Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Trans people who regret decision shut out of debate on Conversion Practices Bill

39 replies

IwantToRetire · 08/11/2026 21:29

People who regret changing gender say they have been shut out of the debate on a proposed transgender law.

Several people who have lived as another gender but later changed their minds offered to give evidence to MPs and peers investigating Labour’s draft Conversion Practices Bill but were not invited to speak.

The Telegraph has launched a campaign to scrap the bill. The legislation threatens people five years in prison for trying to change another person’s sexual orientation or gender identity.

On Thursday, The Telegraph revealed that Stonewall, the controversial pro-trans charity, had been invited to No 10 to discuss the law and make recommendations to the MPs behind the draft legislation.

Michael Kerr, however, said his request to give evidence about the damaging effects of his transition had been ignored, leaving him “pushed aside and completely disregarded” by MPs. The 34-year-old reverted to his birth gender last year having lived as a woman since the age of 27.

Full article https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/11/08/trans-people-who-regret-decision-shut-out-debate-bill/

And at https://archive.is/1vPhv

OP posts:
Kirschcherries · 08/11/2026 21:51

De-transitioners are a really vulnerable group and have a lot of value to add to this debate. They deserve to have their voices heard.

Ariana12 · 08/11/2026 22:04

It's weird that detransitioners are so invisible to the powers that be. I believe there are organisations that will support them to be heard, especially the charity Sex Matters. So if you know anyone in that situation, maybe they could be pointed in that direction.

ScrollingLeaves · 08/11/2026 22:07

IwantToRetire · 08/11/2026 21:29

People who regret changing gender say they have been shut out of the debate on a proposed transgender law.

Several people who have lived as another gender but later changed their minds offered to give evidence to MPs and peers investigating Labour’s draft Conversion Practices Bill but were not invited to speak.

The Telegraph has launched a campaign to scrap the bill. The legislation threatens people five years in prison for trying to change another person’s sexual orientation or gender identity.

On Thursday, The Telegraph revealed that Stonewall, the controversial pro-trans charity, had been invited to No 10 to discuss the law and make recommendations to the MPs behind the draft legislation.

Michael Kerr, however, said his request to give evidence about the damaging effects of his transition had been ignored, leaving him “pushed aside and completely disregarded” by MPs. The 34-year-old reverted to his birth gender last year having lived as a woman since the age of 27.

Full article https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/11/08/trans-people-who-regret-decision-shut-out-debate-bill/

And at https://archive.is/1vPhv

Enraging. Stonewall shoukd be no where near it.

Of course a detransitioner needs to be heard. After all he may have transitioned through a form of conversion therapy.

ScrollingLeaves · 08/11/2026 22:21

IwantToRetire · 08/11/2026 21:29

People who regret changing gender say they have been shut out of the debate on a proposed transgender law.

Several people who have lived as another gender but later changed their minds offered to give evidence to MPs and peers investigating Labour’s draft Conversion Practices Bill but were not invited to speak.

The Telegraph has launched a campaign to scrap the bill. The legislation threatens people five years in prison for trying to change another person’s sexual orientation or gender identity.

On Thursday, The Telegraph revealed that Stonewall, the controversial pro-trans charity, had been invited to No 10 to discuss the law and make recommendations to the MPs behind the draft legislation.

Michael Kerr, however, said his request to give evidence about the damaging effects of his transition had been ignored, leaving him “pushed aside and completely disregarded” by MPs. The 34-year-old reverted to his birth gender last year having lived as a woman since the age of 27.

Full article https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/11/08/trans-people-who-regret-decision-shut-out-debate-bill/

And at https://archive.is/1vPhv

A committee member said,

”The committee has been set a very tight deadline” How very unwise. It might well end up being another entirely ill thought-out bill like the GRA.

“LGBT+ people should never, without exception, have to suffer coercion or abuse in an effort to change who they are.”

The very description of a gender questioning child/ person as an “lgbt+” person is assuming they just are that way. That is “Who they are.”
There is no exploration. It is affirmation without question. That is pure transactivist speech.

Define please. What is an lgbt+ person. There is no such thing.

Tears0fTheMushroom · 08/11/2026 22:31

At this point the ignorance in government is starting to look wilful

SwimWithDragonfly · 09/11/2026 07:16

ScrollingLeaves · 08/11/2026 22:07

Enraging. Stonewall shoukd be no where near it.

