Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Professor/Author Kathleen Stock on proposed "conversion therapy ban"

80 replies

VeryConcernedDad · 04/11/2026 20:23

When did we reach the point where parents might need the state's permission to disagree with their own children? Speaking on Times Radio, Professor Kathleen Stock raises a fundamental question about the proposed Conversion Practices Bill: should a mother or father risk criminal prosecution simply for questioning their child's beliefs about their sex or sexuality? There is a world of difference between abuse and a parent saying, out of love and concern, "I don't think you're right." We can protect children from genuine abuse without criminalising ordinary parental disagreement. The family home should not become another place where free speech requires government approval.

OP posts:
dolorsit · 04/11/2026 22:30

And yet those people who support the bill were unable to point to a single legal loophole that it closes.

And they were asked the question.

JanesLittleGirl · 04/11/2026 22:45

CoolforKats · 04/11/2026 22:07

Um, a court of law with whatever the established threshold is.

But the bill doesn't define an established threshold and it is unreasonable to expect a jury to define it.

CoolforKats · 04/11/2026 22:52

JanesLittleGirl · 04/11/2026 22:45

But the bill doesn't define an established threshold and it is unreasonable to expect a jury to define it.

It doesn't have to. The courts can refer to the aready established meaning in law. This language is established in UK criminal law, specifically under Section 4A of the Protection from Harassment Act 1997 (stalking involving fear of violence or serious alarm or distress) and Section 76 of the Serious Crime Act 2015 (controlling or coercive behaviour in an intimate or family relationship).

JanesLittleGirl · 04/11/2026 23:05

CoolforKats · 04/11/2026 22:52

It doesn't have to. The courts can refer to the aready established meaning in law. This language is established in UK criminal law, specifically under Section 4A of the Protection from Harassment Act 1997 (stalking involving fear of violence or serious alarm or distress) and Section 76 of the Serious Crime Act 2015 (controlling or coercive behaviour in an intimate or family relationship).

Edited

Thanks for this. So the bar is actually so high that the Act will not introduce any offence that isn't already covered by existing legislation. So why introduce it?

JoanOgden · 04/11/2026 23:20

The law already allows the state to remove children from parents who abuse them or fail to keep them safe; and if that abuse is really serious, such parents can face criminal charges.

At present, however, "saying things your children don't agree with and find upsetting" is not a crime, for good reason.

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 04/11/2026 23:21

MrsOvertonsWindow · 04/11/2026 20:55

She's a lesbian and a mother and has written an excellent article in the Times that discusses how criminalising parents for expressing concerns about a child's sexuality / identity is a massive problem.

Society has created the issue by allowing even the youngest of children to be gaslit about their bodies with numerous age inappropriate discussions leading to very young children deciding they must be trans, lesbian gay etc. It's the responsible thing to do to tell a 5 / 7 / 9 year old that deciding on their sexuality or identity is an adult decision and that they can be who they want to be, when they're old enough to understand sexual relationships.

Under the terms of the Conversion Practices draft bill, parents could be criminalised for having these conversations with their primary aged children. She's highlighting the problems.

https://www.thetimes.com/comment/columnists/article/parents-query-child-sexuality-2q97gwwmm

Edited

I've read the article. It's breathtakingly homophobic, transphobic and biphobic.

And yes I do know she's gay.

She claims that being gay is often a phase, is not always lifelong and should not be accepted by parents.

Why the hell not?!

What on Earth does it matter to parents if their child says they're gay? Or if they later have hetero relationships?

Why would anyone discuss such a thing with their child, beyond the usual "does the mean you're having sex, are you being careful, how old are they, are you feeling pressured" talk? If they're underage and not in a relationship, it's absolutely nothing to do with the parent.

Under what circumstances am I meant to care if my of-age child falls in love with women after telling me they prefer men? Perhaps Stock's warning me not to buy too many His & His cake toppers? Or to invest in more pink towels? Because guess what, my children's sexuality is of no interest to me, and I haven't ever planned my household around their preferences.

My eldest is in a relationship with 'someone' but is reluctant to say more - I am totally fine with this. Just tell me who's name's on the wedding details a couple of days before, adding pronouns so I know what to expect (he has friends called things like Star and Phoenix - I've never asked) and that'll be fine with me. He knows and appreciates this.

I could write more about the transphobia but you aren't interested in hearing how trans children are born, not created. Or how no parent 'transes' kids. You're here, you don't want to know, I get that.

Terrorising and harming your child is already illegal. Verbal abuse isn't permitted if it is found to significantly affect a child's life. This Bill closes the loophole which allowed it to be done under the guise of 'conversion therapy' that's all.

And removes an important source of revenue from dangerous charlatans (often religious groups) who claim they can cure being LGBTQIA+. Usually with group bullying, laxatives, imprisonment, berating, physical abuse - and bleach.

Look again at Stock's article. She's denying that being gay is innate and defends homophobic parents. Biphobia is threaded through the whole piece.

Do you believe it's any business of a parent if a child is gay or bi? She clearly does.

The only people criminalised by this Bill, are abusive parents. It exists because children often need defending from them.

And finally: if you genuinely believe in 'transing' then this Bill would ban it. Anti-trans activists failing to celebrate this tells you they know 'transing' is not real.

noblegiraffe · 04/11/2026 23:29

To the people confidently saying that it would only be used in cases of serious abuse.....the same should go for police turning up and arresting people for things they've said on the internet.

Yet we know that the police have turned up and arrested people for saying utterly trivial things on the internet, merely because they have been reported, so why should anyone have any confidence that they wouldn't do the same here?

CoolforKats · 05/11/2026 00:22

JanesLittleGirl · 04/11/2026 23:05

Thanks for this. So the bar is actually so high that the Act will not introduce any offence that isn't already covered by existing legislation. So why introduce it?

As I already said upthread:

"The Conversion Practices Bill is considered necessary by proponents because existing criminal laws (such as assault or physical abuse) do not cover non-physical, psychological, or covert conversion efforts & because targeted bans address the specific intent to change or suppress someone's sexual orientation or gender identity."

CoolforKats · 05/11/2026 00:25

noblegiraffe · 04/11/2026 23:29

To the people confidently saying that it would only be used in cases of serious abuse.....the same should go for police turning up and arresting people for things they've said on the internet.

Yet we know that the police have turned up and arrested people for saying utterly trivial things on the internet, merely because they have been reported, so why should anyone have any confidence that they wouldn't do the same here?

Lapses in following procedural guidelines & the law don't invalidate them.

noblegiraffe · 05/11/2026 00:31

CoolforKats · 05/11/2026 00:25

Lapses in following procedural guidelines & the law don't invalidate them.

Perhaps "procedural lapses" could be anticipated and prevented by much clearer definitions?

CoolforKats · 05/11/2026 00:38

noblegiraffe · 05/11/2026 00:31

Perhaps "procedural lapses" could be anticipated and prevented by much clearer definitions?

It doesn't appear to something that police are using as a defence for breaches in procedure so perhaps its just more a case of garden variety police incompetence like it was at Rotherham. And attributing 'confusion' to incompetence minimises law enforcement culpability….not helpful if that wasn't already obvious.

Heggettypeg · 05/11/2026 02:06

Whether or not the bar is high for being found guilty of conversion therapy (after the gruelling trek through an already overloaded police and criminal justice system), the bar for being innocent but accused will be very low indeed.

It will be anything short of immediate and unconditional affirmation. You only have to read some of the TRA posts on this board to realise that.

quantumbutterfly · 05/11/2026 02:20

MyAmpleSheep · 04/11/2026 21:58

From the Bill:

2. Offence of carrying out an abusive conversion practice on an individual
(1) A person commits an offence if the person carries out an abusive conversion practice on an individual which causes—

  • (a) serious harm to the individual’s physical or mental health, or
  • (b) serious alarm or distress to the individual which has a substantial adverse effect on their usual day-to-day activities.

Who is deciding what "serious" means? Hopefully not a member of the polycule, or Tristan.

Edited

...serious harm to the individual’s physical or mental health, or....

Erm....cross sex hormones, experimental surgery. Surely some practitioners should be having a moment of clarity.

NotBadConsidering · 05/11/2026 03:02

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 04/11/2026 23:21

I've read the article. It's breathtakingly homophobic, transphobic and biphobic.

And yes I do know she's gay.

She claims that being gay is often a phase, is not always lifelong and should not be accepted by parents.

Why the hell not?!

What on Earth does it matter to parents if their child says they're gay? Or if they later have hetero relationships?

Why would anyone discuss such a thing with their child, beyond the usual "does the mean you're having sex, are you being careful, how old are they, are you feeling pressured" talk? If they're underage and not in a relationship, it's absolutely nothing to do with the parent.

Under what circumstances am I meant to care if my of-age child falls in love with women after telling me they prefer men? Perhaps Stock's warning me not to buy too many His & His cake toppers? Or to invest in more pink towels? Because guess what, my children's sexuality is of no interest to me, and I haven't ever planned my household around their preferences.

My eldest is in a relationship with 'someone' but is reluctant to say more - I am totally fine with this. Just tell me who's name's on the wedding details a couple of days before, adding pronouns so I know what to expect (he has friends called things like Star and Phoenix - I've never asked) and that'll be fine with me. He knows and appreciates this.

I could write more about the transphobia but you aren't interested in hearing how trans children are born, not created. Or how no parent 'transes' kids. You're here, you don't want to know, I get that.

Terrorising and harming your child is already illegal. Verbal abuse isn't permitted if it is found to significantly affect a child's life. This Bill closes the loophole which allowed it to be done under the guise of 'conversion therapy' that's all.

And removes an important source of revenue from dangerous charlatans (often religious groups) who claim they can cure being LGBTQIA+. Usually with group bullying, laxatives, imprisonment, berating, physical abuse - and bleach.

Look again at Stock's article. She's denying that being gay is innate and defends homophobic parents. Biphobia is threaded through the whole piece.

Do you believe it's any business of a parent if a child is gay or bi? She clearly does.

The only people criminalised by this Bill, are abusive parents. It exists because children often need defending from them.

And finally: if you genuinely believe in 'transing' then this Bill would ban it. Anti-trans activists failing to celebrate this tells you they know 'transing' is not real.

Look again at Stock's article. She's denying that being gay is innate and defends homophobic parents. Biphobia is threaded through the whole piece.

Where. Copy and paste the lines that do this. Go on.

It is hilariously ironic that you have dramatically accused Stock of being everything-phobic because of your poor comprehension and inherent bias, and also support a bill that would do the same (but with criminal implications) based on the dramatic responses of teenagers and their poor comprehension and inherent bias.

Imagine if a kid hears TPA’s view on what their parent has said to them, and it’s a reasonable, caring approach like Stock has written. “Your mother’s a transphobe! Burn her Call the Police!”

Thank you for demonstrating exactly why the proposed legislation should be binned.

EdithStourton · 05/11/2026 04:09

My eldest is in a relationship with 'someone' but is reluctant to say more - I am totally fine with this. Just tell me who's name's on the wedding details a couple of days before, adding pronouns so I know what to expect
I cannot imagine taking so little interest in who my child is planning to marry.

BunnyBunbunbun · 05/11/2026 06:45

PollyNomial · 04/11/2026 20:29

I don't think anyone chooses their sexuality (I never chose to be straight), so the bit about telling children they've got that wrong is appalling and straight out of s28 homophobia

Yeah, I'm sure lesbian Kathleen Stock believes parents should tell their daughters they are wrong if they come out as lesbians.

Of course, you're twisting the point. As a lesbian, I think it's horrendous when parents criticise their children for being gay. But, I also believe laws that ban or penalise parents from responding in that way are a move towards a totalitarian society. Especially as many parents who initially react badly when their child tells them that he or she is gay eventually come around and fully support their gay child.

But, the big push for a conversion practices ban was never really about the gays. This ban was thought up by people who wanted an unfettered "gender-affirming" policy to be imposed, so that kids and young people who were struggling, who were in a phase of hating themselves, could be told that it's because they are trans and they should go on puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones and have surgery as soon as possible. See Keira Bell, for example, and the horrendous things that were going on at the Tavistock.

The conversion practices ban was precisely intended so that kids could be told that their bodies are wrong and they need to be changed. Many of the young people who get caught up in that are gay. It seems you're fine with destroying the bodies of gay people to make them "straight". Some people really do believe one can choose to be straight through transing.

BunnyBunbunbun · 05/11/2026 06:55

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

CoolforKats · 05/11/2026 06:56

BunnyBunbunbun · 05/11/2026 06:45

Yeah, I'm sure lesbian Kathleen Stock believes parents should tell their daughters they are wrong if they come out as lesbians.

Of course, you're twisting the point. As a lesbian, I think it's horrendous when parents criticise their children for being gay. But, I also believe laws that ban or penalise parents from responding in that way are a move towards a totalitarian society. Especially as many parents who initially react badly when their child tells them that he or she is gay eventually come around and fully support their gay child.

