Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

Screen deaths that have stayed with you

551 replies

SteviesNicks · Yesterday 15:14

There are loads!
But from a discussion with my siblings (we watch the same things) a few of mine are from er - Lucy Knight, Dennis Gant, and Mark Greene of course.

Also PC Kirsten in Happy Valley.

And then there’s Catelyn Stark, Oberyn Martell and Shireen Baratheon in the Game of Thrones.

Which ones have had a visceral effect on you?

OP posts:
AlexandraCarrington · Yesterday 17:41

King Arthur in BBC's Merlin

That happened the same Christmas as Matthew's death in Downton Abbey. My mother was a fan of both series. Put a real downer on her Christmas that year.

SanFairyAnnie · Yesterday 17:42

John Wicks puppy

realsavagelike · Yesterday 17:43

Horses7 · Yesterday 17:32

The annoying thing is that this death wasn’t in Jilly’s book!!
Plus Rupert should be blond and drop dead gorgeous.
Generally a good rompy adaptation but I would have picked different actors except perhaps for Danny Dyer.

I am warming to Rupert as I get used to him, but would never fancy him. Too much chin.

x2boys · Yesterday 17:43

realsavagelike · Yesterday 17:40

Also Ritchie's death. I feel like, as with his friends, the viewer was also denied the chance to say goodbye to him. Cleverly done.

The whole thing was heart breaking i dont think i can watch it again
Those poor men and the way they were treated .

Triskellion75 · Yesterday 17:43

saveforthat · Yesterday 16:30

She was a superb actress but I wouldn't be surprised if some of it was personal sorrow.

I think it was. They were a wonderful double act.

This reminds me of one, Jack Duckworth when Vera comes back to take him with her and they dance. Fucking hell I'm tearing up.

CrystalMighty · Yesterday 17:44

x2boys · Yesterday 17:40

Yes its all on you tube if you want to watch it again.

Thanks, not sure I can put myself through it just now though!

Cookingdoesntgettougher · Yesterday 17:45

Gareth in Four weddings, that poem Funeral Blues, which I knew before will be in the voice of John Hannah

Judd · Yesterday 17:46

Snowleopardsspots · Yesterday 17:08

He is a friend of mine. He is now 62 and still alive and kicking…..

That has bizarrely cheered me! Made me nervous around multi storeys for a long time.

XelaM · Yesterday 17:46

Santino in the Godfather

So awful 😭

GlosGirl82 · Yesterday 17:47

Helen Baxindale in Cold Feet

jesseK · Yesterday 17:48

Jack in Titanic, Jin and Sun in Lost and Anacleto ( Dirk Bogarde) in the Singer, not the Song. I'm old so you will have to look that one up.

SootylovesSue · Yesterday 17:48

Yep another vote for Rachel in cold feet. Still can't listen to the Scientist by Cold Play.

ChimpanzeeThatMonkeyNews · Yesterday 17:49

LaurieFairyCake · Yesterday 15:24

Glen in the Walking Dead. Refused to watch it after that.

Natasha Yar, Star Trek TNG

I stopped watching it after that, as well.

That level of visceral violence was completely at odds with the tone of the show.
They won’t swear on TWD, but a barbed wire covered baseball bat, dripping with blood - was absolutely fine.

It was whites of the eyes violence, and completely unnecessary.

poppetandmog · Yesterday 17:50

CrystalMighty · Yesterday 17:29

Daphne in Neighbours! Think I was 14 at the time and it wasn't so much that she'd died, but it cemented my lifelong phobia of hospitals- the life support machine beeping and then flat-lining. I'm not exaggerating when I say it kept me awake for at least 10 years 🤦‍♀️😂.

Oh me too. I actually remember collecting neighbours stickers randomly, and her sticker was a picture of her hooked up to machines and I always used to quickly flick past that one in my sticker book as I found it terrifying as a child.

MrsDoylesLastTeabag · Yesterday 17:50

It's got to be the finale of Six Feet Under - ALL the deaths of ALL the beloved characters, one after the other, but ESPECIALLY Keith.

Crying just thinking about it now, and I'm generally a cold-hearted bitch. 😥

ButtersBackBitches · Yesterday 17:50

maras2 · Yesterday 17:22

Daphne,
1988 Neighbours after a hit and run.
Her last words to husband, Des
'I love you Clarky'

Omg I've just come on here to say the exact same scene! 😂
I was nine and I was so distraught that I wanted to write to the BBC to ask if she could come back somehow. 🤣

Squirrelsnut · Yesterday 17:51

5289843DM · Yesterday 16:11

Maybe not the type of screen death you are asking about?
It was a documentary years ago about dignitas where you saw a man die. I work in healthcare and have cared for many dying and dead patients, but I found it rather harrowing and do think of the scenes every so often.

Was it the documentary Terry Pratchett did?Yes, it was quite harrowing.

I was only 5 but Bambi's mum...

EmpressSisi · Yesterday 17:52

Shireen in Game of Thrones. God, I can still hear those piercing screams, and the way they suddenly stopped. Absolutely haunting 😭

And Colin in It’s a Sin, dying from AIDS-related dementia. Ritchie’s death was heartbreaking too, but Colin’s absolutely destroyed me. He was such a gentle, innocent sweetheart. I was sobbing.

x2boys · Yesterday 17:52

Triskellion75 · Yesterday 17:43

I think it was. They were a wonderful double act.

This reminds me of one, Jack Duckworth when Vera comes back to take him with her and they dance. Fucking hell I'm tearing up.

Yes Jacks death was beautifully done.

Moonlightdust · Yesterday 17:53

Emma Morley in One day 😩

EmpressSisi · Yesterday 17:53

Triskellion75 · Yesterday 17:43

I think it was. They were a wonderful double act.

This reminds me of one, Jack Duckworth when Vera comes back to take him with her and they dance. Fucking hell I'm tearing up.

I loved this one 🥹

cantpullthetrigger · Yesterday 17:55

Maggie Fitzgerald (Hilary Swank) in Million Dollar Baby

WatchSchlep · Yesterday 17:56

I have not read the full thread, but can I mention a book one? The children in Jude the Obscure is just so sad.

ChimpanzeeThatMonkeyNews · Yesterday 17:56

Anthony in Dead Man’s Shoes.

Fucking heartbreaking. I thought about it for days.

Alwayswithmydog · Yesterday 17:56

Katharine Clifton - The English Patient