Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

JKR response to Stonewall CEO comments

398 replies

BlueLegume · 01/11/2026 17:03

Just posted on X by JKR in response to Stonewall CEO comments re wanting to take the ‘heat’ out of the debate around trans …..even though their slogan was ‘ no debate’.

A lot of us were very willing to have a debate without heat, @stonewalluk, and the reason that never happened wasn't because gender critical feminists didn't want one.
While we were trying to get you to listen to our concerns, your former CEO was telling a BBC boss that gay people not wanting to include the opposite sex in their dating pool was 'sexual racism'. While we were pointing out the homophobia inherent in gender ideology, Stonewall ambassador Alex Drummond (a bearded, heterosexual man who'd had no surgery and taken no cross-sex hormones but liked wearing skirts), was going into schools to talk to students about his 'lesbian' identity. @BluskyeAllison, who actually is a lesbian, was subject to unlawful discrimination at her place of work for tweeting: ‘Stonewall recently hired Morgan Page, a male bodied person who ran workshops with the sole aim of coaching heterosexual men who identify as lesbians on how they can coerce young lesbians into having sex with them. Page called [it] “overcoming the cotton ceiling”.’
When the UK Supreme Court upheld women's right to single sex spaces, you issued a statement expressing your unhappiness about the ruling. In her report on your unhappy influence at the University of Essex, you were found by barrister @akuareindorf to have misrepresented the law as it related to women's rights: '[Stonewall have] stated the law as Stonewall would prefer it to be, rather than the law as it is’.
In 2018, you publicly advised schools to shred a research pack saying there were risks to puberty blockers, in spite of the fact that you aren't a medical charity and that there was already credible evidence that puberty blockers are neither irreversible nor harm-free. Meanwhile you produced your own educational packs, recommending a children's book, for ages 5-9, in which the parent 'is neither a man, nor a woman – they’re non-binary.' In July 2022, Stonewall sent out a tweet that read ‘Research suggests that children as young as two recognise their trans identity'.
^@thetimes has reported how you've sought to control the language used by NHS trusts and government on their social-media accounts. Organisations would get points from you for replacing commonly understood words with ideologically approved terms, eg, 'birthing parent' instead of 'mother'. thetimes.com/uk/society/art…^
In short, you took a maximalist position on gender identity ideology, which you attempted to enforce by diktat. You refused to acknowledge that you'd hitched your wagon to a cause that, unlike civil rights, gay rights or women's rights, sought to strip rights from others. You sought to curtail everyone's right to freedom of speech and belief by controlling what it was permissible to think and say, through the management and political class. You have argued against women's and girl's rights to their own spaces, their sports and to assemble without men. Your CEO tried to shame gay women/men into dating the opposite sex if the latter claimed to be female/male.
Your mantra was 'no debate' because, like all totalitarians, you preferred slogans, bullying and infiltration of powerful institutions to talking to opponents. You appear to have had no concern for the lowly people your ideology was harming: gender confused kids, female rape victims, female prisoners, regular people hounded and investigated at their places of work for refusing to accept the new mandates on sex and gender issued from on high.
Your 'activism' has been a disaster for those trans-identified people who really do just want to get on with their lives in peace. You have besmirched the name of an organisation many of us were once proud to donate to, the charity that was partly responsible for securing the legal right of gay people to marry, which a lot of us thought would never happen in our lifetimes. The milquetoast words quoted below do not erase a decade of gender activism that has been disastrous not only for individuals but for society as a whole.
There was once a debate to be had, but until you acknowledge the direct harm you've caused, it is no more possible to debate you than to persuade a person in the throes of a drug-induced psychosis that they are not, in fact, the reincarnated Christ.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Linenlover · 02/11/2026 11:54

👏👏👏

u3ername · 02/11/2026 12:07

Although the feminist activism gets me excited, it feels incredibly niche. Most people out there just think, ‘I'm not homophobic, JKR is, and there are more important things to care about.’ The majority of the public doesn't even know what Stonewall is, let alone the damage they've caused.
The mainstream media is too cautious to report. What could possibly be done to engage more women?

