Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

How does it feel to be Gender Critical?

900 replies

2021x · 12/11/2026 06:26

I was watching a compilation of Elmo dealing with the fact that everyone is treating Rocco like a living being rather than a rock- especially regarding the cookie!

I felt this is how it feels to be talking to people who wish to validate transgender ideology as a valid identity, or having a conversation about why males shouldn't compete in female categories...

Anyone else have examples of what it is like trying to engage with people who believe TRAs more than their own eyes?

OP posts:
StealthTroublemaker · Today 05:12

caprioska · Today 05:08

😂
Irrelevant is commonly considered a synonym for moot point in modern everyday usage.

More study required!

You’re not exactly showing the Australian educational system in a good light here mate. But that’s beside the point. How does it feel to be gender Critical at the moment in Australia with all the gender batshittery going on and women being stripped of their rights? It’s nice to see there are some GC people still on that godforsaken island. I mean, you ARE GC I presume, otherwise you might (not by me), be accused of coming to just derail the thread and scold people?

caprioska · Today 05:09

inkymoose · Today 05:04

No they can't. They are not synonyms, they are dissimilar words with distinct meanings.

The Thesaurus begs to differ.

caprioska · Today 05:08

inkymoose · Today 05:01

The capricious Antipodean is awfully fond of using the phrase "it's a moot point"

from Grammarly: << The phrase moot point is best used when describing a situation or topic that could be discussed for an indefinite amount of time without ever coming to a clear resolution. Saying that something is moot means that continuing to debate the topic is a waste of time either because there is no chance any agreement will be reached or because it doesn’t matter. >>

so when Capricious A. uses this phrase, it's the way of dismissing what has been said as having no value and contributing nothing to the discussion. How is that useful? Just rubbishing the points made by everybody else without actually bringing anything new themselves.

Oh sorry, I forgot. No debate.
Silly me.

😂
Irrelevant is commonly considered a synonym for moot point in modern everyday usage.

More study required!

StealthTroublemaker · Today 05:08

Transperson · Today 01:00

I actually agree with the point that by associating myself with any gender I am contributing to the problem.

However we live in a society that doesn't really allow for gender abolists to co-exist peacefully. I would want neither man or woman as a class exists, but unfortunately they currently do which means there are politics involved.

I am not trying to make my life more difficult than I have to, and that's subjective. You would argue I'm not doing enough, I would argue I am. We can disagree here and that's not a problem.

But if “man” and “woman” didn’t exist as classes, so there was just “human”, there’d still be two sexes. You can’t eradicate sex. That’s called BIOLOGY. Even if you said everyone was just human, there’d still be one kind of human with penises and one without. So you’d eradicate gender but sex would still be there. Which is why… dun… dun….. sex matters abd gender doesn’t. You’ve literally just made the GC argument. 🏆🏆🏆

inkymoose · Today 05:04

caprioska · Today 04:59

Assign and classify can act as contextual synonyms (such as allocating or placing an item into a specific group/category)

No they can't. They are not synonyms, they are dissimilar words with distinct meanings.

StealthTroublemaker · Today 05:03

Transperson · Yesterday 23:39

I can't speak for other trans people but that's not the case for me.

For me it's coming from how I want to express myself, I transitioned for myself and I don't have a specific box I put myself in.

So as a transperson, how does it fel to be gender critical? I mean, that is the title of the thread so you must have come here to explain how someone can be à GC transperson mustn’t you? Otherwise people might think you just came in the thread to derail and scold people for their beliefs, which would be a touch bigoted of you wouldn’t it?

inkymoose · Today 05:01

The capricious Antipodean is awfully fond of using the phrase "it's a moot point"

from Grammarly: << The phrase moot point is best used when describing a situation or topic that could be discussed for an indefinite amount of time without ever coming to a clear resolution. Saying that something is moot means that continuing to debate the topic is a waste of time either because there is no chance any agreement will be reached or because it doesn’t matter. >>

so when Capricious A. uses this phrase, it's the way of dismissing what has been said as having no value and contributing nothing to the discussion. How is that useful? Just rubbishing the points made by everybody else without actually bringing anything new themselves.

Oh sorry, I forgot. No debate.
Silly me.

caprioska · Today 04:59

selffellatingouroborosofhate · Today 04:56

That's not an assignment, it's a categorisation.

Assign and classify can act as contextual synonyms (such as allocating or placing an item into a specific group/category)

selffellatingouroborosofhate · Today 04:56

caprioska · Today 04:53

categorise and identify based on observations

Bingo.

When a scientist assigns an item, they are placing it into a category that has already been established by a classification or taxonomic system.

That's not an assignment, it's a categorisation.

caprioska · Today 04:53

selffellatingouroborosofhate · Today 04:50

Which branch of science? Because there's quite a lot of science. I'll tell you about the bits I've come across.

