Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

Thread 10 Burnham: zo gaat de molen, zo gaan de wieken.

631 replies

DuncinToffee · 11/11/2026 16:05

Welcome to our long running thread for political discussion, general chit chat, a friendly hug and taxes in kind.

💐 and Brew for anyone who needs them.

Previous thread:
https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/_chat/5594768-thread-9-burnham-bruadar-oidhche-shamhna-am-faca-tu-ton-farage?page=40&reply=155870405

OP posts:
Thread gallery
86
NorthXNorthWest · 17/11/2026 15:07

DuncinToffee · 17/11/2026 12:40

Quite remarkable new stats out today.

301,720 fewer children in poverty because of the abolition of the two child limit.

One single policy change, one huge win for children.

“It assumes that all individuals in the household benefit equally from the combined net income of the household"

Annex B

That assumption is doing a lot of heaving lifting given the many non financial aspects of poverty.

DuncinToffee · 17/11/2026 15:12

pointythings · 17/11/2026 14:44

The .Milburn report worries me. I heard it discussed on R4 this morning and the first thing Milburn did was mention PIP as if it's an out of work benefit. No thought seems to have been given to young people who work and receive PIP. That money keeps them able to work; how are they going to be supported?

They are still debating the report I think, I haven't seen any reactions/statements yet.

OP posts:
TemperanceWest · 17/11/2026 15:18

pointythings · 17/11/2026 14:44

The .Milburn report worries me. I heard it discussed on R4 this morning and the first thing Milburn did was mention PIP as if it's an out of work benefit. No thought seems to have been given to young people who work and receive PIP. That money keeps them able to work; how are they going to be supported?

I have a very strong feeling this could go the way of the attempt to change the scoring for PIP last year. It may not be killed off as completely but there will be changes I reckon.

DuncinToffee · 17/11/2026 15:18

NorthXNorthWest · 17/11/2026 15:07

“It assumes that all individuals in the household benefit equally from the combined net income of the household"

Annex B

That assumption is doing a lot of heaving lifting given the many non financial aspects of poverty.

I don't understand what you are saying

Are you talking about the methodology and its limitations?

OP posts:
SerendipityJane · 17/11/2026 15:22

DuncinToffee · 17/11/2026 15:18

I don't understand what you are saying

Are you talking about the methodology and its limitations?

I read it as just because a household of 4 has a total net income of £100,000 it does not follow that each individual has £25,000.

That's the of logic which has been shitting on women since before I was born.

LizzieW1969 · 17/11/2026 15:30

TemperanceWest · 17/11/2026 15:18

I have a very strong feeling this could go the way of the attempt to change the scoring for PIP last year. It may not be killed off as completely but there will be changes I reckon.

I think there will definitely be amendments, as Labour MPs challenge various aspects of the report.

NorthXNorthWest · 17/11/2026 15:36

DuncinToffee · 17/11/2026 15:18

I don't understand what you are saying

Are you talking about the methodology and its limitations?

The report itself acknowledges the limitations of its own methodologies, and not just the sentence I quoted.

Getting more money into a household is not necessarily the same as lifting children out of poverty. You can't assume that all 301,720 children will be lifted out of poverty, or even the worst poverty, just because household incomes has passed some arbitrary line. What about the many non financial aspects of poverty?

There is no win if it cannot be measured and verified.

OP posts:
NorthXNorthWest · 17/11/2026 16:00

"Actual monetary increase and distance to the relative low-income threshold is used to determine whether the family was lifted out of relative low-income AHC due to the removal of the 2-child limit or not. This publication focuses on relative low-income AHC as this is one of the 2 headline metrics for the Child Poverty Strategy. It is not possible to produce the same analysis for the second headline metric, deep material poverty, as this is not covered within the UCLI data."

Thanks.

Will have a gander. Based on the above from the first page, not sure it's going to support that those figures are a win. I personally think children deserve better than a low bar.

Piggywaspushed · 17/11/2026 16:01

DuncinToffee · 17/11/2026 11:29

I am watching Black Doves. Keira Knightley would fit the bill as does Ben Whishaw (as a promotion from Q)

I was thinking earlier what an exciting departure a gay Bond would be. ben Whishaw is a brilliant actor. But Paddington cannot also be Bond...

Of all the people mooted , Pattinson was bottom of my list - but I don't care for modern Bond films much anyway.

