Hiya, a bit long and a bit emotional at some points - reading it is quite distressing but please do read my message at its entirety
"But all of these characterisations are political." My day to day life and experience isn't political though, or at least shouldn't be. Same for the GNC women getting harassed.
This is the core of my problem, is that trans people are viewed as a political belief rather than a lived reality. I didn't choose to be trans yet there is so much political news about where I should go to the toilet. A bodily function I need to do on a daily basis. It's very distressing and I have it good. I have friends who got physically assaulted in the UK for being trans.
"Gender critical feminism is not ‘about’ trans. It is about sex. But because it is about sex, it clashes with gender identity ideology, which is at the heart of trans activism."
- You only see part of my phonotype, that's the thing society interacts with. No one sees my genotype so why should I care about it if caring about it would cause me great distress?
Caring about genetic sex could cause me my life. It's already hard as it is to exist in this planet as a trans person, it would be harder if I didn't allow myself to do the things that keep me safe, sane, and happy.
Using the facilities that match my genotypic sex would directly put myself in unsafe situations, and at worst sexual assault, violence, and or death. I already got assaulted, so why should I wait until it happens again or worse?
Shouldn't I focus on fighting against the patriarchy, against billionaires profiting off us, cost of living, climate change, or against people that cause harm to women?
I care about my impact on other people a lot, I care about this planet a lot.
Me being happy is not compatible with GC believes, because of what those GC believes ask me to do.
But that doesnt conflict with my wish and fight for better rights to women.
Hell with all of the progress made men are still allowed to not care about emotions, impact. Many are socially conditioned that women are there to serve them (even if not said directly). I know it's not all men, but it's a significant enough proportion that it's a risk to all women.
I don't do any of that. I oppose all of that. I fight against that.
"Because they see sex as central, they campaign against changes to legal sex/gender recognition that make it a matter of subjective identification rather than material fact; "
Again trans isn't really about genotypic sex. I know in my lifetime I wouldn't be able to change it.
That doesn't matter though, because how I interact with the world is social, it's not based on my genotypic sex.
Reducing all of what I wrote to a "political belief" is not humane. This is what she does here.
"Not about trans" but trans people exist and it effects them greatly. The risk of harm to trans people because of GC believes outweighs any restriction for access.
Idk if we disagree about these things but forcing trans people such as myself to be put at harms way because it might be visible or uncomfortable isn't a good enough reason to put us at harm.
I understand fully why women feel uncomfortable - I too feel uncomfortable when a man (presented phenotypically or precieved socially) enters a SSS space, because I am also harmed by men.
But shouldn't all of us work together, in unity? Think of the things we could achieve if we all, as feminists worked together rather than this political in-fighting.