Shortshriftandlethal · 02/11/2026 12:15

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 10:07

I already stated my thoughts on the post which critiqued JKR's misunderstanding of 'no debate' that are backed up by the Stonewall CEO. Might help if you read them.

Stonewall's 'No Debate' mantra was one that the Labour party went on to adopt - and would even chant it in parliament. The meaning of 'No Debate' is pretty conclusive.

KittyWilkinson · 02/11/2026 12:16

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Shortshriftandlethal · 02/11/2026 12:20

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 10:42

Have you even read her statements? She explicitly uses her own personal experiences with a violent predatory cis man & her 'tom boy' phase to imply the motivations of trans people. I repeat, her own personal experiences that don't include trans people to generalise & perpetuate harmful tropes about trans people. If you can't understand what that means in terms of implication that's because you don't want to.

JKR was talking about men, not 'cis' men.

'Cis' is a part of a terminology that only works if you buy into the notion that some men are women And that is kind of the whole point, isn't it....and where trans ideology falls apart...because nobody can change sex and women's protections were created on the basis of their sex and on the differnces between men and women, male and female.

Shortshriftandlethal · 02/11/2026 12:28

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 11:05

The trans population isn't a population that is statistically significant in numbers so its impossible to draw any meaningful conclusions from incarceration not to mention incarcerations aren't reflective of offending an example being its estimated significantly larger numbers of women are offenders of child abuse than is reported. But I will say sex crimes involve prostitution & given trans women are involved in sex work that could be a contributing factor.

But male pattern criminality, including crimes of sexual violence, remains evident even in men that 'identify as' women. You cannot over-ride your sex by identifying with gender.

Datun · 02/11/2026 12:29

u3ername · 02/11/2026 12:07

Although the feminist activism gets me excited, it feels incredibly niche. Most people out there just think, ‘I'm not homophobic, JKR is, and there are more important things to care about.’ The majority of the public doesn't even know what Stonewall is, let alone the damage they've caused.
The mainstream media is too cautious to report. What could possibly be done to engage more women?

😁

JKR is a billionaire based on the fact that so many people buy everything she writes. She's the world's most popular children's author ever. Harry Potter is the best selling book series in history.

So no, most people don't think she's a homophobe.

cryupmykingdom · 02/11/2026 12:37

Shortshriftandlethal · 02/11/2026 12:20

JKR was talking about men, not 'cis' men.

'Cis' is a part of a terminology that only works if you buy into the notion that some men are women And that is kind of the whole point, isn't it....and where trans ideology falls apart...because nobody can change sex and women's protections were created on the basis of their sex and on the differnces between men and women, male and female.

Edited

The c*s slur is just part of a cult, and cults do a lot of jargon.

It's like a 'natter' or a 'DB' (degraded being) in Scientology.

Parking such terms, relegates trans ideology as being this era's version of Scientology. Which is a good way of understanding it.

Even the BBC style guide now advises parking 'c*s' & the Q-slur in the round file.

Unless you're quoting a cult member who still uses it.

solerolover · 02/11/2026 12:43

FouDeFafa · 02/11/2026 11:41

TLDR: JKR writes eloquent and accurate riposte to Stonewall’s attempt to re-write history. TRA’s can’t bear that they still can’t silence her so are going apeshit on Reddit. TRA plopper furious on MN that the goddam women won’t just agree and have the law on their side.

How did I do?

Pretty much sums it up. The TRA's on this site are so desperate to get their points across by bullying women into submission, that one user is operating on no less than three different usernames this past week alone, across multiple threads in FWR. It would be funny if it wasn't so pathetic.

solerolover · 02/11/2026 12:46

JKR is bang on the money as always, especially with this part:

You sought to curtail everyone's right to freedom of speech and belief by controlling what it was permissible to think and say, through the management and political class. You have argued against women's and girl's rights to their own spaces, their sports and to assemble without men. Your CEO tried to shame gay women/men into dating the opposite sex if the latter claimed to be female/male.