SerendipityJane · 17/11/2026 16:04

NorthXNorthWest · 17/11/2026 15:36

The report itself acknowledges the limitations of its own methodologies, and not just the sentence I quoted.

Getting more money into a household is not necessarily the same as lifting children out of poverty. You can't assume that all 301,720 children will be lifted out of poverty, or even the worst poverty, just because household incomes has passed some arbitrary line. What about the many non financial aspects of poverty?

There is no win if it cannot be measured and verified.

No government project has ever published "What success looks like" in advance. And I doubt they are going to start now.

Remember: you can't fail if you don't know if you've succeeded.

BIossomtoes · 17/11/2026 16:05

NorthXNorthWest · 17/11/2026 16:00

"Actual monetary increase and distance to the relative low-income threshold is used to determine whether the family was lifted out of relative low-income AHC due to the removal of the 2-child limit or not. This publication focuses on relative low-income AHC as this is one of the 2 headline metrics for the Child Poverty Strategy. It is not possible to produce the same analysis for the second headline metric, deep material poverty, as this is not covered within the UCLI data."

Thanks.

Will have a gander. Based on the above from the first page, not sure it's going to support that those figures are a win. I personally think children deserve better than a low bar.

It’s a higher bar than when the two child benefit cap was in force.

SerendipityJane · 17/11/2026 16:13

pointythings · 17/11/2026 14:44

The .Milburn report worries me. I heard it discussed on R4 this morning and the first thing Milburn did was mention PIP as if it's an out of work benefit. No thought seems to have been given to young people who work and receive PIP. That money keeps them able to work; how are they going to be supported?

.

Thread 10 Burnham: zo gaat de molen, zo gaan de wieken.
cardibach · 17/11/2026 16:23

NorthXNorthWest · 17/11/2026 16:00

"Actual monetary increase and distance to the relative low-income threshold is used to determine whether the family was lifted out of relative low-income AHC due to the removal of the 2-child limit or not. This publication focuses on relative low-income AHC as this is one of the 2 headline metrics for the Child Poverty Strategy. It is not possible to produce the same analysis for the second headline metric, deep material poverty, as this is not covered within the UCLI data."

Thanks.

Will have a gander. Based on the above from the first page, not sure it's going to support that those figures are a win. I personally think children deserve better than a low bar.

I personally think children deserve better than a low bar
You understand the government isn’t now putting its collective feet up with a cuppa saying ‘ok chaps, that’s child poverty sorted’, right? It’s a first step.

NorthXNorthWest · 17/11/2026 16:23

SerendipityJane · 17/11/2026 16:04

No government project has ever published "What success looks like" in advance. And I doubt they are going to start now.

Remember: you can't fail if you don't know if you've succeeded.

Sadly, that’s the problem. But I think they’d like people to forget they actually set two targets at the start, and they’re only reporting on one.

The trouble with calling this a win, IMO, is that it implies the job is done. Child poverty is complex, and the solutions need to be multifaceted. Children are part of a family and often a community, not standalone levers you can fix by trickling money down. I’ve seen nothing yet that suggests the policy can do what they claim it will.

cardibach · 17/11/2026 16:26

NorthXNorthWest · 17/11/2026 16:23

Sadly, that’s the problem. But I think they’d like people to forget they actually set two targets at the start, and they’re only reporting on one.

The trouble with calling this a win, IMO, is that it implies the job is done. Child poverty is complex, and the solutions need to be multifaceted. Children are part of a family and often a community, not standalone levers you can fix by trickling money down. I’ve seen nothing yet that suggests the policy can do what they claim it will.

It in no way implies the job is done. If I said I want to get to Edinburgh but the first target is the services in Chester, then said I’’d succeeded in getting to Chester nobody in their right minds would think I thought I’d got t9 Edinburgh.

Can I take it you’ve always been a vocal opponent of the two child benefit cap?

LumberPainJackie · 17/11/2026 16:28

NorthXNorthWest · 17/11/2026 16:23

Sadly, that’s the problem. But I think they’d like people to forget they actually set two targets at the start, and they’re only reporting on one.

The trouble with calling this a win, IMO, is that it implies the job is done. Child poverty is complex, and the solutions need to be multifaceted. Children are part of a family and often a community, not standalone levers you can fix by trickling money down. I’ve seen nothing yet that suggests the policy can do what they claim it will.

It was only capped in 2016, so we know poverty before then was not as much of an issue as it became. We have been able to see the cohort since then and track it. So to some extent, yes, we can see what happens when you have a sudden drop in income to a family over 10 years.