In programming, I assign variables. That's a choice, not a law of nature.

When running instruments, I assign samples to wells. That's again a choice, albeit someone else's because I didn't write the protocol.

When examining what's come out of the piston corer this week, we observe and record soil and rock types We don't assign them.

My colleagues staring down microscopes don't assign diatoms to species, they observe their characteristics to identify them.

The flooding researchers don't assign a flow rate or peak water level, they measure it.

The earthquake people measure on ths Richter scale, they don't assign that.

The meteorologists measure air pressure, rainfall, temperature, wind direction, etc. They don't assign cloud cover, they observe it.

I've encountered observe, measure, categorise and identify based on observations and measurements, but never assign, unless choosing a name for a newly-discovered species or element.

categorise and identify based on observations

Bingo.

When a scientist assigns an item, they are placing it into a category that has already been established by a classification or taxonomic system.

selffellatingouroborosofhate · Today 04:50

caprioska · Today 03:57

"Assign" is what my boss

In science, to assign means to designate, allocate or put something into a specific category, value, role or group based on defined rules or observations.

Which branch of science? Because there's quite a lot of science. I'll tell you about the bits I've come across.

In programming, I assign variables. That's a choice, not a law of nature.

When running instruments, I assign samples to wells. That's again a choice, albeit someone else's because I didn't write the protocol.

When examining what's come out of the piston corer this week, we observe and record soil and rock types We don't assign them.

My colleagues staring down microscopes don't assign diatoms to species, they observe their characteristics to identify them.

The flooding researchers don't assign a flow rate or peak water level, they measure it.

The earthquake people measure on ths Richter scale, they don't assign that.

The meteorologists measure air pressure, rainfall, temperature, wind direction, etc. They don't assign cloud cover, they observe it.

I've encountered observe, measure, categorise and identify based on observations and measurements, but never assign, unless choosing a name for a newly-discovered species or element.

caprioska · Today 04:38

TheHereticalOne · Yesterday 22:53

Yes, fair point - my initial wording may have been slightly too strong to allow for the rare exceptions where flexibility actually benefits the sex class of women for whom the spaces are designed.

On the letter of the law you could certainly have a go at arguing the inclusion of young male children with their mothers in single sex spaces constitutes indirect discrimination against women.

However, assuming that one of the justified reasons for having the single sex space in the first place (let's say a swimming pool changing room to borrow from the code of practice) was to increase the uptake of women using the service, though, you would be likely to lose and this would instead constitute a tolerated and lines departure from the baseline rule (the exception that proves it, if you like). This is on the basis that allowing young male children in actually contributes to that benefit for the sex class of women for whom the service is in place because allowing them to bring their children with them will likely increase female uptake if the service. It would also be unlikely to affect women's safety, women's sense of privacy and dignity etc. though all those things could be legally argued. This is why I said "likely" to be direct and indirect discrimination in my original post.

Those things would take you no further at all in arguing that males with a characteristic of gender reassignment should be included because it in no way furthers the original aim and reason for having the single sex space in the first place. That is, permitting men with the protected characteristic of gender reassignment in the space for women had no benefit to the women, is likely to decrease rather than increase their uptake, pose a threat to their safety (not only from those men who genuinely consider themselves women but because it in effect allows all men in, defeating the purpose; conversely including every single young male child in existence in with his mother would not increase the threat to women) and undermine their sense of privacy and dignity.

Another thing people struggle with there is that the focus of the analysis would have to be what benefits it brings to women, not the sub-section of men who want to be included. Not a natural formulation for many people to centre women!

I suppose you could also have a crack at arguing that allowing young boys in with their mothers constitutes direct discrimination against other, older males on the basis of age. I'm a bit too knackered to consider and set out the legal reasons why that would be likely to fail but I think the judge would also resent having to write anything more than "oh fuck offffff" for his or her legal reasoning!

you could also have a crack at arguing

Exactly, & thing is until there's case law on this particular angle its a moot point to argue.

selffellatingouroborosofhate · Today 04:30

Transperson · Today 00:33

  1. Are they precieved as a woman
  2. Are they experiencing SA as a result of that
if the first two are ticked as correct by law no one has a case to challenge them and doing so could open a service provider to suit of indirect discrimination.

This is per the equality act to service providers, including abuse shelters.
Tldr we live in a don't ask don't tell society, because if you ask you open yourself to a suit, if you tell you are legally forcing the hands of service providers.

FWS v the scottish ministers established that we can ask if we are unsure of someone's sex and can exclude a male.

Plenty of men have been raped by other men. Not a single one of them has been made pregnant by their rapist.

