Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Trying to understand why there is dislike towards trans people

1000 replies

Transperson · 10/11/2026 02:23

Hiya! Created this thread to try to have a bit more of an understanding on a human level (not political or news based) why some people dislike and would not want to share space with trans people?

To be transparent, my sex assigned at birth is different than my current representation, I use single sex spaces that align with my phenotypic presentation and no one precieved me differently than my representation, challenged me or expressed discomfort. I do try to be as mindful as I can and I go out of my way to not cause discomfort, distress, or alarm (i.e. showering in my swimsuit in swimming pools).
(Pre-empting the they can always tell argument, in my lived experience it's definitely not true, at least for the last few years).

How does a trans person using a single sex person puts anyone in danger?
There are about 20 trans people in Scottish jails, that's roughly 0.000360652% of the population and 0.23% of the jail population (20/8517) or 0.36 per 100k. General populace rate is 154 per 100k. At that sample count you can't really conclude any patterns since they are so few trans people in prisons (pre-empting the argument that trans people are sexual offenders and dangerous, feel free to double check my maths).

Scotland stats are used as that is where I reside. Thanks for reading, looking forward your replies.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
StealthTroublemaker · 10/11/2026 07:13

BrickMaker · 10/11/2026 07:09

It's true I don't deny that. But is the solution banning trans? I don't know. It was a very upsetting experience for the women and I just don't know the full answer because as a social worker I have had such lovely trans clients that would probably be at real risk in an all men's environment. Maybe a dedicated small shelter would be better.

But were Your women clients not lovely?

Helleofabore · 10/11/2026 07:13

“Phenotypically somewhere leaning towards female.”

Female people are never male people who are ‘near enough’ to being female!

It is misogynistic to declare being ‘near enough is good enough’ to claim to be female in any way. Including using any female language reference terms.

StealthTroublemaker · 10/11/2026 07:14

Floristian · 10/11/2026 07:11

Exactly. Such a waste of time engaging with them. There'll be another along in a minute with more wide-eyed faux naivete.

Or insults…. Im sure the Aussie crowd will be along shortly….

RareGoalsVerge · 10/11/2026 07:15

No dislike of trans people from here. I absolutely believe in and uphold everyone's right to be free of the gender stereotypes that used to constrain people.

I find it deeply sexist that anyone could believe that conforming to the stereotypes of the opposite sex should make them be considered "actually" a member of that sex. Thar is confirming and upholding the stereotypes that should be abolished. It is not possible to "feel" female or "feel" male. We can each only ever feel like ourselves and if a male person's feelings are more similar to a female stereotype than a male one then that broadens the definition of what it can feel like to be male, it doesn't make them female. This is factual, not dislike or hatred or persecution.

Knowing that someone is sexist in this way doesn't make me hate or dislike them. It's very hard not to grow up with internalised sexism given how sexist the world is. I can be friends with a sexist as much as I can be friends with someone of a different religion or different political party - I do not have to agree with my friends on these issues. The idea that someone is "unsafe" in the presence of someone who doesn't validate their opinions on these topics is highly distasteful and regressive.

You are wrong that no one perceives you as the sex that you are. Not being challenged just means that the people who perceive your actual sex are too imtimidated or too compliant to your arrogant imposition to have the courage to challenge you. The few women who have the courage to stand against these situations have their lives ruined by the mob of disgusting misogynists who want the feelings of a male to be prioritised over the needs of a female. I don't blame those who don't have the courage for that fight but you are violating them without their consent every time you use a supposedly all-female space whilst being male. You do not have consent, you are taking without consent. The idea that this is ok because you aren't actually touching a woman in the process doesn't mean it's not a violation of consent. What a low bar of decency, to think that just not raping or touching someone means they should be ok with your presence. Your physical presence in that space is still a wrong.

