Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Why no N/A option for gender identity on NHS forms? (Title amended by MNHQ at the request of the OP)

39 replies

CassOle · 08/11/2026 10:46

Trying to help my elderly father with a call, and of course, he states his sex as male. He is then asked about his gender identity. The issue I have is that when he stated that he didn't have one, but that his sex is male, that didn't help the call handler answer the gender question because N/A wasn't an option they could select.

I think that N/A should be an option. Not everyone believes in, or has, a gender identity. If the NHS is going to have a question about gender identity, there should be options for the whole range of answers, and it should not assume that everyone 'subscribes to that religion' (for want of a better way to phrase it).

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SerendipityJane · 10/11/2026 11:41

So what happens for the majority who don't have a GI?
Either they lie, the call handler lies for them or they get refused a possibly life saving service?

How else can you propagate RightThink ?

E2A: Remember: by removing choice, your are actually empowering people.

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · 10/11/2026 10:12

PriOn1 · 08/11/2026 16:08

I would be extremely frustrated if forced to give a false answer to a question and wasn’t able to get advice unless I did.

There is no way anyone should be offended by the option to say you don’t have a gender identity. Therefore it is less offensive to add that option in than it is to leave it out.

I hope any of us caught up with this nonsense feel able to complain once the immediate effect of the medical problem is resolved. It’s the only way we will ever root this nonsense out.

Great minds think alike! I just posted on one of the Conversion Bill threads that it would be interesting to see how the NHS would respond if I complained that forcing me to declare a gender identity was an attempt to "convert" me, and if I threatened legal action if I was refused treatment because the NHS would not provide alternatives to me never getting past the paperwork stage.

Interesting times ahead for my NHS trust if the Bill does go through! I am... persistent, shall we say, and willing to legally enforce my right not to be converted.

😁

MagpiePi · 09/11/2026 13:05

Still waiting to hear the context in which TPA’s toddler got asked if he smoked.

Did he also get asked how much alcohol he drank or whether he could be pregnant or if he was breastfeeding?

All entirely normal questions that get asked of children in a presumably medical situation, although I don’t remember either of my children being asked those questions. Come to think of it, a professional person would probably ask the parent about the child’s medical history.

Of all the things that didn’t happen to TPA’s children, this must be one of the ones that didn’t happen the mostest. 🙄

YourWatermelonship · 09/11/2026 10:47

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 08/11/2026 15:30

Same reason my toddler got asked how much he smoked, it's a just general form.

Everyone gets asked the same questions. I have zero chance of being pregnant but am not offended to be asked. I've never smoked or taken drugs either.

It's not the same thing - you are given the option to say you don't smoke or have never smoked

The equivalent would be if those options weren't available and you had to lie and give a made up figure about how often you do drugs because the system doesn't allow a zero / no / never answer.

Throughahedgebackwards · 09/11/2026 10:45

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 08/11/2026 15:30

Same reason my toddler got asked how much he smoked, it's a just general form.

Everyone gets asked the same questions. I have zero chance of being pregnant but am not offended to be asked. I've never smoked or taken drugs either.

Presumably your toddler had the option of saying they didn't smoke.
The point of the OP's post is that their father had no option to say they didn't have a gender identity.

CassOle · 09/11/2026 10:39

For the non-UK posters - the 111 line is not the emergency line. The emergency line is 999. I have had to call 999 this year, and interestingly, the gender identity question was not asked when it was an actual emergency.

OP posts:
Cantquitebelievewhatitscometo · 09/11/2026 10:37

I tick other, which usually brings up a free format box and then put something like, you are operating a medical setting, gender is irrelevant.

theilltemperedmonster · 09/11/2026 10:32

Of what relevance is gender identity to diagnosis and treatment? What's needed is birth sex, whether any DSDs (if so what?), and whether transgender (if so please describe treatment history and how you would like to be addressed etc).

Gender identity as a field isn't even serving a purpose for trans people, many of whom, according to a trans friend, will lie when answering the sex question. If that's true, having the gender identity question as well will not reveal the lie.

(I don't know if it is true BTW, but I do know that trans friend not only believes it to be true, but also thinks the lying is justified.)

So, the OP is impossible to answer because the rot starts much further back than the absence of a N/A option.

I guess that the operators default to GI = same as sex if callers seem confused, and that would be a safe approach in most cases. If there are people who are willing to risk their health by lying because of their minority quasi-religious beliefs, that's their lookout.

akkakk · 09/11/2026 10:14

alcovecupboards · 08/11/2026 19:40

Imagine putting your father's health at risk in order to make a point about trans people existing.

do they?

show the evidence that any one person has ever transitioned from biological male to biological female (or v.v.). Never happened...

so what we have is people who have mental-health concern / difficulties / struggles / issues at different levels (along with a few people whose motives re perhaps a bit more dodgy...) - totally different, and nothing to do with being the opposite sex - therefore sex is the only question needing to be answered at a medical level...

so the whole question is flawed and not required - it is purely added because of activist work to try and establish 'evidence' and provide 'validation' for those mental health issues...

her father's health would be better dealt with by not including made up fantasy questions...

if there is a need to know additional information, such that the individual has chosen surgery / hormones due to where they are at, that can be provided by simply asking at the end - anything else it would be helpful to know...