Of course a detransitioner needs to be heard. After all he may have transitioned through a form of conversion therapy.

Completely agree. Detransitioners are essential to this, surely. This is a huge gap and mistake.

How come stonewall are still so listened to in relation to trans issues beats me.

IwantToRetire · 09/11/2026 22:05

SwimWithDragonfly · 09/11/2026 07:16

Completely agree. Detransitioners are essential to this, surely. This is a huge gap and mistake.

How come stonewall are still so listened to in relation to trans issues beats me.

Exactly. And I am glad the Telegraph pointed out that they had been given access to those in Government.

But it is still the case that apart from the Telegraph and the DM, most news outlets never, ever talk about their hold over politicians.

OP posts:
BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · 09/11/2026 23:07

SwimWithDragonfly · 09/11/2026 07:16

Completely agree. Detransitioners are essential to this, surely. This is a huge gap and mistake.

How come stonewall are still so listened to in relation to trans issues beats me.

How come stonewall are still so listened to in relation to trans issues beats me.

I suspect some of those in Stonewall know where the bodies are buried, and some of those in Government would rather no one else found out...

JustTiredOfAllOfThis · 10/11/2026 09:47

The committee brought in Jayne Ozanne who stated the nature of conversion practices makes them difficult for victims to recognise at the time. But they won’t let a Detransioner state how they didn’t realise Transitioning was a type of Conversion practices. It’s absolutely crazy and a sign that this committee is only interested in hearing voices that support their agenda. They don’t want to hear anything negative about Trans. If they don’t hear evidence about Transing away the gay they can pretend it doesn’t exist.

ScrollingLeaves · 11/11/2026 15:38

As well as transing away the gay,
there is:
transing away the isolating effects of autism
transing away trauma and sexual assault
transing away the feeling of abandonment of children in care
transing away the wrong sex child

HearMeSnore · 11/11/2026 15:48

The existence of detransitioners is proof that people can be wrong about their gender identity. And if they can be wrong, then safeguards should be in place to prevent them making catastrophic decisions that could leave them permanently damaged. One of those safeguards is the freedom of their friends, family, teachers, counsellors etc to question their identity.

That is the inconvenient truth that the architects of this bill don’t want to face. So they will do their best to ignore detransitioners. They must not be allowed to do so.

ChequerToRed · 11/11/2026 15:59

It’s the equivalent of sticking their fingers in their ears and going ‘LaalalaLAAAAAA!!!I can’t hear you!’. Not the way a government should behave, but par for the course.
I’m actually at the point of hoping that this does go through resembling its current, terrible form, as the fallout and opportunities for unintended consequences are massive. Trouble is when the inevitable car-crash happens those who acted so irresponsibly will fall back on ‘Oh no, we didn’t intend for this to happen, nobody warned us.’ like the mendacious shitbags they are.

Seriestwo · 11/11/2026 16:09

This is really frightening. This bill is propangander.

Mouldemort · 11/11/2026 16:13

The vast majority of people affected negatively by conversion practices are gay and transgender people. Therapy doesn't make you gay or transgender.

Conversion practitioners, especially those who have have the protected but unscientific belief that being transgender or gay is "an ideology" are absolute poison to LGBTQ+ people, and its those people this legislation needs to stop.

The tiny handful of detransitioners are already disproportionately represented thanks to the gender critical dominance of media and politics.

Shortshriftandlethal · 11/11/2026 16:27

Mouldemort · 11/11/2026 16:13

The vast majority of people affected negatively by conversion practices are gay and transgender people. Therapy doesn't make you gay or transgender.

Conversion practitioners, especially those who have have the protected but unscientific belief that being transgender or gay is "an ideology" are absolute poison to LGBTQ+ people, and its those people this legislation needs to stop.

The tiny handful of detransitioners are already disproportionately represented thanks to the gender critical dominance of media and politics.

If gay people are people who are same sex attracted, then what are 'trans' people? They are people who.......? ( could you fill in the blank?)

AstonCanKissMyArse · 11/11/2026 16:45

There is no evidence that conversation practices are taking place.

All the examples given by the government are already illegal.

Most therapists are afraid to go anywhere near the issue of being trans, lest they lose their accreditation. Detransistioners often talk about how it was impassible to discuss their doubts with anyone.