For the same reason your statistics are meaningless. The number of rapes and sexual attacks are obviously going to be small because the number of people involved is small. Those statistics do not count the aggression of every single time a woman realises she is in what is supposed to be a female space, with a male. She may just get out of there as quickly as she can, she may performatively say or do something that you perceive as acceptance, as a defence mechanism. She may have deeply internalised the same cultural misogyny that you have, but whichever of these it is doesn't stop it from being an aggression that can never be counted in the statistics. The statistics that do matter is that among transwomen, as compared to male people who don't identify as trans, there is no reduction in violent crime or sexual crime. Not all men are violent or sexual offenders and a lot of men are perfectly decent. Not all transwomen are violent or sexual offenders and a lot of transwomen are perfectly decent. But the fact of being a transwoman does not make that individual any less of a threat than any other male person. A small number of rapes and sexual attacks does not mean the situation is acceptable. There is no acceptable number. A small percentage does not meanthere is no threat. Male people do not get to decide what collateral level of harm women shoukd be obliged to accept in the violation of female spaces.

Women are not tools for your validation and support. When you use women's facilities you are objectifying women to be that tool for you without their consent. Any pretended consent cannot be accepted at face value because there are real dangers to refusing that consent and coerced consent is not valid. The only decent and non-aggressive thing to do is to use unisex facilities and campaign for these to be more readily available where they don't exist.

The hatred and violencd and death threats that women get every time they try to uphold keeping any tiny part of the world to be genuinely female only just proves how much it is needed. If the category of "woman" includes males with a particular set of ideas in their head, then there is no such category as women. The word is only meaningful if it is used to describe all people who exist in the world in a female body, regardless of their feeling about their gender or their gender presentation. Transmen are female. There are few arguments and debates about transmen because unless they have overdosed on testosterone to the point of triggering violent rages, they aren't any more a threat than any other female. Their internalised sexism whereby they think their lack of identification with feminine stereotypes makes them less female is sad and misinformed but not usually actively harmful to other women, only to them, so there's less campaigning about that.

It is very tiresome to be continually accused of hatred and fear towards trans people. The issue is not trans people, only those trans people who are male, because they are male, and it's not hatred or fear to say that the same boundaries that we apply to all other male people also apply to those male people who want to be perceived as feminine.

Thisusernameisalwaysavailable · 10/11/2026 07:15

Transperson · 10/11/2026 04:10

Hiya, appreciated the detailed response.

"How does a trans person using a single sex provision put anyone in danger?
An alternative phrasing of this question is ‘how does a male using female only provision put anyone in danger? Or, ‘how does a males with a trans identity using female only provision put anyone in danger? When looking at it at an individual level, Tom, Dick and Harry may present no danger but Fred, Jack and Russell do. Because of this, a blanket rule, making a service or provision single sex, is lawfully."

I would disagree with the proposition that trans people are in the same category of their born sex. Medically transitioing changes them phenotypically, which effect how they are precieved. In this example that would create a new category, of people who are trans. Unless you meaningfully establish that being trans is correlated, linked, with assaulting others, at the same rates or higher as non trans men. They are different.

It's already established that trans people are more likely to be victims of crime than perpetrators.

"It is harmful to trans people to perpetuate ideas that those wanting transwomen to stay out of female only provision hate or dislike transwomen."

How so? From my pov excluding trans people directly increases their risk to be outed and attacked (which you don't do to people you don't dislike!)

"Using female only provision when you are male is harmful to females, it completely violates our boundaries."

Could you define the boundaries and how trans people violate them?

Men who have altered their bodies are still men.

They still are part of the most violent and dangerous sex.

They don't magically become a woman, no matter how much they mutilate their bodies and how many skirts they wear.

They're still men.. strong, dangerous, violent and emotional.

Otherwise there'd be no trans women committing acts of violence.... But there are.

Why? Because men have emotional control issues and because they're stronger and more entitled, they will rape and beat weaker people....women.

Tran Women don't pass, women are just too polite and/or scared to say anything to a man pretending they're a woman, so the men falsely perceive this as them "passing", failing to understand the danger and risk the woman is out in if she was brave enough to confront the man standing beside her in the wash area of a toilet...

YorkshirePuddingsGreatestFan · 10/11/2026 07:16

Women need protecting from men because we know a percentage of men harm women. That's why single sex spaces exist. We can't tell by looking which are harmful men and which are kind men, so all men are barred from women's spaces.

