Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

News about Sarah Summers and Phoenix Publications

310 replies

ProfJoPhoenix · 02/11/2026 18:13

Dear all

It gives me ENORMOUS pleasure to let you know that early in 2027, Phoenix Publications will be publishing Sarah Summers memoir (called Being a girl and other dangerous things).

@iamsarah has had an extraordinary life and write beautifully.

Please spread the word far and wide and please visit Phoenix Publications Ltd website for updates and news of how to pre-order.

The book is a blinder!

Best
Jo Phoenix

OP posts:
womendeserveequalhumanrights · 04/11/2026 13:00

TinselAngel · 04/11/2026 12:55

I think we’ve all done well not to comment on the utterly incompetent attempts at anonymity until now, due to the court case etc.

Yes, this.

womendeserveequalhumanrights · 04/11/2026 13:05

Shedmistress · 04/11/2026 12:39

Just a quick note that it was the Author's publishing company that posted this thread, not anyone from here trying to doxx anyone.

Nothing would have even been said if this thread hadn't appeared.

Yes, a very good point.

TinselAngel · 04/11/2026 13:07

womendeserveequalhumanrights · 04/11/2026 13:00

Yes, this.

Particularly as I understand some women thought it was a deliberate attempt to self sabotage the court case.

Shedmistress · 04/11/2026 13:08

theilltemperedmonster · 04/11/2026 12:52

Well, yes, clearly OP doesn't mind this username being linked to her irl identity, but wouldn't want it linked to her other username if that might mean her mother finding out that she (as otherusername) had said something disobliging about her on another thread (example for illustrative purposes only!).

And not one person has indeed linked to another user name, right?

theilltemperedmonster · 04/11/2026 13:24

Shedmistress · 04/11/2026 13:08

And not one person has indeed linked to another user name, right?

The allegation seemed to be that OP was using one username to attack women whilst simultaneously using another username to gouge them for cash. She offered to DM username history but it was rejected on the basis that she might have created more than one account. I'm not sure I can see any way for her to satisfy the accusers. But there's clearly a lot below the surface that I have no hope of working out.

theilltemperedmonster · 04/11/2026 13:38

Apologies, I keep referring to OP when I actually meant @IamSarah .

IamSarah · 04/11/2026 13:42

Waiting for the next accusation that this entire thread is me sock puppeting from different email addresses 🙄

I’m not really sure how to defend the allegations of posting from multiple accounts other than to repeat that they aren’t true.

Mumsnet takes this stuff seriously so please do feel free to report me if you don’t believe it.

Floisme · 04/11/2026 13:47

theilltemperedmonster · 04/11/2026 13:38

Apologies, I keep referring to OP when I actually meant @IamSarah .

I did the same in my post - made at 11.00am so far too late to edit

StSpiridian · 04/11/2026 18:19

Thanks to all the posters on this difficult thread, including Sarah. I am still digesting it.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 04/11/2026 18:26

Shedmistress · 04/11/2026 12:54

If they wanted to convince lurkers, what are they convincing them about as they never ever answer what it is that changes to make a man into a woman? It is just all incoherent nonsense.

I think it is more about it being the one place they had absolute power. Every report was 'transphobic' and would be deleted and people banned if they reported a few in close succession. They are always just so utterly annoying nonsense merchants and people who responded 'don't be so fucking stupid' or the like, were gone like the wind.

Yes. Those type of posters (not talking about anyone specifically) are usually a particular type of person. Most people plop some nonsense down they’ve copied and pasted and run away because they know they can’t defend it or it’s too much hassle, too upsetting, whatever. The disruptive posters on MN (on all boards, and it’s the same on all social media platforms) actively like winding people up for the thrill of it. And enjoy the control, as you say.

ZIGGY7 · 04/11/2026 23:32

BucketBoots · 03/11/2026 19:39

I was at the WPUK meeting which @IamSarah attended as a TRA reporter. She and her friends sniggered at the back and I think she may have also asked a question. They left before the end of the meeting.

She reported at the time either on here or on her blog (it was a really long time ago so I can’t remember details) that she was spat at or similar.

It was an egregious lie. And she was posting on here under multiple accounts.

Many women were banned or sanctioned for questioning this over the years and most of us have kept publicly kept our mouths shut. We’ve heard about the crowdfund for a case that never went to trial, the business venture which has been repeatedly advertised on MN explicitly against the rules (and yes, I know they’re supposed to be about healing women but it is still a business), and now the book.

