Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

School telling us to remove nut trees from community orchard

884 replies

Calling · 18/09/2026 19:15

We are in a local voluntary group and local people planted an orchard in the grounds of a school, for the school.

Now, the school has written to say that we have to remove the nut trees because one pupil has a bad nut allergy.

There are fruit and nut trees, that the local people planted some years ago and we have put a lot of work into weeding and watering. The yield was actually for the kids and we are volunteering with the school with and nature sessions outside.

Before anyone says we are potential child killers, we do understand the importance of safety. There is a management plan in place, but the school has been asked by a parent to remove our trees.
I do feel disheartened - nobody in the school said no to nut trees originally.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
23
Shedmistress · 20/09/2026 09:36

Perspectives123 · 20/09/2026 09:13

I think at the end of the day you just need to ask yourself this - if something were to happen to this child because of your refusal to remove these trees after if was brought to your attention would that bother you?
You can probably trust the kid in question to stay away from the tree it’s every other kid in the school would need to be worried about.
By the way I do think you should revert back to the school and get them to organise it so that the responsibility is out of your hands.

Wait til you find out about pollen! Mind Blown.

GlassBluebird · 20/09/2026 09:48

likelysuspect · 18/09/2026 19:27

I thought schools had been told not to do that because its poor allergy management?

I'm not sure if anyone has replied to this, but schools haven't necessarily been told to do this. It's more that they shouldn't advertise themselves as "nut free" schools because that can't realistically be guaranteed, and the title can lull people into a false sense of security.

genuineflexor · 20/09/2026 09:49

Why can’t the child be contained in the school building away from the trees or told not to go near the vicinity of the tree? One child. Easy fix. They’ll be gone in 4/5 years anyway.

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about this subject:

InMySpareTime · 20/09/2026 10:08

As I said earlier, there’s no need to remove the whole trees, just cut off the flowers/unripe nuts over the spring and summer months and there won’t be any nuts to fall anyway. It’s not that onerous a task if you’re pruning anyway and ten minutes a week would easily catch the vast majority of nuts and mitigate any potential risk before it develops.
My DS was allergic to milk proteins and would react on contact with dairy products. He spent a lot of his time at school dosed up on antihistamines or sent home early to recover because school wouldn’t take any measures to keep his environment clear of milk (even down to wiping his lunch table with a clean cloth). I agree with the many PPs sentiments about the disparity between how risks from nuts are viewed compared to other allergens.
Nuts are not a special case among food allergens, and nut allergies are not necessarily more severe than other allergies.

CruCru · 20/09/2026 10:30

I don’t have a comment on allergies - nut or otherwise.

I think the issue here is organisations relying on free volunteers and then expanding the scope of their role. The volunteers (some in their 70s and 80s) put their hands up to plant and look after trees and do some sessions with the children - sounds fairly pleasant and rewarding. The school now want them to dig up a bunch of the trees and start again with new ones - a really hard task.

You see it quite often with PTAs. I once put in place a role description of what our PTA was actually for (this was for the parents - some of whom wanted us to get involved in something that was nothing to do with us). People want a thing done, there isn’t any scope or budget for it so they decide that the people who already give up their time can do this other thing as well. Then they are surprised and disappointed when the volunteers get cross and won’t do any more.

Ferrit6 · 20/09/2026 10:44

How many children will have peanut butter or a chicken bar with nuts or wash their hair with products with nut oils - I think this needs to be discussed further to see what other options are on the table that allow for the child’s safety and the realities of living in a world that you can’t control everything

MrsKateColumbo · 20/09/2026 11:06

It's unreasonable for a school to command a VOLUNTEER to do anything like dig up a tree. The reason is irrelevant, you just need to tell the school "lol no" and they can do what they like with the trees they are responsible for. You can still offer the services that suit you.

I would genuinely laugh at anyone who asked me to go around digging up trees by hand! If theyre that fussed that can pay for professionals.