Likewise when men identify as women, we can't tell who is a nice trans and who is a harmful trans. Some women have the same fearful reaction when a man dressed as a woman enters a female space, in exactly the same was as if a man walked in.

In my case, I knew he was a man dressed as a woman in a woman's toilet but my "be kind" conditioning kicked in and I didn't say anything. Then she sexually assaulted me with her penis.

If men want to be women, they have the right to do that and live their life as they see fit. However, they cannot demand that women accept this and give them access to women's spaces as it makes women uncomfortable. A common argument is that transwomen feel unsafe using male toilets, but if women say they feel unsafe with transwomen in women's toilets, they're branded hateful transphobes.

I believe that instead of fighting with women, the trans community would be better using their energy to fight for their own safe spaces that don't infringe on the safety and privacy of women.

ConciseOxford · 10/11/2026 07:17

I go to a nail salon and it’s such a joy. All sorts of women go - it’s very diverse in terms of age, ethnicity, social class etc. But it’s all women together and we talk freely about things that women only talk about together and when they feel safe. Eg the many challenges of breastfeeding. Post menopausal bleeding - investigations/ outcomes. One lady’s daughter has a controlling boyfriend. Etc, etc, etc. ALL sorts. Different every time, obviously. Older women share experiences and wisdom and younger women get support and information. It’s like a safe sanctuary and totally enriches everyone.

There is a transwoman who comes. He has NO idea that his presence kills all this stone dead. When he is there there is little chat and what there is is ‘how was your holiday/ are you getting ready for Christmas’. It’s night and day from how it normally is and it’s because a man in the mix totally changes the dynamic. I know his regular slot and avoid it now because my one hour in that place, once every three weeks, is such a treat and so heartwarming for me and it’s just not the same when he is there. We can’t possibly talk about women’s experiences with him there.

I don’t ‘dislike’ him - as per OP’s question - but I don’t want to overlap with him.

Transwomen never pass. You can always, always, always tell.

Shedmistress · 10/11/2026 07:18

I dislike men who pretend they are women and use the spaces designated for women.

And I see we have moved to a new description of 'sex', 'Phenotypical' sex is not a thing.

You know what sex you are, use the facilities provided for yours and stop thinking you are some sort of guru who knows the inside of people's heads. you do not.

And as a footnote, not one person on the planet has ever 'changed sex'.

DeafLeppard · 10/11/2026 07:18

The OP is (as is common with males) being told no by women, and hearing women don’t like me.

HermioneWeasley · 10/11/2026 07:20

BrickMaker · 10/11/2026 07:09

It's true I don't deny that. But is the solution banning trans? I don't know. It was a very upsetting experience for the women and I just don't know the full answer because as a social worker I have had such lovely trans clients that would probably be at real risk in an all men's environment. Maybe a dedicated small shelter would be better.

Women are not human shields for vulnerable men

anyolddinosaur · 10/11/2026 07:20

Your post is not really "trying to understand" at all - and you are asking the wrong people. You are at no risk from women, which is one of the reasons you insist on forcing yourself into places you know you are not welcome. Most trans people claim to "pass" and the vast majority will only do so through the most rose coloured of spectacles. The rest have had extreme plastic surgery. Some men do seem to be violent towards people claiming a trans identity. Some men are violent and sometimes any excuse will do.

Why do you, personally, insist on going into places where you know your presence causes discomfort and distress? Why not use gender neutral facilities? Dont try the usual guff about "outing" as it isnt. In doing so you demonstrate quite clearly that you are not, never will be, a woman.

If there are trans people who stay out of womens spaces dont dress inappropriately around children, just quietly get on with living their best life and sleeping with anyone who will have them then I doubt anyone here would dislike them, Unfortunately if they exist they dont generally turn up here. The people who do post here saying they are trans usually display some deeply unpleasant behaviour and hence are disliked.

Helleofabore · 10/11/2026 07:20

BrickMaker · 10/11/2026 07:09

It's true I don't deny that. But is the solution banning trans? I don't know. It was a very upsetting experience for the women and I just don't know the full answer because as a social worker I have had such lovely trans clients that would probably be at real risk in an all men's environment. Maybe a dedicated small shelter would be better.