Detransistioners are absolutely part of the picture. Why wouldn't you want to look at the whole picture? Im glad the Telegraph are in the case.

AzureStaffy · 11/11/2026 16:49

Kirschcherries · 08/11/2026 21:51

De-transitioners are a really vulnerable group and have a lot of value to add to this debate. They deserve to have their voices heard.

Agreed, they are crucial. Also, those detransitioners who speak out publicly are hugely courageous.

Wishesandhorses · 11/11/2026 17:17

Its appalling that detransitioners haven't been included in this.

I would be extremely interested in funding sources during the Labour party's time in opposition, and particularly when funding their election campaign. I could be very cynical and wonder if a deal was done that funding was conditional on jamming this through, and also if the govt (especially now Scots govt have leapt into action) are seeing this as a way to undo the Equality Act and SCJ.

They know the issues. They are wilfully ignoring them. There will be an unholy mess - and actually the people who will suffer are those being weaponised by those busy ranting on about needing this law. But my MP does do exactly the fingers in ears shouting lalalalala if I ever contact explaining the issues with something. All I get back is ignoring of the issues and the evidence and a lot of shouting about Labour is wonderful and never wrong about anything, rahhh Labour. I don't honestly think they have read or understood much, most thinking is downloaded bites from others. They certainly knew fuck all about the SCJ (but had lots of opinions on it.)

I despair at the calibre of people who get into positions of power.

alcovecupboards · 11/11/2026 17:22

Are these the same 1,000 de-transitioners who have been apparently preparing to sue the Tavistock for years? And yet have done so so cunningly that they have managed to avoid being known at all?

Wishesandhorses · 11/11/2026 17:26

Well no, I suspect it's as the article actually says and is quoted in the OP, the several detransitioners who approached the MPs and peers, one of whom is named?

But in your hurry to slur people who you always talk so passionately about supporting, perhaps you missed that? Are they they wrong kind of trans?

ChequerToRed · 11/11/2026 17:28

Mouldemort · 11/11/2026 16:13

The vast majority of people affected negatively by conversion practices are gay and transgender people. Therapy doesn't make you gay or transgender.

Conversion practitioners, especially those who have have the protected but unscientific belief that being transgender or gay is "an ideology" are absolute poison to LGBTQ+ people, and its those people this legislation needs to stop.

The tiny handful of detransitioners are already disproportionately represented thanks to the gender critical dominance of media and politics.

Caveat emptor.
I hope you appreciate that as the draft bill stands T people who try and pressure L and G people into opposite sex relationships just because they identify as gay/lesbian could find themselves on the pointy end of it. Also married men who transition and tell their wives, who entered into a heterosexual relationship, that they’re now in a ‘lesbian’ relationship.
As the draft bill stands, there’s nothing stopping any of those situations being considered attempted conversion on the grounds of sexuality.

Wishesandhorses · 11/11/2026 17:31

Not to mention T lobby groups going into schools and preaching one sided propaganda to children.

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 11/11/2026 18:15

Yes, because it's a Bill closing a loophole in child abuse law.

Talking about being trans is not being criminalised. I shall not be in front of the magistrate next time I accidentally misgender my son when screaming "get towels!!" as the washing machine floods, neither will anyone who disagrees with their child.

Those who terrorise their children and cause them significant harm under the guise of belief, or subject them to the serious abuse which is 'conversion therapy,' will.

alcovecupboards · 11/11/2026 18:47

Wishesandhorses · 11/11/2026 17:26

Well no, I suspect it's as the article actually says and is quoted in the OP, the several detransitioners who approached the MPs and peers, one of whom is named?

But in your hurry to slur people who you always talk so passionately about supporting, perhaps you missed that? Are they they wrong kind of trans?

What slur?

Mouldemort · 11/11/2026 19:01

ChequerToRed · 11/11/2026 17:28

Caveat emptor.
I hope you appreciate that as the draft bill stands T people who try and pressure L and G people into opposite sex relationships just because they identify as gay/lesbian could find themselves on the pointy end of it. Also married men who transition and tell their wives, who entered into a heterosexual relationship, that they’re now in a ‘lesbian’ relationship.
As the draft bill stands, there’s nothing stopping any of those situations being considered attempted conversion on the grounds of sexuality.

This has literally nothing to do with therapists providing services to LGBTQ people.

Swipe left for the next trending thread