Perspectives123 · 20/09/2026 11:37

Phineyj · 20/09/2026 09:24

I'm not sure guilt is the best approach here especially with a bunch of volunteers who are probably more empathetic than most.

Cool calm heads are needed. A proper risk assessment (no rushing ahead then finding it's a peanut allergy) and quotes for professionals to do the removal. Or fencing. Whatever the solution, it's the school that needs to sort it.

I’m just saying that’s what I would ask myself. It really isn’t that difficult for the op to pass the responsibility to the school and let them do what they need. I would imagine it’s much easier for schools to mitigate the risk rather than mange it.

Perspectives123 · 20/09/2026 11:40

Shedmistress · 20/09/2026 09:36

Wait til you find out about pollen! Mind Blown.

In what way?

NotPerfectlyAdverage · 20/09/2026 11:51

Perspectives123 · 20/09/2026 11:37

I’m just saying that’s what I would ask myself. It really isn’t that difficult for the op to pass the responsibility to the school and let them do what they need. I would imagine it’s much easier for schools to mitigate the risk rather than mange it.

That would another worry as a volunteer. I would want to mitigate my own risk. Surely OP isn't insured? I'd be saying "gosh that sounds so risky, I don't feel comfortable taking on this new level of risk and risk management" or will be doing the risk management plans op?

jdb9803 · 20/09/2026 12:44

Calling · 18/09/2026 20:28

The school doesn't want fruit trees in their place, but other trees.
And it wants us volunteers to plant them with the children, which sounds nice and very educational, but in reality needs to be done by adults with kids doing a little bit, as it turns out.

This is where you say no
NO, we are volunteers and removing the nut trees is a specialist job so you will need to pay for specialists to do it
NO, we are not planting new trees in their place or looking after any remaining trees
They are expecting way too much and it sounds like being very ungrateful about it too

EmmaB1309 · 20/09/2026 12:45

Yanbu. Who do they think is going to pay for this? It would be a big fat no from me, if they insist on removing the trees they need to handle it themselves. And when were they planted? Nut allergies are not exactly a new thing so they should never have agreed to it being planted in their grounds if they were worried about allergies. They could easily keep the child away from the trees. They could keep all the children from directly accessing the trees if they needed to, by cordoning the orchard off. Which would be a pity, but perhaps unavoidable to avoid cross contamination.

CaptainMyCaptain · 20/09/2026 12:46

Dolphinnoises · 20/09/2026 09:34

Yes, but probably not before it became a nut free school. Most UK schools have been nut free for well over a decade. DD’s infant school was and she’s in sixth form now…

I've been retired for 11 years and my school wasn't nut free. My grandchildren's schools haven't been nut free.

Morechocmorechoc · 20/09/2026 13:11

TastingTheRainbow · 19/09/2026 20:29

Children will also pick up cheese and throw it, in fact a child died in school for exactly that reason. Do you support banning cheese as well? Or any allergens that a child could throw? Or should we focus on education instead?

What an ignorant argument to not remove the nuts. You've made a good point for better care around all allergens

BreezyLurker · 20/09/2026 13:45

I’m shocked at the sheer lack of empathy & absolute ignorance on this post! Trees can be replanted & replaced, a human life can not! The tree won’t be sad! That tree is a danger to life in the playground & needs to go. I don’t think the volunteers should have to pay for it to be removed but I also think it was pretty silly planting a nut tree in a school yard to begin with as schools are notoriously nut free environments. We all know that kids are inquisitive & if they see nuts on the ground will pick it up or crack the shell or pull it apart or put it in their pocket & that is a serious risk for the but allergy sufferer. Can you imaging feeling in fear of your life 5 days a week. Kids are also well known for not washing their hands so it’s not about the student taking responsibility for themselves, they literally wouldn’t be able to be in the school as all it would take is a child to touch a nut then open the door or touch something to transfer the oils. Epi pens aren’t 100% successful either, there’s literally a new law been rolled out in memory of a little boy who lost his life at school because of other peoples carelessness. I’m really quite disgusted at the I’m alright jack attitudes in here!

