass slipper.

Over-thinking.