Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Trying to understand why there is dislike towards trans people

1000 replies

Transperson · 10/11/2026 02:23

Hiya! Created this thread to try to have a bit more of an understanding on a human level (not political or news based) why some people dislike and would not want to share space with trans people?

To be transparent, my sex assigned at birth is different than my current representation, I use single sex spaces that align with my phenotypic presentation and no one precieved me differently than my representation, challenged me or expressed discomfort. I do try to be as mindful as I can and I go out of my way to not cause discomfort, distress, or alarm (i.e. showering in my swimsuit in swimming pools).
(Pre-empting the they can always tell argument, in my lived experience it's definitely not true, at least for the last few years).

How does a trans person using a single sex person puts anyone in danger?
There are about 20 trans people in Scottish jails, that's roughly 0.000360652% of the population and 0.23% of the jail population (20/8517) or 0.36 per 100k. General populace rate is 154 per 100k. At that sample count you can't really conclude any patterns since they are so few trans people in prisons (pre-empting the argument that trans people are sexual offenders and dangerous, feel free to double check my maths).

Scotland stats are used as that is where I reside. Thanks for reading, looking forward your replies.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
Mapletree1985 · 10/11/2026 05:44

Brainworm · 10/11/2026 04:46

In the UK, where I am based, the law states that access to sex provision should be based on biological sex/ natal sex. There has to be a legitimate and proportionate rationale to exclude males from a space and make it female only. Therefore, biological/ natal males unilaterally deciding that the rule doesn’t apply to them and using the provision anyway are, in my view a risk. They are undermining the rule of law and, in turn, paving the way for others to do the same.

I think expect that this thread is going to come down to you claiming you are not biologically male or a natal male, that sex is complex etc.

If this is the case, I’m out. I’m willing to have a conversation about the rights and wrongs of natal males with trans identities using female only provision, but I’m not willing to engage in nonsense about the complexity of sex.

Over 99.9% of humans can be straightforwardly categorised as male or female and this is easily identifiable. The remaining population have disorders of sexual development that has nothing to do with identity and they are still are male or female.

Put it another way, over 90% of the population could conceive if they chose to. There is no doubt in any sane person’s mind as to which role in conception anyone would play. Of the remaining 90% with fertility issues, the issues arising would not have anything to do with uncertainty over which reproductive role a individual plays.

If your role in sexual reproduction is/would be / could have been sperm production, you are male. And, no, this isn’t reductionist, it is a straight forward, factually based definition of sex.

"If your role in sexual reproduction is/would be / could have been sperm production, you are male. And, no, this isn’t reductionist, it is a straight forward, factually based definition of sex."

I agree with you, and in fact this "reductionist" point is the foundation of my objection to the trans rights ideology. People are more than just their sex (or gender). It is indeed the role in sexual reproduction that determines whether a human individual is a man or a woman, but the fact that they are a man or a woman doesn't say anything more about them than that.

I find trans ideology to be far more "reductionist" than sex realism. Why can't a man dress like a woman and enjoy some the various interests traditionally associated with women while still remaining a man?

Coatsoff42 · 10/11/2026 05:51

I don’t dislike trans people, I find the world can be quite predictable and gender non conforming people are one of the many interesting groups it’s nice to come across.

However, I like honesty and consideration for others much more. I want us all to live in a high trust society where we feel safe, free and confident, and trans people are in opposition to that.

Helleofabore · 10/11/2026 05:52

ChocolateCinderToffee · 10/11/2026 05:27

Any statistician will tell you that a good sample size is 1,000.

Twenty is nowhere near large enough for a sample.

The OP made this statement:

“So my point is that we shouldn't take any negative actions at all against trans people, since is simply not enough data to support it.”

When it comes to assessing additional risk for female people to have to accept by allowing a male person into a female single sex provision, what do you think is a good sample size to have gathered enough information to be able to justify that exclusion?

Do anyone think that female people should remain protected until a robust statistically strong sample size has been collated, or should female people have to wait for that sample size to be collated and analysed before the safeguarding policies are reinstated?

The issue is that the argument that there are ‘only a few’ has been used to remove the protective safeguarding policy and is then being argued to discredit the policies changing back.

The sample size that convinced the IOC that it is unfair discrimination to exclude any male with a transgender identity describing themselves as a woman in 2015 was 8.

https://nequals8.com

Just 2 male athletes can displace thousands of female athletes. Just 1 male prisoner can harm numerous, if not many female prisoners.

The issue is that policies were changed to include male people on small samples sizes yet we are told (by many people on FWR threads) that any statistic we use to highlight an issue is statistically insignificant. So much harm to women and girls has been caused already.

