Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

Brother got badly injured and refuses to talk

31 replies

Crinklecutcookie · Today 16:35

My brother got badly beaten up and also stabbed once this weekend. He did go to A&E himself and the wound is not life-threatening but needs surgery.
I only found out when he texted me (he didn’t even call), asking if I’d be able to pick him up tomorrow at some point. I went to see him and he looked awful, but refuses to tell me what happened or who even did this to him. I mean he told me something but I don’t think it’s true at all, and apparently he refused to talk to police at all.

I’m quite shaken by all of this and I am worried about him, but I also feel uneasy about not knowing what happened. I know that I can’t force him to tell me but this is not normal. He’s in his mid 30s and not in some weird gang stuff.
He didn’t want to tell me who he was with yesterday, and again I know that I can’t force him to talk but it’s not how he normally acts.
I hope that this doesn’t sound selfish now but I also feel uncomfortable having him potentially stay with me for a few days if he is involved in something that could put me in danger. That’s probably me overthinking but I can’t help it.

Ah yes he also doesn’t want our parents to know. I haven’t told them yet but this also doesn’t sit well with me because I don’t want to lie to them.

I’m not sure why I’m posting this, because I know that nobody can help me with this. I just wanted to get it off my chest.

OP posts:
Arineerine · Today 16:37

Does he live alone?

Arineerine · Today 16:38

There will be a story behind all this, maybe involving drugs? That he doesn’t want you or the police to know about . I wouldn’t push it further.

FreshInk · Today 16:38

You’re shaken by it? Can you imagine how he is feeling. Give him time.

HeddaGarbled · Today 16:39

You need to give him time. He’ll be traumatised.

ToastAndCoffee8 · Today 16:40

How sad, he is obviously in a very extremely vulnerable position and I think it’s best he stays with you and fingers crossed he’ll want to open up and talk. Do you have any idea at all, any chance he could be the victim of a domestic violence situation?

tomorrowfollowstoday · Today 16:41

Just take a pause. You don't need to know today. He's probably in serious shock, you're also very shocked.

I understand your worries but the best thing you can do right now is look after yourself emotionally.

Arlanymor · Today 16:41

It’s very likely his unwillingness to talk to the police will get overtaken by the A&E doctor reporting it themselves. It would be in his best interests to alert the police first. There are usually two reasons why people don’t report an attack to the police, either they are afraid or they themselves are involved in criminality. If it were me I would at least be asking him that question if he’s coming to stay with you as either scenario can put you potentially in harm’s way. If he won’t talk to you, you need to be really clear that he needs to talk to someone. I understand he might be afraid and I understand that he probably just wants to close his eyes and forget it ever happened, but unfortunately we live in the real world where repercussions - of any type - can be incredibly serious. I hope you’re ok and I hope you have someone outside of your family that you can lean on. You can always call Victim Support as they will speak to you at any time, regardless of whether the crime was committed against you and regardless of whether it has been reported to the police or not.

Crinklecutcookie · Today 16:41

Thank you so much. I will stop badgering and give him space. I hadn’t quite thought of this.
He lives alone and doesn’t have a partner so I don’t think DV

OP posts:
Besidemyselfwithworry · Today 16:53

Crinklecutcookie · Today 16:41

Thank you so much. I will stop badgering and give him space. I hadn’t quite thought of this.
He lives alone and doesn’t have a partner so I don’t think DV

I do some bank shifts in our A&E as admin and any incidents that are suspicious injuries without explanation are escalated to the police.
im sorry this has happened tho but give him some time and maybe ask the hospital to assist with relevant referrals if he’ll open you.

ginasevern · Today 16:55

If it was a totally random attack (wrong place, wrong time in a bar or nightclub for example) then he'd have no reason to keep quiet about it. Which strongly suggests that he knew the perpetrators and the reason for the attack. It could be about money, drugs or a woman. Who knows. But if he's coming to stay with you then you have every right to know if you or your family might be in danger. It is totally unreasonable of him not to offer you reassurance and some kind of explanation.

likelysuspect · Today 16:59

Crinklecutcookie · Today 16:41

Thank you so much. I will stop badgering and give him space. I hadn’t quite thought of this.
He lives alone and doesn’t have a partner so I don’t think DV

It could be DV in that he has dallied with someone's girlfriend or wife and the bloke is violent

It could be drugs and money dealing/lending etc

I doesnt sound as if its likely to be a one off unknown event out of the blue at a bar or something because otherwise why would he hide this

This is something that he knows about and knows the cause of.

SalmonOnFinnCrisp · Today 17:00

Its clearly not random

If he doesnt want to talk i'd be looking at

Crime related
Drug related
Homophonic / racist attack?

Could he have a drink / drug problem? I've got trashed and behaved crazily/badly around the wrong people?

Very sad all round - hope he can trust you and tell you what happened

likelysuspect · Today 17:01

Oh Ive only just seen he is going to be staying with you for a short while

No I wouldnt have that, you'll be bringing trouble to the door. He clearly has someone targeting him.

Smallbrowndog · Today 17:04

If you don't have one already, you should get a ring doorbell right away, just in case anyone comes to your home to see him, and make sure his location can't be found from any apps on his phone.

PamPamPamPambaconandPam · Today 17:14

You need to protect yourself. If you don't feel safe having him stay with you, then you ought to tell him so.

AmnesiacDream · Today 17:26

Not badgering him is the best advice. But your other concerns are also valid. I would tell him, while you aren’t going to report to your parents you aren’t prepared to lie to them either. But if they get to know he’s been hurt and ask you for details, you should tell them they need to talk to him.

on the him coming to stay with you front, It wouldn’t be unreasonable to say you can’t do that unless you know more about what happened and if there are any risks to you and your home you need to mitigate, but it’s also a risk you could just accept (or refuse) based on what you think of your brother more generally.

I hope your brother recovers well and it’s not something that’s going to track or haunt him for a long time.

TheShitChefShow · Today 17:30

OP do you have a violence reduction unit where you are?

People often don't want to talk for fear of reprisals as well... Lots of suggestions above as to why this could have happened but another one is debt

The hospital staff will report it to police and there may well be a referral to MASH as well.

Agree with giving him time but if you say the general area then others may be able to offer links of support for you both

TheShitChefShow · Today 17:32

Also the police will investigate regardless as it's a major crime.

SouthLondonMum22 · Today 17:33

I wouldn't badger him for more information but I would make it clear that without knowing the full situation, you can't take the risk of him staying at your place.

Ohthatsabitshit · Today 17:33

I’d be worried he’d been raped rather than he was a villain. He’s your brother, surely you will be his safe place?

FourEggsSomeCheeseAndATomato · Today 17:38

It doesn’t necessarily mean he’s done something shady. You’d hope we were beyond it by now but I do know of a recent attack on someone I know which was a gay assignation that went wrong. He isn’t out to his family and so didn’t want them to know.

But I do think that you have the right to know what happened, since he’s going to stay with you, and he could be bringing trouble to your door if it is because he’s involved in something dodgy.

Restlessdreams1994 · Today 18:03

likelysuspect · Today 16:59

It could be DV in that he has dallied with someone's girlfriend or wife and the bloke is violent

It could be drugs and money dealing/lending etc

I doesnt sound as if its likely to be a one off unknown event out of the blue at a bar or something because otherwise why would he hide this

This is something that he knows about and knows the cause of.

That’s not domestic violence, that’s just violence.

Domestic violence is within a relationship (partner/family).

Crinklecutcookie · Today 18:05

Sorry I don’t know how to quote individual posts so I’ll try to address questions or comments in one go.

Police already came to see him and he refused to speak to him, and they have taken some of his things.

I don’t think that he wants to stay with me and he will likely ask me to drop him straight off at home, which I won’t be able to do after he had surgery. I just assume that he should be staying considering his injury which would leave his right arm unusable post surgery.

I really hope nothing else happened to him that he doesn’t want to talk about. The suggestion of sexual assault horrifies me tbh. He isn’t gay and if he was nobody in our family would even care because I’ve been openly gay since my teens. Racist motive also seems unlikely because he is white but I guess anything is possible.

I’ve messaged two of his friends.

OP posts:
Dontcallmescarface · Today 18:05

SalmonOnFinnCrisp · Today 17:00

Its clearly not random

If he doesnt want to talk i'd be looking at

Crime related
Drug related
Homophonic / racist attack?

Could he have a drink / drug problem? I've got trashed and behaved crazily/badly around the wrong people?

Very sad all round - hope he can trust you and tell you what happened

Edited

It could absolutely be random.
Years ago I was out with a male cousin in a city centre pub when some guy neither of us knew punched my cousin in the face breaking his jaw. The pub CCTV showed the guy get up from his seat, walk towards the exit and just throwing a punch as he passed by. When the case went to court the attacker even admitted he didn't know why he did it and blamed it on being drunk.

Not all attacks have to have a criminal reason behind them, sometimes it's as pathetic as "he looked at me funny so I shanked him".

BackToLurk · Today 18:06

Could he be seeing someone who has a partner?