DuncinToffee · 17/11/2026 16:30

It wasn't an official Government line calling it a win for children if that is your issue

OP posts:
TemperanceWest · 17/11/2026 16:35

NorthXNorthWest · 17/11/2026 16:23

Sadly, that’s the problem. But I think they’d like people to forget they actually set two targets at the start, and they’re only reporting on one.

The trouble with calling this a win, IMO, is that it implies the job is done. Child poverty is complex, and the solutions need to be multifaceted. Children are part of a family and often a community, not standalone levers you can fix by trickling money down. I’ve seen nothing yet that suggests the policy can do what they claim it will.

How long has the policy been in place? The damage of a decade can't be quickly reversed.

SerendipityJane · 17/11/2026 16:36

cardibach · 17/11/2026 16:26

It in no way implies the job is done. If I said I want to get to Edinburgh but the first target is the services in Chester, then said I’’d succeeded in getting to Chester nobody in their right minds would think I thought I’d got t9 Edinburgh.

Can I take it you’ve always been a vocal opponent of the two child benefit cap?

Rather than thinking A->B, we should really use the circle line to inform us ...

SerendipityJane · 17/11/2026 16:41

LumberPainJackie · 17/11/2026 16:28

It was only capped in 2016, so we know poverty before then was not as much of an issue as it became. We have been able to see the cohort since then and track it. So to some extent, yes, we can see what happens when you have a sudden drop in income to a family over 10 years.

The problem is nothing stands still so just pretending 2026=2016+10 isn't an honest use of figures.

We've had Brexit and a pandemic and an escalation in world conflict. All of which have made comparing then and now pretty fluid at best and useless at worst.

Differential equations aren't intuitive, I grant. But that doesn't mean they don't work ....

placemats · 17/11/2026 16:43

NorthXNorthWest · 17/11/2026 15:36

The report itself acknowledges the limitations of its own methodologies, and not just the sentence I quoted.

Getting more money into a household is not necessarily the same as lifting children out of poverty. You can't assume that all 301,720 children will be lifted out of poverty, or even the worst poverty, just because household incomes has passed some arbitrary line. What about the many non financial aspects of poverty?

There is no win if it cannot be measured and verified.

Could you explain this, respectfully. What are the many non financial aspects of poverty?

NorthXNorthWest · 17/11/2026 16:43

cardibach · 17/11/2026 16:23

I personally think children deserve better than a low bar
You understand the government isn’t now putting its collective feet up with a cuppa saying ‘ok chaps, that’s child poverty sorted’, right? It’s a first step.

I think you’ll find it started patting itself on the back before the policy had even begun.

It’s not a first step, it’s a sticking plaster on a gunshot wound. A plaster absolutely has its place, but not before a surgeon with the right skills has done the hard work of removing the bullet and cleaning the wound. None of those steps is a fix on its own. Labour has neither the right surgeon nor the skills, and nothing so far shows it’s actually tackling the root causes. Sure, we can talk about free school meals, but what about the language and literacy skills a child needs to access education and get the kind of job that takes them out of poverty for good? Many of these children start school way behind their peers and never catch up. IMO all that is on offer is a pretty sticking plaster, with them calling it a success. I stand by my low bar comment.

SerendipityJane · 17/11/2026 16:43

placemats · 17/11/2026 16:43

Could you explain this, respectfully. What are the many non financial aspects of poverty?

poor diet, health and health outcomes ?

placemats · 17/11/2026 16:46

NorthXNorthWest · 17/11/2026 16:43

I think you’ll find it started patting itself on the back before the policy had even begun.

It’s not a first step, it’s a sticking plaster on a gunshot wound. A plaster absolutely has its place, but not before a surgeon with the right skills has done the hard work of removing the bullet and cleaning the wound. None of those steps is a fix on its own. Labour has neither the right surgeon nor the skills, and nothing so far shows it’s actually tackling the root causes. Sure, we can talk about free school meals, but what about the language and literacy skills a child needs to access education and get the kind of job that takes them out of poverty for good? Many of these children start school way behind their peers and never catch up. IMO all that is on offer is a pretty sticking plaster, with them calling it a success. I stand by my low bar comment.

Oh now that's a reply that's not helpful at all for signposting to helpful information for those who lack the skills and education to comprehend what you are saying.

Swipe left for the next trending thread