Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Anti-trans media undermine human rights.

209 replies

theilltemperedmonster · 07/11/2026 10:31

The University of Birmingham has published a report (and associated timeline) on its website, to the above effect. Report and timeline are also linked by Trans Media Watch here:

https://transmediawatch.org/how-anti-trans-media-undermines-human-rights-and-equality-for-everyone

The main proposal for countering the problem appears to involve press regulation, although it's unclear how they intend to drum up support for that - I only found the report by accident, and haven't seen it mentioned in MSM.

How Anti-Trans Media Undermines Human Rights and Equality for Everyone – Trans Media Watch

https://transmediawatch.org/how-anti-trans-media-undermines-human-rights-and-equality-for-everyone

OP posts:
theilltemperedmonster · 07/11/2026 16:19

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 15:10

I had the same experience, but I'm stuck in a waiting room and have time to kill so I got stuck in to a proper analysis.

The actual academic thesis is that specific Eurosceptic newspapers leverage hostile coverage of landmark LGBTQIA+ legal cases to mock the ECtHR courts as "alien" or "mad", then exploit public confusion between the ECtHR and the EU to systematically erode support for the EU.

So, a very specific mechanism where "anti-LGBTQIA+" media could be said to be directly undermining a specific human rights protection, the ECtHR.

So far so fair enough. Knowing the papers in question I wouldn't argue with that.

The report’s title, "How anti-trans media undermines human rights and equality for everyone," is therefore technically true in that the report outlines a specific mechanism where anti-LGBTQIA+ reporting, which is by definition "anti-trans" but is not specifically anti-trans, is likely being utilised to undermine a specific human rights and equality provision.

But the title also and more naturally reads as if there is a direct, causal link where any media content critical of trans policies inherently degrades universal civil liberties, a monolithic attack on the public good. That frames any media analysis regarding competing rights and fairness of policy concessions as something which is inherently and avoidably, just by happening, going to result in an undermining of human rights and equality.

A very different conclusion and not what the report supports, or even (on the face of it)set out to show.

Tl,dr; the thesis on the media is reasonable, the title is pure propaganda thst goes way beyond the actual findings.

Disclaimer: I haven't done the deep dive on the claims about LGBA and press oversight yet, so don't take my comments on the actual research being reasonable to cover anything beyond the analysis of actual media content.

Edited

These people are unwittingly helping the Eurosceptic press, or would be if anyone listened to them, because they're assuming the ECtHR would give them what they want. The average reader may well be more upset about men in women's sport than same-sex marriage, although I expect that asylum seekers with pets trump both. So the extreme nature of TRA demands are being used to traduce the ECtHR, without any basis.

(I don't think the ECtHR is that mad, but so what if they are? We can ignore them, and do.)

OP posts:
Aisha176 · 07/11/2026 20:17

theilltemperedmonster · 07/11/2026 10:31

The University of Birmingham has published a report (and associated timeline) on its website, to the above effect. Report and timeline are also linked by Trans Media Watch here:

https://transmediawatch.org/how-anti-trans-media-undermines-human-rights-and-equality-for-everyone

The main proposal for countering the problem appears to involve press regulation, although it's unclear how they intend to drum up support for that - I only found the report by accident, and haven't seen it mentioned in MSM.

The main proposal for countering the problem appears to involve press regulation, although it's unclear how they intend to drum up support for that.

Regulation of misinformation/disinformation & a balance of views would seem to be the obvious answer which are already journalistic standards so perhaps a review of practices is in order? Education of school children on media bias & its consequences?

"We need to recognise anti-trans media as part of a wider reactionary agenda."

Whatever you think about trans people, like immigrants & gay people they are the canaries in the coal mine in an effort to erode general human rights. History shows us that sustained media hate campaigns primed citizens for acceptance & participation of the human rights abuses that followed in the Holocaust, Rwanda, Bosnia, Myanmar & Cambodia.

"First they came for the Communists
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a Communist
Then they came for the Socialists
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a Socialist
Then they came for the trade unionists
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a trade unionist
Then they came for the Jews
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a Jew
Then they came for me
And there was no one left
To speak out for me"

-Niemoller

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 20:36

Aisha176 · 07/11/2026 20:17

The main proposal for countering the problem appears to involve press regulation, although it's unclear how they intend to drum up support for that.

Regulation of misinformation/disinformation & a balance of views would seem to be the obvious answer which are already journalistic standards so perhaps a review of practices is in order? Education of school children on media bias & its consequences?

"We need to recognise anti-trans media as part of a wider reactionary agenda."

Whatever you think about trans people, like immigrants & gay people they are the canaries in the coal mine in an effort to erode general human rights. History shows us that sustained media hate campaigns primed citizens for acceptance & participation of the human rights abuses that followed in the Holocaust, Rwanda, Bosnia, Myanmar & Cambodia.

"First they came for the Communists
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a Communist
Then they came for the Socialists
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a Socialist
Then they came for the trade unionists
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a trade unionist
Then they came for the Jews
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a Jew
Then they came for me
And there was no one left
To speak out for me"

-Niemoller

Whatever you think about trans people, like immigrants & gay people they are the canaries in the coal mine in an effort to erode general human rights. History shows us that sustained media hate campaigns primed citizens for acceptance & participation of the human rights abuses that followed in the Holocaust, Rwanda, Bosnia, Myanmar & Cambodia.

I suggest you read the paper. That's not what this research is saying, although it's certainly what the person who picked the title is hoping people will assume it says.

Aisha176 · 07/11/2026 20:38

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 20:36

Whatever you think about trans people, like immigrants & gay people they are the canaries in the coal mine in an effort to erode general human rights. History shows us that sustained media hate campaigns primed citizens for acceptance & participation of the human rights abuses that followed in the Holocaust, Rwanda, Bosnia, Myanmar & Cambodia.

I suggest you read the paper. That's not what this research is saying, although it's certainly what the person who picked the title is hoping people will assume it says.

Edited

I did read the paper & it does sight misinformation & the erosion of human rights protection as a problem.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 20:39

Aisha176 · 07/11/2026 20:38

I did read the paper & it does sight misinformation & the erosion of human rights protection as a problem.

Edited

That's not the part of your post I was referring to, although I appreciate you may have posted before I added a clarifying quote.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 20:40

Ironically the report title is a pretty good example of misinformation itself.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 20:48

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 20:39

That's not the part of your post I was referring to, although I appreciate you may have posted before I added a clarifying quote.

Ah, I see you since editted yours to add "erosion of human rights". But still, that is not exactly the research is it? The research is looking specifically at how the Eurosceptic press was using anti-LBGTQIA+ writing to undermine the ECtHR and support for the EU. It's in no way showing that anti-LBGTQIA+ press directly results in a weakening of human rights simply by being allowd to exist, which is what the title implies.

To be clear, I'm no fan of reactionary press and I agree with your broader statement, but I am very wary of how easily media controls to "protect trans people" can be weaponised to deny women the reporting of our voices and our perspectives, presenting a sexist and one sided narrative as "the facts".

Aisha176 · 07/11/2026 20:55

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 20:39

That's not the part of your post I was referring to, although I appreciate you may have posted before I added a clarifying quote.

We must not be reading the same report.

"The timeline reveals the long history behind the current anti-trans moral panic. It traces how the press has advanced an anti-rights agenda as LGBTQ people have gained equal rights and journalistic standards have declined.
The report further argues, with supporting evidence, that the press has used anti-trans stories not just as a political tool to undermine European equality and human rights frameworks. It also establishes a base from which they oppose lesbian and gay rights, migration and asylum rights, gender equality protections, and to criticise Islam.

We need to recognise anti-trans media as part of a wider reactionary agenda. in particular, to withdraw the UK from the European Convention on Human Rights. Anti-trans media stories affect everyone, and the time for action is now."

A prime example of how the media exploit anti trans reporting is to undermine the left in general. 'They don't know what a woman is so don't trust them'. Its become their gotcha like 'woke' & its faux threat of impending authoritarianism has. While on the surface these might be appealing arguments they run cover for a much broader agenda that undermines rights in general.

Aisha176 · 07/11/2026 20:59

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 20:48

Ah, I see you since editted yours to add "erosion of human rights". But still, that is not exactly the research is it? The research is looking specifically at how the Eurosceptic press was using anti-LBGTQIA+ writing to undermine the ECtHR and support for the EU. It's in no way showing that anti-LBGTQIA+ press directly results in a weakening of human rights simply by being allowd to exist, which is what the title implies.

To be clear, I'm no fan of reactionary press and I agree with your broader statement, but I am very wary of how easily media controls to "protect trans people" can be weaponised to deny women the reporting of our voices and our perspectives, presenting a sexist and one sided narrative as "the facts".

It's in no way showing that anti-LBGTQIA+ press directly results in a weakening of human rights simply by being allowd to exist, which is what the title implies.

The attached 'time line' to the report shows this.

solerolover · 07/11/2026 21:00

EmpressaurusKitty · 07/11/2026 14:17

John Ozimek, the man who defends violent pornography & said that a lot of murders are accidental because of women’s ’eggshell skulls’. Lovely chap.

Wait, what?? This is horrifying.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 21:02

Aisha176 · 07/11/2026 20:55

We must not be reading the same report.

