Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Trans people who regret decision shut out of debate on Conversion Practices Bill

39 replies

IwantToRetire · 08/11/2026 21:29

People who regret changing gender say they have been shut out of the debate on a proposed transgender law.

Several people who have lived as another gender but later changed their minds offered to give evidence to MPs and peers investigating Labour’s draft Conversion Practices Bill but were not invited to speak.

The Telegraph has launched a campaign to scrap the bill. The legislation threatens people five years in prison for trying to change another person’s sexual orientation or gender identity.

On Thursday, The Telegraph revealed that Stonewall, the controversial pro-trans charity, had been invited to No 10 to discuss the law and make recommendations to the MPs behind the draft legislation.

Michael Kerr, however, said his request to give evidence about the damaging effects of his transition had been ignored, leaving him “pushed aside and completely disregarded” by MPs. The 34-year-old reverted to his birth gender last year having lived as a woman since the age of 27.

Full article https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/11/08/trans-people-who-regret-decision-shut-out-debate-bill/

And at https://archive.is/1vPhv

OP posts:
JustTiredOfAllOfThis · 11/11/2026 19:14

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 11/11/2026 18:15

Yes, because it's a Bill closing a loophole in child abuse law.

Talking about being trans is not being criminalised. I shall not be in front of the magistrate next time I accidentally misgender my son when screaming "get towels!!" as the washing machine floods, neither will anyone who disagrees with their child.

Those who terrorise their children and cause them significant harm under the guise of belief, or subject them to the serious abuse which is 'conversion therapy,' will.

There are already laws preventing child abuse!
This law has been deliberately brought about to criminalise anyone who questions the ideology of the trans identifying child. A casual correctly describing the sex of your own child wouldn’t warrant the police but if you sat down and explained to your child that they can never change sex; that would put you in the crime of conversion practices.

Kirschcherries · 11/11/2026 19:17

Mouldemort · 11/11/2026 19:01

This has literally nothing to do with therapists providing services to LGBTQ people.

So no couples therapist has ever said to the wife of a transwoman you are now in a same sex relationship as TWAW?

Mouldemort · 11/11/2026 19:42

Kirschcherries · 11/11/2026 19:17

So no couples therapist has ever said to the wife of a transwoman you are now in a same sex relationship as TWAW?

That is one hell of a stretch. This desperate shoehorning of edge cases and unrelated issues is exactly what happens every time progress is attempted on LGBT+ rights. We got the same nonsense with marriage equality and equalising the age of consent.

ScrollingLeaves · 11/11/2026 21:05

Mouldemort · 11/11/2026 19:42

That is one hell of a stretch. This desperate shoehorning of edge cases and unrelated issues is exactly what happens every time progress is attempted on LGBT+ rights. We got the same nonsense with marriage equality and equalising the age of consent.

Thank you OP for highlighting that the committee is refusing to hear evidence from a detransitioner. It suggests a serous bias.

Kirschcherries · 11/11/2026 21:17

Mouldemort · 11/11/2026 19:42

That is one hell of a stretch. This desperate shoehorning of edge cases and unrelated issues is exactly what happens every time progress is attempted on LGBT+ rights. We got the same nonsense with marriage equality and equalising the age of consent.

The whole point of legislation is it applies to everyone equally, including niche cases like married couples where one partner transitions.

You were claiming This has literally nothing to do with therapists providing services to LGBTQ people. in response to a poster pointing out T people trying to pressure L & G people into opposite sex relationships.

I’ve just given you a valid situation where spouses of Transpeople maybe in couples therapy and subjected to conversion therapy that they are now in a same sex relationship. Yes the numbers will be small but why do they not deserve to be protected?

Wishesandhorses · 11/11/2026 21:20

ScrollingLeaves · 11/11/2026 21:05

Thank you OP for highlighting that the committee is refusing to hear evidence from a detransitioner. It suggests a serous bias.

It does. As seen on this thread, detransitioners are not liked by activists, who will rush to suggest they don't exist and try to erase them. It's never explained why someone who was so very precious during their transition becomes instantly rejected if they desist. It suggests that the person was never valuable at all, nor their inner selves, choices or feelings - only when those feelings and selves served an agenda. And that they present a threat to genderism.

As the man quoted in the article and the OP states, the effects can be damaging. Fixing it in law that no professional can talk about whether or not genderism is the right thing for them, and not being able to have a professional question or challenge thinking IS damaging. Keira Bell has said many times she felt betrayed by professionals and people around her who encouraged her down that path towards permanently damaging her body and future. The consequences of transition are so serious that it has to be taken into account that it isn't the right answer for everyone.

Kirschcherries · 11/11/2026 21:51

@Wishesandhorses I often think of Keira Bell and the fact she is in legal limbo having a GRC stating she is male with no legal way to reverse it.

