Please or to access all these features

AMA

I have been a primary teacher for 20 years, AMA.

27 replies

DiamondDandelion · 15/11/2026 19:08

Anything you want to know?!

OP posts:
Imdunfer · 15/11/2026 19:14

What hours do you find yourself needing to work?

Are parents more difficult than they were in your early years?

DiamondDandelion · 15/11/2026 19:17

Imdunfer · 15/11/2026 19:14

What hours do you find yourself needing to work?

Are parents more difficult than they were in your early years?

I generally work from about 8am until 5pm as I don't want to take work home.

I don't particularly find parents more difficult. There is much more communication with parents now which I don't necessarily think is a bad thing. Most parents I deal with have a genuine concern and are reasonable.

OP posts:
BarbaraUsher · 15/11/2026 19:18

What comedy names have you come across?
What the best age to teach?
What do you wish parents would do to make your life easier?

DiamondDandelion · 15/11/2026 19:23

BarbaraUsher · 15/11/2026 19:18

What comedy names have you come across?
What the best age to teach?
What do you wish parents would do to make your life easier?

I don't think I have taught anyone with an awful name, Fox is probably the most unusual 😂.

I like about age 8-9, more independent but still enthusiastic!

Most teachers don't worry about the academic stuff so much when starting school, what is really useful is if they can dress themselves, do you their jackets, tie their laces etc.

Overall though the most important things are learning to deal with disappointment and social skills such as turn taking.

OP posts:
Uponthewhiteveranda · 15/11/2026 20:11

Where in the UK do you teach? If Scotland, what do you think of the curriculum for excellence? If England what about Goves reforms? Do either benefit children, in your experience?

Echobelly · 15/11/2026 20:17

Do you agree with the people who say there had been a fairly recent step change decline in children's ability and willingness to learn?

FluffMagnet · 15/11/2026 20:28

Can I ask what thinking goes on behind the scenes with consideration of when the school engages with parents? When I was at school the only event during the day that parents were invited to was sports day (and leavers' assembly in Yr 6, so only an occurrence once in my school life!) yet now we have invites to a whole host of events during normal working hours, including the Nativity (6pm starting time in both my primary schools, 2pm in my kids' school) and parent's "evening", which I recall going on to 8pm when I was young (Mum taught, so when we were in primary the teachers' kids all hung out in the TV room until their other parent finished their consultation). Also, does your school map out the year's event in advance and communicate with parents at the beginning of each year/term? To be fair, our school is really good with this, but I know my friend's school is dreadful about last minute requests and it causes a lot of stress and confusion.

DiamondDandelion · 15/11/2026 21:13

Uponthewhiteveranda · 15/11/2026 20:11

Where in the UK do you teach? If Scotland, what do you think of the curriculum for excellence? If England what about Goves reforms? Do either benefit children, in your experience?

I teach in Scotland. The curriculum is overloaded but we are in the process of getting a new curriculum so we will see what that brings. What I will say, is children that move from England to Scotland are almost always further ahead in their education.

One of the biggest problems is so much of what was a parent's job to teach is now the schools, so we do A LOT of stuff that we wouldn't have done years ago e.g. toothbrushing, cooking etc. Things constantly get added and never removed. You see it all the time in the news, the answer always seems to be to teach it in schools! It's very hard to keep on top of it all.

OP posts:
DiamondDandelion · 15/11/2026 21:16

Echobelly · 15/11/2026 20:17

Do you agree with the people who say there had been a fairly recent step change decline in children's ability and willingness to learn?

💯. Since the introduction of free hours in nursery, it has changed from an education setting to a childcare setting with much more focus on freeplay and not interrupting a child's flow of play to have group time or read a story etc. That combined with 'gentle parenting' means that chlldren are starting school having never been told no or made to do something. It makes teaching lower school classes very challenging and lots of mu colleagues now prefer to teach older classes because of that.

