Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Stonewall CEO attempting to adopt a more moderate position

208 replies

ItsCoolForCats · 01/11/2026 11:16

He wants to "turn down the heat" 🙄

I can't imagine this going down well amongst the TQ++++.....

"Stonewall was not, Blake stressed, aiming to overturn the supreme court ruling.* *“We understand that this is the law. But we also want to ensure that trans people are protected and, along with other organisations, we are looking at what that would look like.”

Article in the Guardian today

https://www.theguardian.com/society/2026/nov/01/progress-takes-time-stonewall-ceo-on-turning-down-the-heat-on-the-trans-debate?shem=dsdf,sharefoc,agadiscoversdl,,sh/x/discover/m1/4

‘Progress takes time’: Stonewall CEO on turning down the heat on the trans debate

Leader is charting a course through troubled waters as a new survey finds trans people feel more pessimistic about social acceptance after combative decade

https://www.theguardian.com/society/2026/nov/01/progress-takes-time-stonewall-ceo-on-turning-down-the-heat-on-the-trans-debate?shem=dsdf%2Csharefoc%2Cagadiscoversdl%2C%2Csh%2Fx%2Fdiscover%2Fm1%2F4

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Ereshkigalangcleg · 02/11/2026 11:09

Pingponghavoc · 02/11/2026 11:01

Stonewall push for 'trans rights', claiming that these rights didnt impact women at all.

That was in 2015. They started to lobby for a change in the GRA despite not being involved in the orginal GRA. In 2017 Theresa May attempted to remove the diagnosis process from the GRA. I have no idea if the government used stonewall to prime the public for this change, or stonewall influence the government.

The current stonewall ideas around gender, sex and sexual orientation are only about 10 years old or so. Before this, stonewall didnt think a man could identity as a woman and therefore be a lesbian. If they did, why didnt they involve themselves with a key 'LGBT++' legislation?

Whats happening is what always happens with trans- the narrative changes.

Trans is and isnt diagnosable, trans is changing sex and it isnt, trans is gender, only trans people have gender, everyone has gender, gender is innate, gender is agency, gender is more important than sex, no one knows anyone's sex, but can see everyone gender, gender is up to the individual and dont assume gender.

The public support trans, trans are a victimised minority without any public support. Trans have a right to use SS spaces, there are no single sex spaces.

The only point that stays constant is men wanting to be in women's spaces, and grasping at any argument justify it.

Stonewall lost the argument because they didnt know what the argument was. It could only work if everyone accepted that a woman was anything a man said we were.

At first Gendered Intelligence and GIRES were the ones the government was working with on this. As you say, Stonewall entered this post 2015 but it ramped up a lot after that.

Datun · 02/11/2026 11:41

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 04:13

Trans people aren’t claiming they changed their reproductive sex. They are claiming to be 'trans gender' not 'trans sexual'.

Well, that's not true. Willoughby's cervix, Doctor Upton's I'm a biological woman.

But neither have they changed gender. Transactivists act like stereotypical men across the board. Going off alarming when they don't get their own way, threatening women, pouring piss on themselves.

They've changed fuck all. They're trans nothing. Common or garden men demanding access to vulnerable women.

Datun · 02/11/2026 11:45

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 05:06

I'm not assuming anything about children, or anyone else. I'm asking about men who come to transness in middle age. Don't deflect.

How do you know they only "came to transness in middle age"? You only know they came out at that time…not the same thing.

I asked "What percentage of middle-aged men donning dresses and wigs do so for sexual gratification, do you think?"

And I answered your irrelevant nonsensical question.

Hahaha!!

cryupmykingdom · 02/11/2026 11:52

Ereshkigalangcleg · 02/11/2026 10:31

Of course. But it’s less relevant now, as are Stonewall. As pp say, it’s the cosy back room stuff we have to watch. And the Conversion Practices Bill, which most people, including MPs, don’t really understand, and sounds like an unequivocally good thing on the face of it, if you don’t inform yourself on what it actually means.

Edited

Yes, if there's anything people should be doing it's responding to the call for evidence. If you need help with phrasings, ask Sex Matters / Helen Joyce :
committees.parliament.uk/submission/4010/#/evidence/4010/call-for-evidence

Datun · 02/11/2026 11:53

If I had a pound for every transactivist who said AGP was made up nonsense.

I probably have just as much money as the number of men who can't stop drooling telling the world all about it!

Myalternate · 02/11/2026 11:54

CoolforKats Trans people aren’t claiming they changed their reproductive sex.

That’s very sly.

AlexandraLeaving · 02/11/2026 12:01

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 06:59

You act as if exemptions from anti discrimination law for cis/natal women don't exist & they do so shared words (that involve prefix distinctions mind you) is irrelevant to what it actually takes to justify the protection of spaces.