N=8

https://nequals8.com

Mapletree1985 · 10/11/2026 05:53

ChocolateCinderToffee · 10/11/2026 05:27

Any statistician will tell you that a good sample size is 1,000.

Twenty is nowhere near large enough for a sample.

I am not a statistician, but my understanding is that 1,000 is a good sample size to represent the general population, which usually numbers in the millions. When the population we want to study is much smaller, then the sample size can be smaller too. For example, if we were studying the silky sifaka, an endangered species with less than 1,000 surviving individuals, we wouldn't say we can't make any generalisations about them because we don't have a big enough sample size.

ScathingAngelAgrona · 10/11/2026 05:54

Why trust or agree with a person who wishes you participate in a fantasy? Humans cannot change sex, gender is irrelevant and I was punished when young for telling lies.

Not forgetting a few male pretenders have been aggressive when it is obvious I know they are male.

MidlifeMiseryGuts · 10/11/2026 05:58

Transperson · 10/11/2026 03:21

Hiya, thank you for taking the time to reply.

I personally believe that policies and actions we take as a society should be based on scientific evidence and rigor. Any group of people would have a few bad apples but it doesn't mean we treat the entire group as bad.

So my point is that we shouldn't take any negative actions at all against trans people, since is simply not enough data to support it.

However, we do have more data on the larger trans population and they are more likely to get harassed or assaulted than the general populace. So we should as a society take action against it.

Some individuals might feel uncomfortable sharing a space with trans people, and I am trying to understand why.

In your opinion does it matter if the trans person is being respectful? Minding their own business? Not being weird, etc?

If not, what is it about their presence that could make someone uncomfortable (assuming that somehow they disclose that they are trans)?

This is a really decent response OP. However it’s not trans rights that is the only area where people struggle to see clearly on stats vs prejudice. Our immigration policies are currently predicated on daft ideas about immigrants being more likely to be a danger or a drain. Even though it’s not true.

PeachyDaisy · 10/11/2026 06:02

Transperson · 10/11/2026 03:21

Hiya, thank you for taking the time to reply.

I personally believe that policies and actions we take as a society should be based on scientific evidence and rigor. Any group of people would have a few bad apples but it doesn't mean we treat the entire group as bad.

So my point is that we shouldn't take any negative actions at all against trans people, since is simply not enough data to support it.

However, we do have more data on the larger trans population and they are more likely to get harassed or assaulted than the general populace. So we should as a society take action against it.

Some individuals might feel uncomfortable sharing a space with trans people, and I am trying to understand why.

In your opinion does it matter if the trans person is being respectful? Minding their own business? Not being weird, etc?

If not, what is it about their presence that could make someone uncomfortable (assuming that somehow they disclose that they are trans)?

all against trans people, since is simply not enough data to support it.

To be fair there is not enough data to prove that they are are a threat but there also isn't enough data to prove that they not. To me, the onus is on the trans community to prove that transitioning MTF actually reduces a man's propensity for violence.

In the absence of evidence, we err on the side of safety and what we know for certain (which is that males tend to commit violence at far higher rates)

Lucy4Advoc8 · 10/11/2026 06:02

GoddammitDonut · 10/11/2026 04:02

"In your opinion does it matter if the trans person is being respectful?"

Transwomen are NOT being respectful when they use female spaces. I don’t care if you think you pass or you think you’re not being weird. You don’t and you are. It’s weird to use a space you don’t belong in especially when you KNOW many girls and women don’t want you there.

I think the problem is transwomen need a space they DO belong in and they don't currently have that. As you say, some girls and women don't want transwomen in a female-only space, but equally it may not be safe for transwomen to be in a male-only space. OP, how would you feel if a place had a designated transgender space? Would it make you feel recognised or excluded?

StealthTroublemaker · 10/11/2026 06:05

Transperson · 10/11/2026 02:23

Hiya! Created this thread to try to have a bit more of an understanding on a human level (not political or news based) why some people dislike and would not want to share space with trans people?

To be transparent, my sex assigned at birth is different than my current representation, I use single sex spaces that align with my phenotypic presentation and no one precieved me differently than my representation, challenged me or expressed discomfort. I do try to be as mindful as I can and I go out of my way to not cause discomfort, distress, or alarm (i.e. showering in my swimsuit in swimming pools).
(Pre-empting the they can always tell argument, in my lived experience it's definitely not true, at least for the last few years).