That privilege of knowing from birth that no one can ever force you to be pregnant is part of male privilege. You cannot identify out of it. No amount of surgery and hormones will deprive you of that privilege. You have never had and will never have your life limited by the safety precautions you take to minimise the chance of being forcibly made pregnant.

No amount of whatabouttery can change this truth.

caprioska · Today 03:57

selffellatingouroborosofhate · Today 00:00

"Assign" is what my boss does when he gives me a task to do. It's his choice, as he could choose to assign it to someone else at his discretion.

The sex of a neonate is a recorded observation. Midwives do not use their discretion when observing and recording a neonate's sex. If they see a penis and scrotum, they cannot tick the "female" box and must tick the "male" box. Failure to record accurate observations is clinical negligence.

In situations where external genitalia are ambiguous, the child is referred to appropriate specialists to diagnose the disorder of sexual development because at least one of those disorders ([https://www.ijsr.net/getabstract.php?paperid=SR25830182821 salt-wasting CAH]) is life-threatening.

"Assign" is what my boss

In science, to assign means to designate, allocate or put something into a specific category, value, role or group based on defined rules or observations.

FlirtsWithRhinos · Today 01:07

Transperson · Today 01:00

I actually agree with the point that by associating myself with any gender I am contributing to the problem.

However we live in a society that doesn't really allow for gender abolists to co-exist peacefully. I would want neither man or woman as a class exists, but unfortunately they currently do which means there are politics involved.

I am not trying to make my life more difficult than I have to, and that's subjective. You would argue I'm not doing enough, I would argue I am. We can disagree here and that's not a problem.

You are making it worse.

Disagree with that all you like, the logic is plain. As soon as you validate the idea that something in the mind, presentation choices or behaviour is what matters for being a man or woman rather than the simple fact of the body, you reinforce gender. You reinforce sexism.

You, a male person, can challenge gender and sexism as a man but you cannot as "a woman" because your ability to be "a woman" depends on them.

So please, save us the self serving justifications. The truth is you do this because you want to, and women - actual women - simply don't matter as much to you as that.

Transperson · Today 01:00

FlirtsWithRhinos · Today 00:44

So, it is about the sexist stereotypes. Gotcha.

And noted that your "gender abolitionism" - a concept with which I agree with FWIW - apparently requires you not to fight the gender stereotypes attached to your own sex by proving you exist perfectly well as a man despite aligning more with (what you perceive as) the hallmarks of a woman, but in fact to reinforce the stereotypes of both men and women by claiming that you are so much more aligned with "women" that you might as well be one.

Well wow. Well done you! An interesting definition of "abolition"you have there!😂

So I ask you again.

What is the difference between men and women that you are perceiving when you recognise yourself as one rather than the other?

Edited

I actually agree with the point that by associating myself with any gender I am contributing to the problem.

However we live in a society that doesn't really allow for gender abolists to co-exist peacefully. I would want neither man or woman as a class exists, but unfortunately they currently do which means there are politics involved.

I am not trying to make my life more difficult than I have to, and that's subjective. You would argue I'm not doing enough, I would argue I am. We can disagree here and that's not a problem.

FlirtsWithRhinos · Today 00:50

Datun · Today 00:28

It never ceases to amaze me how Tim's claim they act like woman, or it's the label closest to their innate feelings, when they shit all over women and interrupt them in their spaces. Not to mention the attempts to erase the meaning of the bloody word, politically, linguistically and legally.

They couldn't act more like the men they are. They are at the most male end of male behaviour evah.

So we all know, it ain't that.

Exactly. Such self serving logic.

They take it upon themselves to decide what is and is not significant when it comes to being a woman, and if that should differ with any opinions we, the original of that name, may have on the matter of what is and is not significant to our lives as women, well we all see whose view on the matter apparently takes precedence!

And, by some werd, crazy coincidence, it just happens to turn out that all the things deemed significant to being a woman are things that a man can achieve, while the thing he can never achieve, the simple reality of existing as female, is waved away as an irrelevency.

Oh, but not a sexist belief system at all, no siree! 😂

FlirtsWithRhinos · Today 00:44

Transperson · Today 00:21

I'm a gender abolitionist, I definitely do things that don't align with the "women" box.
It's just happens that society really cares about labels and it happens to be the closest one. I prescribe to my own gender identity which has an intersection with a proper subset of the "women" social box.

Tldr I define my own gender but I still have to co-exist in society with people that don't align with my views.

So, it is about the sexist stereotypes. Gotcha.

And noted that your "gender abolitionism" - a concept with which I agree with FWIW - apparently requires you not to fight the gender stereotypes attached to your own sex by proving you exist perfectly well as a man despite aligning more with (what you perceive as) the hallmarks of a woman, but in fact to reinforce the stereotypes of both men and women by claiming that you are so much more aligned with "women" that you might as well be one.