But I appreciate that the use of shared words is a sore point regardless of prefix distinction & rights already being protected regardless so I'm open to any reasonable ideas that might help alleviate the conflict. Its an interesting proposal because its still directly representative of the phenomena itself without the added baggage of stereotypical associations to sex & certainly worth pursuing. Well done!

But here's the rub, there can be no united 'trouble shooting' until both parties are willing to acknowledge the others humanity & concerns.

That's not entirely fair. I don't act as if exemptions don't exist. I know they do, but whenever I have raised them in the past by those purporting to advocate for trans people that they are irrelevant because 'trans women are women'. And I have always been happy to acknowledge trans people's humanity and listen to their concerns. But here's the rub: none of that has made them more willing to engage with me on the subject of protection of women's rights and the need for precision in the use of language.

WomanXXWorldsOriginsofMothersofAllNations · 02/11/2026 12:36

CoolforKats, step back from the thread-derailing if you can. It just sounds like you’ve swallowed a dictionary to try and make yourself look important. If you’re desperate for a semantic win to feed your ego, carry on—maybe you’ll manage to scrape together another 24 asspats ‘likes’ this time, dear. 😉

Anyway, back to what’s actually interesting - the Stonewall CEO’s sudden pivot to a 'moderate' stance. It's a massive admission of failure. For years, organisations like Stonewall pushed a completely uncompromising line, entirely dismissing the valid safeguarding concerns of women as mere 'bias'.

Now that the public and legal tide has turned, they are desperately trying to reverse ferret and pretend they were reasonable all along. Even the head of Stonewall has realised their high-handed strategy has completely lost them support.

And no amount of copy pasta of academic definitions from you is going to change the fact that in the real-world the argument is over.

BlueLegume · 02/11/2026 12:41

Myalternate · 02/11/2026 11:54

CoolforKats Trans people aren’t claiming they changed their reproductive sex.

That’s very sly.

Yes very sly. This is the new language. The old TWAW didn’t work so they are back-peddling saying ‘no one said reproductive sex’.

Very convenient and definitely a gear shift. I genuinely think a lot of the TRAs and their allies simply thought us women, and men, would eventually give up the fight and let things me on their terms. Big Steph has waded in from Translucent again. JKR and Akua Reindorf have set him straight. His arrogance is well,manly.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 02/11/2026 12:52

BlueLegume · 02/11/2026 12:41

Yes very sly. This is the new language. The old TWAW didn’t work so they are back-peddling saying ‘no one said reproductive sex’.

Very convenient and definitely a gear shift. I genuinely think a lot of the TRAs and their allies simply thought us women, and men, would eventually give up the fight and let things me on their terms. Big Steph has waded in from Translucent again. JKR and Akua Reindorf have set him straight. His arrogance is well,manly.

Idly wonders what Stonewall (we never claimed men could change sex) are doing with this merch?

https://x.com/stonewalluk/status/1044530203261915137?lang=da

Stonewall (@stonewalluk) på X

Our new ‘Trans Women Are Women’, ‘Trans Men Are Men’ and ‘Some People Are Non-Binary. Get Over It!’ T-shirts are available online now: https://t.co/VJ9uAhROYS Use discount code SEP20 at checkout for 20% off throughout September! #ComeOutForTransEqualit...

https://x.com/stonewalluk/status/1044530203261915137?lang=da

murasaki · 02/11/2026 12:54

MrsOvertonsWindow · 02/11/2026 12:52

Idly wonders what Stonewall (we never claimed men could change sex) are doing with this merch?

https://x.com/stonewalluk/status/1044530203261915137?lang=da

They'll be using Kat's definition of women. Rather than the actual one.

Although it falls down due to the lack of allegedly stereotypical female behaviour and looks in that photo....

poppsocks · 02/11/2026 12:55

PronounssheRa · 01/11/2026 11:24

Trans people are already protected, he isn't clear on what more he wants, though I could take a bloody good guess.

Also I dont know how he can say this without his brain short circuiting

That the ban on conversion practices currently under parliamentary scrutiny is trans-inclusive matters to him personally because “it’s saying you don’t need to be changed, you’re good enough”, something he needed to hear as a teenager.

Wow. Do you think people will twig that he's repeating what 'terfs' have been saying for the past decade about kids unhappy with their bodies?

MyAmpleSheep · 02/11/2026 12:57

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 05:06

I'm not assuming anything about children, or anyone else. I'm asking about men who come to transness in middle age. Don't deflect.

How do you know they only "came to transness in middle age"? You only know they came out at that time…not the same thing.

I asked "What percentage of middle-aged men donning dresses and wigs do so for sexual gratification, do you think?"

And I answered your irrelevant nonsensical question.

