Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Anti-trans media undermine human rights.

209 replies

theilltemperedmonster · 07/11/2026 10:31

The University of Birmingham has published a report (and associated timeline) on its website, to the above effect. Report and timeline are also linked by Trans Media Watch here:

https://transmediawatch.org/how-anti-trans-media-undermines-human-rights-and-equality-for-everyone

The main proposal for countering the problem appears to involve press regulation, although it's unclear how they intend to drum up support for that - I only found the report by accident, and haven't seen it mentioned in MSM.

How Anti-Trans Media Undermines Human Rights and Equality for Everyone – Trans Media Watch

https://transmediawatch.org/how-anti-trans-media-undermines-human-rights-and-equality-for-everyone

OP posts:
FlirtsWithRhinos · 08/11/2026 08:35

WaterThyme · 08/11/2026 08:26

I am dubious about the methodology and its execution.

The data was analysed using a feminist narrative approach and coded using qualitative data analysis software QSR NVivo. Feminist narrative analysis demonstrates how the media exercises power through stories. Narratives are stories with characters and a plotline with a beginning, middle and an end. The analysis considered two dimensions: storytelling by the media; and storytelling through the media.

I am no sociologist but isn’t there a risk that this can become a cover for cherry-picking examples that confirm your argument?

When I have seen feminist arguments that use narrative like this there has been comparison with the alternative narratives for the comparator population.

Having asserted that their coverage was a list of newspapers from the Guardian to the Telegraph including the Mail and the Sun, the Guardian gets just one mention, for an article on inheritance rights in 1989. Does the rest of th Guardian’s output not suit their argument?

IAMNAA (not an academic) but from the brief reading I did I think the methodology is fine for the conclusion the research actually drew. The bias in the selection of sources is fine given that they were looking at the behaviour of those sources over time.

Where this falls down IME is the executive summary and title, which are making wider claims that the research doesn't back up. Those claims would need a full media survey including media they didn't classify as "anti-trans", and indeed would need to classify specifically ant-trans as opposed to anti-LGBTQIA+.

Helleofabore · 08/11/2026 08:32

By keeping the focus on a broad focus of ‘rights’ it allows points about LGB Alliance to be included with Reform and UKIP and far right.

The paper needs to keep focus on the ‘anti-trans’ and ‘anti-rights’ umbrella term while not focusing on women’s rights campaigners.

I wonder what the paper would have looked like prior to that Amnesty report.

I think it is a paper that really isn’t that useful. It is using highly emotive terminology while hypocritically discussing ‘trans-panic’. Maybe ‘trans panic’ is this constant panic that a group of privileges that have been wrongly declared rights by campaigning and support groups are being clarified and people are more wary of supporting these additional privileges while still supporting basic human rights for all. That derisory term ‘trans panic’ doesn’t look all that meaningful when you start to look beneath the surface claims.

WaterThyme · 08/11/2026 08:26

I am dubious about the methodology and its execution.

The data was analysed using a feminist narrative approach and coded using qualitative data analysis software QSR NVivo. Feminist narrative analysis demonstrates how the media exercises power through stories. Narratives are stories with characters and a plotline with a beginning, middle and an end. The analysis considered two dimensions: storytelling by the media; and storytelling through the media.

I am no sociologist but isn’t there a risk that this can become a cover for cherry-picking examples that confirm your argument?

When I have seen feminist arguments that use narrative like this there has been comparison with the alternative narratives for the comparator population.

Having asserted that their coverage was a list of newspapers from the Guardian to the Telegraph including the Mail and the Sun, the Guardian gets just one mention, for an article on inheritance rights in 1989. Does the rest of th Guardian’s output not suit their argument?

Helleofabore · 08/11/2026 08:19

The biggest failing of this paper is not being very clear what ‘human rights’ it is referring to as being eroded. All
while using that emotionally driven term ‘trans panic’.

Maybe a reminder of the article that commonly gets a mention on these threads - Article 8.

From the ECHR documentation
https://www.echr.coe.int/documents/d/echr/convention_ENG

page 11

Article 8 – Right to respect for private and family life

1. Everyone has the right to respect for his private and family life, his home and his correspondence.

2. There shall be no interference by a public authority with the exercise of this right except such as is in accordance with the law and is necessary in a democratic society in the interests of national security, public safety or the economic well-being of the country, for the prevention of disorder or crime, for the protection of health or morals, or for the protection of the rights and freedoms of others.

