Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Professor/Author Kathleen Stock on proposed "conversion therapy ban"

80 replies

VeryConcernedDad · 04/11/2026 20:23

When did we reach the point where parents might need the state's permission to disagree with their own children? Speaking on Times Radio, Professor Kathleen Stock raises a fundamental question about the proposed Conversion Practices Bill: should a mother or father risk criminal prosecution simply for questioning their child's beliefs about their sex or sexuality? There is a world of difference between abuse and a parent saying, out of love and concern, "I don't think you're right." We can protect children from genuine abuse without criminalising ordinary parental disagreement. The family home should not become another place where free speech requires government approval.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ProfessoressaSazzasez · 05/11/2026 21:40

CoolforKats · 04/11/2026 22:26

The law includes ‘attempts to change or deny “gender identity”’ That’s undefined, is a new concept in law, & many of us don't believe we have one.

You could say the same about religious beliefs but that's irrelevant to whether an abusive coercive practice to change a belief is taking place.

Are you seriously claiming that religious beliefs are a new concept in law?

May I introduce you to the whole history of these islamds from c1450 to, say, the lifting of the bar on Catholics, nonconformists, Jews & atheists from attending university - or even later.

But you’re quite correct in seeing ‘gender identity’ as a counterfactual unevidenced religious belief.

This bill would make it compulsory to act as if you believed in it, under threat of litigation from believers.

Exactly analogous to requiring everyone to pretend they believe in the Apostolic Succession, on pain of prosecution.

ProfessoressaSazzasez · 05/11/2026 21:29

CoolforKats · 04/11/2026 22:26

The law includes ‘attempts to change or deny “gender identity”’ That’s undefined, is a new concept in law, & many of us don't believe we have one.

You could say the same about religious beliefs but that's irrelevant to whether an abusive coercive practice to change a belief is taking place.

So are you making it illegal for religious people to doorknock? To deliver leaflets? To offer catechism classes ?

UtopiaPlanitia · 05/11/2026 14:40

MrsOvertonsWindow · 05/11/2026 10:05

Interestingly, the appalling drafting of the bill has also resulted in there being considerable risk to organisations and businesses due to corporate liability. Lawyers are pointing out that employers could face vexatious criminal allegations as clause 5 of the bill imposes wide ranging and draconian criminal liability risks for employers. And we know how many vexatious claims come from certain transactivists,

We are quite rightly focused on children and families but interesting to see employers now raising concerns.

Tanya De Grunwald's HR podcast did an episode discussing the issues arising from the proposed legislation for businesses and membership organisations, as well as for employees:

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://youtu.be/mB6xxHTazC4

MrsOvertonsWindow · 05/11/2026 14:24

TrappedByThisDesk · 05/11/2026 14:10

@MrsOvertonsWindow does it give a definition of gender identity in the bill? If not, as soon as it is tested in court a definition will be needed.

No it doesn't define gender identity or transgender identity - which in terms of the criminal law is a major failing. Criminal barrister Dennis Kavanagh points out this will lead to both parties in any criminal case and the jury having to engage in political discussions / disagreements.

It also doesn't define abuse - given that some consider wrong sex pronouns to be literal genocide, the failure to clarify the term again has the potential for major problems.

Link below. If you're on X it's worth looking at his contributions - he gave very clear evidence to the committee outlining all the problems that the poor drafting of the bill creates.

https://x.com/Jebadoo2/status/2117568001381982711

Dennis Noel Kavanagh profile picture

Dennis Noel Kavanagh (@Jebadoo2) on X

The government are proposing to criminalise abuse but refusing to define what that means in criminal law. That is a recipe for chaos, tyranny and misery for parents.

https://x.com/Jebadoo2/status/2117568001381982711

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · 05/11/2026 14:23

TrappedByThisDesk · 05/11/2026 14:10

@MrsOvertonsWindow does it give a definition of gender identity in the bill? If not, as soon as it is tested in court a definition will be needed.