How do you know they only "came to transness in middle age"? You only know they came out at that time…not the same thing.

OK, if you prefer, what percentage of men who came out in middle age do so for sexual gratification?

And I answered your irrelevant nonsensical question.

It's not nonsensical or irrelevant - you understand it perfectly well, and you know why it's relevant, and no, you didn't answer it. Have another go.

What percentage of men who came out in middle age do so for sexual gratification?

(I'm going to start collecting the difficult questions that no trans advocates are ever willing to answer. There are many.)

38thparallel · 02/11/2026 13:01

Many of the larger organisations once proudly championing Stonewall have quietly dropped their name from their websites

@SerafinasGoose I
In these organisations, who decided to sign up for Stonewall? Was it the CEO? the PR department?
I would be interested to hear what the employee/s who actually made the decision to support Stonewall have got to say about it now, and why they signed up in the first place.
However I guess any enquiries would be brushed off with some generic PR bullshit line.

Shedmistress · 02/11/2026 13:08

They signed up because they could box tick by changing the toilet signs to 'gender neutral' and changing their policies to 'gender neutral' wordings and get higher up the rankings to enable them to get either contracts, investment or funding. As all 3 insisted on 'DEI' being part of the company policy.

HermioneWeasley · 02/11/2026 13:14

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 04:13

Trans people aren’t claiming they changed their reproductive sex. They are claiming to be 'trans gender' not 'trans sexual'.

Many prominent trans people and their allies are claiming just that - India Willoughby claims to have a cervix, David Lammy thinks men can grow a cervix, Dr Upton claimed to be a “biological woman because he’s a woman and made of biological material”.

I believe that people’s subjective, changeable and not verifiable feelings about themselves (their “gender identity”) are not a better basis for law and policy than the objective fact of their sex.

MyAmpleSheep · 02/11/2026 13:22

CoolforKats · 02/11/2026 04:13

Trans people aren’t claiming they changed their reproductive sex. They are claiming to be 'trans gender' not 'trans sexual'.

Has anyone else noticed that as soon as one defintion of sex is "issued", about two months later trans people claim to have changed it. So another one comes along....

Trans people aren’t claiming they changed their reproductive sex.

Except for the ones who do. And the others will be along shortly.

BlueLegume · 02/11/2026 13:25

HermioneWeasley · 02/11/2026 13:14

Many prominent trans people and their allies are claiming just that - India Willoughby claims to have a cervix, David Lammy thinks men can grow a cervix, Dr Upton claimed to be a “biological woman because he’s a woman and made of biological material”.

I believe that people’s subjective, changeable and not verifiable feelings about themselves (their “gender identity”) are not a better basis for law and policy than the objective fact of their sex.

Well said @HermioneWeasley

Thing is @CoolforKats you can’t suddenly say ‘none said they could change reproductive sex’ because that has never been a phrase used by TRAs. Phrases used have been TWAW/TMAM; women can have a penis/ lesbians can have a penis/men can have a vagina; politicians have said women can have a penis and men can have a cervix.

I cannot think of one exchange over the past decade where any TRA or ally has ever intervened or caveated any statement with - ‘oh we know they can’t change reproductive sex’.

Happy to be schooled but to me this whiffs of back pedalling as you see the quick sand shifting and the house of cards falling into it.

38thparallel · 02/11/2026 13:30

@Shedmistress
They signed up because they could box tick by changing the toilet signs to 'gender neutral' and changing their policies to 'gender neutral' wordings and get higher up the rankings to enable them to get either contracts, investment or funding. As all 3 insisted on 'DEI' being part of the company policy

That’s interesting, thank you. When did this change? I mean, when did leaving Stonewall stop affecting chances of contracts etc?

cryupmykingdom · 02/11/2026 13:44

>In these organisations, who decided to sign up for Stonewall? Was it the CEO? >the PR department?
>I would be interested to hear what the employee/s who actually made the >decision to support Stonewall have got to say about it now, and why they >signed up in the first place

Goes back a ways. Tell you a tale.

There's a certain type of fussy, very bureaucratic gay man who missed out on having much of a sex life because of AIDS.

Fear of AIDS existed well into the 2000s; the new treatments took a long time to start being understood or prescribed appropriately. In 2001, I nursed a gay injecting heroin user to his death 3-4 years after the first really effective 'cocktail' therapies had come along The cocktails stopped working if you didn't take them exactly on time, or missed doses. You became resistant and died quite fast.

And these were cautious, conservative, very corporate gay men. I think Gareth Roberts is the only person, apart from me, to have described them as a 'type'.

I noticed them, because I was the kind of person who the instant it looked like HIV was over, started having the sex life of a wild dog.

Not proud of that, but I was hardly the only one and a lot of it was a reaction to no longer being under death's yoke.