NannyOggsFavouriteJug · 09/11/2026 10:04

If they wanted to be inclusive to everyone they would include those who don’t believe in gender identities

MagpiePi · 09/11/2026 10:01

GrannyAchingsShepherdsHut · 09/11/2026 09:51

This drives me mad. My employer does it too on staff surveys.

It's exactly the same as a mandatory question saying 'what's your religion, A. catholic or B. protestant?' which would rightly be absolutely unacceptable.

We have this too and it is mandatory so you have to answer implying you do have a GI, or tick ‘prefer not to say’ which is not the same as N/A, otherwise you can’t move on to the rest of the survey.

I complain every year and get told some bullshit about ‘groups’ were consulted on the wording and ‘we want to be inclusive to everyone.’

NannyOggsFavouriteJug · 09/11/2026 09:58

I agree there should be a not applicable or none option for any question about a person’s gender identity, and I wonder how not making this option available complies with the accuracy part of GDPR.

MagpiePi · 09/11/2026 09:54

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 08/11/2026 15:30

Same reason my toddler got asked how much he smoked, it's a just general form.

Everyone gets asked the same questions. I have zero chance of being pregnant but am not offended to be asked. I've never smoked or taken drugs either.

In what context?

GrannyAchingsShepherdsHut · 09/11/2026 09:51

This drives me mad. My employer does it too on staff surveys.

It's exactly the same as a mandatory question saying 'what's your religion, A. catholic or B. protestant?' which would rightly be absolutely unacceptable.

Rightsraptor · 09/11/2026 09:43

I read an article from the US by someone whose elderly father sought health care for whatever condition but didn't get it because the doctor corrected him/policed his speech, so the doctor said 'partner' every time the man said 'wife' etc.

I hope that doctor was pleased with himself.

CassOle · 09/11/2026 08:46

I also want to add, what a spectacular example of a bad-faith post we have on this thread.

OP posts:
CassOle · 09/11/2026 08:43

alcovecupboards · 08/11/2026 19:40

Imagine putting your father's health at risk in order to make a point about trans people existing.

And where - apart from in your imagination - did what you insinuate happen?

Once again, the TRAs are not actually engaging with the point of my post, which is that there should be an N/A option for that question.

OP posts:
NotBadConsidering · 09/11/2026 06:14

alcovecupboards · 08/11/2026 19:40

Imagine putting your father's health at risk in order to make a point about trans people existing.

Well isn’t that silly. Are you actually saying that if someone doesn’t comply they are risking their health? Because that just acknowledges that trans ideology holds non-believers to ransom to the point where they must comply to receive healthcare.

“Let’s make non-believers comply with our belief system through emotional blackmail, lest they put their health at risk, that will soon win them round.”

TRAs: winning the day, every day.

Rightsraptor · 09/11/2026 05:26

Oh ffs, TPA! There's no equivalence between being asked about drugs/alcohol and gender identity. The first are tangible and have clearly evidenced effects while the latter is a belief system.

You do make yourself look foolish.

Rightsraptor · 09/11/2026 05:20

This is where the Conversion Practices Act (as it will be if passed) comes in handy.

It will be a criminal offence to try to persuade someone that they have a gender identity if they say they don't. Because this law will work both ways - telling someone they do have a GI or a specific one OR that they don't have one at all.

Of course, getting the police to act against an NHS Trust might be no easy thing but the results could be a delight.

Fun times ahead!

MrsOvertonsWindow · 08/11/2026 19:47

alcovecupboards · 08/11/2026 19:40

Imagine putting your father's health at risk in order to make a point about trans people existing.

Surely you're not suggesting you believe in trampling over the rights and beliefs of others?

The OP's father stated he doesn't have a gender identity. He's entitled to his belief. I'm sure you don't think that older people aren't entitled to rights and self determination as that would be awful ageism?

alcovecupboards · 08/11/2026 19:40

Imagine putting your father's health at risk in order to make a point about trans people existing.

Kirschcherries · 08/11/2026 19:38

@CassOle I agree 100% “I don’t have a gender identity” should be an option. If it helps I go for “other” and then there is usually a free form box to add I don’t have a gender identity.

rocer · 08/11/2026 18:55

MrsOvertonsWindow · 08/11/2026 13:20

So what happens for the majority who don't have a GI?
Either they lie, the call handler lies for them or they get refused a possibly life saving service?

That's how this crap has been embedded into society - by compelling others to buy into it and then using the fake stats that result to make draw various inaccurate conclusions.

There's so much in the NHS that is anti social and unfit for purpose and this is just one example.

I'm not sure it's right to say 'the majority' don't have a gender identity.

Actually, no-one has a gender identity; there's no such thing.

Likewise, no-one has a guardian angel or an immortal soul. It's true some people think they do ... but they're wrong.

Of course we shouldn't discriminate against those who believe in such things. (Our pity should mostly be left hidden, for kindness' sake.) But by the same token, such foolish believers should not be allowed to call shots against the rest of us sensible people.

-- No place on an NHS form for 'What is your guardian angel called?'. Likewise no place for 'What is your gender identity?'

CassOle · 08/11/2026 17:17

It's not the same as asking if someone has smoked (however old they are). It is more similar to asking what religion someone follows and having no option for 'none'.

ETA - please also note that I was posting about adding a 'N/A' option when answering a question. TPA's post essentially stated that I shouldn't object to the question being asked. So, completely missing the point of my post.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread