Rather than me cite chapter and verse of the (in modern times) offences committed just up to where you say "he stopped when asked" I decided to use my fine tuned model so you don't have to:
-
Under current law in England and Wales, the incident described potentially involves two distinct criminal offences: sexual assault and common assault/battery. Both can arise from the same incident, although that does not automatically mean two separate charges or convictions.
The important point is that stopping when someone objects does not retrospectively make the preceding physical contact consensual.
The potential criminal offences
Pushing her against the cellar wall
- Common assault/battery
- Criminal Justice Act 1988, s.39 (common-law offence)
Forcibly kissing her while holding her against him
- Sexual assault
- Sexual Offences Act 2003, s.3
Continuing to hold her against him during the kiss
- Potentially part of the sexual assault and/or battery
- Same provisions
Asking whether she was sure after being rejected
- Not ordinarily a separate offence
Offence 1: Sexual assault
Sexual Offences Act 2003, Section 3(1) requires four elements:
- Intentional touching of another person.
- Touching that is sexual.
- The other person does not consent.
- The perpetrator does not reasonably believe that the other person consents.
The described incident includes an unsolicited kiss, physical restraint and an initial reaction of shock.
A court would examine whether there was consent and whether the colleague could reasonably have believed there was consent. The fact that they worked together and knew one another does not establish consent.
The statute also requires consideration of what steps the perpetrator took to establish consent.
Maximum penalty: 10 years' imprisonment on indictment.
Statute: Sexual Offences Act 2003, Section 3.
Offence 2: Common assault/battery
The description says:
He came over to the area I was in and pushed me up against the wall and kissed me whilst putting his arms around me to pull me in.
Deliberately pushing someone against a wall without lawful justification can amount to battery, because it involves the intentional or reckless application of unlawful force.
Battery does not require injury, and the victim does not have to express an objection before the physical contact occurs.
Maximum penalty: six months' imprisonment for ordinary common assault/battery.
Statute: Criminal Justice Act 1988, Section 39.
2. Why her argument about stopping is legally incorrect
The Sexual Offences Act 2003, Section 74 defines consent as:
“agrees by choice, and has the freedom and capacity to make that choice.”
Consent is not established simply because someone fails to resist immediately.
Nor does the law require someone to say no before sexual contact can constitute an offence. The question is whether they consented and whether the other person reasonably believed they did.
Stopping when challenged may be relevant to the circumstances and seriousness of an incident, but it is not a defence to sexual assault that has already occurred.
3. What about the other behaviour she mentions?
Her opening paragraph also describes behaviour she considered normal in bars during her youth.
Behaviour
- Legal position today
- Unwanted slap on the bottom
- Potential sexual assault under s.3
Unwanted sexual kiss
- Potential sexual assault under s.3
- Pushing someone against a wall
- Potential battery
Sexually explicit comments
- Potential workplace sexual harassment under Equality Act 2010, s.26; not automatically criminal
- Repeated harassment
- Potential criminal harassment under Protection from Harassment Act 1997, s.2, if the statutory conditions are met
Sexual harassment under the Equality Act is generally a civil employment-law matter, rather than a standalone criminal offence.
4. One important historical qualification
She says she was about 21 when the incident occurred. If that was in the 1990s, the Sexual Offences Act 2003 was not yet in force.
Sexual assault was criminalised under earlier legislation and common law, but it would be incorrect to apply the 2003 Act retrospectively to determine which offence was committed at that time.
We cannot establish that either offence was legally proved from this account alone, but her assertion that stopping after being rejected means the conduct cannot have been assault is wrong.
And neither the age of consent nor the perpetrator having a formal position of authority is a prerequisite for the basic offence of sexual assault.