It's not about 'anger' it's about opinions based on facts and observations. For me this includes observations on this thread. So you don't have to go too far back.
What I find particularly offensive is when women's observations and evidence-based opinions are reduced to a problem with their 'feelings'. No. That's behaving in the same bloody way the man who identify as women do.
A bit like when men say 'I'm a woman' and then any woman who says 'well you are a man in material reality' is told it's HER feelings that are the problem and she's 'angry' and 'bigoted' for pointing out reality and needs to 'reframe her trauma' or some such crap. See the Darlington nurses. See Sandie Peggie.
Personally I think this is a pattern of behaviour which is insidious misogyny within society particularly affecting those most disadvantaged and so I think we need to call it out every time.
I'm going to talk about myself although I haven't been personally tagged. But Tinsel has and I'm going to say framing this issue about her (assumed) 'feelings' for a transwidow is an extra level of shitty, in my opinion.
I'm personally not offended or angry any more than I would be if I saw anything else I thought was evidence of a lack of credibility or poor behaviour.
Women - many women not just one - have sat on their opinions for years. Given MN is basically a site set up for women to share opinions openly, that's actually pretty big and I've personally done that because yes, even people who've behaved appallingly or dishonestly in the past or were TRAs should be given a second chance if in good faith.
It's only now that Jo P has come on here and asked us fairly directly to buy a book that we've said anything at all, and honestly not that much, and we've, within this thread, been accused of 'doxxing' or 'trolling' (which no-one's done) and told it's all about our feelings.
No. It's not.
I'm not buying this memoir for the same reason I won't be buying Prince Harry's memoir. Because I'm interested in 'the truth' not any individual person's interpretation of such. As the late Queen said 'some recollections may vary' and I think this sums up this thread.
Anyone reading this can take or leave my opinion. I don't care which you do. I don't care if you decide Sarah is more credible than me. That's fine.
Anyone who says it's my 'feelings' that are the problem, then actually that suggests to me you have a problem with ANY woman getting a voice and actually find it really tricky when normal women - without power, without status - disagree with you. Personally I think it's a strength of Mumsnet. FWS met here. I've been handed my arse on here many times, I think it's made me a better person.
I wish Sarah luck with her future endeavours and the yoga sessions and retreats.