A glaring issue with the GRA was no thought someone might want to rescind a GRC. So there is no process to achieve this.

Given only c8-10k people have a GRC the number of de-transitioned people with a GRC is very small. So small @Mouldemort would probably consider them edge cases too, rather than an incredibly vulnerable group with less legal rights than transpeople, rejected by the trans community, and with no right to a voice in this process.

Wishesandhorses · 11/11/2026 22:15

It is absolutely mad that there is a way to legally move to the opposite sex but no way to then move back should the person's situation or wishes change again. That should have been sorted a very long time ago.

ScrollingLeaves · 11/11/2026 22:20

Kirschcherries · 11/11/2026 21:51

@Wishesandhorses I often think of Keira Bell and the fact she is in legal limbo having a GRC stating she is male with no legal way to reverse it.

A glaring issue with the GRA was no thought someone might want to rescind a GRC. So there is no process to achieve this.

Given only c8-10k people have a GRC the number of de-transitioned people with a GRC is very small. So small @Mouldemort would probably consider them edge cases too, rather than an incredibly vulnerable group with less legal rights than transpeople, rejected by the trans community, and with no right to a voice in this process.

The GRA was full of idiocy.

IwantToRetire · 11/11/2026 22:25

ScrollingLeaves · 11/11/2026 22:20

The GRA was full of idiocy.

The GRA was totally indoctrinated in the false narrative that changing sex was the ultimate solution for the most oppressed group in the world, who would of course never, ever, what to give up this treasured goal.

To give it up, or to allow for it to be given up, would allow the heresy to become legal that the supposed changing of one's sex isn't actually the solution to whatever problems someone is experiencing.

OP posts:
NowSober · 12/11/2026 07:07

alcovecupboards · 11/11/2026 18:47

What slur?

Evidently you cannot distinguish between a verb & a noun.

Mouldemort · 12/11/2026 10:49

No one has a problem with detransitioners - they have a problem with the even smaller subset who have been radicalised and used as pick-mes by the gender critical movement who are then disproportionately platformed in the media.

The argument that we should allow conversion therapy because of a subset of a subset for whom there is no evidence they have been “converted” is simply a gender critical ploy by people who don’t even believe LGBT+ identities are valid.

https://www.thepinknews.com/2022/11/11/ky-schevers-detransition/

'Former detransitioner' rebuilding her life after falling for 'cult-like' TERFs

Ky Schevers detransitioned after being "sucked in" by "gender-critical feminism". Now, she's rebuilding her life.

https://www.thepinknews.com/2022/11/11/ky-schevers-detransition/

Kirschcherries · 12/11/2026 11:46

@Mouldemort Firstly I am certainly not arguing to allow conversion therapy and we already have laws to prevent that.

My concern is, as Baroness Cass said, that affirmation is not a neutral act. This draft legislation is going too far.

I would also separate out LGB which are sexual orientations and a separate protected characteristic. Most gender critical people supported LGB people to gain equal legal rights and do not believe you can change someone’s sexual orientation. A persons sexual orientation is only relevant to their partner or future partners it does not affect anyone else’s rights.

T is for gender reassignment, a separate PC and the consequences for individuals can be lifelong in terms of their physical and mental health. Transition can involve medication and surgery and the ability to make sure someone fully understands the risks and potential outcomes before making a decision is not and should not be considered conversion therapy.

A good example is Freddie McConnell who was 27 when they voluntarily had a double mastectomy. Freddie subsequently went on to become pregnant and have two children. Freddie was devastated to realise they could not breastfeed their children due to the mastectomy. Freddie clearly did not understand the full consequences of the double mastectomy. Under this proposed legislation a parent or friend pointing out to a 16 year old they would not be able to breastfeed in the future could be viewed as conversion therapy.

ScrollingLeaves · 12/11/2026 14:03

Mouldemort · 12/11/2026 10:49

No one has a problem with detransitioners - they have a problem with the even smaller subset who have been radicalised and used as pick-mes by the gender critical movement who are then disproportionately platformed in the media.

The argument that we should allow conversion therapy because of a subset of a subset for whom there is no evidence they have been “converted” is simply a gender critical ploy by people who don’t even believe LGBT+ identities are valid.

https://www.thepinknews.com/2022/11/11/ky-schevers-detransition/

That is in my mind an odd response because you are saying people who regret their transition are radicalised rather than people who now realise their earlier decision with enormous physical consequences was a mistake.

Please define ‘conversion therapy’ as applied to trans people with exact incidences and descriptions to show as examples.

Please let me know if you can envisage how on-line ‘egg-crackers’ and trans activists, and librarians with ‘born in the wrong body’ children’s books might influence an unhappy teen into believing they are ‘trans’, eg converting them?

New posts on this thread. Refresh page