I think that this is a significant part of the lack of clarity and the overall impression of obfuscation that comes from this paper. I wonder if there was a section removed after the amnesty report came out and it is why the paper seems to be so disconnected and the ‘next steps’ / conclusion so weak.
“ Background to the research
This report presents findings from the research project ‘Gendering Europe: British national identity
from EEC accession to EU secession’, funded by a Leverhulme Trust Research Fellowship. It set out to explore how ideas about gender and sexuality shaped representations of national identity
within the mainstream and pink press coverage of the European Union (EU), and the UK’s membership of it.
As the UK was facing the aftermath of the vote to leave the EU, what seemed like steady progress for trans rights was slipping back. Gender critical groups and their allies mobilised around the public consultation on gender recognition that Theresa May opened in 2018. They organised concerted responses opposing a move to a self- declaration system. In some cases, they pushed for an outright rollback of trans rights. The research explored whether this opposition to trans rights might have been part of the motivation for leaving the EU all along.“
This is the main thrust of the background. It specifically has stated that ‘gender critical groups’ are the issue. Without defining or describing what and who those groups are in this relevant section. Or who their ‘allies’ are.
This section giving the background of why the research was done, has blamed ‘gender critical groups’ for something that is no defined clearly, but is described as removing ‘human rights’.
And yet, apparently gender critical feminists intention of removing the human rights of people with transgender identities, this opposition to trans rights “might have been part of the motivation for leaving the EU all along.“
That feminists were voting for and campaigning for Brexit based on wanting to remove human rights from trans people is farcical. It is hyperbolic and a huge misrepresentation. Considering how few ‘gender critical groups’ there were at the time of the Brexit vote, the issues relating to the conflicts to women and girls had really only started being recognised by more than a very small group of people. And of course, I am not convinced in any way that those people were Brexit supporters.
However, in the need to align left wing feminists as being far right supporters or aligned with far right political groups, the authors have made this unlikely connection. Hence the ambiguous use and accusations about ‘gender critical groups’.
In the introduction the authors added this fourth point as a key finding:
“Analysis revealed a broader societal concern that allowing trans people to legally change gender could result in ‘daughters’ inheriting male wealth.”
Firstly, ‘broader’ has to be considered an erroneous attempt at making this issue far more popular as a discussion point than it is in real life. And it also is a misrepresentation that female children being excluded from a will for transfer of wealth and title is in anyway something feminists support. Yet, it is listed as a finding such significance it is described as key.
Needless to say, yet again there is absolutely no statement given about what ‘gender critical groups’ have been campaigning for. ie. Protection of female single sex provisions. Just this repeated implied hatred, bigotry and very vague guilt by association.
And yet, the examples the authors then give are broad and I don’t think any refer negatively to feminist campaigns. (And why the fuck is this person Littlejohn featuring so heavily in the examples? Were the authors finding it so hard to find examples they got stuck on what they stated was a satire column?)
Here are the headings in order and the sub headings
Opposing trans rights to oppose ‘Europe’
Conflating the EU and ECtHR
Opposing the EU and ECtHR
The run up to the EU referendum
Opposing trans rights to oppose gay and lesbian rights
Opposing protections from sexual orientation discrimination
Opposition to equal marriage
Opposing LGBTQ rights to oppose migration and racial equality
Opposing the right to asylum
A disingenuous approach to free speech
Opposing trans rights to oppose gender equality rights
Aristocracy and inherited wealth
Military
Parliament and the workplace
I keep scanning to find the feminist campaigning issues that apparently motivated this research project. LGB Alliance was mentioned in passing with that old claim about their office address.I couldn’t find anything in thosw sections that was clear, detailed as what human rights were being removed and what feminists were campaigning for that removed those human rights.
I think this paper has significant issues. It uses dishonest tactics to make connections to ‘gender critical groups’ without definition and using mostly weak examples. It doesn’t present even medium strength support for its claim. It reads as inconsistent in intention and usefulness.
Yet it claims to be a resource for organisations to make policy:
“Policymakers, who also have limited time and capacity, need a strong evidence base when advocating for change. The research informing this report uses established methodological tools. Organisations and policymakers can use it to push for changes to rules on reporting accuracy or for a more responsive media regulator. Organisations can also use this report to challenge other anti-trans and anti-LGBTQ policies promoted by the press and by reactionary politicians and
movements. “
By all means, this should be read widely by policymakers. It should be analysed on its merits and considered as one of many resources. If a policymaker considered it a strong tool, I would consider that policymaker lacking balance and the background knowledge to be able to create the policy they have been tasked to do.
This paper however, does show just how much harm the detaching of ‘gender critical’ from the original term of ‘gender critical feminist’ causes. That detachment allows authors such as this to demonise feminists through guilt by association which is what this paper seems to be all about.
TLDR: this paper is a good example of how false guilt by association accusations are used to discredit feminist and women’s and girl’s rights campaign groups. It is a poorly written paper that ends up highlighting just how much transgender activists need to falsely force team taking points to support their demands.