Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

JKR response to Stonewall CEO comments

398 replies

BlueLegume · 01/11/2026 17:03

Just posted on X by JKR in response to Stonewall CEO comments re wanting to take the ‘heat’ out of the debate around trans …..even though their slogan was ‘ no debate’.

A lot of us were very willing to have a debate without heat, @stonewalluk, and the reason that never happened wasn't because gender critical feminists didn't want one.
While we were trying to get you to listen to our concerns, your former CEO was telling a BBC boss that gay people not wanting to include the opposite sex in their dating pool was 'sexual racism'. While we were pointing out the homophobia inherent in gender ideology, Stonewall ambassador Alex Drummond (a bearded, heterosexual man who'd had no surgery and taken no cross-sex hormones but liked wearing skirts), was going into schools to talk to students about his 'lesbian' identity. @BluskyeAllison, who actually is a lesbian, was subject to unlawful discrimination at her place of work for tweeting: ‘Stonewall recently hired Morgan Page, a male bodied person who ran workshops with the sole aim of coaching heterosexual men who identify as lesbians on how they can coerce young lesbians into having sex with them. Page called [it] “overcoming the cotton ceiling”.’
When the UK Supreme Court upheld women's right to single sex spaces, you issued a statement expressing your unhappiness about the ruling. In her report on your unhappy influence at the University of Essex, you were found by barrister @akuareindorf to have misrepresented the law as it related to women's rights: '[Stonewall have] stated the law as Stonewall would prefer it to be, rather than the law as it is’.
In 2018, you publicly advised schools to shred a research pack saying there were risks to puberty blockers, in spite of the fact that you aren't a medical charity and that there was already credible evidence that puberty blockers are neither irreversible nor harm-free. Meanwhile you produced your own educational packs, recommending a children's book, for ages 5-9, in which the parent 'is neither a man, nor a woman – they’re non-binary.' In July 2022, Stonewall sent out a tweet that read ‘Research suggests that children as young as two recognise their trans identity'.
^@thetimes has reported how you've sought to control the language used by NHS trusts and government on their social-media accounts. Organisations would get points from you for replacing commonly understood words with ideologically approved terms, eg, 'birthing parent' instead of 'mother'. thetimes.com/uk/society/art…^
In short, you took a maximalist position on gender identity ideology, which you attempted to enforce by diktat. You refused to acknowledge that you'd hitched your wagon to a cause that, unlike civil rights, gay rights or women's rights, sought to strip rights from others. You sought to curtail everyone's right to freedom of speech and belief by controlling what it was permissible to think and say, through the management and political class. You have argued against women's and girl's rights to their own spaces, their sports and to assemble without men. Your CEO tried to shame gay women/men into dating the opposite sex if the latter claimed to be female/male.
Your mantra was 'no debate' because, like all totalitarians, you preferred slogans, bullying and infiltration of powerful institutions to talking to opponents. You appear to have had no concern for the lowly people your ideology was harming: gender confused kids, female rape victims, female prisoners, regular people hounded and investigated at their places of work for refusing to accept the new mandates on sex and gender issued from on high.
Your 'activism' has been a disaster for those trans-identified people who really do just want to get on with their lives in peace. You have besmirched the name of an organisation many of us were once proud to donate to, the charity that was partly responsible for securing the legal right of gay people to marry, which a lot of us thought would never happen in our lifetimes. The milquetoast words quoted below do not erase a decade of gender activism that has been disastrous not only for individuals but for society as a whole.
There was once a debate to be had, but until you acknowledge the direct harm you've caused, it is no more possible to debate you than to persuade a person in the throes of a drug-induced psychosis that they are not, in fact, the reincarnated Christ.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
RapidOnsetGenderCritic · 02/11/2026 10:10

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 09:59

If you bothered to actually read my posts rather than be triggered by them you might find I'm addressing the 'no debate' accusation that JKR made of Stonewall in her post as I already explained to you. Its not my fault that other posters are asking for clarification so perhaps your attempted censorship of uncomfortable conversations be better directed at them for digging in than me.