Here is the part so often missed.

https://www.equalityhumanrights.com/human-rights/human-rights-act/article-8-respect-your-private-and-family-life

The EHRC link covers what this means. Including these restrictions:

Restrictions to the right to respect for your private and family life
There are situations when public authorities can interfere with your right to respect for private and family life, home and correspondence. This is only allowed where the authority can show that its action is lawful, necessary and proportionate in order to:

protect national security
protect public safety
protect the economy
protect health or morals
prevent disorder or crime, or
protect the rights and freedoms of other people.

Action is ‘proportionate’ when it is appropriate and no more than necessary to address the problem concerned.

https://www.echr.coe.int/documents/d/echr/convention_ENG

StealthTroublemaker · 08/11/2026 08:14

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 08/11/2026 07:45

Of course it does. Anti-trans activism is packed with men for a reason: it allows then to be misogynistic, bully people and promote biological essentialism.

And to discuss children's genitals at length, of course. And call things which aren't child abuse 'child abuse' in order to attack parents and make themselves out to be righteous saviours. Just repulsive.

Oh im sorry, you must be confused, youre describing the gender ideologists. You know, the ones issuing rape threats, death threats and threatening violence to women for saying no to men in female spaces

MontyMadness99 · 08/11/2026 08:08

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 08/11/2026 07:45

Of course it does. Anti-trans activism is packed with men for a reason: it allows then to be misogynistic, bully people and promote biological essentialism.

And to discuss children's genitals at length, of course. And call things which aren't child abuse 'child abuse' in order to attack parents and make themselves out to be righteous saviours. Just repulsive.

And if you remove the ‘anti’ from your second sentence your statement still rings true…

Helleofabore · 08/11/2026 07:45

Here is a link to the paper

https://epapers.bham.ac.uk//id/eprint/4465/1/Anti-Trans-Media-Equality-Human%20Rights%20FINAL.pdf

Dr Charlotte Galpin & Dr Ash Stokoe
November 2026

Executive summary
A moral panic about trans people has been raging in the UK press, amplified by social media. While it started ramping up in 2017, the political hostility to trans people goes back decades. Anti-trans media stories have served as a political tool to attack European equality and human rights frameworks for many years. Failing to take media transphobia seriously endangers everybody’s civil rights.

Many of the rights and protections that LGBTQ people have in the UK resulted from EU law and judgments by the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR). This research examines the stories that the British press told about ‘Europe’ and LGBTQ rights between 1973 and 2017. It also includes some illustrative examples from the 2020s. The report’s findings are based on analysis of four widely-read newspapers: The Guardian; The Telegraph; The Daily Mail; and The Sun. The data was analysed using a feminist narrative approach.

In a healthy democracy, the media informs citizens on political issues, enabling debate and political participation, and holds political representatives to account. But the media is no longer fulfilling this democratic function. Newspaper ownership has become increasingly concentrated in a few powerful conglomerates. The Internet and social media created economic pressures that reduced journalistic standards. The UK press has resisted efforts to regulate it. The decline in media standards has accompanied the increasing input of billionaires and global far-right actors in
our politics and our press.

Key findings
• The press has used its opposition to LGBTQ rights to oppose the EU and the ECtHR. It has done this by conflating the EU and ECtHR when reporting or commenting on legal cases. LGBTQ people, and major legal developments in LGBTQ rights, were also used to directly attack the EU, the ECtHR and the Human Rights Act 1998. By the 2010s, newspaper articles used support for LGBTQ rights to criticise pro -European politicians or to justify Brexit.

• The press linked its opposition to trans rights to its opposition to gay and lesbian rights. Some news articles opposed the first anti-discrimination protections for trans people because they might similarly lead to protections based on sexual orientation. After trans people won the right to legal gender recognition, some articles opposed it because they saw it as a step towards same-sex marriage. News articles later opposed marriage equality as part of general opposition to David Cameron’s brand of liberal conservativism and support for remaining in the EU.

• Parts of the press have used criticisms of protections for LGBTQ people to stereotype Black, Brown and Muslim migrants. Many articles opposed the right to asylum on the basis of gender identity or sexual orientation. Black, Brown and/or Muslim LGBTQ people were brought into association with deception and criminality. Trans rights were further joined to anti-migrant hostility and Islamophobia through the issue of free speech. Respect for trans
people was portrayed as a threat to fundamental British liberties. Such stories undermine support for press regulation and hate crime legislation.

Parts of the press portrayed rights for women and LGBTQ people as a challenge to established male power. Analysis revealed a broader societal concern that allowing trans people to legally change gender could result in ‘daughters’ inheriting male wealth. Articles opposing LGBTQ people serving in the military also opposed protection from dismissal for soldiers who became pregnant. Such articles portrayed both cis and trans women as a threat to the effectiveness of the British Armed Forces. Later, workplace rights and protections for cis and trans women were portrayed as a threat to post-Brexit Britain.

Where next ? (Summary)
Anti-trans media is a warning of a wider agenda: to withdraw the UK from the European Convention on Human Rights and repeal the Equality Act and Human Rights Act. Fundamentally, it is an agenda that fundamentally reshapes who belongs in Britain.

The time for action is now. We need a stronger intersectional coalition of advocates, journalists, policymakers, academics, and individuals who recognise anti-trans media as part of a bigger reactionary agenda. A cross-sector coalition should involve trans- and LGBTQ advocacy, groups advocating for migrants' rights, racial equality, disability rights and climate action, political parties and policymakers, as well as media reform campaigners.

We also need coordinated efforts to better regulate an increasingly hostile media system. Implementing Leveson in full would be an important first step. But we need to go further. We need to treat press and social media regulation as related issues. Working together, groups advocating against discriminatory and hateful speech online and in the mainstream media must identify steps forward for media regulation in the digital age and advocate to change the current system.

Where next? (Full text)
Parts of the right-wing press want to repeal the Human Rights Act and erode the Equality Act. They would like the UK to withdraw from the European Convention. This would affect women, queer folk, Black and Brown people, people seeking asylum, disabled people and all workers in the UK. It is part of a global movement challenging civil rights around the world.

The anti-rights agenda already has the support of political parties in the UK. The Conservative Party has pledged to withdraw from the European Convention, repeal the Human Rights Act, and overhaul the Equality Act. Reform UK has gone further, pledging to replace the Human Rights Act with a British Bill of Rights. It has also proposed replacing the 2010 Equality Act with a ‘Women and Motherhood Act’. The Trade Unions Congress suggests this would remove the right to equal pay between women and men for work of equal value . The place of equality and human rights within the UK’s legal system seems far from settled.

In this context, our findings suggest that the anti-trans moral panic may be read as a strategy by billionaire media owners to undermine wider public support for human rights and equality protections. But the contemporary media economy intensifies it. Press regulators have demonstrated little willingness to balance press freedoms with the protection of minority groups. Findings show that newspapers have also defended the right to offend minority groups.

IPSO, for example, rejects most complaints about discriminatory reporting against individuals – in 2018, for example, it acted on only two out of 8,000 complaints about discrimination. Clause 12 (Discrimination) of its Editors’ Code of Practice applies only to prejudicial content published about individuals. The Code provides no way to hold newspapers to account for publishing stories that legitimise discrimination towards minority groups.

News media are increasingly reliant on the outrage economy for visibility and revenue. In the AI age, Big Tech leaders seek to influence global democratic processes in support of their business model. This includes supporting far-right parties and undermining efforts to fight disinformation and improve online safety. It also includes a political agenda not only promoting deregulation
but seeking to fundamentally restructure the state. Attacks on civil rights will only get worse.

We need a stronger intersectional coalition that works together on defending equality and human rights for everybody. To build this, we need to recognise anti-trans media as part of a bigger reactionary agenda. A cross-sector coalition should involve trans- and LGBTQ advocacy, groups
advocating for migrant rights, racial equality, disability rights and climate action, political parties and policymakers, and media reform campaigners.

It also needs coordinated efforts to better regulate an increasingly hostile media system that generates outrage about equality and human rights protections for the most vulnerable groups in society. Such coverage is likely driven by financial incentives. Implementing Leveson in full, including measures to incentivise the use of a Leveson-compliant regulator, would be an important first step.

But we need to go further. We need to treat press and social media regulation as related issues. The digital age has fundamentally changed – and will continue to change – how the news operates and how it treats minority groups. Working together, groups advocating against discriminatory and hateful speech online and in the mainstream media, and those researching these issues, must identify steps forward for media regulation in the digital age and advocate to change the current system.

The authors then include this pdf ‘timeline’

https://epapers.bham.ac.uk//id/eprint/4465/2/Anti-Trans-Media-Equality-Human%20Rights%20Timeline%20FINAL.pdf

https://epapers.bham.ac.uk/id/eprint/4465/1/Anti-Trans-Media-Equality-Human%20Rights%20FINAL.pdf

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 08/11/2026 07:45

Of course it does. Anti-trans activism is packed with men for a reason: it allows then to be misogynistic, bully people and promote biological essentialism.

And to discuss children's genitals at length, of course. And call things which aren't child abuse 'child abuse' in order to attack parents and make themselves out to be righteous saviours. Just repulsive.

FrippEnos · 08/11/2026 07:40

Aisha176

What trans rights are the media trying to have revoked?

nutmeg7 · 08/11/2026 07:33

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I’m not sure that someone who calls women “utter vermin” and “vile” and “ bitter tramps” without listening to a single word they have to say, or giving a moments thought to their experiences can teach anyone anything about “basic human decency”.

StealthTroublemaker · 08/11/2026 06:31

Aisha176 · 08/11/2026 00:23

This is what I posted upthread:

"The title is How Anti Trans Media Undermines Human Rights. The fact the media hasn't actually been successful in the removal of rights yet in the examples given doesn't change the fact the media has undermined those rights by advocating against them. That's what the point of advocating for their removal is. Advocating against rights alters public perception and institutional priorities creating a pathway to dismantle protections."

So what rights are “the media” advocating that trans people should lose?

StealthTroublemaker · 08/11/2026 06:29

EmpathyMatters77 · 08/11/2026 00:26

Apparently not, but even so does that mean a feminist article written by a woman would be biased too???

I would suggest before you defend the man who write this article you go and see his thoughts on women killed by Domestic Violence. And his thoughts on extreme porn…

CohensDiamondTeeth · 08/11/2026 05:50

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I've reported you because it's a discussion forum, not a place to just throw empty insults at people.

A person who named themselves Empathy Matters calling women "tramps" and "unteachable vermin" while preaching about not being hateful to other people. Anyone else's irony meter explode?

Heggettypeg · 08/11/2026 04:40

EmpathyMatters77 · 08/11/2026 03:24

Let's just cut to the chase. Do you hate all trans people? Do you think it's acceptable to make their lives a misery? Do you think that high suicide rate among trans people is okay?

I'm not suggesting that womens rights, single sex spaces, and protection for girls is not important. But I do take issue with outright hatred of a group of people just for existing.

No, I don't "hate all trans people." I know several.

And I am sick of the hyperbolic assumption that any criticism of how some of them behave, and of the bad effects on women's rights when transactivist demands are enshrined in official policies, somehow means that you "hate all trans people" and "want to erase them", and all the other exaggerated nonsense. Like the media articles saying that trans people are being "banned" from sport, when what's actually happening is that they are just being told to stick to their own sex category.

I know that some right wing outlets spin anything they can as "woke gone mad", with nefarious intent. And some left wing outlets spin women's reasonable requests to have their rights back, and for due diligence before supplying young people with puberty blockers and hormones, as "transphobia".

Therefore I don't trust transactivists who want to control what the Press gets to say, any more than I'd trust a right- wing pressure group who were wanting the same thing. Neither of them should be indulged.

MontyMadness99 · 08/11/2026 04:12

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Oh dear.

My comment was in direct response to your assertion that any trans people are loved and matter.

I didn’t make any such claim about women - that’s your extrapolation…

Teaching basic understanding of the English language…

EmpathyMatters77 · 08/11/2026 04:08

Ile finish by saying that like suffragettes, slaves, and gay people, trans people are not going to cease to exist for the comfort of others.

I'm not Trans, but I'm one of many allies.

EmpathyMatters77 · 08/11/2026 04:05

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

MontyMadness99 · 08/11/2026 04:01

EmpathyMatters77 · 08/11/2026 02:48

FYI to any trans people who see this. Ignore the hatred. You are loved and you matter.

I posted something like this before, and MNHQ removed it (no idea why). This one has been screenshot.

Edited

How can you love and accept a whole group of people which includes rapists, sexual offenders and misogynists?

Surely, using your argument, they are all loved and matter. Don’t think that about those factions of the trans ‘group’? You love them all equally regardless?

Hating male violence doesn’t necessarily equal hating men.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 08/11/2026 03:54

EmpathyMatters77 · 08/11/2026 02:48

FYI to any trans people who see this. Ignore the hatred. You are loved and you matter.

I posted something like this before, and MNHQ removed it (no idea why). This one has been screenshot.

Edited

What even the ones who are rapists like Karen white and Katie Dolatowski? The ones who punched a woman in the face like Tara Woolf?

