Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

Labour isn't Working - Thread 44

430 replies

Nuthatch26 · 16/11/2026 17:40

A chat thread for those who don't like this Labour government. ☕️💙

The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money.

Previous thread
https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/_chat/5595388-labour-isnt-working-thread-43?utm_campaign=thread&utm_medium=share

Labour isn't Working - Thread 44
OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
Nuthatch26 · 18/11/2026 15:47

redange · 18/11/2026 15:28

Sound like Aristotle Starmer, a man of such greatness and huge vision !

😂😂😂

OP posts:
EasternStandard · 18/11/2026 15:59

redange · 18/11/2026 15:25

I could not mentally watch PM Questions after 12.18 Pm Questions today ! Andy Burnham is the biggest Clown Parliament has ever had . He makes Kier Starmer seem like Aristotle when speaking at PM Questions. The voice and diction sound like he is in the third year of a "Shite" Comprehensive debating in a classroom over who supports the better football team. Perhaps that's why he connects with the target audience ..

Aristotle description made me laugh. I can't listen to him either.

redange · 18/11/2026 16:29

Who programs these Labour Mp's the Labour MP for Blackpool South is now s on GB News. He is saying that rejoining the EU will offer the same opportunities to Blackpool Youngsters that he had ! The MP is a "Goon" how is any working class young person from Blackpool going to have a career in Brussels Paris Berlin or Rome ! For gods sake how does a "Working Class" Northern man like him actually believe that shit !

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about this subject:

Nuthatch26 · 18/11/2026 16:36

redange · 18/11/2026 16:29

Who programs these Labour Mp's the Labour MP for Blackpool South is now s on GB News. He is saying that rejoining the EU will offer the same opportunities to Blackpool Youngsters that he had ! The MP is a "Goon" how is any working class young person from Blackpool going to have a career in Brussels Paris Berlin or Rome ! For gods sake how does a "Working Class" Northern man like him actually believe that shit !

Good grief.
He needs to spend more time in his own constituency if that's his view. How do these idiots get people to vote for them? 🤯

OP posts:
DenizenOfAisleOfShame · 18/11/2026 18:48

The Rosebank rebellion will be very interesting.

Net zero is even more likely as a cause to have Labour MPs turning on Burnham than are welfare cuts. It’s very difficult to argue with, and impossible to reason with, followers of an absolutist faith like climate change obsessives.

Burnham’s problem is that any hint of substantial discontent within Labour will hurt him badly. He’s not from a wing of the party - except the Burnham self-interest wing - so doesn’t have the right or the left of Labour behind him as a matter of allegiance and instinct. He’s been play-acting as a left-winger, but that’s a dangerous game: they’re all about ideological purity.

And Labour are stuck with him. A third Labour PM would be utterly disastrous for them. So any in-fighting will just grow and grow.

Nuthatch26 · 18/11/2026 19:10

Another village is holding a vote on whether to symbolically leave the UK over migrant accommodation.
Barnham in Suffolk is following in Piddington's footsteps by holding a vote to symbolically leave the UK.Like the Oxfordshire village, Barnham wants a vote due to plans for around 1,000 asylum seekers to be housed at a nearby MoD site.Proposals says RAF Barnham could be home to as many as 931 immigrants to the UK.

OP posts:
GasPanic · 18/11/2026 19:16

DenizenOfAisleOfShame · 18/11/2026 18:48

The Rosebank rebellion will be very interesting.

Net zero is even more likely as a cause to have Labour MPs turning on Burnham than are welfare cuts. It’s very difficult to argue with, and impossible to reason with, followers of an absolutist faith like climate change obsessives.

Burnham’s problem is that any hint of substantial discontent within Labour will hurt him badly. He’s not from a wing of the party - except the Burnham self-interest wing - so doesn’t have the right or the left of Labour behind him as a matter of allegiance and instinct. He’s been play-acting as a left-winger, but that’s a dangerous game: they’re all about ideological purity.

And Labour are stuck with him. A third Labour PM would be utterly disastrous for them. So any in-fighting will just grow and grow.

I don't understand why he has raised the rejoin issue.

He could have done the EU deal without going down that rabbit hole, see how it worked out and then maybe put rejoin forward for the next election.

But he pushed it forwards, which makes him look like an idiot and self serving over Makerfield and probably weakens the hand in the EU and other negotiations, then he appears to flip flop on it while things are going his way.

He is literally all over the place on this issue - I just don't see what he thinks he has to gain from it, especially since anti-rejoin is now ramping up and has several years to do so before the next election.

It's not as if there aren't any other pressing issues that he could sort that would probably have much more of an impact for uk voters.

As for Rosebank, I am less pro this than I was Jackdaw. Jackdaw at least produces a quick and meaningful contribution to ours (and in fact Europes as a whole) gas supply - delaying on this was ridiculous, whereas Rosebank will take a longer to come on line - maybe early 2028, we will be further along the transition to net zero by the time it starts producing and the current climate on oil supply could be completely flipped on its head. In fact it is likely that Burham will end up taking the pain if he approves it, while the next government gets the financial benefits.