Yes, many of us have been saying this for years now. There is no definition other than what the person who says it, feels it, or imposes it on others, means at the time they say it, feel it, or impose it. We've been asking for a definition that can hold up in court. We're still waiting. Yet, the Bill is still being proposed. Go figure.

As we've seen in many a tribunal, a lot of people would rather be sued later, than think about what they are putting into law first. Probably because they know it's easier to write a law than to make it work, and a lot of women won't have the means to sue later.

Imdunfer · 05/11/2026 14:16

RoyalCorgi · 05/11/2026 10:53

When I was younger, I was sceptical about the idea that same-sex attraction could be a "phase". My view then was that people tend to know from quite a young age whether they are attracted to the opposite sex or the same sex.

I've changed my mind slightly on this. For one thing, a surprising number of previously heterosexual women enter into same-sex relationships when they're older.

For another, the number of teenage girls calling themselves lesbian has been implausibly high in recent years. A recent study in the US found that the number of ninth-grade girls (ie age 14-15) describing themselves as lesbian fell from 30% in 2021 to 17% in 2025.

That's still much higher than in the general population - the last UK census found about 2% of the population identifying as gay or lesbian - but it's a dramatic fall nonetheless. That certainly suggests a strong element of social contagion amongst teenagers when it comes to their sexuality.

I'd also point out, wearily, that modern gender activists endlessly talk about how gender and sexuality are "fluid" rather than fixed categories. If that's the case, then it follows from their own logic that a child who describes herself as lesbian aged 14 may not do so two years later.

When it was routine for upper and upper middle class girls to go to boarding school, the phenomenon of the female to female "teenage crush" was well known, and it was just as well known that most of them grew out of it was soon as they started mixing with boys.

TrappedByThisDesk · 05/11/2026 14:10

@MrsOvertonsWindow does it give a definition of gender identity in the bill? If not, as soon as it is tested in court a definition will be needed.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 05/11/2026 14:03

TrappedByThisDesk · 05/11/2026 13:48

Is there any other legislation or proposed legislation that uses the term 'gender identity'?
Does this proposed legislation give a definition of 'gender identity'?

The bill is a trojan horse to put "gender identity", the nonsense non binary and presumably the 100 other delusional identities on the statute book.

Once it's enshrined in criminal law then it gives this tiny unrepresentative group in society even more power over the rest of society. More power than they've previously acquired by intimidation, coercion and bullying.

That's why it's being promoted so vigorously by those with an evident history of bullying and intimdating others.

TrappedByThisDesk · 05/11/2026 13:48

Is there any other legislation or proposed legislation that uses the term 'gender identity'?
Does this proposed legislation give a definition of 'gender identity'?

SquelchyFelch · 05/11/2026 13:29

The bill also makes possible a hypothetical situation where simultaneous allegations are made about the same person from opposing angles ie a child could claim a parent was denying the child’s trans identity while the parent could claim the child’s friends/therapist/teacher were seeking to convert the child’s sexuality.

It really is so incomprehensible when the law is based on feelings and subjective stuff. Crazy times.

SquelchyFelch · 05/11/2026 12:44

RoyalCorgi · 05/11/2026 10:53

When I was younger, I was sceptical about the idea that same-sex attraction could be a "phase". My view then was that people tend to know from quite a young age whether they are attracted to the opposite sex or the same sex.

I've changed my mind slightly on this. For one thing, a surprising number of previously heterosexual women enter into same-sex relationships when they're older.

For another, the number of teenage girls calling themselves lesbian has been implausibly high in recent years. A recent study in the US found that the number of ninth-grade girls (ie age 14-15) describing themselves as lesbian fell from 30% in 2021 to 17% in 2025.

That's still much higher than in the general population - the last UK census found about 2% of the population identifying as gay or lesbian - but it's a dramatic fall nonetheless. That certainly suggests a strong element of social contagion amongst teenagers when it comes to their sexuality.