Well wow. Well done you! An interesting definition of "abolition"you have there!😂

So I ask you again.

What is the difference between men and women that you are perceiving when you recognise yourself as one rather than the other?

Transperson · Today 00:33

selffellatingouroborosofhate · Today 00:24

Changing your phenotypic sex doesn't migrate you from the impregnator class to the impregnable class or vice-versa. And it's your classification as "possible rapist" or "possible pregnant rape victim" that determines which single-sex you should use.

You can't identify into or out of reproductive oppression.

  1. Are they precieved as a woman
  2. Are they experiencing SA as a result of that
if the first two are ticked as correct by law no one has a case to challenge them and doing so could open a service provider to suit of indirect discrimination.

This is per the equality act to service providers, including abuse shelters.
Tldr we live in a don't ask don't tell society, because if you ask you open yourself to a suit, if you tell you are legally forcing the hands of service providers.

Datun · Today 00:28

It never ceases to amaze me how Tim's claim they act like woman, or it's the label closest to their innate feelings, when they shit all over women and interrupt them in their spaces. Not to mention the attempts to erase the meaning of the bloody word, politically, linguistically and legally.

They couldn't act more like the men they are. They are at the most male end of male behaviour evah.

So we all know, it ain't that.

selffellatingouroborosofhate · Today 00:24

Transperson · Yesterday 16:30

Hormones influence your phenotypic sex.
To a large degree you can influence it.

Changing your phenotypic sex doesn't migrate you from the impregnator class to the impregnable class or vice-versa. And it's your classification as "possible rapist" or "possible pregnant rape victim" that determines which single-sex you should use.

You can't identify into or out of reproductive oppression.

Transperson · Today 00:21

FlirtsWithRhinos · Today 00:16

That is not true though.

The word "woman" existed before you. It wasn't a blank sheet of paper. Not at all. So when you decided you were also "a woman" you did put yourself in a box, you did assign to yourself all those other things, all those things that were already attached to the idea of a woman when you picked that name, that "expression" to label who you are rather than all the other ways you could have expressed yourself.

If you disagree, tell me this -

If you do not see any connection between yourself and all the other people, the female people, who are called "women", why did you decide the way to express yourself is to call yourself a "woman" and appropriate women's spaces?

It's not like you could have been unaware it was a word already in use for a long time with some pretty specific pre-existing meanings and expectations attached to it... so why "woman"?

I'm a gender abolitionist, I definitely do things that don't align with the "women" box.
It's just happens that society really cares about labels and it happens to be the closest one. I prescribe to my own gender identity which has an intersection with a proper subset of the "women" social box.

Tldr I define my own gender but I still have to co-exist in society with people that don't align with my views.

FlirtsWithRhinos · Today 00:17

Transperson · Today 00:07

Aren't you policing what women should look like?

I'm not whining and definitely not campaigning to isolate trans people from public life.

I am trying to advocate for myself and share my lived experience. Yes it's selfish, but you kinda have to be selfish to some extent to have self-preservation and advocate for it.

Edited

Yes mate. Reducing half the fucking human race into a metaphor for your personality is indeed "kinda" selfish. Just a tad.

FlirtsWithRhinos · Today 00:16

Transperson · Yesterday 23:39

I can't speak for other trans people but that's not the case for me.

For me it's coming from how I want to express myself, I transitioned for myself and I don't have a specific box I put myself in.

That is not true though.

The word "woman" existed before you. It wasn't a blank sheet of paper. Not at all. So when you decided you were also "a woman" you did put yourself in a box, you did assign to yourself all those other things, all those things that were already attached to the idea of a woman when you picked that name, that "expression" to label who you are rather than all the other ways you could have expressed yourself.

If you disagree, tell me this -

If you do not see any connection between yourself and all the other people, the female people, who are called "women", why did you decide the way to express yourself is to call yourself a "woman" and appropriate women's spaces?

It's not like you could have been unaware it was a word already in use for a long time with some pretty specific pre-existing meanings and expectations attached to it... so why "woman"?

Transperson · Today 00:07

GriseldaandMike · Today 00:02

You have no idea what I do or don't do for world peace or improving women's lives. You do know that however much you want to be you are not a woman and that means there are a few select places you are excluded from to protect the safety, dignity and /or privacy of women. If you feel you aren't safe or happy in mens spaces then you need to champion acceptance from men or campaign for 4th spaces not whine on the internet that if women should make way for you.

Aren't you policing what women should look like?

I'm not whining and definitely not campaigning to isolate trans people from public life.

I am trying to advocate for myself and share my lived experience. Yes it's selfish, but you kinda have to be selfish to some extent to have self-preservation and advocate for it.