Nuthatch26 · 18/11/2026 19:17

DenizenOfAisleOfShame · 18/11/2026 18:48

The Rosebank rebellion will be very interesting.

Net zero is even more likely as a cause to have Labour MPs turning on Burnham than are welfare cuts. It’s very difficult to argue with, and impossible to reason with, followers of an absolutist faith like climate change obsessives.

Burnham’s problem is that any hint of substantial discontent within Labour will hurt him badly. He’s not from a wing of the party - except the Burnham self-interest wing - so doesn’t have the right or the left of Labour behind him as a matter of allegiance and instinct. He’s been play-acting as a left-winger, but that’s a dangerous game: they’re all about ideological purity.

And Labour are stuck with him. A third Labour PM would be utterly disastrous for them. So any in-fighting will just grow and grow.

Interesting. I hadn't considered Burnham’s lack of affiliation with the left or right. I see him as soft left, but you're right, he's just play acting there. He's been a bit of everything in his political career so who knows where he stands. Depends who he's talking to.
Starmer was similar in his lack of affiliation and it didn't do him any favours.

There's another rebellion brewing on the tourist tax. A Labour MP plans to table an ammendment to try and protect hospitality. She said ideally, she wants it scrapped.

OP posts:
DenizenOfAisleOfShame · 18/11/2026 19:43

Nuthatch26 · 18/11/2026 19:17

Interesting. I hadn't considered Burnham’s lack of affiliation with the left or right. I see him as soft left, but you're right, he's just play acting there. He's been a bit of everything in his political career so who knows where he stands. Depends who he's talking to.
Starmer was similar in his lack of affiliation and it didn't do him any favours.

There's another rebellion brewing on the tourist tax. A Labour MP plans to table an ammendment to try and protect hospitality. She said ideally, she wants it scrapped.

It doesn’t take long for MPs to start looking at their constituents’ wishes above their leader’s.

What matters for party cohesion is a general belief in the bigger ‘project’. If overwhelming numbers of government MPs stand with the party despite it hurting them you get policy making and direction. If they peel off by the dozen you get mayhem.

Burnham is entering the ‘what do we do?’ phase, despite his distraction techniques. Bus fares, Google maps information and online subscription tinkering will not cut it. There’ll be a split within Labour soon enough on big policy.

The markets’ reaction will just speed up the angry exchanges in Westminster corridors between Labour whips and backbenchers if it becomes inevitable that public spending will have to go into reverse.

CandidLurker · 18/11/2026 19:46

Dinnerontheterrace · 18/11/2026 16:48

Poor reporting leads to misinformed voters. We do we have to pay for it?

How Today covered the Neets report was cheap

https://www.thetimes.com/article/91fc81d3-c06d-4084-9107-d4deb46fe906?shareToken=0a32226f4157e00ad90b33d887b4747f

Read that earlier. Most sensible thing Matthew Parris has said in a long time

EasternStandard · 18/11/2026 19:50

@Nuthatch26I just saw your thread title on Kemi’s post ; ‘Labour isn’t working’. 11.9k likes which is pretty high. Loads of go Kemi comments.

She looks good too. That dress, her energy. He looks so tired!

Nuthatch26 · 18/11/2026 20:01

DenizenOfAisleOfShame · 18/11/2026 19:43

It doesn’t take long for MPs to start looking at their constituents’ wishes above their leader’s.

What matters for party cohesion is a general belief in the bigger ‘project’. If overwhelming numbers of government MPs stand with the party despite it hurting them you get policy making and direction. If they peel off by the dozen you get mayhem.

Burnham is entering the ‘what do we do?’ phase, despite his distraction techniques. Bus fares, Google maps information and online subscription tinkering will not cut it. There’ll be a split within Labour soon enough on big policy.

The markets’ reaction will just speed up the angry exchanges in Westminster corridors between Labour whips and backbenchers if it becomes inevitable that public spending will have to go into reverse.

Excellent analysis of where we are rn. Your take really makes sense when you look at Burnham's PMQs performance today.
He has a big majority to wrangle too which will make life even harder.

Times Radio breakfast presenters keep pointing out that Burnham has made an obscene amount of promises that even a hugely talented PM with a thriving economy could never accomplish all at the same time.

OP posts:
Nuthatch26 · 18/11/2026 20:03

EasternStandard · 18/11/2026 19:50

@Nuthatch26I just saw your thread title on Kemi’s post ; ‘Labour isn’t working’. 11.9k likes which is pretty high. Loads of go Kemi comments.

She looks good too. That dress, her energy. He looks so tired!

Good stuff 😁😁😁

Kemi ended with 'the Labour Party isn't working' at PMQs today. Made me smile.

OP posts:
Nuthatch26 · 18/11/2026 20:09

Can anyone work out why Burnham (and his fans) think that there's a huge appetite for re-opening the Brexit shitshow? I don't get it either @GasPanic. There are so many big issues that need urgent attention. Perhaps that's why Burnham wants to walk this path to distract from what he should be doing?