I’ll probably be banned for this post but I don’t care. If ‘Sarah’ is really coming clean, then she needs to own all the damage she has done properly. ‘I was a TRA and now I’ve seen the light’ doesn’t cut it. Especially not when your wife is still fully on board.

Well said.

IamSarah · 05/11/2026 07:33

I’ve never denied that I posted things in the past that I now regret, and I’ve apologised for those. I understand why people might remember me negatively.

I don’t want to deny things I genuinely said or did, but some things are being attributed to me that I didn’t do or say.

I’ve been honest about changing my views, and I accept that not everyone will trust me. But I don’t think continuing to apologise or explain myself is going to help.

Floisme · 05/11/2026 08:34

Can I suggest two things @IamSarah that might help move this forward, at least as far as I'm concerned?

  1. You could be a bit more forthright about the kind of things you posted on this board in the past. I know you want to protect previous identities and I understand that but it feels like we're getting a very broad-brush, 'Sorry I was an idiot' kind of explanation which could mean anything.
  2. A lot of women kept silent about your previous behaviour on this board while your court case was going on. A 'thank you' to them wouldn't go amiss. My apologies if you've don't that already but I think I've read the whole thread and I've not seen it.
Floisme · 05/11/2026 08:42

Sorry too late to edit: ‘My apologies if you’ve done that already.’

womendeserveequalhumanrights · 05/11/2026 08:54

theilltemperedmonster · 04/11/2026 13:24

The allegation seemed to be that OP was using one username to attack women whilst simultaneously using another username to gouge them for cash. She offered to DM username history but it was rejected on the basis that she might have created more than one account. I'm not sure I can see any way for her to satisfy the accusers. But there's clearly a lot below the surface that I have no hope of working out.

I don't think anyone wants a forensic account of past posting history or 'satisfaction'. There are good reasons you can namechange on here and overall that's a huge benefit to the women that need a site like this the most.

What some women who've posted here for years are pointing out is that they have observed a pattern of behaviour and they want to share their experience / opinion with others.

Enabling other women to make an informed choice about any purchases is surely a good thing? That's one of the things MN is for - to share experiences. I find it's one of the most beneficial parts of MN. Especially for women who don't have lots of money. MN is open to all, remember, including working class women. That's a positive too.

The OP here is someone lots of people have respect for asking women to 'spread the word' (provide free advertising) and we're asked to buy the book 'I would strongly encourage all of you to buy the book once it is out and make up your own minds'. Knowing that lots of women on here really don't have much spare cash - cost of living etc - I think this pretty strong series of statements is what has pushed trusted names to comment and question.

I think some of the questions asked have produced some really helpful answers from Sarah about Sisters Heal, and useful clarity for those who may want to consider donating or buying the book for charitable purposes.

Anyone who's been on FWR for any period of time knows that you can't expect the very intelligent women on here to take things on trust. There's an expectation of providing evidence, demonstrating consistency, credibility, having good arguments and good answers to questions. That, in my opinion, is one of the best attributes of FWR, and has made me much better and producing evidence-based arguments. It has tripped me up more than once and made me change my opinion on things (though I never thought humans could change sex).

It does mean that any OP that pretty much asks women to buy something is going to get questions. Anyone who's spent 5 mins on here should know that.

Generally speaking people on FWR are very generous to those who do change their mind, and they have been in this case too - evidenced by the fact these concerns are only being raised now when there's a direct plug to buy a book, which of course was not by Sarah.

Everyone can make up their own mind, it would be a sad world where people who don't have money or power are not allowed to give their opinion about why other women such as them should perhaps equally consider NOT buying anything that is being promoted.

TinselAngel · 05/11/2026 09:18

womendeserveequalhumanrights · 05/11/2026 08:54

I don't think anyone wants a forensic account of past posting history or 'satisfaction'. There are good reasons you can namechange on here and overall that's a huge benefit to the women that need a site like this the most.

What some women who've posted here for years are pointing out is that they have observed a pattern of behaviour and they want to share their experience / opinion with others.

Enabling other women to make an informed choice about any purchases is surely a good thing? That's one of the things MN is for - to share experiences. I find it's one of the most beneficial parts of MN. Especially for women who don't have lots of money. MN is open to all, remember, including working class women. That's a positive too.

