Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Trans identifying people gaslight their parents - a heartbreaking read.

1000 replies

Soontobe60 · 28/10/2026 06:58

www.pittparents.com?utm_source=navbar&utm_medium=web

This broke my heart to read. The impact a child who chooses to declare themselves the opposite sex has on their mother in particular is brutal. I cannot imagine a world where my children would demand that I change my own history to bow to their indoctrination.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
BlueLegume · 01/11/2026 07:01

Twoallbeepattiesspecialsaucelettucecheesepickles · 01/11/2026 06:08

bragging

You claimed I served no functionality & I convinced no one remember? That I was able to provide evidence this was incorrect & you weren't is hardly bragging. Its called correcting your lies.

while literally calling the other mothers here "wild cornered animals". You've just proven my point completely.

Other commenters uncivilised behaviour that you interestingly ignore is akin to wild cornered animals. And that you assume the obvious activist activity is only from mothers is delusional.

Get back to us when you show some consistency in your critique of 'appropriate' tone until then your comments are irrelevant here.

Edited

@Twoallbeepattiesspecialsaucelettucecheesepickles you derail or detract so many threads with interesting titles. We are not stupid people and debates about sex based rights matter to us. Most of your posts are hard to read as they are so long and verbose. We get it. You have decided gender is a thing more important than reality. Just do not expect everyone to agree when we have reality in our corner.

TheignT · 01/11/2026 07:11

allthemind · 28/10/2026 07:28

Poor lady. I see no control issues. She is fully aware of the process of letting go as children become adults and knows it is a natural part of the process. But here she knows that natural order has been interrupted and destroyed by a cruel ideology that means her daughter is negating those years as a child and adolescent and banning her mother from calling her her own name. God that has got to be tough. The whole dead naming thing is one of the cruelest part of this terrible con that a whole generation of children were enabled into by amoral adults. I feel so sorry for these famillies, of which I know 3 in real life, with lesbian daughters who now identify as extremely unconvincing men. Its so sad they couldn't just be happy as gay women (and maybe have a breast reduction, fair enough, what teenage girl hasnt hated having large breasts? I know I did, and still fantasise about having a reduction).

And of course the parents have to pretend to back it to the hilt, for their won sanity and because of a cruel sunken cost fallacy they've been shoved into because, like all parents, they wanted their daughters to be happier than they were. They will be on this thread, calling this bigoted and transphobic, but its all part of the same cruel gaslighting their family got sucked into. Very sad.

Why is it wrong to say what you are comfortable with as your name? Nothing to do with trans but I cringe at the sound of the name my siblings still call me 62 years after I voiced my hatred of the name. With me it is the shortening of my name. Say my given name is Elizabeth,, it isn't, from birth my parents and family called me Betty, I got to 11 and hated it and said I wanted people to call me Elizabeth or Liz. My parents, my siblings couldn't do that. My siblings children, born years after that have grown up calling me Betty, their children now do the same. I find it so hurtful when I've explained how it feels to me. If Im not entitled to choose my own name what can I choose? Why is it cruel for me to want to be known by the name I identify with but seemingly fine for other people to choose for me.

Pingponghavoc · 01/11/2026 07:26

Its not the name change, just as its not the choice of clothes. Its what they represent.

The name change represents a rejection of sex. The parent is concerned about what follows on from that. Not being able to call your child Betty is a constant reminder of the dangers.

TheignT · 01/11/2026 07:33

Pingponghavoc · 01/11/2026 07:26

Its not the name change, just as its not the choice of clothes. Its what they represent.

The name change represents a rejection of sex. The parent is concerned about what follows on from that. Not being able to call your child Betty is a constant reminder of the dangers.

Read the post I quoted, it is saying changing a name is the cruellest thing. It really isn't, it's about respecting your child and how that name makes them feel. In my view it is the least important thing about the whole trans issues. Maybe parents being unable to respect that is the heart of the problem. If being called a name other people choose is like a punch in the face who do you think should be able to make the decision?

Imdunfer · 01/11/2026 07:42

Twoallbeepattiesspecialsaucelettucecheesepickles · 01/11/2026 02:20

More A &C….

Err the difference between sex & gender .

Can you please describe how trans people indicate in their daily lives that they are no longer male and have become female?

If you do that, I think you'll find that it's you who is confusing sex and gender.

PriOn1 · 01/11/2026 07:43

NotBadConsidering · 01/11/2026 02:50

The most useful thing from this thread that that mother could gain from lurking and reading (or any lurker for that matter) is seeing that she has many people in her corner, who have empathy for her situation, who are willing to support her through the gaslighting and to push back on the idea there’s some semblance of sense to made from the position she’s in. She would know that she’s not going crazy because she can’t see the logic, everyone here, including you, will have helped her see there is no logic in it.

You just haven’t helped in the way you think you have 🤪

I’ve been shown afresh, just how desperate teansactivists are to silence us and stop us talking about the grief we feel because transactivism has turned our previously loving children against us.

It’s shockingly clear from this thread. Those who try to silence us are narcissists through and through and I need to remember that my children have been captured by a thoroughly cruel cult-like sect.

So thanks to all the obsessives on this thread who are trying to stop us being heard. I (and hopefully others) will take this as a sign that we need to keep talking about how transactivism has harmed us, wherever we see the opportunity.

OldCrone · 01/11/2026 07:44

Pingponghavoc · 01/11/2026 07:26

Its not the name change, just as its not the choice of clothes. Its what they represent.

The name change represents a rejection of sex. The parent is concerned about what follows on from that. Not being able to call your child Betty is a constant reminder of the dangers.

I thought she made too much of the name change - lots of people change their name for various reasons, and to me the name change seems to be one of the least important aspects of a trans Identity.

Your explanation of the name as a sort of symbol of the wish to be the opposite sex and a reminder of where this might lead makes sense.

PriOn1 · 01/11/2026 07:45

WomanXXWorldsOriginsofMothersofAllNations · 01/11/2026 02:55

Twoallbee, I normally just a lurker, but I honestly feel compelled to post because of what you’re doing here. Could you step back from the debate club tactics for a minute and look at what you’re actually achieving?

By treating a thread about worried, grieving parents like some high-stakes uni debate tournament, you’re completely scoring an own goal. When a mum posts on here sharing raw, visceral pain about her child, and you jump in with cold, clinical pedantry about sociological constructs, you aren’t dismantling gender-critical views - you’re completely validating them.

To those of us quietly lurking on these threads, you are providing a daily, living caricature of exactly what parents are worried about: a movement that’s uncompromising, totally detached, and lacking any actual human warmth, or empathy for mothers.

You aren't moving the needle at all, you're just hardening the cement. If you're only here for the dopamine hit of a circular semantic win, then honestly, carry on.

But if your actual goal is to make the world a safer, more compassionate place for trans people, you need to wake up to the fact that your current posting style is the single best recruiting tool the gender-critical movement has on this site. Is winning a pedantic point really worth losing the whole room?

Thank you. 🙏

OldCrone · 01/11/2026 07:51

Imdunfer · 01/11/2026 07:42

Can you please describe how trans people indicate in their daily lives that they are no longer male and have become female?

If you do that, I think you'll find that it's you who is confusing sex and gender.

The thing about sex and gender being different is that there are two possibilities.

Either they are totally different and unrelated to each other, so either sex can correspond to any gender, or gender and sex are linked in a one to one correspondence, with a specific sex linked to one specific gender.

When we are told how this works, perhaps we can move on.

Imdunfer · 01/11/2026 07:54

WomanXXWorldsOriginsofMothersofAllNations · 01/11/2026 02:55

Twoallbee, I normally just a lurker, but I honestly feel compelled to post because of what you’re doing here. Could you step back from the debate club tactics for a minute and look at what you’re actually achieving?

By treating a thread about worried, grieving parents like some high-stakes uni debate tournament, you’re completely scoring an own goal. When a mum posts on here sharing raw, visceral pain about her child, and you jump in with cold, clinical pedantry about sociological constructs, you aren’t dismantling gender-critical views - you’re completely validating them.