"The timeline reveals the long history behind the current anti-trans moral panic. It traces how the press has advanced an anti-rights agenda as LGBTQ people have gained equal rights and journalistic standards have declined.
The report further argues, with supporting evidence, that the press has used anti-trans stories not just as a political tool to undermine European equality and human rights frameworks. It also establishes a base from which they oppose lesbian and gay rights, migration and asylum rights, gender equality protections, and to criticise Islam.

We need to recognise anti-trans media as part of a wider reactionary agenda. in particular, to withdraw the UK from the European Convention on Human Rights. Anti-trans media stories affect everyone, and the time for action is now."

A prime example of how the media exploit anti trans reporting is to undermine the left in general. 'They don't know what a woman is so don't trust them'. Its become their gotcha like 'woke' & its faux threat of impending authoritarianism has. While on the surface these might be appealing arguments they run cover for a much broader agenda that undermines rights in general.

You are just quoting the summary though. If you read the actual research they did, it doesn't actually back that narrative up.

To be clear, it doesn't disprove it either, it's just not looking at the same thing.

The timeline is factual, yes, but superficial because it's only showing content that was picked to be anti-LGBTQIA+ in the first place, so it's not really showing anything other than these papers express anti-LGBTQIA+ views consistently, which we all knew already.

Again, it's not that I'm defending the reactionary press, it's just that the report is written with a very clear agenda that IMO the actual research at its core does not justify.

Aisha176 · 07/11/2026 21:07

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 21:02

You are just quoting the summary though. If you read the actual research they did, it doesn't actually back that narrative up.

To be clear, it doesn't disprove it either, it's just not looking at the same thing.

The timeline is factual, yes, but superficial because it's only showing content that was picked to be anti-LGBTQIA+ in the first place, so it's not really showing anything other than these papers express anti-LGBTQIA+ views consistently, which we all knew already.

Again, it's not that I'm defending the reactionary press, it's just that the report is written with a very clear agenda that IMO the actual research at its core does not justify.

See the 'time line' how the consequences & the reporting are interlinked.

And its not even as though we need a report to know how biased media reporting by Murdoch has influenced political outcomes that aren't exactly human rights friendly.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 21:09

As a thought experiment, you could draw the same timeline but using pro trans rights and pro ECtHR extracts from the Guardian et all, and show that increasingly pro-LGBTQIA+ media has appeared to lead to roll backs in human rights legislation. Not that I am suggesting this is the case, simply highlighting what the report does and does not actually prove.

AstonCanKissMyArse · 07/11/2026 21:18

Dragonasaurus · 07/11/2026 12:52

Another uni to cross off the list. Not because it is pro/anti trans, but because such a lax approach to academic rigour makes them unfit to teach

I thought it was some undergraduate dross (that write up on the trans media website is virtually unintelligible). But then I noticed it was written by 2 'Dr' s.

Standards are definitely slipping.

I wondered if this was linked to the awful biased PhD from Aston Uni a couple of years ago (my namesake) but it appears to be the actual Birmingham uni.

AstonCanKissMyArse · 07/11/2026 21:22

Aisha176 · 07/11/2026 21:07

See the 'time line' how the consequences & the reporting are interlinked.

And its not even as though we need a report to know how biased media reporting by Murdoch has influenced political outcomes that aren't exactly human rights friendly.

And its not even as though we need a report to know how biased media reporting by Murdoch has influenced political outcomes that aren't exactly human rights friendly.

Out of interest, do you have any specific examples of
A) this biased reporting
B) how it links to the outcomes you are suggesting, bearing in mind that correlation is not causation
C) what human rights have been infringed by these outcomes (actual human rights, ref the universal declaration on human rights, not some vague manufactured sense of injustice).

EmpressaurusKitty · 07/11/2026 21:24

solerolover · 07/11/2026 21:00

Wait, what?? This is horrifying.

Yes, isn’t it?

Aisha176 · 07/11/2026 21:49

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 21:09

As a thought experiment, you could draw the same timeline but using pro trans rights and pro ECtHR extracts from the Guardian et all, and show that increasingly pro-LGBTQIA+ media has appeared to lead to roll backs in human rights legislation. Not that I am suggesting this is the case, simply highlighting what the report does and does not actually prove.

The report shows many examples of how the media has used trans rights to advocate for withdrawal of the EU & UK from the ECHR. It shows how they opposed trans rights on the basis they would extend rights for gay & lesbian couples. Also examples of how trans rights are used to oppose gender equality rights.

You couldn't get much more proof than examples of the media actually opposing other groups rights via trans rights.

As a thought experiment, you could draw the same timeline but using pro trans rights and pro ECtHR extracts from the Guardian et all, and show that increasingly pro-LGBTQIA+ media has appeared to lead to roll backs in human rights legislation.

Examples?