Your mantra was 'no debate' because, like all totalitarians, you preferred slogans, bullying and infiltration of powerful institutions to talking to opponents. You appear to have had no concern for the lowly people your ideology was harming: gender confused kids, female rape victims, female prisoners, regular people hounded and investigated at their places of work for refusing to accept the new mandates on sex and gender issued from on high.

Tea Celebrate GIF by IndyWindy
HousePlantEmergency · 02/11/2026 12:53

I always find it most telling the cherry picked aspects of "gendered behaviours" and stereotypes TiM like to identify with to show us how womanly they are, and how they are just like us "CIS" women:

*Makeup
*Long hair
*Heels
*Revealing clothing...

All superficial shit that most GC women and feminists reject as representing womanhood.

Funny how they ignore the rest of the "gendered behaviours" typically forced upon women:

*Careers taking a hit due to pregnancy abd child rearing
*being the primary parent
*Being left to parent alone when a spouse fucks off
*Being paid less
*Doing the shit work at home
*Umpaid care work-elderly parents and relatives
(Home & Family Management (the mental load)
*Social and emotional load within the family
*Constant safety awareness and vigilance
*Managing contraception and reproductive health.... (and on and on and on)

Absolutely fucking clueless that being a woman is HARD.

We can ignore the first list for the superficial shit it is (if we want to)
Sadly, it is incredibly hard to ignore the second.

akkakk · 02/11/2026 12:54

CoolforKats · 01/11/2026 23:44

Please enough with the denial, the goal posts have always been the same: Gender. And gender as a valid identity. Let's be honest here, its a concept that the gender critical movement can't or won't reckon with which is at the heart of this dispute that they will use all manner of other perverse motivations for the existence of trans people to avoid.

Now before anyone starts up, I get it. I get that for gender critical feminists gender identity is understood as a perpetuation of gender stereotypes but the thing is, that in itself doesn't invalidate the identity or the motivation for it existing. And if you can't accept trans people's own conception of their identity then there is no moving forward with a civilised discussion about competing rights.

I see only one way forward here & that's a recognition of gender identity (which isn't the same as justifying it) without attributing other nefarious motivations from gender critical feminists & trans people accepting that rights need to be balanced. And until gender critical feminists make a good faith charitable move in acknowledging gender as a legitimate identity they can't be realistically be considered to ever have been serious about wanting to debate.

Edited

It is so wonderful to see you understanding reality - that men can not become women...

and as men can perform their feminine self in the gents loos - there is no need for men to be anywhere near women's spaces...

there are two things you might want to actually understand though...

gender is an external stereotype of patterns of observed behaviour.
therefore it is not a pick and mix where a man can choose to be 'feminine' or to have a 'woman's gender'... if a man mimics / playacts at being a woman by observing the stereotypes and adopting them - they are not 'putting on woman' or 'becoming a woman' - they are simply a man doing man a different way - and the more they and others do that, the more that the external observation will see the stereotype of a man changing. ie. they simply normalise a different way of being man

JKR's response to Stonewall is a reminder that the devious sand-shifting lies of the TRA movement won't work - those who support honesty and truth keep a note of the history of those lies and can repeat them back as required... you don't get to tell one lie and then 10+ years later tell others and deny the first... (however much it reinforces the understanding of the underlying

and as for your 'keep up' I am not sure that misogynistic arrogance is needed in this forum - especially while proving your own inability to understand the most basic arguments...

a man is a man and that is that #noDebate

BlueLegume · 02/11/2026 12:58

solerolover · 02/11/2026 12:43

Pretty much sums it up. The TRA's on this site are so desperate to get their points across by bullying women into submission, that one user is operating on no less than three different usernames this past week alone, across multiple threads in FWR. It would be funny if it wasn't so pathetic.

Edited

@solerolover agree as to the user operating under different names across threads. Their style and use of certain phrases calls them out. Especially telling is as the tantrum peaks the use of “try & keep up” .