Ooohaaahjustalittlebit · 20/09/2026 14:20

BreezyLurker · 20/09/2026 13:45

I’m shocked at the sheer lack of empathy & absolute ignorance on this post! Trees can be replanted & replaced, a human life can not! The tree won’t be sad! That tree is a danger to life in the playground & needs to go. I don’t think the volunteers should have to pay for it to be removed but I also think it was pretty silly planting a nut tree in a school yard to begin with as schools are notoriously nut free environments. We all know that kids are inquisitive & if they see nuts on the ground will pick it up or crack the shell or pull it apart or put it in their pocket & that is a serious risk for the but allergy sufferer. Can you imaging feeling in fear of your life 5 days a week. Kids are also well known for not washing their hands so it’s not about the student taking responsibility for themselves, they literally wouldn’t be able to be in the school as all it would take is a child to touch a nut then open the door or touch something to transfer the oils. Epi pens aren’t 100% successful either, there’s literally a new law been rolled out in memory of a little boy who lost his life at school because of other peoples carelessness. I’m really quite disgusted at the I’m alright jack attitudes in here!

So you would agree that milk and cheese and yoghurt should be banned in schools too?
In fact, to have kept my son "safe" in this way they would have to have banned - milk and milk products, wheat, eggs all nuts and all fruit.

CruCru · 20/09/2026 14:40

BreezyLurker · 20/09/2026 13:45

I’m shocked at the sheer lack of empathy & absolute ignorance on this post! Trees can be replanted & replaced, a human life can not! The tree won’t be sad! That tree is a danger to life in the playground & needs to go. I don’t think the volunteers should have to pay for it to be removed but I also think it was pretty silly planting a nut tree in a school yard to begin with as schools are notoriously nut free environments. We all know that kids are inquisitive & if they see nuts on the ground will pick it up or crack the shell or pull it apart or put it in their pocket & that is a serious risk for the but allergy sufferer. Can you imaging feeling in fear of your life 5 days a week. Kids are also well known for not washing their hands so it’s not about the student taking responsibility for themselves, they literally wouldn’t be able to be in the school as all it would take is a child to touch a nut then open the door or touch something to transfer the oils. Epi pens aren’t 100% successful either, there’s literally a new law been rolled out in memory of a little boy who lost his life at school because of other peoples carelessness. I’m really quite disgusted at the I’m alright jack attitudes in here!

But do you think the volunteers aged 70- and 80-something should have to remove them? Or should it be passed back to the school?

Ooohaaahjustalittlebit · 20/09/2026 14:54

Loss of biodiversity is seen as a factor in the increase in allergies and their severity. I see no reason to remove the trees unless the school is going to ban all other foods children are allergic too from the site - even in a small school there will be children who are anaphylactic to milk

My son has nut allergies and there are numerous nut trees in our local woods and they don't cause him any issues.

I empathise with the desire for parents and carers of children with nut allergies to remove all risk from their environment but all the allergy charities and allergy specialists agree this isn't the right approach .

Bugbognor · 20/09/2026 14:56

You’ve not said what type of nut. https://www.allergyuk.org/resources/tree-nut-allergy-factsheet/ lists only 9 tree types that may prompt an allergic reaction and Anaphylaxis is rare. Only 3 of those listed are commonly grown in the UK.

  1. if you want to protect the trees, get evidence that the trees planted could cause harm.
  2. Depending on where you are, the local authority may need to approve removal of the (even if it’s on private property).
  3. If the tree does indeed need to be removed, if you don’t agree, don’t get involved and certainly don’t volunteer to remove it.

Tree Nut Allergy

What are the signs and symptoms of an allergic reaction to Tree Nuts? Find out in our information Factsheet.

https://www.allergyuk.org/resources/tree-nut-allergy-factsheet/

CaptainMyCaptain · 20/09/2026 15:43

CruCru · 20/09/2026 14:40

But do you think the volunteers aged 70- and 80-something should have to remove them? Or should it be passed back to the school?

This is the point.