I heard someone recently say 'the view is not worth the climb'. Thats sums up how I feel about it perfectly.

OP posts:
Nuthatch26 · 18/11/2026 20:27

Made me laugh. Tim Stanley's take on PMQs. 😆

Like all living saints, the PM cannot stand it when others refuse to indulge his virtue. If your motives are holy, only the Devil can disagree.

I’ll ask AI how to make this headline better – that’s how Our Andy does it

www.telegraph.co.uk/gift/f9676f7dff05c000

OP posts:
Ereshkigalangcleg · 18/11/2026 20:35

EasternStandard · 17/11/2026 10:06

Yes I agree with you too and @caringcarer

It’s no wonder they’re oblivious on this, the experience and insight just isn’t there.

It’s not helping to have that lack so clearly demonstrated in policy.

Yes, absolutely this is a big problem.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 18/11/2026 20:36

Nuthatch26 · 18/11/2026 20:09

Can anyone work out why Burnham (and his fans) think that there's a huge appetite for re-opening the Brexit shitshow? I don't get it either @GasPanic. There are so many big issues that need urgent attention. Perhaps that's why Burnham wants to walk this path to distract from what he should be doing?

I heard someone recently say 'the view is not worth the climb'. Thats sums up how I feel about it perfectly.

Exactly, I’m always sideeying when these people start floating controversial and unpopular policies. They all operate from the same Big Book of Clever Comms Strategy.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 18/11/2026 20:37

Nuthatch26 · 18/11/2026 20:03

Good stuff 😁😁😁

Kemi ended with 'the Labour Party isn't working' at PMQs today. Made me smile.

I saw that too, my reaction was similar 😂

GasPanic · 18/11/2026 20:49

Nuthatch26 · 18/11/2026 20:09

Can anyone work out why Burnham (and his fans) think that there's a huge appetite for re-opening the Brexit shitshow? I don't get it either @GasPanic. There are so many big issues that need urgent attention. Perhaps that's why Burnham wants to walk this path to distract from what he should be doing?

I heard someone recently say 'the view is not worth the climb'. Thats sums up how I feel about it perfectly.

Don't know. Guesses :

He thinks it will help him improve vote share - capture votes from the Lib Dems.

He thinks he will get a better deal with the EU if they think he is interested in rejoining. And again that will improve his vote.

He thinks its useful as a method of distraction away from scrutiny of his own policies/government.

He is a conviction politician and believes this is the best thing to do in spite of anything else (I think it has already been demonstrated that this is not the case).

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · 18/11/2026 20:51

GasPanic · 18/11/2026 19:16

I don't understand why he has raised the rejoin issue.

He could have done the EU deal without going down that rabbit hole, see how it worked out and then maybe put rejoin forward for the next election.

But he pushed it forwards, which makes him look like an idiot and self serving over Makerfield and probably weakens the hand in the EU and other negotiations, then he appears to flip flop on it while things are going his way.

He is literally all over the place on this issue - I just don't see what he thinks he has to gain from it, especially since anti-rejoin is now ramping up and has several years to do so before the next election.

It's not as if there aren't any other pressing issues that he could sort that would probably have much more of an impact for uk voters.

As for Rosebank, I am less pro this than I was Jackdaw. Jackdaw at least produces a quick and meaningful contribution to ours (and in fact Europes as a whole) gas supply - delaying on this was ridiculous, whereas Rosebank will take a longer to come on line - maybe early 2028, we will be further along the transition to net zero by the time it starts producing and the current climate on oil supply could be completely flipped on its head. In fact it is likely that Burham will end up taking the pain if he approves it, while the next government gets the financial benefits.

Raising Europe is just a distraction tactic. There is a reason people like Lammy were out on the media round talking about Europe rather than what was meant to be the big new of the Milburn report.

Nuthatch26 · 18/11/2026 20:58

Reeves called for us to rejoin the EU just two days after Burnham's first budget.

OP posts:
justasking111 · 18/11/2026 21:01

The government are stepping back from wind farms. The wind or the lack of it produced is too unpredictable. They stepped away from hydro electric. Solar farms are too fragile in bad storm conditions. Successive government's have painted themselves into a corner.

Three public enquiries in 20 years stopped a reservoir being created outside Abingdon, Ditto one in Suffolk. The timeline for a reservoir is 25 years.

It's a bloody nightmare which could leave us in the dark and thirsty. The only way to slow down the process is to up the price of water and energy to a point at least double where people are careful within their own homes.

Nuthatch26 · 18/11/2026 21:06

Is that the Welsh government @justasking111 ?

OP posts:
justasking111 · 18/11/2026 21:14

Nuthatch26 · 18/11/2026 21:06

Is that the Welsh government @justasking111 ?

No, we've loads of water, get our fair share of power cuts already. Our council tax has gone up 39% in four years. Our water went up 27% this year, but it's cheap to start with.

No Abingdon and Suffolk are in England. 😁