Maybe being too kind but I do worry that seeing their beloved trans movement no longer ‘winning’ and getting all the rights they want must feel frightening.

I am concerned vulnerable people believed what the TRAs and allies told them that trans, an over valued belief if ever there was one, would win the day and everything would be lovely, did not bargain for common sense and sex reality being used. These people are vulnerable. Trans was never the way forward but compassion and empathy to understand their discomfort was. Not hormones and surgery.

OP posts:
Ereshkigalangcleg · 02/11/2026 13:14

JKR continuing with the truth bombs in response to Steph Richards, the male TRA founder of Translucent:

I’ve never told any trans person what they ‘should be.’ As far as I’m concerned, trans people can call themselves whatever they like and believe whatever they like about themselves. What trans people aren’t entitled to is universal agreement that they’ve changed sex, acclaim for their embodiment of sex stereotypes, the reconfiguration of laws around an objective untruth or women’s surrender of their sex-based rights.

Meanwhile, trans activists tell women they have no right to speak about themselves and their own bodies in any way that might trigger narcissistic rage in trans-identified men, apply the ideological term 'cis' to people who neither describe themselves that way nor believe in gender identities, assert the right to redefine 'woman' not by the observable characteristics of biological sex but by sex stereotypes, and seek to dictate what rights women and girls should surrender to men.

https://x.com/jk_rowling/status/2117207884442300638

https://x.com/jkrowling/status/2117232754383282392

MarieDeGournay · 02/11/2026 13:17

BlueLegume · 02/11/2026 12:58

@solerolover agree as to the user operating under different names across threads. Their style and use of certain phrases calls them out. Especially telling is as the tantrum peaks the use of “try & keep up” .

Maybe being too kind but I do worry that seeing their beloved trans movement no longer ‘winning’ and getting all the rights they want must feel frightening.

I am concerned vulnerable people believed what the TRAs and allies told them that trans, an over valued belief if ever there was one, would win the day and everything would be lovely, did not bargain for common sense and sex reality being used. These people are vulnerable. Trans was never the way forward but compassion and empathy to understand their discomfort was. Not hormones and surgery.

More worryingly, the TRA tactic of a sense of exaggerated threat - 'most vulnerable', 'literal genocide', days of trans remembrance in countries where there haven't been any transphobic murders, 'apartheid' etc. - probably work best on people who are ill-informed or in some way vulnerable.

Linking the trans movement with the suffragettes, or Black people in apartheid South Africa, or victims of actual genocides is as breathtakingly insulting as it is ahistorical and inaccurate.

But it seems to work, as overwrought activists, hyped up by the hyperbole, engage in 'justifiable' acts of 'resistance', ranging from the aggressive through the ridiculous to the disgusting to the violent.

Datun · 02/11/2026 13:43

Ereshkigalangcleg · 02/11/2026 13:14

JKR continuing with the truth bombs in response to Steph Richards, the male TRA founder of Translucent:

I’ve never told any trans person what they ‘should be.’ As far as I’m concerned, trans people can call themselves whatever they like and believe whatever they like about themselves. What trans people aren’t entitled to is universal agreement that they’ve changed sex, acclaim for their embodiment of sex stereotypes, the reconfiguration of laws around an objective untruth or women’s surrender of their sex-based rights.

Meanwhile, trans activists tell women they have no right to speak about themselves and their own bodies in any way that might trigger narcissistic rage in trans-identified men, apply the ideological term 'cis' to people who neither describe themselves that way nor believe in gender identities, assert the right to redefine 'woman' not by the observable characteristics of biological sex but by sex stereotypes, and seek to dictate what rights women and girls should surrender to men.

https://x.com/jk_rowling/status/2117207884442300638

https://x.com/jkrowling/status/2117232754383282392

Edited

Despite knowing that these men will get hugely excited if she responds to them, I'm glad she's nailing it home.

The rank hypocrisy of that fucking organisation is appalling. A gay rights organisation telling lesbians they have to sleep with men!

And now the grift is up they're getting all oh hang on a minute.

I can see this running and running.

u3ername · 02/11/2026 13:47

@datunI am someone who has always made a point of supporting JKR.
My post was based on impressions I get from other forum sites/ social media/ work colleagues…
Even on here these threads need to be in a particular section rather than part of the wider conversation, which doesn't help change the mind of more people, imo.

Anyway, as I’ve been called too dim to post on this thread (keep shining bright
@KittyWilkinson ) I will bow out and leave you to it.
Good gatekeeping.

Imdunfer · 02/11/2026 13:59

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 11:07

'Naughty' protesters aren't exclusive to trans people. See: The Suffragettes.

Don't you dare compare women bravely protesting for women's rights at a time when they couldn't even vote with men throwing piss around in public to mark their territory like a dog in order to usurp women's rights.

Datun · 02/11/2026 14:04

u3ername · 02/11/2026 13:47

@datunI am someone who has always made a point of supporting JKR.
My post was based on impressions I get from other forum sites/ social media/ work colleagues…
Even on here these threads need to be in a particular section rather than part of the wider conversation, which doesn't help change the mind of more people, imo.

Anyway, as I’ve been called too dim to post on this thread (keep shining bright
@KittyWilkinson ) I will bow out and leave you to it.
Good gatekeeping.

Edited

I don't know where you work, but there are plenty of captured organisations. Likewise, social media and forum sites.

I don't think anyone thinks J. K. Rowling is homophobic. Even on those sites.

Perhaps you meant transphobic?

But again, the receipts for her work, her series, her video games, her books, the studio tours, the shops, even the Christmas lights on Oxford Street, plus the massive awareness of her charity work for women and children would seem to indicate otherwise.

Transactivists have tried, desperately, for years, to discredit J. K. Rowling. It hasn't worked.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 02/11/2026 14:10

Imdunfer · 02/11/2026 13:59

Don't you dare compare women bravely protesting for women's rights at a time when they couldn't even vote with men throwing piss around in public to mark their territory like a dog in order to usurp women's rights.

👏

EmpressDomesticatednottamed · 02/11/2026 14:17

MarieDeGournay · 02/11/2026 13:17

More worryingly, the TRA tactic of a sense of exaggerated threat - 'most vulnerable', 'literal genocide', days of trans remembrance in countries where there haven't been any transphobic murders, 'apartheid' etc. - probably work best on people who are ill-informed or in some way vulnerable.

Linking the trans movement with the suffragettes, or Black people in apartheid South Africa, or victims of actual genocides is as breathtakingly insulting as it is ahistorical and inaccurate.

But it seems to work, as overwrought activists, hyped up by the hyperbole, engage in 'justifiable' acts of 'resistance', ranging from the aggressive through the ridiculous to the disgusting to the violent.

When The World at War was on tv during 70s my parents sat down with us to watch the episode about the Holocaust, whihc was not a usual thing for them to do, neither was it usual for me to watch it. Don't panic, I was old enough at the time, my parents weren't bonkers.
There are images from it that are seared on my brain and when I see the "literal genocide' thrown about it digusts me, those doing so don't have a clue.
There's a tv programme I could recommend for their education.

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · 02/11/2026 14:18

More and more proof the TRA wing can't be relied on for the biological facts and it seems the recollection of recent history over the last 15 years.
So, TWAW <and> there was no cancel culture from the TRA side.
Trying to draw a false equivalence of opposing viewpoints of TWAW and TWANW.
I don't recall <any> GC voices saying that noone could <believe/feel>TWAW. None. There were no calls from Rowling, or Helen Joyce etc etc saying that no-one could say TRA mantras, that such people should be silenced or cancelled for saying such.
Indeed the call from GCs was simply to be invited to panels and discussions to put the scientific view. That we have freewill on thought. But if there was going to be a revolution on science and public policy, this could not happen in the vacuum of TRA-imposed No Debate.
Sure, we know GI is anti-woman performative shit, but not one prominent GC said it couldn't be an opinion, to had to be silenced.
In fact we needed to hear it, as much as anything to show the population at large how insane it all is.
Of course, in reverse that was never the view from the vast majority of TRAs.
No, child specialists, liberal GC journalists, other scientists, doctors, writers, academics, young people in university, were all told to/expected to toe the TRA party line.
No discussion, no varying opinions, no dissent.
Stating an equivalence between GCs saying the views were crazy but feel free to express them, versus TRAs saying all discussion off limits, is willful misinterpretation of 15 years of history equivalent to their misinterpretation of science.