How does a trans person using a single sex person puts anyone in danger?
There are about 20 trans people in Scottish jails, that's roughly 0.000360652% of the population and 0.23% of the jail population (20/8517) or 0.36 per 100k. General populace rate is 154 per 100k. At that sample count you can't really conclude any patterns since they are so few trans people in prisons (pre-empting the argument that trans people are sexual offenders and dangerous, feel free to double check my maths).

Scotland stats are used as that is where I reside. Thanks for reading, looking forward your replies.

How does à transperson using the single sex facilities if their sex put them in danger?

do you believe TIF should be put in male prisons, psych wards and use all male facilities, even though this could be dangerous for them and has caused actual harm?
Why do you believe you are entitled to take single sex spaces away from those who want and need them?

StealthTroublemaker · 10/11/2026 06:07

Transperson · 10/11/2026 03:40

Hiya, thank you for the link.
Read some of the articles and I am more interested in individual engagements as that allows for exchange of ideas. Are there specific reasons of why you think trans people shouldn't be included?

Transpeople should totally be included. In facilities relevant to their sex. Easy. Next.

StealthTroublemaker · 10/11/2026 06:10

Transperson · 10/11/2026 04:18

"Transwomen are male" - not phenotypically, although most are in terms of genetic and gonadal sex.

I believe my last reply covers the rest of the message.

The only criteria to be a “transwoman” is to be male. All “transwomen” are male. Sex is binary and immutable.
we hear a lot about how allowing males into female spaces will benefit those males. What material benefit do women get for allowing all spaces to be mixed sex? How will this make women and girls safer?

Airconfan · 10/11/2026 06:10

I don’t dislike trans people. In simple terms it’s like religion or smoking. Do I want to hear about it 24/7 - no. Just live your life not negativitly impacting anyone else as much as possible.

I have no issue with someone being religious, smoking or being trans just don’t make it your whole personality, and don’t try to change my rights based on your views.

I believe in single sex spaces based your birth or alternate areas others can use. I don’t think trans people should compete in sports of their new assigned gender or be in prison of that gender too.

It’s the age old saying of having a box of Maltesers, one is actually a little ball of poop. Would you be suspicious of all the chocolates?

Helleofabore · 10/11/2026 06:10

Transperson · 10/11/2026 02:49

Hiya! I posted some stats about this, as I said in Scotland there about 20 trans people in prisons which means you can't meaningfully conclude any patterns (sample size is tiny)
I think CI (confidence interval) here is less than 0.5%, scientific regior aims for 95% at the very least.

So it's very unlikely for you to share single sex space with an offender who is trans.
I don't think anyone would be comfortable sharing any space with any sexual offender.

Edited

Safeguarding principles don’t consider how “very unlikely for you to share single sex space with an offender who is trans.”

Safeguarding principles consider that somewhere in the country setting the policy, some, or even one, female people WILL share a single sex provision with an offender who is trans if policy is not created to protect the female people from the potential.

The difference in perspective shows the difference between protecting female people vs dismissing those protection because it won’t happen to many.

The question remains the same though,

How many female people do you consider acceptable to be harmed before all male people are fully excluded from all single sex provisions?

StealthTroublemaker · 10/11/2026 06:11

Lucy4Advoc8 · 10/11/2026 06:02

I think the problem is transwomen need a space they DO belong in and they don't currently have that. As you say, some girls and women don't want transwomen in a female-only space, but equally it may not be safe for transwomen to be in a male-only space. OP, how would you feel if a place had a designated transgender space? Would it make you feel recognised or excluded?

they do have a space they belong in. They have all the facilities relevant to their sex. Do you think “transmen” should be put in male prisons and psych wards? If “transwomen” are not safe in male facilities, do you think “transmen” would be safe?

Yello24 · 10/11/2026 06:12

OP. Ask yourself why you thought it important to highlight that you have medically transitioned and that you believe you ‘pass’?
Why is that relevant?

Do you believe that there should be different attitudes to transwomen who retain their penis (98%?) or who don’t ‘pass’? And why would that be?

I don’t dislike trans identifying people at all. I just dislike mendaciousness, unfairness, aggression, selfishness, patriarchy and bullshit. I think the TRA have been very harmful to quiet and respectful TW who have always been among us.

Again. Why did you feel the need to label yourself as one of the good ones? You’re keen on stats so why couldn’t you ask your questions without feeling the need to differentiate yourself from other TW? We know there are decent people in any group of humans but that’s not the point is it? TW are men. Women deserve the right to protect themselves from men.