But, the big push for a conversion practices ban was never really about the gays. This ban was thought up by people who wanted an unfettered "gender-affirming" policy to be imposed, so that kids and young people who were struggling, who were in a phase of hating themselves, could be told that it's because they are trans and they should go on puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones and have surgery as soon as possible. See Keira Bell, for example, and the horrendous things that were going on at the Tavistock.

The conversion practices ban was precisely intended so that kids could be told that their bodies are wrong and they need to be changed. Many of the young people who get caught up in that are gay. It seems you're fine with destroying the bodies of gay people to make them "straight". Some people really do believe one can choose to be straight through transing.

In terms of the law, the potentially nefarious intentions of those proposing this change is irrelevant. Ultimately, abusive coercion to change one's belief is already legally unacceptable.

BunnyBunbunbun · 05/11/2026 06:59

CoolforKats · 05/11/2026 00:22

As I already said upthread:

"The Conversion Practices Bill is considered necessary by proponents because existing criminal laws (such as assault or physical abuse) do not cover non-physical, psychological, or covert conversion efforts & because targeted bans address the specific intent to change or suppress someone's sexual orientation or gender identity."

Of course the proponents of this bill would be misrepresenting the situation, because they need to argue why they are proposing this unnecessary legislation. They can't give actual examples, though.

CoolforKats · 05/11/2026 07:02

BunnyBunbunbun · 05/11/2026 06:59

Of course the proponents of this bill would be misrepresenting the situation, because they need to argue why they are proposing this unnecessary legislation. They can't give actual examples, though.

You want them to prove a negative? As in prove something that doesn't exist?
That's for the opposition.

BunnyBunbunbun · 05/11/2026 07:03

CoolforKats · 05/11/2026 06:56

In terms of the law, the potentially nefarious intentions of those proposing this change is irrelevant. Ultimately, abusive coercion to change one's belief is already legally unacceptable.

I don't think it's irrelevant to comment on the origins of this proposed bill if one wishes to, especially when its proponents claim those oppose it are homophobic, when gay people are likely to suffer from it.

Other nefarious aspects of it are that it again yokes gay people with the trans-identified.

CoolforKats · 05/11/2026 07:12

BunnyBunbunbun · 05/11/2026 07:03

I don't think it's irrelevant to comment on the origins of this proposed bill if one wishes to, especially when its proponents claim those oppose it are homophobic, when gay people are likely to suffer from it.

Other nefarious aspects of it are that it again yokes gay people with the trans-identified.

All irrelevant to whether a crime is or isn't occurring.

BunnyBunbunbun · 05/11/2026 07:15

CoolforKats · 05/11/2026 07:12

All irrelevant to whether a crime is or isn't occurring.

Is that the only aspect this bill that we're allowed to discuss on this thread? Unfortunately, if passed, this bill could criminalise simple words. If understanding its origins and intent can help scrap the bill and hence prevent simple words from becoming a crime, then surely that should be mentioned too.

Edit to add: given this bill is piggybacking on gay people in order to be passed and trying to get so-called "gay conversion practices" banned in order to have unfettered transing, surely it's relevant to point out that, rather than helping gay people, gay youth in particular are going to end up transed because of this bill in an effort to stop them from being gay.

CoolforKats · 05/11/2026 07:18

BunnyBunbunbun · 05/11/2026 07:15

Is that the only aspect this bill that we're allowed to discuss on this thread? Unfortunately, if passed, this bill could criminalise simple words. If understanding its origins and intent can help scrap the bill and hence prevent simple words from becoming a crime, then surely that should be mentioned too.

Edit to add: given this bill is piggybacking on gay people in order to be passed and trying to get so-called "gay conversion practices" banned in order to have unfettered transing, surely it's relevant to point out that, rather than helping gay people, gay youth in particular are going to end up transed because of this bill in an effort to stop them from being gay.

Edited

Saying something is irrelevant isn't the same as saying you can't discuss it. By all means knock yourself out but it doesn't change the fundamental issue which is determining whether a crime is occuring.

noblegiraffe · 05/11/2026 07:33

CoolforKats · 05/11/2026 00:38

It doesn't appear to something that police are using as a defence for breaches in procedure so perhaps its just more a case of garden variety police incompetence like it was at Rotherham. And attributing 'confusion' to incompetence minimises law enforcement culpability….not helpful if that wasn't already obvious.

So you agree that the police can't be trusted to implement this policy properly and therefore parents are right to be worried that they might be arrested for disagreeing with their child?