It is spectacularly ironic that you are seeking to censor relevant opinions on a thread regarding 'no debate'. The lack of self awareness is breathtaking.

SerafinasGoose · Today 08:43
#NoDebate coincided with TERF [sic] blockers all over Twitter, the closure of feminist sub-Reddits, the cancellation of feminist speakers from public platforms, the sacking of prominent feminists from their posts, doxing, public intimidation and the disruption of women who grouped in conferences or online (this site was targeted).
From this content, it’s extremely difficult to uphold the position that #NoDebate was restricted to discussions of a refusal to validate trans identity. In any case, ‘trans people don’t exist’ is a straw man. I have not seen JKR or any other women’s rights advocate make such a claim.
So forgive me if I don’t give a furry rat’s arse about now discussing the rights of the lying, aggressive, abusive, gaslighting activist body who attempted to commandeer women’s rights and deny even our language and autonomy whilst telling us to ‘enjoy your erasure’.
Sort out your own problems. Women have always had to. We are not your nursemaids.

This post of SerafinasGoose answers your #nodebate claim.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 02/11/2026 10:12

Heggettypeg · 02/11/2026 09:37

What was that thing that went
' "Meet me in the middle", said the unjust man' ?

Yes, indeed.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 02/11/2026 10:14

The point is that TRAs refusing to debate benefitted them in the past, especially before the Forstater judgment, FWS and other key moments, but now it means that the debate just happens without them.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 02/11/2026 10:18

And absolutely pivotal in all this has been JKR and her platform. She’s been internationally influential in taking down #nodebate and providing a space for debate to happen. Lots of other amazing and brave women without JKR’s advantages laid the groundwork for this, but JKR helped bring it to the attention of worldwide media. Yay 🥳

BlueLegume · 02/11/2026 10:19

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 10:07

I already stated my thoughts on the post which critiqued JKR's misunderstanding of 'no debate' that are backed up by the Stonewall CEO. Might help if you read them.

Stonewall are trying to reframe their ‘no debate’ slogan.

Why? Funding drying up, people getting trans fatigue? Looking bad when the inevitable scandal surrounding children and minors impacted by PBs and people like Sam Hall and Helen Webberly? Who knows?

We never get a straight answer to what rights trans people do not have.

Stonewall have now said they will not contest the SC ruling yet trans people and TRAs and allies repeatedly tell us they will fight the ruling. How? If the very charity they think supports them has come out and said they will not be contesting it?

We know Ruth Hunt stated in black and white there would be collateral damage when she opted to follow the trans funding. She was right. Woman in particular were expected to sacrifice their rights to single sex spaces. Well we have had enough and if it takes JKR to keep reminding people that women’s rights matter then I am definitely on her side.

OP posts:
NotBadConsidering · 02/11/2026 10:19

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 10:04

Um, I'm explaining why there can be no debate & what needs to occur for there to be one not that its impossible. Try & keep up.

“Um, try & keep up”?

🤔

BlueLegume · 02/11/2026 10:20

Ereshkigalangcleg · 02/11/2026 10:18

And absolutely pivotal in all this has been JKR and her platform. She’s been internationally influential in taking down #nodebate and providing a space for debate to happen. Lots of other amazing and brave women without JKR’s advantages laid the groundwork for this, but JKR helped bring it to the attention of worldwide media. Yay 🥳

Absolutely. It would be pretty disingenuous for even the most fervent ally or TRA to read her post yesterday and in anyway break it down to read ‘transphobia’.

OP posts:
BlueLegume · 02/11/2026 10:21

NotBadConsidering · 02/11/2026 10:19

“Um, try & keep up”?

🤔

Edited

As ever on derailed threads re this issue there always comes a point where ‘try and keep up’ is chucked in. Every time.

OP posts:
LowlandLucky · 02/11/2026 10:22

She is incredible💖

DialSquare · 02/11/2026 10:23

She cuts to the chase every time. The TRA’s have no one near her equivalent and they fucking hate it.