OP posts:
DiamondDandelion · 15/11/2026 21:19

FluffMagnet · 15/11/2026 20:28

Can I ask what thinking goes on behind the scenes with consideration of when the school engages with parents? When I was at school the only event during the day that parents were invited to was sports day (and leavers' assembly in Yr 6, so only an occurrence once in my school life!) yet now we have invites to a whole host of events during normal working hours, including the Nativity (6pm starting time in both my primary schools, 2pm in my kids' school) and parent's "evening", which I recall going on to 8pm when I was young (Mum taught, so when we were in primary the teachers' kids all hung out in the TV room until their other parent finished their consultation). Also, does your school map out the year's event in advance and communicate with parents at the beginning of each year/term? To be fair, our school is really good with this, but I know my friend's school is dreadful about last minute requests and it causes a lot of stress and confusion.

Our parents get an annual calendar at the start of the year outlining all the dates (same in my own childrens' school). The only things that occur during the school day are Christmas concerts and sports day, we try to keep it to a minimum. I feel like my school are very considerate of parents' time but I know some of the demands you see on here are crazy. My HT is also very good at allowing us to attend our children's school events which is great.

OP posts:
Solasum · 15/11/2026 21:40

Can you tell in reception which children are going to be academic? Looking at my son’s class, there were always a few children who stood out, and they have continued to do so.

DiamondDandelion · 15/11/2026 21:43

Solasum · 15/11/2026 21:40

Can you tell in reception which children are going to be academic? Looking at my son’s class, there were always a few children who stood out, and they have continued to do so.

Sometimes. But sometimes children who are miles ahead when starting school plateau and others catch up, it's hard to say.

OP posts:
Jamas42 · 15/11/2026 21:49

What are your views on deferring P1 start for winter born children rather than them starting at 4yo. Is it beneficial?

Do you ever feel judgemental of some parents and their lifestyles? I struggle when I see some parents at my child’s school and often wonder what the teacher thinks when she’s sending the child out the door and back to them 😔

DiamondDandelion · 15/11/2026 21:57

Jamas42 · 15/11/2026 21:49

What are your views on deferring P1 start for winter born children rather than them starting at 4yo. Is it beneficial?

Do you ever feel judgemental of some parents and their lifestyles? I struggle when I see some parents at my child’s school and often wonder what the teacher thinks when she’s sending the child out the door and back to them 😔

I deferred by own child and now it's such a popular thing to do, that if you don't your child can end up being really young compared to the rest of the class. I don't think it's a one size fits all thing though and if you think your child is ready and would be bored having another year in nursery then go for school, you know your child best.

Not gonna lie, I do feel judgemental sometimes and wish some parents would be more supportive and back up consequences in class. People are busy but some parent are so disorganised and it can be really frustrating when they don't support their child with homework and to remember their things for school, especially when they are young.

OP posts:
Denim4ever · 15/11/2026 22:09

DiamondDandelion · 15/11/2026 19:23

I don't think I have taught anyone with an awful name, Fox is probably the most unusual 😂.

I like about age 8-9, more independent but still enthusiastic!

Most teachers don't worry about the academic stuff so much when starting school, what is really useful is if they can dress themselves, do you their jackets, tie their laces etc.

Overall though the most important things are learning to deal with disappointment and social skills such as turn taking.

So if kids have problems with para 3 of your reply but are very bright, what do you feel?

Jamas42 · 15/11/2026 22:26

DiamondDandelion · 15/11/2026 21:57

I deferred by own child and now it's such a popular thing to do, that if you don't your child can end up being really young compared to the rest of the class. I don't think it's a one size fits all thing though and if you think your child is ready and would be bored having another year in nursery then go for school, you know your child best.

Not gonna lie, I do feel judgemental sometimes and wish some parents would be more supportive and back up consequences in class. People are busy but some parent are so disorganised and it can be really frustrating when they don't support their child with homework and to remember their things for school, especially when they are young.

@DiamondDandelion This was my thought process. We have a winter born who has just started P1 after a deferred year (around 80 in his nursery that could defer chose to do so) and seeing how quickly he settled into P1 has cemented the fact we absolutely made the correct decision. It allowed extra time for him do develop socially and emotionally.

There are children in the class who don’t turn 5 until the end of February though and the age gap is huge.