Igneococcus · 10/11/2026 06:13

I don't think you understand the word phenotypical.
Clothes, hair style, make up are all not part of your phenotype.

ohfook · 10/11/2026 06:16

I don’t dislike trans people at all. I would just like a bit more nuance than currently exists. If I had to outline my ideal situation I’d like one where we understand that people can identify however they want, transphobia wouldn’t exist, we’d have done enough research to understand the best care to provide for trans people and anyone can dress how they want/cal themselves what they want etc but alongside that I’d like an understanding that at times biology does make a difference so kindness and acceptance would work both ways and go hand in hand with the understanding that there are some issues where biology does take a priority- sports/prisons/intimate care and it shouldn’t be a big deal to expect this.

I think what irks me (and I’ve mentioned it loads) is I’ve heard gay friends say that trans men would not be allowed into a gay sauna unless they were specifically invited (and I’ve heard trans men say that) and there’s been no accusations of transphobia whereas women have to be quiet and be kind or all hell breaks loose.

Also to me it seems really obvious that the problem is men. Trans women don’t want to continue using mama bathrooms and changing areas because of the danger that men using them present. Statistically the vast majority of violence against trans women is committed by a man. Some women (myself included) don’t want to open up the bandwidth of who can be admitted to places where we’re vulnerable (changing rooms etc) because it makes it much harder to deny people access once you’ve opened that door and I personally don’t want to rely on a system that has already plagued women for years where by the trans women that look ok (ie pass) are accepted more so than those that don’t. It just seems so obvious to me that sometimes identity trumps biology and sometimes biology trumps identity and it feels odd to me that not everyone thinks exactly like me can see that.

HermioneWeasley · 10/11/2026 06:16

you seem to think that someone’s subject unverifiable and changeable feelings about themself are a better basis for policy and law than the objective fact of their sex

i disagree

by the way, I have seen TIMs in women’s toilets plenty of times and not confronted them because I have been scared to. Assuming you are a TIM not a TIF that may by why you think you pass and nobody has ever commented

Helleofabore · 10/11/2026 06:17

How many additional female people do you consider acceptable to be harmed by including any male person with a transgender identity in a female single sex provision, before all male people above around 8 years old are fully excluded from all single sex provisions?

What is your number?

This is a question for @Transperson . However, I encourage everyone to answer.

My number is zero. in the past we had answers such as 100 and I think 35.

StealthTroublemaker · 10/11/2026 06:17

Igneococcus · 10/11/2026 06:13

I don't think you understand the word phenotypical.
Clothes, hair style, make up are all not part of your phenotype.

It’s all they’ve got though isn’t it? The only way they can try yo “prove” à man is a woman is by clinging to the outdated sexist stereotypes of what a woman should look like. I bet we’re either gonna have another ghost OP or we get to page 5 before the insults start….

bellinisurge · 10/11/2026 06:17

Had trans activists spent the last 10 years lobbying for 4th spaces, for men to be more accepting of other men in men’s spaces and not tried to neutralise important sex based language to describe women, particularly in healthcare , I would have had some positive feelings. But the relentless bullying and gaslighting of women who raised thoroughly reasonable concerns about the safeguarding risks posed by self ID and the dehumanising neutralising health language ended that. Forever. There is no coming back from the harm that has been done.

StealthTroublemaker · 10/11/2026 06:17

Helleofabore · 10/11/2026 06:17

How many additional female people do you consider acceptable to be harmed by including any male person with a transgender identity in a female single sex provision, before all male people above around 8 years old are fully excluded from all single sex provisions?

What is your number?

This is a question for @Transperson . However, I encourage everyone to answer.

My number is zero. in the past we had answers such as 100 and I think 35.

Zero for me too.

the7Vabo · 10/11/2026 06:18

I don’t know how society got to a place where we believe that someone was born in the wrong body. I have no issue with anyone wishing they were the opposite sex. That is honest. What isn’t is claiming that they are somehow the same as the opposite sex.

Im sick of how aggressively this idea is pushed and pushed. Endless debates about why men need to be in women’s spaces and women being asked to justify why they want women only bathrooms. Women being labelled as “cis”, and “chest feeders” while also being lectured about using the “correct” pronouns. Children’s libraries with books about trans rights front and centre.

Women’s rights were hard won. We are entitled to single sex bathrooms without having to explain why to a man.

SockPlant · 10/11/2026 06:20

Frankly? I try not to give them a passing thought.

But, for eg, have you seen the reaction of trans activists when women want to march to reclaim the night? Or gather to share experiences of MVAWAG?

That is why so many people are sick to the back teeth of it all.

SockPlant · 10/11/2026 06:20

Frankly? I try not to give them a passing thought.

But, for eg, have you seen the reaction of trans activists when women want to march to reclaim the night? Or gather to share experiences of MVAWAG?

That is why so many people are sick to the back teeth of it all.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.