But I'd meet these fussy, bureaucratic queens; they were either my age or slightly younger. I remember them, because a lot of them loathed me on sight.

Many got into their late thirties without having a 'sowing the wild oats' period, the sort of thing heteros did in their teenage years, back then.

And by then, it was too late - they were more prone to being ashamed anyway, and they were in the corporate sphere, in an era where a gay & lesbian corporate world was quickly developing, and participants were keen to be seen as responsible and stable.

So, being caught out had a greater cost, and they were getting a bit old for it anyways. Also around that time, starting in the late 90s and into the early 2000s, some of their friends will have slipped into the world of meth, and that reinforced their conservatism.

So, instead, they found a new passion. This was just after gay marriage came in.

They'd had an involvement in that, but gay marriage wasn't radical by then. There was and is, something a bit middle class and 'schoolmarm-ish' about it. TBH, a lot of gay marriage still gives me the creeps, lol

But what they found, the radical stuff they'd missed out on, was trans activism. I am sure a number of these guys were in Stonewall themselves, or related orgs. And their networks were through the Civil Service, NGOs and charities, and later, business services/advertising.

So, trans activism became their big thing. It was built on the Macusian/ Foucaultian gibberish they'd learnt at university. They could talk the talk, and parrot its philosophy - they were way too senior and well-connected to be affected by its downsides.

They could performatively get into it themselves, like the Alex Drummonds of the world.

Or later on, post covid, as they moved into business services and advertising, they could come up with stuff like the Jaguar campaign, that killed one of the UK's best brands stone dead.

I tend to think, that's why you see disaster after disaster there. And it's not over yet.

Shedmistress · 02/11/2026 13:48

38thparallel · 02/11/2026 13:30

@Shedmistress
They signed up because they could box tick by changing the toilet signs to 'gender neutral' and changing their policies to 'gender neutral' wordings and get higher up the rankings to enable them to get either contracts, investment or funding. As all 3 insisted on 'DEI' being part of the company policy

That’s interesting, thank you. When did this change? I mean, when did leaving Stonewall stop affecting chances of contracts etc?

It hasn't really. What happened is that the legal teams got more involved and they realised that they were breaking the law so have had to balance keeping legal with keeping the activists happy.

ItsCoolForCats · 02/11/2026 13:59

Does anyone know how Stonewall's new scheme is doing compared to the Diversity Champion's one? It would be interesting to see some figures.

OP posts:
FlirtsWithRhinos · 02/11/2026 16:21

MyAmpleSheep · 02/11/2026 13:22

Has anyone else noticed that as soon as one defintion of sex is "issued", about two months later trans people claim to have changed it. So another one comes along....

Trans people aren’t claiming they changed their reproductive sex.

Except for the ones who do. And the others will be along shortly.

Oh absolutely. 100%.

They have to. Because reality keeps derailing them. It simply isn't possible to have language that gives them what they want, because reality undermines it every time. Sex is socially and physically consequential, and that means sooner ot later people need to differentiate it from gender identity and presentation.

Gehderists keep coining new terms so they can set the definitions to be what they want the world to be like.

Then we show how the new definitions still don't magically make female bodies and male feelings of gender interchangeable.

So they respond by giving up those terms and trying again with new ones, and round it goes again.

It's no different to the constantly changing usernames really. The aim is always to get debunked arguments back on the table by presenting the same content with a new label.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 02/11/2026 16:23

Callback to this post from 2022...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/4651362-friend-of-joanne?reply=120609236

the consensus in "trans-ally" society will gradually move towards the type of reasonable position we have been asking for all along (ditch society's gender roles, accept sex sometimes matters, safeguard children and vulnerable women, do everything possible to help people live happy lives in the bodies they already have) but it will be painted (and indeed by the participants genuinely believed) as an evolution of the trans-accepting side they were always on rather than a recognition that the woman who raised concerns and were demonized for it were right all along.

They will continue to believe they fought the good fight against TERFs, GCs and others who were just motivated by bigotry against trans people.

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · 02/11/2026 16:24

@ItsCoolForCats

From the evidence I've found online, badly. Organizations are either not jumping to sign up, or they're being very quiet about it (not publishing the fact on their websites). The official list is members-only, so there's no way to tell 100%, but I'm convinced the current members have been led to Stonewall by activists within the organizations, rather than by being courted and pursued by Stonewall.

This may change if Stonewall manage to recruit someone to "increase sales" - they are recruiting for this person right now.

Their accounts for 2026 may show us more, once they are published.

The current list (which I compiled) is here:

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womensrights/5537780-educate-motivate-and-inspire-lawmakers-stonewalls-new-proud-employers-scheme-and-strategy?page=3&reply=155696790

ed to @ OP