As a social worker, how do you understand safeguarding principles if you don’t understand why all male people are excluded from a female single sex provision?

The policy excluding all male people is not ‘banning trans’. It is segregating a provision by sex category of human to prevent harms that include but are not limited to physical harm.

Do you think a male person with a transgender identity has somehow become ‘not male’? Do you then segregate the group of male people with transgender identities into those with a penis and those without? What has changed to make those without a penis less risk of sexual abuse and any other harm that including a male person in a female single sex provision can cause a female person using that provision?

Igneococcus · 10/11/2026 07:22

BrickMaker · 10/11/2026 07:09

It's true I don't deny that. But is the solution banning trans? I don't know. It was a very upsetting experience for the women and I just don't know the full answer because as a social worker I have had such lovely trans clients that would probably be at real risk in an all men's environment. Maybe a dedicated small shelter would be better.

Yes, the solution is not allowing any men, no matter how they identify, into women only spaces. A man's feeling should not override safety concern for women although in reality it always does.
Third spaces would seem like the obvious solution but have been rejected by trans -identified men because it is about validation, not safety.

zen1 · 10/11/2026 07:22

I innately don’t trust people who profess to be something they’re not. A man can take hormones, dress however he wants and undergo surgery to try and appear ‘female’, but this doesn’t make him a woman. If you did all these things and still acknowledged you’re a man and used men’s facilities, then I wouldn’t have a problem. No man will ever understand what it’s like to be born and grow up as a female.

Comeinsideforacupoftea · 10/11/2026 07:22

To clarify OP your phenotype in the case of sexual identification is the body build and genital organs that you were born with whether you feel that these are correct or not. These are determined by your genotype which is the genes you were born with. The clothes and make up you wear and even any cosmetic surgery that you have are not a phenotype they are an expression of your personality

Your blunder probably goes a long way to explaining why you feel that many people 'dislike' trans people. They don't dislike or fear trans people they dislike the distortion of reality that people who understand the above are meant to go along with.

Not all but many trans women don't present themselves as average everyday women. Drag queens are the prime example of this. They play very overexaggarated and actually quite insulting charicatures of women. If they observed the women they claim to so desperately want to be they'd know that virtually none of them prance about with their butt cheeks hanging out calling themselves names like 'Alotta Fagina' It's all a little bit mysogynistic but just good fun until the same drag queen starts sobbing about how they always struggled with gender identity and knew they were a female blah blah blah.... Nope sod off with that. It's the same with lots of influencers, Dillan Mullvany for example. If you want to dress as a woman, give yourself a woman's name, play a charicature of a woman then there's nothing wrong with this as such but your phenotype will always be male and you need to follow the societal rules that a male does. In addition to this btw I do even fully support trans people having toilets and changing spaces that they feel safe in but I just don't believe that this should be at the expense of biological women feeling safe.

Let me finish by asking why do you feel that somebody insisting that they are a woman, an oppressed and vulnerable section of society, should be indulged by society but if a white person dressed as and insisted that they're black we'd all be horrified?

WhyamIinahandcartandwherearewegoing · 10/11/2026 07:23

Could you define the boundaries and how trans people violate them?

my boundary - women are adult human females. Born female.

my boundary - not sharing my private spaces designated for females with people who are not female. And I mean female, not had some alteration to try and appear so (you can argue gonads and phenotypes all day long, but another of my boundaries is the right to not accept this). Medically altering yourself to mimic a phenotype you prefer does not mean you are phenotypically female btw.

you said I do try to be as mindful as I can and I go out of my way to not cause discomfort, distress, or alarm (i.e. showering in my swimsuit in swimming pools). - a male pretending to be female in this situation absolutely causes me discomfort, distress and alarm. The fact you try to mitigate this means you are aware of the potential harm you are doing but you choose to continue.

my boundary - not believing that males who want to be women are.

I don’t dislike trans people, call yourself what you want, wear what you think makes you a woman - but it doesn’t.