Aisha176 · 07/11/2026 21:51

AstonCanKissMyArse · 07/11/2026 21:22

And its not even as though we need a report to know how biased media reporting by Murdoch has influenced political outcomes that aren't exactly human rights friendly.

Out of interest, do you have any specific examples of
A) this biased reporting
B) how it links to the outcomes you are suggesting, bearing in mind that correlation is not causation
C) what human rights have been infringed by these outcomes (actual human rights, ref the universal declaration on human rights, not some vague manufactured sense of injustice).

The report has examples of how the media has specifically advocated for the roll back of rights. See above comment for particulars.

Aisha176 · 07/11/2026 22:04

Aisha176 · 07/11/2026 21:51

The report has examples of how the media has specifically advocated for the roll back of rights. See above comment for particulars.

In terms of Murdoch's biased reporting in general it's no secret its heavily politically right wing coded oversimplified outrage bait which effectively primes its readership towards right wing ascension. Do I really need to spell out how the right historically hasn't been rights friendly?

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 22:18

Aisha176 · 07/11/2026 21:49

The report shows many examples of how the media has used trans rights to advocate for withdrawal of the EU & UK from the ECHR. It shows how they opposed trans rights on the basis they would extend rights for gay & lesbian couples. Also examples of how trans rights are used to oppose gender equality rights.

You couldn't get much more proof than examples of the media actually opposing other groups rights via trans rights.

As a thought experiment, you could draw the same timeline but using pro trans rights and pro ECtHR extracts from the Guardian et all, and show that increasingly pro-LGBTQIA+ media has appeared to lead to roll backs in human rights legislation.

Examples?

The report shows many examples of how the media has used trans rights to advocate for withdrawal of the EU & UK from the ECHR.

Yes!

Yes, that is exactly what the report is actually saying. Not a general claim that "anti-trans" media (which is a dangerously vague label) inherently leads to an undermining of human rights, but (as I said) that there is evidence that the Eurosceptic press leveraged anti-LGBTQIA+ stories in order to undermine support for specifically European legal and government structures.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 22:25

Aisha176 · 07/11/2026 22:04

In terms of Murdoch's biased reporting in general it's no secret its heavily politically right wing coded oversimplified outrage bait which effectively primes its readership towards right wing ascension. Do I really need to spell out how the right historically hasn't been rights friendly?

While I agree with your rage bait point, I suspect your knowledge of history may be limited. It's not right vs left that determines human rights outrages and atrocities, it's authoritarianism/totalitarianism vs freedom of choice.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 22:32

Although here's something interesting - the media quotes timeline starts with "Media ownership deregulated. Rupert
Murdoch expands media empire in UK.
Defeats print unions at Wapping in 1986" but almost all the quotes are the Daily Mail and the Telegraph, neither of which are Murdoch papers. The only Murdoch content on the timeline is a single quote from the Sun. So interesting PP singles out the Murdoch press.

RhannionKPSS · 07/11/2026 22:35

What rights don’t trans people have ?
I simply can’t be arsed to read this propaganda, better time spent reading The Women Who Wouldnt Wheesht and The Terf Diaries

Aisha176 · 07/11/2026 22:40

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 22:18

The report shows many examples of how the media has used trans rights to advocate for withdrawal of the EU & UK from the ECHR.

Yes!

Yes, that is exactly what the report is actually saying. Not a general claim that "anti-trans" media (which is a dangerously vague label) inherently leads to an undermining of human rights, but (as I said) that there is evidence that the Eurosceptic press leveraged anti-LGBTQIA+ stories in order to undermine support for specifically European legal and government structures.

Edited

The title is How Anti Trans Media Undermines Human Rights. The fact the media hasn't actually been successful in the removal of rights yet in the examples given doesn't change the fact the media has undermined those rights by advocating against them. That's what the point of advocating for their removal is. Advocating against rights alters public perception and institutional priorities creating a pathway to dismantle protections.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 22:44

Aisha176 · 07/11/2026 22:40

The title is How Anti Trans Media Undermines Human Rights. The fact the media hasn't actually been successful in the removal of rights yet in the examples given doesn't change the fact the media has undermined those rights by advocating against them. That's what the point of advocating for their removal is. Advocating against rights alters public perception and institutional priorities creating a pathway to dismantle protections.

Yes, when you know the content of the rseearch, if you squint a bit you can see how the title fits it.

But, again, the title is - I would say deliberately - written to imply something much wider and more insidious than the research actually captured. To the degree I consider the title and the summary politically motivated misinformation in their own right. The fact you happen to agree with it should not give it a free pass.

It's been interesting watching you go through the process as your posts have gone on of going from what you thought the research was saying to what it was actually saying.

This thread prevents users from posting on it until they have been members for at least 2 days.