To those of us quietly lurking on these threads, you are providing a daily, living caricature of exactly what parents are worried about: a movement that’s uncompromising, totally detached, and lacking any actual human warmth, or empathy for mothers.

You aren't moving the needle at all, you're just hardening the cement. If you're only here for the dopamine hit of a circular semantic win, then honestly, carry on.

But if your actual goal is to make the world a safer, more compassionate place for trans people, you need to wake up to the fact that your current posting style is the single best recruiting tool the gender-critical movement has on this site. Is winning a pedantic point really worth losing the whole room?

Fabulous post !

Waitingfordoggo · 01/11/2026 08:03

Twoallbeepattiesspecialsaucelettucecheesepickles · 01/11/2026 05:26

Sounds like your 'lurking' hasn't been that thorough because if it was you would know that the most benign & unconfrontational posts on this forum get vicious pushback & insults lest they break from the company line. There is no effective polite reasoning in these parts because its become a notorious territorial GC activist fortress rather than a discussion forum that's renowned as a hot bed of transphobia. You just have to look at other discussion threads on MN to understand the monumental difference in civilised discussion. Many of these commenters are akin to wild cornered animals & I don't see you calling them out.

In any case, whether a poster is functionally useful isn't necessarily determined by the visible pushback given lurkers like yourself exist. Most of my posts get many likes here's one btw that got 24 likes on this thread & who know how many more informed people & I have noticed an uptick in more opposing voices that no doubt are encouraged by those already here.

I also think there's something to be said for bringing in new ideas that pushback isn't necessarily reflective of whether seeds are planted. People particularly those that have long established biases often take time to accustom themselves to new ideas. Repetition helps so strap yourself in for more of the same 'medicine'.

What I am grieving is the loss of a shared story.
"Two things stand out about this piece is a parent that can't accept their child evolving into an adulthood identity that they don't recognise on a superficial level & because of that they mustn’t have had any individual agency in doing so.
Brings back memories of my children who are adults now where I remember mourning each milestone that "this little person as they are now will soon be gone forever & I need to let go". The idea that children don't grow up & change often into people we wouldn't necessarily like them to be is very naive.
Perhaps the author may find peace & reconciliation with her child if she works on her control issues rather than seeking imaginary culpability elsewhere.

24

Edited

Why did you put 24 in bold at the end? Did you think that was evidence? 😂

borntobequiet · 01/11/2026 08:14

Abbot & Costello?

A 1940s American comedy duo on a MN FWR thread in 2026?

Before my time, and l’m well past pension age. Tell me without telling me that someone is relying a little too much on AI for their material.

MontyMadness99 · 01/11/2026 08:17

It’s funny how #be kind isn’t employed to:

-the mother in the OP
-detransitioners
-desisters
-victims of male violence
-basic questioning
-genuine fears women have

Just saying…

thepurcellsisters · 01/11/2026 08:26

This mother has shared how her daughter’s decisions and the “healthcare” said daughter received have caused her distress.

She has been coherent and vulnerable with us all.

And there are people who i believe are grown women who are desperately screaming about how wrong, how bad, how not-a-good-mother she is because she hasn’t rewritten her own history to fit her child’s new narrative.

I hope she doesn’t see this thread. I hope she has people in her life who are there to hold her when she cries because the daughter she birthed and brought up and loves is hurting herself. I hope that she has someone she can send that funny video to who will appreciate that it hurts that she can’t share that with her child at the moment.

i keep hoping that maybe this madness will end and fewer girls will be funnelled into this pathway.

BlueLegume · 01/11/2026 08:26

MontyMadness99 · 01/11/2026 08:17

It’s funny how #be kind isn’t employed to:

-the mother in the OP
-detransitioners
-desisters
-victims of male violence
-basic questioning
-genuine fears women have

Just saying…

This is why I hate the ‘be kind’ mantra. It has been weaponised to violate boundaries and make sensible comments sound mean. It is also why we are in 20026 allowing a man wearing fetish rubber boobs to teach young people in university. We must ‘be kind’ to him whilst he smirks into the camera.

cryupmykingdom · 01/11/2026 08:27

.

MontyMadness99 · 01/11/2026 08:37

BlueLegume · 01/11/2026 08:26

This is why I hate the ‘be kind’ mantra. It has been weaponised to violate boundaries and make sensible comments sound mean. It is also why we are in 20026 allowing a man wearing fetish rubber boobs to teach young people in university. We must ‘be kind’ to him whilst he smirks into the camera.

Agreed.

And reminds me of the heightened sense of injustice young children go through but from a clearly subjective standpoint. Which is understandable because they’re learning, developing and maturing. What is unfair to them is unjustified but what is unfair to others, but serves them, is justified

Some adults seem to be stuck in that space 🤷‍♀️

cryupmykingdom · 01/11/2026 08:42

WomanXXWorldsOriginsofMothersofAllNations · 01/11/2026 02:55

Twoallbee, I normally just a lurker, but I honestly feel compelled to post because of what you’re doing here. Could you step back from the debate club tactics for a minute and look at what you’re actually achieving?

By treating a thread about worried, grieving parents like some high-stakes uni debate tournament, you’re completely scoring an own goal. When a mum posts on here sharing raw, visceral pain about her child, and you jump in with cold, clinical pedantry about sociological constructs, you aren’t dismantling gender-critical views - you’re completely validating them.

To those of us quietly lurking on these threads, you are providing a daily, living caricature of exactly what parents are worried about: a movement that’s uncompromising, totally detached, and lacking any actual human warmth, or empathy for mothers.

You aren't moving the needle at all, you're just hardening the cement. If you're only here for the dopamine hit of a circular semantic win, then honestly, carry on.

But if your actual goal is to make the world a safer, more compassionate place for trans people, you need to wake up to the fact that your current posting style is the single best recruiting tool the gender-critical movement has on this site. Is winning a pedantic point really worth losing the whole room?

Great post.

OP needs to stick to her view. She can do it tactfully, but being right here, will pay off.

The trans movement is quite obviously supported by parents who have arranged and enabled castration of their children.

The reason they keep up the support is that tho they know in their heart of hearts they were wrong, the cost of having to admit being responsible for that harm - and the things taken from their children that emanate from it - no children, end of family line, no adult sex life - is that you probably can't remain alive yourself.

It is very bleak.

Pingponghavoc · 01/11/2026 08:55

TheignT · 01/11/2026 07:33

Read the post I quoted, it is saying changing a name is the cruellest thing. It really isn't, it's about respecting your child and how that name makes them feel. In my view it is the least important thing about the whole trans issues. Maybe parents being unable to respect that is the heart of the problem. If being called a name other people choose is like a punch in the face who do you think should be able to make the decision?

Read my post.

Its not the name change. Its the reason for the name change.

Every little detail about 'transition' is framed as no big deal for the mother - its just clothing choice, name change, prefered pronouns, but so important for their child.

Is it important or not?

The name change is the first step to transition for the child. You are dismissing this detail. You are ignoring baby steps to transition and how they are used to manipulate the mother to accepting and supporting the next step.

As I said, the name change is the constant reminder of the path her child could go down. Who wants the constant reminder of 'top' or 'bottom' surgery? The effects of drugs?

The article was a mothers feeling about her child's 'transition'. As an observer its easy to dismiss each stage as insignificant, but they can add up to surgery and a lifetime of drugs. Why is it up to observers to decide where a mothers concern should start?

Myalternate · 01/11/2026 09:31

Pingponghavoc · 01/11/2026 08:55

Read my post.

Its not the name change. Its the reason for the name change.

Every little detail about 'transition' is framed as no big deal for the mother - its just clothing choice, name change, prefered pronouns, but so important for their child.

Is it important or not?

The name change is the first step to transition for the child. You are dismissing this detail. You are ignoring baby steps to transition and how they are used to manipulate the mother to accepting and supporting the next step.

