I don't think anyone wants a forensic account of past posting history or 'satisfaction'. There are good reasons you can namechange on here and overall that's a huge benefit to the women that need a site like this the most.
What some women who've posted here for years are pointing out is that they have observed a pattern of behaviour and they want to share their experience / opinion with others.
Enabling other women to make an informed choice about any purchases is surely a good thing? That's one of the things MN is for - to share experiences. I find it's one of the most beneficial parts of MN. Especially for women who don't have lots of money. MN is open to all, remember, including working class women. That's a positive too.
The OP here is someone lots of people have respect for asking women to 'spread the word' (provide free advertising) and we're asked to buy the book 'I would strongly encourage all of you to buy the book once it is out and make up your own minds'. Knowing that lots of women on here really don't have much spare cash - cost of living etc - I think this pretty strong series of statements is what has pushed trusted names to comment and question.
I think some of the questions asked have produced some really helpful answers from Sarah about Sisters Heal, and useful clarity for those who may want to consider donating or buying the book for charitable purposes.
Anyone who's been on FWR for any period of time knows that you can't expect the very intelligent women on here to take things on trust. There's an expectation of providing evidence, demonstrating consistency, credibility, having good arguments and good answers to questions. That, in my opinion, is one of the best attributes of FWR, and has made me much better and producing evidence-based arguments. It has tripped me up more than once and made me change my opinion on things (though I never thought humans could change sex).
It does mean that any OP that pretty much asks women to buy something is going to get questions. Anyone who's spent 5 mins on here should know that.
Generally speaking people on FWR are very generous to those who do change their mind, and they have been in this case too - evidenced by the fact these concerns are only being raised now when there's a direct plug to buy a book, which of course was not by Sarah.
Everyone can make up their own mind, it would be a sad world where people who don't have money or power are not allowed to give their opinion about why other women such as them should perhaps equally consider NOT buying anything that is being promoted.