This is replying to Lacksie's long reply [thank you !]
Lacksie · Yesterday 13:53
Page 20 | Sandie Peggie has lost her case against the nursing union. | Mumsnet
to my post
MarieDeGournay · Yesterday 13:33
I'm moving it over here so as not to take up more space on the SP thread.
Lacksie That there is one clear, consistent, scientific definition of woman/female. Which one — chromosomes, gametes, gonads, hormones, anatomy? They don’t always agree
MarieDeGournay I'd always have picked 'chromosomes' in the past, but I learn from people who are more knowledgeable than me, so I'll go for 'chromosomes+designed to produce large gametes'.
That being verifiable makes a definition “more true” than another. But plenty of definitions are verifiable — chromosomes, gonads, birth certificate, legal sex — and they don’t all pick out the same people. If verifiability were the test, they’d all be equally “true”. So how does that make any sense?
It makes sense if only people with XX chromosomes/large gamete potential [XX/LG] is defined as 'female/woman', because that is something that can be established in an objective way. The other things you mention - birth certificate, legal sex - are not definitions of sex, they are things that that record sex, i.e. whether a person is XX/LG or XY/SG.
The concept of 'Single Source [or Point] of Truth' is used in data organisation to ensure that everybody is working from the same data, to ensure consistency and accuracy and to increase efficiency.
The absence of a pragmatic SSoT based on biological sex results in the kind of expensive and time-consuming inconsistencies and inefficiencies we've seen in the past couple of decades.
That your definition of the word "woman" is the only one that counts. This is the entire dispute. Why have you assumed the answer?
That's the whole point of my post: explaining why I believe the standard scientific definition of the word 'woman' is the only one that is valid.
I haven't assumed the answer, I've explained my rationale for it.
That every alternative definition lacks clarity and consistency. Have you examined them? Demonstrate why.
'Demonstrate why' -should I wrote on only one side of the paper and show my workings?😄
I've encountered several definitions of 'woman' that use phrases like 'feminine essence' 'female brain in male body' 'trans woman' 'sociological sex as opposed to biological sex' 'gender identity' 'because I say so'... and they are unclear and inconsistent.
That the definition is “established” and there is consensus. If so, why is it in front of the Supreme Court, Parliament and the tribunals? A definition under active legal dispute is contested, not established.
Why was it in front of the Supreme Court? because a small number of people want to replace the established meaning of the world 'woman' with a range of alternative meanings, and it had such potential far-reaching consequences for equality legislation that it was taken to the highest court to decide on the accepted meaning of 'woman'. Which it did. It ruled that where the law protects the rights of women, 'woman' meant 'biological woman'.
That "works fine for the majority" is the definitive test of the value of a definition. Every exclusion works fine for the people it doesn’t exclude.
That's how language works as a form of communication: a word has to carry the same meaning to a majority for it to be useful as a word.
A word that defines a group excludes anything that is not in that group - the group 'caravans' excludes motorbikes; the group 'apples' excludes oranges, the group 'women' [XX/LG] excludes men - they have characteristics in common, but they are different enough for language to have developed separate words for them, as well as shared words like 'vehicles' 'fruit' and 'humans'.
That majority usage settles meaning, but minority usage doesn’t count. Which is it? Every change in a word’s meaning started with a minority using it differently. Also you haven't established that your definition is the "majority" one - you've just asserted it.
Language normally changes through the wear-and-tear of centuries of usage, not by artificially altered the established meaning of a word to include the opposite meaning in the space of a few years. Apart from the word 'quiz' which may have been introduced overnight by Richard Daly chalking it on walls around Dublin
That a group being “very small” reduces the weight of its interests. Where did that principle come from?
See above about how words work as a means of communication - there has to be an agreed meaning for the basic transmit/receive function of language to work. A very small group asserting that a word should change its meaning significantly, in a very short space of time, with no rational justification for the change doesn't carry much weight in how a language group use and understand words like 'woman'. I wonder how many English speakers use the word 'women' to mean 'women and some men who claim to be women'.
I wonder how many English speakers are even aware of a niche movement to alter the meaning of the word woman - your guess is as good as mine, but my guess is 'not a lot'.
That disputing what a word covers is “post-factual.” Which fact has anyone denied?
The fact that there is an established definition of the word 'woman' which is based on verifiable fact.
That using language more inclusively than you want to use it is “disproportionate.” Disproportionate to what? You haven’t named a single cost to the majority.
The obvious cost to the majority is the loss of a word to describe half the human race. The more subtle linguistic cost is the idea that a very small minority can seek to unilaterally enforce a change in the meaning of words as used by the majority. That's disproportionate.
“I believe that makes it unfair and unacceptable” — so the conclusion rests on your belief. Which is where we started.
Well, quite! Your conclusion rests on your belief. My conclusion rests on my belief, which rest on thought and reflection and study and knowledge and an interest in words and language[s]. I don't believe that all definitions of a word, in this case 'woman', are equally valid, and I explained why.