The OP here is someone lots of people have respect for asking women to 'spread the word' (provide free advertising) and we're asked to buy the book 'I would strongly encourage all of you to buy the book once it is out and make up your own minds'. Knowing that lots of women on here really don't have much spare cash - cost of living etc - I think this pretty strong series of statements is what has pushed trusted names to comment and question.

I think some of the questions asked have produced some really helpful answers from Sarah about Sisters Heal, and useful clarity for those who may want to consider donating or buying the book for charitable purposes.

Anyone who's been on FWR for any period of time knows that you can't expect the very intelligent women on here to take things on trust. There's an expectation of providing evidence, demonstrating consistency, credibility, having good arguments and good answers to questions. That, in my opinion, is one of the best attributes of FWR, and has made me much better and producing evidence-based arguments. It has tripped me up more than once and made me change my opinion on things (though I never thought humans could change sex).

It does mean that any OP that pretty much asks women to buy something is going to get questions. Anyone who's spent 5 mins on here should know that.

Generally speaking people on FWR are very generous to those who do change their mind, and they have been in this case too - evidenced by the fact these concerns are only being raised now when there's a direct plug to buy a book, which of course was not by Sarah.

Everyone can make up their own mind, it would be a sad world where people who don't have money or power are not allowed to give their opinion about why other women such as them should perhaps equally consider NOT buying anything that is being promoted.

Can confirm have not received thanks.

theilltemperedmonster · 05/11/2026 10:44

womendeserveequalhumanrights · 05/11/2026 08:54

I don't think anyone wants a forensic account of past posting history or 'satisfaction'. There are good reasons you can namechange on here and overall that's a huge benefit to the women that need a site like this the most.

What some women who've posted here for years are pointing out is that they have observed a pattern of behaviour and they want to share their experience / opinion with others.

Enabling other women to make an informed choice about any purchases is surely a good thing? That's one of the things MN is for - to share experiences. I find it's one of the most beneficial parts of MN. Especially for women who don't have lots of money. MN is open to all, remember, including working class women. That's a positive too.

The OP here is someone lots of people have respect for asking women to 'spread the word' (provide free advertising) and we're asked to buy the book 'I would strongly encourage all of you to buy the book once it is out and make up your own minds'. Knowing that lots of women on here really don't have much spare cash - cost of living etc - I think this pretty strong series of statements is what has pushed trusted names to comment and question.

I think some of the questions asked have produced some really helpful answers from Sarah about Sisters Heal, and useful clarity for those who may want to consider donating or buying the book for charitable purposes.

Anyone who's been on FWR for any period of time knows that you can't expect the very intelligent women on here to take things on trust. There's an expectation of providing evidence, demonstrating consistency, credibility, having good arguments and good answers to questions. That, in my opinion, is one of the best attributes of FWR, and has made me much better and producing evidence-based arguments. It has tripped me up more than once and made me change my opinion on things (though I never thought humans could change sex).

It does mean that any OP that pretty much asks women to buy something is going to get questions. Anyone who's spent 5 mins on here should know that.

Generally speaking people on FWR are very generous to those who do change their mind, and they have been in this case too - evidenced by the fact these concerns are only being raised now when there's a direct plug to buy a book, which of course was not by Sarah.

Everyone can make up their own mind, it would be a sad world where people who don't have money or power are not allowed to give their opinion about why other women such as them should perhaps equally consider NOT buying anything that is being promoted.

As an outsider, I was grateful to have the book drawn to my attention, as it's not likely to be otherwise high-profile. And the discussion about charities versus CICs was interesting and useful. But the insinuations of bad character on the part of the author are too cryptic to be of any use: at this rate, I might buy the book just to see if it casts any further light on the matter!

Anyway, I'm interested in the SN story, and admire Professor Phoenix, so that's probably enough info for me to be going on with.

And also, thank you for your very detailed answer.

Shedmistress · 05/11/2026 11:10

theilltemperedmonster · 05/11/2026 10:44

As an outsider, I was grateful to have the book drawn to my attention, as it's not likely to be otherwise high-profile. And the discussion about charities versus CICs was interesting and useful. But the insinuations of bad character on the part of the author are too cryptic to be of any use: at this rate, I might buy the book just to see if it casts any further light on the matter!

Anyway, I'm interested in the SN story, and admire Professor Phoenix, so that's probably enough info for me to be going on with.

And also, thank you for your very detailed answer.