I'd also point out, wearily, that modern gender activists endlessly talk about how gender and sexuality are "fluid" rather than fixed categories. If that's the case, then it follows from their own logic that a child who describes herself as lesbian aged 14 may not do so two years later.

I think this is really interesting, the fluidity of sexuality and how it can change through our lives. I think of sexuality as a spectrum between fully hetero to fully homo and where we sit on the spectrum will change over time and due to our environment and experiences. I know mine own certainly has.

However, if sexuality isn't necessarily fixed categories but more like leaky containers, how do we protect the rights of LGB people from those wishing to infiltrate or coerce them into accepting sex with someone they're not attracted to?

I'd go for improving young people's understanding of consent and what a good relationship looks and feels like. Limiting access to porn. Encouragement and acceptance of free and fluid gender expression without the need to label. Widening the bandwidth of everyone.

SquelchyFelch · 05/11/2026 12:29

My son came out to me as gay when he was 9, which apart from saying something along the lines of 'that's nice dear' I haven't felt the need to talk much to him about. His sexuality doesn't effect how I care from him or what I think of him. My main concerns at the time were about him pigeonholing himself at a point that he would be unlikely to actually experience sexual attraction. However, from research it seems that children that age can have a sense of who they are attracted to, which reassured me. I was also concerned about how 'out & proud' he was at school, challenging homophobia (which of course I deplore) but inevitably making himself a potential bully's target. He's navigated it all fantastically so far.

But the biggest concern I have for him, which the bill makes so much more worrying, is the potential for him to be influenced by trans ideology and start to think of himself as actually a girl. In the past 6 months (he's now 13) he has started expressing himself with his hair, the clothes he wears (emo style), some eyeliner, platformed goth-style shoes etc. None of which I have any issue with at all. But his peers are now heavily influencial, including with high rates of self-harm (or experimenting with it) amongst his friendship group. If he is so easily influenced on things like self-harm, how easy would it be for friends/other influences to start suggesting he could be trans?

There are girls in his friendship group who have gone through a lesbian phase and out the other side already. Which of course they should be entitled to do, but trying to avoid your child putting limiting labels on themselves via their sexuality or gender expression/identity is definitely not something which should be potentially criminalised.

I should be able to have exploratory. sensitive conversations about this with him, both his sexuality and his gender identity, if he thinks he has one. However, he is also very volatile and can quickly get to the point of screaming how he hates me and I'm terrible if I ask him to clear up his room or do his homework. Would I be coercively controlling him, as HJ suggests, by limiting his screen time or hypothetically telling him I don't think he's a girl?

RoyalCorgi · 05/11/2026 10:53

When I was younger, I was sceptical about the idea that same-sex attraction could be a "phase". My view then was that people tend to know from quite a young age whether they are attracted to the opposite sex or the same sex.

I've changed my mind slightly on this. For one thing, a surprising number of previously heterosexual women enter into same-sex relationships when they're older.

For another, the number of teenage girls calling themselves lesbian has been implausibly high in recent years. A recent study in the US found that the number of ninth-grade girls (ie age 14-15) describing themselves as lesbian fell from 30% in 2021 to 17% in 2025.

That's still much higher than in the general population - the last UK census found about 2% of the population identifying as gay or lesbian - but it's a dramatic fall nonetheless. That certainly suggests a strong element of social contagion amongst teenagers when it comes to their sexuality.

I'd also point out, wearily, that modern gender activists endlessly talk about how gender and sexuality are "fluid" rather than fixed categories. If that's the case, then it follows from their own logic that a child who describes herself as lesbian aged 14 may not do so two years later.

NotBadConsidering · 05/11/2026 10:43

And we know how many vexatious claims come from certain trans activists

Exactly. Look how quickly one of our resident TRAs accused Stock of the sort of action the law would criminalise. And TRAs have reported people to the police for tweets.

noblegiraffe · 05/11/2026 10:41

CoolforKats · 05/11/2026 07:38

By this logic they can't be trusted with implementing any law given their consistent bumbling & as such all laws should be 'canned'.