I agree with a PP in that “I don’t know how society got to a place where we believe that someone was born in the wrong body. I have no issue with anyone wishing they were the opposite sex. That is honest. What isn’t is claiming that they are somehow the same as the opposite sex.”

Sometimes in life you don’t get what you want - trans or not.

I don’t dislike “trans people” though I am pretty certain they, just as the rest of society, are not comprised of a homogenous group of decent people.

I won’t participate in this deception.

HylianShroom · 10/11/2026 07:24

I feel safer and more comfortable with FTM trans people than I do with MTF trans people, because FTM (transmen) were raised and socialised as girls and women. I don’t have an issue at all with trans women living their lives and being happy and I wish them peace on their journey but anyone who was raised and socialised as a boy and a man is going to make me feel wary. That’s just how I am wired biologically. I can’t switch it off or override it.

I would never go about attempting to clock anyone but if I did notice, say in a bathroom, I would be on my guard around a transwoman. I know that they are statistically more likely to be a victim of assault and I’m sorry for that but they were still raised as boys and they aren’t the same as someone who was raised as a girl. I think all women who were raised and socialised as girls feel an innate sense of wariness around people who were socialised as men, whether that person is now a transwoman or not.

JenRummy · 10/11/2026 07:25

I don’t dislike trans people OP. I just hate everyone equally. Just kidding but thanks for starting such an interesting debate.

Medical transitioning as we know does not alter a person's DNA or chromosomal structure (trans ‘females’ still have XY chromosomes). Even if a trans woman undergoes gender-affirming surgery they cannot develop female ovaries/produce eggs.

Phenotype - the observable characteristics, likes of body shape, breast development etc is different. HRTs and surgeries can alter these aspects.

Some people view trans people as therefore mimicking their preferred sex via phenotype to some extent.

As a trans person would imagine that is hurtful and frustrating, and don’t have a view personally, but overall that might explain why the resistance to shared spaces is so marked.

It could simply be that some bio women don’t want what they view as a bio male (however female looking and however lovely) in their space.

The Equality and Human Rights Commission’s current recommendation is having a 3rd or neutral space. What’s your view on that OP? Is part of wanting to use female spaces to feel accepted, included and validated?

Sorry too for any harassment you’ve suffered. That and cat calling not right.

I’d be interested too to know how you view missing out on key aspects of being female? Menstruation, menopause, child birth? Appreciate not every female experiences these but structurally unless there’s a problem we are designed to.

ProudCat · 10/11/2026 07:25

For me, it's not a dislike as such. I work closely and respectfully with several trans people ...

I was influenced a lot by second wave feminism. I remember as a teenager reading 'Our Bodies, Ourselves' and this situated my sense of empowerment as woman in my lived experience within a woman's body, also it reinforced an idea of collective struggle. Other writers such as Solanas (SCUM Manifesto), French (The Women's Room) and Muscio's ' A Declaration of Independence' provided a backbone to the radical feminism movement of the 60s, 70s, 80s and 90s. As reference points, they don't leave a lot of space for a reinterpretation of womanhood. They couldn't. At the time we were really up against it.

So what we're being asked to do is abandon these ideas, a bit like a communist being asked to abandon The Communist Manifesto. That's a big ask because cases like Epstein, Everard and more recently Brand (apologies for privileging the male there) show we're (women) still under attack. Under these circumstances, it's really hard to consider that others also need defending when they're saying very little to support us. Remember, both first and second wave feminism are based on the idea of collective action, whether that's the suffragettes or setting up orgs like Rape Crisis and / or Women's Aid. Without the collective action, and instead a focus on things like service use, it can feel kind of off.

There's also the issue of validation. My purely anecdotal, and yet apparently fairly common experience, suggests those who were AMAB are often looking for approval. There's often a lot of announcements and display, electrolysis, short skirts, breast buds with no bra, hours on make up, hair and nails, eyelash fluttering, etc. When your feminism is embodied, and a mediation or straightforward rejection of 'come hither', this can feel challenging. If, to paraphrase De Beauvoir, a woman is not born but is made, it's problematic that so many AMAB are choosing to remake woman in the projected image of man.