Edited

Why are you now implying this is an insider outsider issue?

This is a 'the fucking cheek of it' issue.

You didnt have to be an insider ie presumably living in the same town to have been tarred by the brush of 'feminists spat on people' lie that was put about at the time.

We were ALL put into the extreme bracket by the lies of TRAs.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 05/11/2026 11:34

To be fair pp doesn’t know what happened and how Sarah was involved.

IamSarah · 05/11/2026 11:46

Floisme · 05/11/2026 08:34

Can I suggest two things @IamSarah that might help move this forward, at least as far as I'm concerned?

  1. You could be a bit more forthright about the kind of things you posted on this board in the past. I know you want to protect previous identities and I understand that but it feels like we're getting a very broad-brush, 'Sorry I was an idiot' kind of explanation which could mean anything.
  2. A lot of women kept silent about your previous behaviour on this board while your court case was going on. A 'thank you' to them wouldn't go amiss. My apologies if you've don't that already but I think I've read the whole thread and I've not seen it.

Totally fair suggestions Floisme and if it helps move things forward then I’ll try and answer.

I posted some really stupid things on here. Idiotic things. I claimed trans women are women, single sex spaces are exclusionary and I was an apologist for rapey weirdos claiming men can be lesbians.

It’s really embarrassing and I’m ashamed of it. l don’t think I was awful to anyone in particular but I was certainly annoying and I accept the accusation of being antagonistic.

I did not attack anyone.
I did not get anyone banned.
I did not post from multiple accounts.

Once I saw the error of my ways and I realised how very harmful trans activism is I held my hands up and apologised.

Since then I’ve tried my best to raise awareness of the importance of single sex spaces. I am proud to be involved with local organisations that support women and girls and I obviously brought the case against Survivors Network.

I was granted anonymity by the court and i am really grateful to everyone who respected that during the court case. Thank you.

My posting history is dubious, it is fair enough to be challenged on that and I don’t expect everyone to trust me but I have genuinely changed position and the memoir covers how and why that happened. As @ProfJoPhoenixsays if you read it you can make up your own mind.

Thank you to those who have offered the golden bridge.

IamSarah · 05/11/2026 12:27

Shedmistress · 05/11/2026 11:10

Why are you now implying this is an insider outsider issue?

This is a 'the fucking cheek of it' issue.

You didnt have to be an insider ie presumably living in the same town to have been tarred by the brush of 'feminists spat on people' lie that was put about at the time.

We were ALL put into the extreme bracket by the lies of TRAs.

I do vaguely recall the spitting accusation. I believed it at first and then when I realised it was made up I was as shocked and appalled as anyone.

The detectives among you will know who organised the WPUK meeting in 2018. You will also know which of the Brighton feminists is my best friend. Make of that what you will.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 05/11/2026 13:21

Sarah, I think you’re digging yourself a bigger hole and I’d personally stop now. Just my advice, take it or leave it.

IamSarah · 05/11/2026 13:41

Ereshkigalangcleg · 05/11/2026 13:21

Sarah, I think you’re digging yourself a bigger hole and I’d personally stop now. Just my advice, take it or leave it.

Thank you. Like I said I understand some people don’t trust me and happy to leave it at that unless there are specific questions

I am going to DM you as in your other post you mention something that happened and how I was involved and I’d like to discuss that privately if that’s ok?

TinselAngel · 05/11/2026 14:22

IamSarah · 05/11/2026 12:27

I do vaguely recall the spitting accusation. I believed it at first and then when I realised it was made up I was as shocked and appalled as anyone.

The detectives among you will know who organised the WPUK meeting in 2018. You will also know which of the Brighton feminists is my best friend. Make of that what you will.

Thank you for the invitation. If you’re talking about who I think you’re talking about, what I make of it is that you’re as bad as each other, in the way you’ve berated other women who don’t agree with you.

DrSpartacularsMagnificentOctopus · 05/11/2026 14:51

Once I saw the error of my ways and I realised how very harmful trans activism is I held my hands up and apologised.

Sort of, as you did it under a name change therefore disconnecting yourself from your previous personas.

I don't think there's any benefit now to you declaring your previous names, you're as entitled to privacy and a history of being a dick as any of us. Those of us who have known your RL identity for many years have no intention of outing your old names now, and we never have, because we do care about women's safety and well-being, and that includes women who have a history of not giving a shit for ours.

Swipe left for the next trending thread