Twoallbee, I normally just a lurker, but I honestly feel compelled to post because of what you’re doing here. Could you step back from the debate club tactics for a minute and look at what you’re actually achieving?
By treating a thread about worried, grieving parents like some high-stakes uni debate tournament, you’re completely scoring an own goal. When a mum posts on here sharing raw, visceral pain about her child, and you jump in with cold, clinical pedantry about sociological constructs, you aren’t dismantling gender-critical views - you’re completely validating them.
To those of us quietly lurking on these threads, you are providing a daily, living caricature of exactly what parents are worried about: a movement that’s uncompromising, totally detached, and lacking any actual human warmth, or empathy for mothers.
You aren't moving the needle at all, you're just hardening the cement. If you're only here for the dopamine hit of a circular semantic win, then honestly, carry on.
But if your actual goal is to make the world a safer, more compassionate place for trans people, you need to wake up to the fact that your current posting style is the single best recruiting tool the gender-critical movement has on this site. Is winning a pedantic point really worth losing the whole room?