SparklingGlitteryWine · 10/11/2026 07:26

I don't care what people choose to identify as but I take umbrage to a lot of behaviour, mlsrly form angry men who don't like being told no my women and try to silence them.

I don't like how you aren't allowed to use the term "Hello Ladies" on the Verity PMOS (PCOS) Website anymore as it's upsets Trans People (and yes there have been posts asking for the term not to be used)

I find it an insult when Trans People say they have period pains especially when they "celebrate" They have no fucking idea of the misery of periods, endometriosis, PCOS to name a few and it's not a game of dress up.

I don't like the treatment of JK Rowling.

I don't like how the word "Bigot" is now thrown around so cheaply

My Daughter is a Girl Guide and she and her friends have been made to feel in the wrong because they want to keep it a Girls space and don't Boys dressed as Girls with them.

I don't want to be called CIS and am sick of hearing it's always been used, I am 44 years old and will not be told by people who weren't even alive in the 90s that it was regular used back then, it wasn't.

I don't like being told by Men that a Woman is a social construct, pregnant person or chest feeder or someone that bleeds.

Otherwise do what you want and don't bother me with it.

CatCobain · 10/11/2026 07:27

Sorry if this is over simplistic but I think basically women don't trust men or any one who has ever been a man (as it were) for, I think, very obvious reasons. So the problem here as usual is actually men. They're the ones you aught to blame for women being suspicious of trans people. Not women.

havitualcrime · 10/11/2026 07:28

Would also like to say I don’t NOT like trans people, but having spent some time on Reddit I have to say there are quite a lot of very unlikeable trans people bullying women, not managing their parenting issues and mental health and instead snatching hard earned women’s rights for their own. I started in quite a neutral position a few years ago but trans activists are loud, entitled, and extremely selfish. I have found it harder to find any empathy as time goes on.

BlueLegume · 10/11/2026 07:29

@Transperson so having read the thread and seen the majority of posters clearly state ‘I don’t dislike trans people’ and then followed up with very clear sensible reasons based on safeguarding/fear of violence/personal boundaries etc. Are you able to see that most of our concerns are based around trust/truth and not data?

I have seen this played out by TRAs and allies over the past decade. Firstly truth matters. Why should I have to lie in the workplace for example when a person presents as someone they are not? Having worked with several male to female people they were all ‘main character syndrome’. From their ‘announcement’ usually via a breezy email telling us and I quote(ish) ‘just remember I am still me but just prettier’….yes that happened. So they crossed boundary after boundary but it was me and my colleagues who had to comply with the lie. Can you not see how uncomfortable that is?

vdbfamily · 10/11/2026 07:29

Transperson · 10/11/2026 04:24

Scientifically it is not established that trans people are more likely to be perpetrators of crime.
www.woodhullfoundation.org/fact-checked/transgender-people-are-not-a-threat-to-public-safety/

No one is claiming that Tranwomen are MORE likely to commit crimes, but the evidence is that they are no LESS likely to do so than other males. The reason they experience violence at the level they do is because men can be violent, are more likely to cause physical harm through their violence and often Transwomen are looking for relationships with men. All of the above reasons is why women were given spaces that were penis free,to protect us from possible harm in situations where we are vulnerable/ in a state of undress etc. Also , because we are generally physically weaker, we had to have item category of sports,to give us a chance to excel and not be harmed in physical type sports.
These things have been hard fight for and only recently achieved and were slowly being removed again, which is why women are fighting to keep these rights and not have them systematically removed by biological males. The reason you find that hard to understand is because you are a biological male who has grown up not experiencing the microagressions that women face on a daily basis from the youngest of ages.

Margaritaaahhh · 10/11/2026 07:29

I have no issues with trans people.

I have a huge issue with men being in women's spaces. Also the medicalisation of children and invasive, irreversible surgeries presented as 'care'. And the death and rape threats dished out by trans identifying males towards women who dare to speak up. And lesbians being told that unless they welcome men into their dating pool, they are bigoted genital fetishists. And men telling rape and DV survivors that unless we allow them into our rape crisis services and refuges, we are fascists. And women unwilling to undress in front of men being branded Nazis.

I have a huge issue with trans people who support or engage in any of the above.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.