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 10:23

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · 02/11/2026 10:10

SerafinasGoose · Today 08:43
#NoDebate coincided with TERF [sic] blockers all over Twitter, the closure of feminist sub-Reddits, the cancellation of feminist speakers from public platforms, the sacking of prominent feminists from their posts, doxing, public intimidation and the disruption of women who grouped in conferences or online (this site was targeted).
From this content, it’s extremely difficult to uphold the position that #NoDebate was restricted to discussions of a refusal to validate trans identity. In any case, ‘trans people don’t exist’ is a straw man. I have not seen JKR or any other women’s rights advocate make such a claim.
So forgive me if I don’t give a furry rat’s arse about now discussing the rights of the lying, aggressive, abusive, gaslighting activist body who attempted to commandeer women’s rights and deny even our language and autonomy whilst telling us to ‘enjoy your erasure’.
Sort out your own problems. Women have always had to. We are not your nursemaids.

This post of SerafinasGoose answers your #nodebate claim.

I have not seen JKR or any other women’s rights advocate make such a claim.

JKR implies so in her statements that imply trans women are motivated by predation & trans men are motivated by being in a 'tom boy' phase rather than gender identification.

And if you have spent 5 minutes on this forum or X you would see the same vicious trope accusations incessantly on repeat.

So please save the fake outrage.

BlueLegume · 02/11/2026 10:24

DialSquare · 02/11/2026 10:23

She cuts to the chase every time. The TRA’s have no one near her equivalent and they fucking hate it.

They now appear to not have the ear of Stonewall either.

OP posts:
SerafinasGoose · 02/11/2026 10:25

Ereshkigalangcleg · 02/11/2026 09:29

I think they finally realise that it’s not going to be possible to do this in plain sight, and they need to be more sly about it, like they were in the beginning. As pp have said, watch the Conversion Practices Bill. The police and the chilling effect are intended to do this work for them.

Exactly what was in my mind. They sneaked so much in through the back door, without consent and whilst (wilfully?) misinterpreting the law, that the stranglehold on major public institutions was locked in by the time people truly realised what had happened.

This time, it's to be hoped people will be more leery of it. No coincidence that JKR spoke out in response to that rapid reverse ferret from Stonewall.

We see you, fuckers.

BlueLegume · 02/11/2026 10:25

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 10:23

I have not seen JKR or any other women’s rights advocate make such a claim.

JKR implies so in her statements that imply trans women are motivated by predation & trans men are motivated by being in a 'tom boy' phase rather than gender identification.

And if you have spent 5 minutes on this forum or X you would see the same vicious trope accusations incessantly on repeat.

So please save the fake outrage.

Jesus - vicious trope accusations?

No - women fought hard for the rights we have and we do not want to share them with men. Show me vicious in that sentence?

Gender identity - please it is nonsense.

OP posts:
SerafinasGoose · 02/11/2026 10:27

BlueLegume · 02/11/2026 10:25

Jesus - vicious trope accusations?

No - women fought hard for the rights we have and we do not want to share them with men. Show me vicious in that sentence?

Gender identity - please it is nonsense.

Edited

'Implies'.

Always implications, or 'that nasty woman said so and so' - without being able to point straight at exactly what it was she said that was so cancellable and 'unsafe'.

Always the obfuscation, nothing tangible to argue with. And nothing changes.

These people must think we zip up the back.

cryupmykingdom · 02/11/2026 10:28

>> Um, I'm explaining why there can be no debate

At a certain point the jokes take out a pen and start writing themselves😂

BlueLegume · 02/11/2026 10:32

So essentially @CoolforKats you read JKRs work and then decide she is not actually writing truths she is obfuscating and ‘implying’ things. It is like saying someone gave you a funny look when actually they weren’t even looking at you.

OP posts:
cryupmykingdom · 02/11/2026 10:35

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 02/11/2026 10:38

SerafinasGoose · 02/11/2026 10:25

Exactly what was in my mind. They sneaked so much in through the back door, without consent and whilst (wilfully?) misinterpreting the law, that the stranglehold on major public institutions was locked in by the time people truly realised what had happened.