LeopardStar1 · 20/09/2026 15:48

Bjorkdidit · 18/09/2026 19:20

Wouldn't it just be more sensible for the severely allergic child to not go into the orchard?

It's unfortunate that they have a severe allergy but they can't avoid all contact.

Um.... Actually "avoiding all contact" is literally what someone with a nut allergy has to do, to avoid anaphylaxis!

Phoenixfire1988 · 20/09/2026 15:52

Calling · 18/09/2026 19:25

The trees have to be removed by us volunteers, I can't see the school doing that or paying anyone.

I have to ensure that the trees survive and find responsible people to transport them and replant them!

It falls to me to organise it but I feel so disheartened.

How big are these trees ? Surely its not safe for a bunch of people to move trees ? What if someones injured who will be liable then ? Refuse to move it on safety grounds and tell the school they will will need to get professionals in and either they or the parent wanting them moved pay the costs .

TastingTheRainbow · 20/09/2026 16:07

BreezyLurker · 20/09/2026 13:45

I’m shocked at the sheer lack of empathy & absolute ignorance on this post! Trees can be replanted & replaced, a human life can not! The tree won’t be sad! That tree is a danger to life in the playground & needs to go. I don’t think the volunteers should have to pay for it to be removed but I also think it was pretty silly planting a nut tree in a school yard to begin with as schools are notoriously nut free environments. We all know that kids are inquisitive & if they see nuts on the ground will pick it up or crack the shell or pull it apart or put it in their pocket & that is a serious risk for the but allergy sufferer. Can you imaging feeling in fear of your life 5 days a week. Kids are also well known for not washing their hands so it’s not about the student taking responsibility for themselves, they literally wouldn’t be able to be in the school as all it would take is a child to touch a nut then open the door or touch something to transfer the oils. Epi pens aren’t 100% successful either, there’s literally a new law been rolled out in memory of a little boy who lost his life at school because of other peoples carelessness. I’m really quite disgusted at the I’m alright jack attitudes in here!

You clearly haven’t read much about the ‘boy that lost his life’ you mention as you would know this is Benedict and it’s his parents who campaigned tirelessly for better allergy education in schools after he died from being given milk. They do not support make the environment allergy free as this has shown in evidence studies to not reduce the risk and in fact does the opposite by making staff complacent and lulled into a false sense of security.

I may be wrong on this but I thought the poster said the orchard isn’t accessible to children all the time, playtimes etc. but for certain lessons in small groups which makes it very easy to mitigate the risk by installing a canopy to catch fallen nuts and supervising children in the area. It then also allows education to hundreds of children about recognising allergies, why they must be careful with allergens and even allow the allergic child to recognise what nut trees look like etc. This is what Benedict’s parents have been campaigning for, education as there are 2 children that died in school due to milk allergy that both could have been alive if the staff were not negligent.

TastingTheRainbow · 20/09/2026 16:11

LeopardStar1 · 20/09/2026 15:48

Um.... Actually "avoiding all contact" is literally what someone with a nut allergy has to do, to avoid anaphylaxis!

That’s actually not quite true, there is some amazing work being done right now on gradual micro exposures to reduce the allergen response and it’s been very successful so far. Obviously this must be done in a very controlled area with medical supervision so I’m not proposing school start doing this but it’s interesting to see that exposure is actually reducing allergies. It’s also why they removed the advice for pregnant women to not eat nuts when pregnant, avoiding it led to more allergies in their children.

Perspectives123 · 20/09/2026 16:17

Ooohaaahjustalittlebit · 20/09/2026 14:20

So you would agree that milk and cheese and yoghurt should be banned in schools too?
In fact, to have kept my son "safe" in this way they would have to have banned - milk and milk products, wheat, eggs all nuts and all fruit.

Banning dairy products is not at all practical for a school as it is in so many foods and it would affect a lot of people eg students and parents. Digging up a few trees is not going to affect anyone or make anyone’s life’s more difficult.
As a parent of an allergy sufferer you should know well that there is a big difference.