As I said, the name change is the constant reminder of the path her child could go down. Who wants the constant reminder of 'top' or 'bottom' surgery? The effects of drugs?

The article was a mothers feeling about her child's 'transition'. As an observer its easy to dismiss each stage as insignificant, but they can add up to surgery and a lifetime of drugs. Why is it up to observers to decide where a mothers concern should start?

👍

It’s insidious creep.

OldCrone · 01/11/2026 09:44

Pingponghavoc · 01/11/2026 08:55

Read my post.

Its not the name change. Its the reason for the name change.

Every little detail about 'transition' is framed as no big deal for the mother - its just clothing choice, name change, prefered pronouns, but so important for their child.

Is it important or not?

The name change is the first step to transition for the child. You are dismissing this detail. You are ignoring baby steps to transition and how they are used to manipulate the mother to accepting and supporting the next step.

As I said, the name change is the constant reminder of the path her child could go down. Who wants the constant reminder of 'top' or 'bottom' surgery? The effects of drugs?

The article was a mothers feeling about her child's 'transition'. As an observer its easy to dismiss each stage as insignificant, but they can add up to surgery and a lifetime of drugs. Why is it up to observers to decide where a mothers concern should start?

Every little detail about 'transition' is framed as no big deal for the mother - its just clothing choice, name change, prefered pronouns, but so important for their child.

Is it important or not?

This sums up so much about what is happening. There are all these things which we're told are really important for the trans identifying person. So important that if they aren't fulfilled their mental health will suffer terribly to the extent that they might kill themselves.

At the same time, these same things are framed as trivial and unimportant for everyone else, because its so easy to do the 'right thing'. But if it's so trivial, why is it so important for the trans person?

It can't be trivial and important at the same time.

MoistVonL · 01/11/2026 09:45

That the amputation of perfectly healthy body parts of young women is celebrated as 'top surgery ' and not as radical self harm is more evidence of how sick and misogynistic trans activism truly is.

I felt a pang when my DD got tattoos on that beautiful body I grew in my womb. I can't imagine how a mother would feel seeing her child desecrate her own body enthusiastically in such a way.

Soontobe60 · 01/11/2026 10:32

Twoallbeepattiesspecialsaucelettucecheesepickles · 31/10/2026 22:51

Lol,🤪.

The point is they get to speak for their own group.

Their own group being males if they are male trans identifying, and females if they’re female trans identifying.

OP posts:
Kalalily · 01/11/2026 12:06

Pingponghavoc · 01/11/2026 08:55

Read my post.

Its not the name change. Its the reason for the name change.

Every little detail about 'transition' is framed as no big deal for the mother - its just clothing choice, name change, prefered pronouns, but so important for their child.

Is it important or not?

The name change is the first step to transition for the child. You are dismissing this detail. You are ignoring baby steps to transition and how they are used to manipulate the mother to accepting and supporting the next step.

As I said, the name change is the constant reminder of the path her child could go down. Who wants the constant reminder of 'top' or 'bottom' surgery? The effects of drugs?

The article was a mothers feeling about her child's 'transition'. As an observer its easy to dismiss each stage as insignificant, but they can add up to surgery and a lifetime of drugs. Why is it up to observers to decide where a mothers concern should start?

It is exactly this. Thank you @Pingponghavoc

And I would add that the mothers know that one step leads to another - and eventually it may feel too hard to roll it back.

Kalalily · 01/11/2026 12:36

BlueLegume · 01/11/2026 08:26

This is why I hate the ‘be kind’ mantra. It has been weaponised to violate boundaries and make sensible comments sound mean. It is also why we are in 20026 allowing a man wearing fetish rubber boobs to teach young people in university. We must ‘be kind’ to him whilst he smirks into the camera.

Such a disgrace. We need to call this behaviour out for what it is. Shame on Oxford for exposing young students to this deviant behaviour. One of the females in his department needs to turn up for work with a huge prosthetic penis strapped under her leggings

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread