Reader’s note:
In light of the male people under oath who have made declarations about having changed sex, including medical doctors who have made the claim, this statement is inaccurate - “They are claiming they have more in common with the typical inclinations & interests of women as a group & therefore are more like them categorically than men as a group. That's not the same as claiming women & men exclusively have a distinct set of inclinations & interests.”
This is a statement that has been made by someone who is not transgender themselves about how people who have transgender identities perceive themselves which doesn’t match what some people with transgender identities have articulated about their own experience. It also is not consistent with any claim that male people have to be treated as if they were female people for access to female single sex provisions, which are provisions that have been created on the basis of sex category.
A person’s or group’s insistence that it is behavioural and personality traits / inclinations that form a material and objective basis for defining a sex class for access provisions defined as single sex under the UK EA2010 is misinformation. People can have any identity they wish, however, if that identity is not the sex category of human their body has been formed around, that identity is irrelevant to accessing a single sex provision.
The only detail that is relevant as to whether a person accesses a female single sex provision is the person’s sex category (unless the person is a child under the age of around 8 -10 years old). Sex categories have scientifically definable and testable category boundaries. A person who claims to have a ‘gender identity’ in the UK has not changed sex category.
People who are not transgender making statements on behalf of an entire group of people who are transgender about how trans people define themselves should be considered in comparison to the statements directly from people with transgender identities.