Do you even understand what you’re suggesting here?

No, that doesn’t follow. The absolute farce around the policing of non-crime hate incidents has led to them being abandoned because the whole thing ended up being seriously abused. This hasn’t led to police no longer being able to investigate murders as you fear. It’s not a slippery slope to lawlessness to abandon or tighten up poor legislation.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 05/11/2026 10:05

Interestingly, the appalling drafting of the bill has also resulted in there being considerable risk to organisations and businesses due to corporate liability. Lawyers are pointing out that employers could face vexatious criminal allegations as clause 5 of the bill imposes wide ranging and draconian criminal liability risks for employers. And we know how many vexatious claims come from certain transactivists,

We are quite rightly focused on children and families but interesting to see employers now raising concerns.

Imdunfer · 05/11/2026 09:13

Going back to the bill, so long as the affirmation model persists, it will also criminalise any therapist who tries to lead any person to understand why they might feel that they are in the wrong body if that person becomes upset as a result of the therapy. And therapy will often, even normally, result in periods of being upset, it's part of the process.

It will seal in stone forever the "affirm is the only way" model of dealing with gender dysphoria. And that would be an appalling thing to do, especially for the children.

HoppityBun · 05/11/2026 09:13

HoppityBun · 05/11/2026 09:10

Yes, and people provide sources from time to time. If you Google something like “Peter Tatchell supported underage sex“ you’ll get a whole list of references including to his own Peter Tatchell foundation where he wriggles his way out of it..

The main issue seems to be a letter that he wrote to the guardian in 1997. I don’t know if this will be permitted or allowed through:

Yes, I am not allowed to post a copy of the letter. But there is a letter that he wrote to the Guardian in 1997 where he said that not all sex with children is unwanted, harmful or abusive. If you Google around for Peter Tatchell letter to Guardian 1997, you will find it.

HoppityBun · 05/11/2026 09:10

Imdunfer · 05/11/2026 09:02

I sometimes think I am dreaming when I see Tatchell now as he bears no relationship to his activist younger self. I was sure when he was younger he was a supporter of under age sex. Is that documented anywhere credible, do you know?

Yes, and people provide sources from time to time. If you Google something like “Peter Tatchell supported underage sex“ you’ll get a whole list of references including to his own Peter Tatchell foundation where he wriggles his way out of it..

The main issue seems to be a letter that he wrote to the guardian in 1997. I don’t know if this will be permitted or allowed through:

Imdunfer · 05/11/2026 09:02

MrsOvertonsWindow · 05/11/2026 08:54

Akua Reindorf KC pointed out some of his "inaccuracies" :

"You have made this up out of thin air
@PeterTatchell
Why? The [draft] law does not say “parents are entitled to have conversations” Nor does it say anything about parents believing their child is "perverted, sick, abnormal, unnatural, depraved, broken and damaged”

It appears there's a group of men in society very excited at the thought of potentially criminalising family interactions. And are in support of a bill that would allow any random to make an allegation against a parent and initiate a criminal investigation and subsequent SS section 47 investigation.

Tatchell weighing in is very revealing given his evidenced history of promoting abusive adults having sex with young children as "acceptable".

I sometimes think I am dreaming when I see Tatchell now as he bears no relationship to his activist younger self. I was sure when he was younger he was a supporter of under age sex. Is that documented anywhere credible, do you know?

MrsOvertonsWindow · 05/11/2026 08:54

Imdunfer · 05/11/2026 08:29

Peter Tatchell was on TV last night defending this bill. One of his main arguments was that a similar law is already in place in Australia and NZ and in 2 years not one single parent has been prosecuted.