KittyWilkinson · 02/11/2026 14:20

u3ername · 02/11/2026 13:47

@datunI am someone who has always made a point of supporting JKR.
My post was based on impressions I get from other forum sites/ social media/ work colleagues…
Even on here these threads need to be in a particular section rather than part of the wider conversation, which doesn't help change the mind of more people, imo.

Anyway, as I’ve been called too dim to post on this thread (keep shining bright
@KittyWilkinson ) I will bow out and leave you to it.
Good gatekeeping.

Edited

These threads are in a particular section. This is the Feminism board.

Your previous post referred to JKR being homophobic. She isn't. Nor is she transphobic.
She stands for Women and Girls. As do all genuine posters here.
To call Feminism niche as you did in you earlier post, is not the bright analysis you seem to think it is.

So yes. Kindly, that post was dim. Saying such is not gatekeeping. Post away.

Good day to you.

rocer · 02/11/2026 14:30

CoolforKats · 01/11/2026 23:44

Please enough with the denial, the goal posts have always been the same: Gender. And gender as a valid identity. Let's be honest here, its a concept that the gender critical movement can't or won't reckon with which is at the heart of this dispute that they will use all manner of other perverse motivations for the existence of trans people to avoid.

Now before anyone starts up, I get it. I get that for gender critical feminists gender identity is understood as a perpetuation of gender stereotypes but the thing is, that in itself doesn't invalidate the identity or the motivation for it existing. And if you can't accept trans people's own conception of their identity then there is no moving forward with a civilised discussion about competing rights.

I see only one way forward here & that's a recognition of gender identity (which isn't the same as justifying it) without attributing other nefarious motivations from gender critical feminists & trans people accepting that rights need to be balanced. And until gender critical feminists make a good faith charitable move in acknowledging gender as a legitimate identity they can't be realistically be considered to ever have been serious about wanting to debate.

Edited

@CoolforKats: "I see only one way forward here & that's a recognition of gender identity"

I recognise gender identity much as I recognise immortal soul. That is, although I am fairly sure there is no such thing, I'm aware some people think there is.

Scientologists or mormons, catholics, muslims, zoroastrians, ... whatever you like. We rub along. We even laugh, sometimes, at one another's crazy beliefs.

Same with trans? Why not? So long as they don't expect to get to indoctrinate my children, insist on silly changes to my language, cheat at sport, deny me freedom of speech, get me sacked as a heretic ... and so on. (We sort of stopped all that based on beliefs a while ago, even if there are still a few hangovers like bishops in HoL, RE in some schools and Thought for the Day on BBC.)

Different beliefs rub along. Fair enough?

(I think JKR said something quite similar to this, in fact.)

WintersFrog · 02/11/2026 14:39

KittyWilkinson · 02/11/2026 14:20

These threads are in a particular section. This is the Feminism board.

Your previous post referred to JKR being homophobic. She isn't. Nor is she transphobic.
She stands for Women and Girls. As do all genuine posters here.
To call Feminism niche as you did in you earlier post, is not the bright analysis you seem to think it is.

So yes. Kindly, that post was dim. Saying such is not gatekeeping. Post away.

Good day to you.

I think you might have misunderstood @u3ername's post. I think she was saying that's how other people perceive jkr and was asking how we can widen the conversation and not just be put in a corner here on mn.

Unless I'm the one who misunderstood?

Swipe left for the next trending thread