This time, it's to be hoped people will be more leery of it. No coincidence that JKR spoke out in response to that rapid reverse ferret from Stonewall.

We see you, fuckers.

Absolutely.

BlueLegume · 02/11/2026 10:39

I might be ‘implying’ something here so please bear with me.

Does ‘try & keep up’ mean ‘no debate’ or ‘shut up silly women?’ @CoolforKats

OP posts:
CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 10:42

BlueLegume · 02/11/2026 10:32

So essentially @CoolforKats you read JKRs work and then decide she is not actually writing truths she is obfuscating and ‘implying’ things. It is like saying someone gave you a funny look when actually they weren’t even looking at you.

Have you even read her statements? She explicitly uses her own personal experiences with a violent predatory cis man & her 'tom boy' phase to imply the motivations of trans people. I repeat, her own personal experiences that don't include trans people to generalise & perpetuate harmful tropes about trans people. If you can't understand what that means in terms of implication that's because you don't want to.

HenriettaSwanLeavitt2 · 02/11/2026 10:44

DialSquare · 02/11/2026 10:23

She cuts to the chase every time. The TRA’s have no one near her equivalent and they fucking hate it.

It doesn't help that they cannot agree about anything. That's the problem with basing your ideology on lies. Lying becomes the ideology, and every individual 'trans' person adheres to their own set of lies and disputes other 'trans' people's lies. No-one could summarise such a conflicitng set of opinions and demands.

cryupmykingdom · 02/11/2026 10:47

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 10:42

Have you even read her statements? She explicitly uses her own personal experiences with a violent predatory cis man & her 'tom boy' phase to imply the motivations of trans people. I repeat, her own personal experiences that don't include trans people to generalise & perpetuate harmful tropes about trans people. If you can't understand what that means in terms of implication that's because you don't want to.

😂😅😆

TrappedByThisDesk · 02/11/2026 10:47

CoolforKats · 01/11/2026 23:44

Please enough with the denial, the goal posts have always been the same: Gender. And gender as a valid identity. Let's be honest here, its a concept that the gender critical movement can't or won't reckon with which is at the heart of this dispute that they will use all manner of other perverse motivations for the existence of trans people to avoid.

Now before anyone starts up, I get it. I get that for gender critical feminists gender identity is understood as a perpetuation of gender stereotypes but the thing is, that in itself doesn't invalidate the identity or the motivation for it existing. And if you can't accept trans people's own conception of their identity then there is no moving forward with a civilised discussion about competing rights.

I see only one way forward here & that's a recognition of gender identity (which isn't the same as justifying it) without attributing other nefarious motivations from gender critical feminists & trans people accepting that rights need to be balanced. And until gender critical feminists make a good faith charitable move in acknowledging gender as a legitimate identity they can't be realistically be considered to ever have been serious about wanting to debate.

Edited

I totally accept trans people's own conception of their identity.
I recognise that some people have a gender identity and do not have any nefarious motivations.
I am very happy to make a good faith charitable move and acknowledge gender as a legitimate identity.
Trans people exist. I have no problem with this.
(Although trans people don't change sex, obviously, because that is impossible.)

There are no rights that need to be balanced here. Trans people already have the right to believe in their gender identity, dress how they like (within the bounds of decency in public), adopt whatever mannerisms and speech patterns they like, refer to themselves however they like. They have all these rights and all the rights that any other human has.

What transpeople don't have the right to do is:
A. compel me to address them in a particular way (e.g. using non-sex-based pronouns)
or
B. enter spaces and places legitimately designated as only for the opposite sex.

cryupmykingdom · 02/11/2026 10:49

HenriettaSwanLeavitt2 · 02/11/2026 10:44

It doesn't help that they cannot agree about anything. That's the problem with basing your ideology on lies. Lying becomes the ideology, and every individual 'trans' person adheres to their own set of lies and disputes other 'trans' people's lies. No-one could summarise such a conflicitng set of opinions and demands.

One thing they could seem to agree on was when they attacked 'transracialism' - the Hypatia Controversy.

Even tho ALL their own arguments supported transracialism 110%