He is conveniently forgetting, I think, just how embedded in trans culture those countries are, where a lesbian can be fined for blocking a female identified male from joining her lesbian club. Where a female in court facing her rapist can commit a crime by calling him "he".

What parent in that kind of environment would dare tell a trans child they can't change sex?

He was also keeping firmly to the line that this is about trying to convert gay people, but we all know that this is actually being driven by the trans lobby who want very young children affirmed by their parents as being born in the wrong body.

Akua Reindorf KC pointed out some of his "inaccuracies" :

"You have made this up out of thin air
@PeterTatchell
Why? The [draft] law does not say “parents are entitled to have conversations” Nor does it say anything about parents believing their child is "perverted, sick, abnormal, unnatural, depraved, broken and damaged”

It appears there's a group of men in society very excited at the thought of potentially criminalising family interactions. And are in support of a bill that would allow any random to make an allegation against a parent and initiate a criminal investigation and subsequent SS section 47 investigation.

Tatchell weighing in is very revealing given his evidenced history of promoting abusive adults having sex with young children as "acceptable".

JoanOgden · 05/11/2026 08:44

"Verbal abuse isn't permitted if it is found to significantly affect a child's life. This Bill closes the loophole which allowed it to be done under the guise of 'conversion therapy' that's all."

What loophole is this? I don't think there are any mentions of conversion therapy in the existing law. Can you link to the law you're talking about which creates this apparent loophole?

I'm not in favour of parents or therapists being homophobic (or transphobic, in the genuine sense of the word), towards kids or otherwise. I'm not in favour of adultery either, but I don't think that should be criminalised either. The criminal law is not the right place for this stuff.

Imdunfer · 05/11/2026 08:40

NotBadConsidering · 05/11/2026 08:36

Tatchell is pretty stupid, so I suspect he has absolutely no idea how medical practitioners in Victoria are terrified of offering anything other than an affirmation service lest they be accused of conversion therapy. He will also have no idea how some practitioners have actually been reported to the health boards in various states for opposing medical treatments.

https://www.genderclinicnews.com/p/witch-hunt

Watching him, I'm pretty sure he knows. He's developed some political skill since his student activist days. He presents now as the adult, reasonable face of the gender debate, but it looks fake to me.

NotBadConsidering · 05/11/2026 08:36

Imdunfer · 05/11/2026 08:29

Peter Tatchell was on TV last night defending this bill. One of his main arguments was that a similar law is already in place in Australia and NZ and in 2 years not one single parent has been prosecuted.

He is conveniently forgetting, I think, just how embedded in trans culture those countries are, where a lesbian can be fined for blocking a female identified male from joining her lesbian club. Where a female in court facing her rapist can commit a crime by calling him "he".

What parent in that kind of environment would dare tell a trans child they can't change sex?

He was also keeping firmly to the line that this is about trying to convert gay people, but we all know that this is actually being driven by the trans lobby who want very young children affirmed by their parents as being born in the wrong body.

Tatchell is pretty stupid, so I suspect he has absolutely no idea how medical practitioners in Victoria are terrified of offering anything other than an affirmation service lest they be accused of conversion therapy. He will also have no idea how some practitioners have actually been reported to the health boards in various states for opposing medical treatments.

https://www.genderclinicnews.com/p/witch-hunt

Witch hunt

Clinicians who point out the flaws and dangers of 'gender-affirming care' are hounded and harried

https://www.genderclinicnews.com/p/witch-hunt

RareGoalsVerge · 05/11/2026 08:32

CoolforKats · 04/11/2026 21:35

The point you are missing is the legal bar is a lot higher than a simple disagreement. There's needs to be evidence of serious harmful abuse that's consistent with what's already established in law.

Anything that is actual serious harmful abuse is already illegal under existing legislation. There is no need for anything new to stop real abusive practices. The Bill is designed to widen the definitions in line with the TRA belief that "having and expressing opinions" should be treated the same as hatred, death-threats and telling someone they don't exist and have no rights.