EmpathyMatters77 · 08/11/2026 03:24

Heggettypeg · 08/11/2026 03:16

You are dismissing the systemic damage done to women and children by the prioritisation of trans demands over other people's rights.. Until that stops, my priority and that of many other women on here, is the wellbeing of those women and children. They are not "acceptable collateral damage" to the validation of somebody else's identity, and ignoring them is not feminism.

Standing up for them is not "hate". Some women on here have been doing that for a very long time, in the face of extreme unpleasantness from trans supporters. If those women no longer "have any fucks to give," I am not going to judge them. Human patience has its limits.

Let's just cut to the chase. Do you hate all trans people? Do you think it's acceptable to make their lives a misery? Do you think that high suicide rate among trans people is okay?

I'm not suggesting that womens rights, single sex spaces, and protection for girls is not important. But I do take issue with outright hatred of a group of people just for existing.

EmpathyMatters77 · 08/11/2026 03:21

Heggettypeg · 08/11/2026 03:16

You are dismissing the systemic damage done to women and children by the prioritisation of trans demands over other people's rights.. Until that stops, my priority and that of many other women on here, is the wellbeing of those women and children. They are not "acceptable collateral damage" to the validation of somebody else's identity, and ignoring them is not feminism.

Standing up for them is not "hate". Some women on here have been doing that for a very long time, in the face of extreme unpleasantness from trans supporters. If those women no longer "have any fucks to give," I am not going to judge them. Human patience has its limits.

The OP was about Trans people having their human rights impinged. There is no need to come and try derail.

The person didn't need to comment at all. If I had been attacked by a group of women, I would not feel the need the next day to say "I don't give a fuck" another women who had been trafficked.

This is like me going to a holocaust museum and trying to debate Palestine.

Basically, what you ate saying is: "some trans activism hurts women, so I'm okay with trans people on the whole being attacked"

It's disgusting, vile, and awful logic.

Heggettypeg · 08/11/2026 03:16

EmpathyMatters77 · 08/11/2026 02:36

"Some trans activists went too far, so I'm now going to dismiss hate against all trans people"

This logic is like me being okay with systemic racism because BLM went to far a couple of times.

It's warped and twisted logic.

You are dismissing the systemic damage done to women and children by the prioritisation of trans demands over other people's rights.. Until that stops, my priority and that of many other women on here, is the wellbeing of those women and children. They are not "acceptable collateral damage" to the validation of somebody else's identity, and ignoring them is not feminism.

Standing up for them is not "hate". Some women on here have been doing that for a very long time, in the face of extreme unpleasantness from trans supporters. If those women no longer "have any fucks to give," I am not going to judge them. Human patience has its limits.

EmpathyMatters77 · 08/11/2026 02:48

FYI to any trans people who see this. Ignore the hatred. You are loved and you matter.

I posted something like this before, and MNHQ removed it (no idea why). This one has been screenshot.

EmpathyMatters77 · 08/11/2026 02:39

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

EmpathyMatters77 · 08/11/2026 02:36

Heggettypeg · 08/11/2026 01:40

Except it goes way beyond "a few bad actors".

Referring to your rapist as "she", or be found in contempt of court, was written into the official guidelines for the conduct of court cases. It has been removed now, after campaigning, but it was official policy, not one or two " bad actors".

Official NHS policies and prison service policies, likewise, were influenced by transactivists and it was following those policies that led to men in women's prisons and men and women in opposite-sex wards, and the lack of proper procedures at the Tavistock.

Ideas like being born in the wrong body" have been actively pushed in schools, and that is only now being corrected.

"No debate" on trans issues has been pushed in universities, to the detriment of academic freedom, and has cost people their jobs.

Stonewall and similar organisations have peddled the line that women legally have to include transwomen in their spaces. This was not the law, and women had to go to the Supreme Court to get this spelled out. Despite this, many organisations are still dragging their heels over giving women their rights. Some organisations have now disaffiliated from Stonewall, but not long ago there were dozens of public bodies and private companies subscribing to them and listening to their version of the law.

You seem to have a naive image of a tiny, powerless minority. In fact, they have had the ear of the authorities for a long time.

"Some trans activists went too far, so I'm now going to dismiss hate against all trans people"

This logic is like me being okay with systemic racism because BLM went to far a couple of times.

It's warped and twisted logic.

This thread prevents users from posting on it until they have been members for at least 2 days.

Swipe left for the next trending thread