I completely agree with you. People are busy, and life gets chaotic BUT I don’t think there’s any excuse for forgetting children’s school things or not supporting learning at home. Obviously I’m talking about these things happening repeatedly - anyone can have a bad day and forget something from time to time to time!

Echobelly · 16/11/2026 07:14

DiamondDandelion · 15/11/2026 21:16

💯. Since the introduction of free hours in nursery, it has changed from an education setting to a childcare setting with much more focus on freeplay and not interrupting a child's flow of play to have group time or read a story etc. That combined with 'gentle parenting' means that chlldren are starting school having never been told no or made to do something. It makes teaching lower school classes very challenging and lots of mu colleagues now prefer to teach older classes because of that.

I've not heard this linked with free nursery hours before - why do you think that leads to less school readiness (I think the idea was it would improve that): poor quality of care/supervision? Parents abdication responsibility for school readiness?

ThaneOfGlamis · 16/11/2026 07:28

What reforms would you make if you could?

It is my belief that teaching such strong academics so young is off putting. Why a 6 year old needs to learn what an expanded noun phrase is instead of learning to read for the joy of stories, I will never know. Do you agree, or does your teaching experience show it is of benefit longer term?

FluffMagnet · 16/11/2026 08:38

DiamondDandelion · 15/11/2026 21:19

Our parents get an annual calendar at the start of the year outlining all the dates (same in my own childrens' school). The only things that occur during the school day are Christmas concerts and sports day, we try to keep it to a minimum. I feel like my school are very considerate of parents' time but I know some of the demands you see on here are crazy. My HT is also very good at allowing us to attend our children's school events which is great.

So glad you get to attend your own children's events. I recall my mum and family friends bitterly complaining every child mattered, unless it was a child of a member of staff.

Screamingabdabz · 16/11/2026 08:49

In your opinion, what top three things could the govt do to improve the education of children in this country?

DiamondDandelion · 16/11/2026 10:23

Screamingabdabz · 16/11/2026 08:49

In your opinion, what top three things could the govt do to improve the education of children in this country?

Edited

I think inclusion was the biggest mistake as there are no where near enough staff to support the children who would previously have been at an additional support establishment. There are far too many children in mainstream with no, or very little, support that just cannot cope. It has an impact on every child and member of staff in the school. Everything in education is about saving money at the cost of education. The difference in the last 20 years is stark, it's very depressing.

OP posts:
DiamondDandelion · 16/11/2026 10:23

FluffMagnet · 16/11/2026 08:38

So glad you get to attend your own children's events. I recall my mum and family friends bitterly complaining every child mattered, unless it was a child of a member of staff.

Yes, we are very lucky with our HT.

OP posts:
DiamondDandelion · 16/11/2026 10:33

Echobelly · 16/11/2026 07:14

I've not heard this linked with free nursery hours before - why do you think that leads to less school readiness (I think the idea was it would improve that): poor quality of care/supervision? Parents abdication responsibility for school readiness?

When children used to go to nursery for 2.5 hrs, it was very structured with group time, story time etc, all children were in the same hours. Now nurseries are used for the additional hours there are children coming and going throughout the day so the structure has gone and it's now mainly free play. They don't have to sit and listen to a story for example, everything is a choice. So you have some children starting school who have never had to sit and listen, even just for 5-10 mins. It's also then difficult for them to understand that not everything is a choice and optional at school.

Home life it so busy for some parents as well that children haven't ever played a game for example, so have no experience of turn taking and experiencing disappointment. It's all a perfect storm for 25 5 year olds all coming together!

OP posts:
MidLifeMeh01 · 16/11/2026 10:41

Do you think there’s enough checks and balances in Scottish primary schools, without any boards of governors and a more light touch inspection system (compared to OFSTED in England)?

DiamondDandelion · 16/11/2026 11:03

MidLifeMeh01 · 16/11/2026 10:41

Do you think there’s enough checks and balances in Scottish primary schools, without any boards of governors and a more light touch inspection system (compared to OFSTED in England)?

Yes I do, my school have just been through an inspection and it was extremely thorough.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread