Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

How does it feel to be Gender Critical?

726 replies

2021x · 12/11/2026 06:26

I was watching a compilation of Elmo dealing with the fact that everyone is treating Rocco like a living being rather than a rock- especially regarding the cookie!

I felt this is how it feels to be talking to people who wish to validate transgender ideology as a valid identity, or having a conversation about why males shouldn't compete in female categories...

Anyone else have examples of what it is like trying to engage with people who believe TRAs more than their own eyes?

OP posts:
caprioska · 12/11/2026 08:22

moderate · 12/11/2026 08:20

No I’m not. Try again.

Unless 'understanding' & 'approval' mean the the same things & they don't you certainly are.

brownbootsandhats · 12/11/2026 08:23

Yes there are no qualifying criteria for gender in the gender critical case

but there are for sex

and I think we should have a cut and paste section for why sex matters

moderate · 12/11/2026 08:25

OldCrone · 12/11/2026 08:21

Do you mean gender or sex?

They mean to attempt to conflate sex with gender and gender with gender identity, as and when it suits their argument.

DialSquare · 12/11/2026 08:25

I’m lucky that the people I mix with all pretty much agree with me and think that gender ideology is a load of bollocks. When I see the genderists on here, I just feel embarrassment for them really.

caprioska · 12/11/2026 08:26

moderate · 12/11/2026 08:22

Again you are attempting to conflate gender with gender identity, and again gender identity is as irrelevant as Jesus identity.

Do try to keep up.

Let me help you.

The qualifying criteria for age depends on chronology.
The qualifying criteria for gender depends on the socially constructed roles, behaviours , expression, and identities that societies consider typical for women, men, and gender-diverse people.

BlueLegume · 12/11/2026 08:27

caprioska · 12/11/2026 08:20

The difference being the qualifying criteria to age is different to that of gender.

When did this criteria pass in law?

Lolamorte · 12/11/2026 08:28

caprioska · 12/11/2026 07:15

You don't believe in introspection just in case its your priors are off the mark? Reactionary oversimplified perspectives are made in such ways.

Well, I’d say of myself, I started off firmly in the TRA camp: I’ve always had a ‘live and let live’ perspective, and when a friend from university came out 25 years ago and began their transition I was entirely supportive and affirming. I’ve never felt that sex differences affect my daily life significantly anyway. I campaigned for the GRA and when that went through, thought all was settled bar skirmishes with the hostile types.
But gradually, it dawned on me the organisational problems when institutions become sex-blind were significant. I have no issue with individual people- wear what you like! - but when institutions start down a counterfactual route, the effects are too great and they’re pernicious, mainly for women.
I’ve also noticed some very harmful consequences for young people, particularly troubled or vulnerable kids. The focus on the medicalisation of gender also strikes me as unpleasantly exclusive. I’ve never thought there was anything wrong with being a masculine woman or a feminine man, like my friend is, and always hoped the world is accepting enough to acknowledge presentational changes in preference to surgical ones.
So for me, the past three decades have been a constant measuring of my impressions against reality, the rules, and society. The facts of life ultimately trump every modish approach and exciting new worldview, and institutions should hold the line whilst people modify their views to accommodate their fellows.

BlueLegume · 12/11/2026 08:28

caprioska · 12/11/2026 08:26

Let me help you.

The qualifying criteria for age depends on chronology.
The qualifying criteria for gender depends on the socially constructed roles, behaviours , expression, and identities that societies consider typical for women, men, and gender-diverse people.

Add phenotype and you nearly got a full house on the bingo card.

Imdunfer · 12/11/2026 08:28

caprioska · 12/11/2026 06:55

Did you ever consider that you might be experiencing the "Everyone But Me" dynamic aka the spotlight effect (overestimating how much others are paying attention to or judging you) or missing a blind spot in your own behaviour while others are reacting to a pattern you haven't noticed?

Edited

A pattern we haven't noticed?

A pattern created by the most attention seeking, look at me look at me, my rights matter more than yours do, I can do the physically impossible, group of people in known history?

And you think we haven't noticed?

moderate · 12/11/2026 08:28

caprioska · 12/11/2026 08:22

Unless 'understanding' & 'approval' mean the the same things & they don't you certainly are.

They’re actually inversely related. Increasing understanding of the trick you’re trying to pull is correlated with increasing disapproval.

moderate · 12/11/2026 08:32

caprioska · 12/11/2026 08:26

Let me help you.

The qualifying criteria for age depends on chronology.
The qualifying criteria for gender depends on the socially constructed roles, behaviours , expression, and identities that societies consider typical for women, men, and gender-diverse people.

Again you are attempting to conflate gender with gender identity, and again gender identity is as irrelevant as Jesus identity.

I literally told you that we can see through your attempts to conflate them in the very message to which you replied with an attempt at the same conflation.

To answer the OP, being gender critical is like playing chess with a pigeon.

Imdunfer · 12/11/2026 08:33

caprioska · 12/11/2026 08:26

Let me help you.

The qualifying criteria for age depends on chronology.
The qualifying criteria for gender depends on the socially constructed roles, behaviours , expression, and identities that societies consider typical for women, men, and gender-diverse people.

And women can behave "like men" and men can behave "like women" and all manner of presentations in between the extremes, with the exception of spaces and activities reserved for a single sex.

It really is as simple as that.

MagpiePi · 12/11/2026 08:33

caprioska · 12/11/2026 08:02

What are you talking about? Its trans gender not trans sexual. And god is also an undefinable, untestable and unfixed sense of your own identity but we don't go around denying religious believers their identity.

Identity is about how an individual defines one's self based on how they personally understand the world. Its not a concept that requires public approval.

Identity is about how an individual defines one's self based on how they personally understand the world. Its not a concept that requires public approval.

...really? No public approval required....hmmmm.

Also, maybe I haven't been following as closely as I should, but I am seeing the argument 'It's trans gender, not trans sexual' more often.

I thought that the mantra was 'trans women are women' not 'trans women are men with a woman-gender identity'?

OldCrone · 12/11/2026 08:35

caprioska · 12/11/2026 08:26

Let me help you.

The qualifying criteria for age depends on chronology.
The qualifying criteria for gender depends on the socially constructed roles, behaviours , expression, and identities that societies consider typical for women, men, and gender-diverse people.

And the qualifying criteria for sex?

Imdunfer · 12/11/2026 08:40

To answer the OP, it feels like my lifetime battle to be accepted as an assertive, self confident female with many behaviour traits (gender) and some physical traits (sex). that fall into the male stereotype is under attack by a group of men (and some unbelievably non-feminist women) who think that all it takes to be female is to declare yourself female and adopt a wholly female gender stereotype.

caprioska · 12/11/2026 08:52

Lolamorte · 12/11/2026 08:28

Well, I’d say of myself, I started off firmly in the TRA camp: I’ve always had a ‘live and let live’ perspective, and when a friend from university came out 25 years ago and began their transition I was entirely supportive and affirming. I’ve never felt that sex differences affect my daily life significantly anyway. I campaigned for the GRA and when that went through, thought all was settled bar skirmishes with the hostile types.
But gradually, it dawned on me the organisational problems when institutions become sex-blind were significant. I have no issue with individual people- wear what you like! - but when institutions start down a counterfactual route, the effects are too great and they’re pernicious, mainly for women.
I’ve also noticed some very harmful consequences for young people, particularly troubled or vulnerable kids. The focus on the medicalisation of gender also strikes me as unpleasantly exclusive. I’ve never thought there was anything wrong with being a masculine woman or a feminine man, like my friend is, and always hoped the world is accepting enough to acknowledge presentational changes in preference to surgical ones.
So for me, the past three decades have been a constant measuring of my impressions against reality, the rules, and society. The facts of life ultimately trump every modish approach and exciting new worldview, and institutions should hold the line whilst people modify their views to accommodate their fellows.

Look I hear you but malpractice is common to all forms of medical treatments particularly in underfunded unregulated incompetent health systems like the NHS so treatment guidelines aren't necessarily in the wrong here rather their inappropriate implementation is.

Would it be easier on us if we all accepted ourselves as we are without medical interventions? Sure, but whilst medical experts & authorities determine interventions help those who can't accept themselves that's a moot point.

Badvocthebad · 12/11/2026 08:53

Sex is biological fact
Gender is a societal construct

Grammarnut · 12/11/2026 08:55

13RidgmontRoad · 12/11/2026 06:39

Repeat after me: 2+2=5

Shades of Room 101. Which is where we have been and still are - hopefully, that crack of light we see is the door out.

Lolamorte · 12/11/2026 08:58

@caprioska I would not say malpractice is common! But I do think the Cass report uncovered some significant issues in how children struggling with their gender identity are treated, and on what basis that treatment is formulated. The evidence seems of extremely low quality, and shaky in the extreme. I cannot imagine a scenario where anyone could talk me into agreeing we SHOULDN’T treat people exactly as they are. Self-acceptance is the goal in every situation- we don’t go telling tetraplegics that if they really want to, they can play tennis, or anorexics they can starve themselves happy.

brownbootsandhats · 12/11/2026 09:01

Yes but

I’ve explained this on a previous thread this is coming directly from my own experiences of gender dysmorphia - 40 years ago and in the last 15

having the option of having surgery and treatment changes how you think about the problem you are facing , the feelings and thoughts you have

its much harder to get to “this is my body i have to live with it” state of mind if the option of surgery is available

It’s much harder to understand that there is nothing really wrong with me other than people trying to treat me as a woman ( gender assumptions ) rather than a person. Suddenly “this will all go away if they can see in just like any other man “

the whole concept of being able to have a double mastectomy changed how I felt about my body. It brought back feelings of self hate that I had not deeply experienced for many years. ( edit this first thought was around 15 years ago when the trans thing emerged in my horizons )

surgery and medication needs to be an absolute last resort. It needs to be hidden under the counter or it changes how people feel and how they process their feelings

basically saying people can have “treatment” makes the illness worse.

that’s what’s so evil about this

because the treatment has severe costs

you know I had a recall for Brest screening recently. My primary thought was how to convince them that a double mastectomy would be best. That’s warped.

nutmeg7 · 12/11/2026 09:01

caprioska · 12/11/2026 07:30

The priors mistakenly being sex instead of gender identity. It's trans gender identification not transexual. While I appreciate some people don't agree gender is a legitimate identity, identity is a personal perspective on the world. That others don't agree with that perspective doesn't invalidate it.

Not this again.

On the one hand, “it’s just gender”, on the other hand, “we demand access to spaces and services set aside for the opposite sex”.

I fully understand gender expression is not sex. But trans people (some of them) expect to be treated as if they have changed sex. The ideology is muddled as hell.

HPFA · 12/11/2026 09:02

caprioska · 12/11/2026 07:30

The priors mistakenly being sex instead of gender identity. It's trans gender identification not transexual. While I appreciate some people don't agree gender is a legitimate identity, identity is a personal perspective on the world. That others don't agree with that perspective doesn't invalidate it.

What a lot of people think is that trans people should be treated as if they were their preferred sex.

But they've been told that isn't acceptable and bigoted so superficially they believe in gender but any close questioning or encounter with reality threatens it. Hence the collapse into gibbering when politicians are faced with the penis question.

I don't think trans people benefit from this either. It's actually easier to make a case for people being treated as their preferred sex than arguing they have actually changed it.

There are some sad tales on trans Reddit from people who thought their friends and work colleagues saw them as women but then work out they don't. I don't mean discovering their friends are secret subscribers to Sex Matters. But like the transwoman on Reddit who realised she was the only one in her group of female friends who wasn't given a blow by blow account of a friend's relationship breakup. And said "I'm never really going to belong, am I?"

Imdunfer · 12/11/2026 09:04

caprioska · 12/11/2026 08:52

Look I hear you but malpractice is common to all forms of medical treatments particularly in underfunded unregulated incompetent health systems like the NHS so treatment guidelines aren't necessarily in the wrong here rather their inappropriate implementation is.

Would it be easier on us if we all accepted ourselves as we are without medical interventions? Sure, but whilst medical experts & authorities determine interventions help those who can't accept themselves that's a moot point.

Edited

Your description on the NHS as "unregulated" is laughable.

State sponsored malpractice in giving life changing drugs that produce irreversible effects to people without the capacity to consent to them, especially when they are children, is not at all common.

The puberty blocker trial is entirely unethical.

nutmeg7 · 12/11/2026 09:05

OldCrone · 12/11/2026 08:35

And the qualifying criteria for sex?

Yes please @caprioska I would like the answer to this one.

Don’t care how people present, gendered or otherwise, but it only matters when it comes to things set aside for males or females for very good reasons. Then it’s about sex.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 12/11/2026 09:13

Pombearsinmyhair · 12/11/2026 08:02

It just means ‘your assumptions’ but they think it sounds clever because it’s referencing Bayesian statistics. They think they’re intellectual and super rational but they are using it as a shibboleth or perhaps just for their own satisfaction rather than attempting to communicate clearly, which doesn’t seem very rational to me.

Only time I've heard a reference to 'priors' is in American police procedurals when referring to the perp's previous crimes.

Swipe left for the next trending thread